It was Sunday night. Riley was at home in her kitchen working out her lesson plans for the week. Her phone started to ring.

"Hello?" She said.

"Hi baby." John said.

"Hi." "I'm surprised you're calling me now." "It's after ten." "Where's Nikki?"

"Out with Brie." "She won't be back till at least bar closing time."

"Oh."

"I wanted to hear your voice."

"You did?"

"Yeah."

"Aw."

"What are you doing?"

"Making my lesson plans for the week."

"Are you gonna watch Raw tomorrow?"

"I'm gonna try, hopefully I'm home in time for your part."

"You really wanna see me huh?"

"Yeah." "I miss you."

"I miss you to."

"I coach the girls senior softball team every year and tomorrow's our first game."

"What time does it start?"

"Five."

"It'll be cutting it close."

"Yeah." "I need to see that sexy face of yours to hold me over till I see you again."

"Is my face the only thing you're gonna be looking at?"

"I might look at a few other places."

"Really?" "Like where?"

"Your chest, your abs, your cute ass."

"Sounds like you're getting a little turned on Riley."

"Well I haven't had sex in a few weeks." "You wouldn't know what that's like."

"Hey."

"It's true." "You have sex with Nikki whenever you want." "I don't have sex with other people." "Not that I would anyway because I don't want to."

"I know it's not fair to you." "I'm sorry."

"It's alright."

"Let's not talk about Nikki." "Let's talk about you." "What are you wearing?"

"My pajamas."

"I bet you look sexy."

"Not really."

"I wish I was there." "I'd kiss you all over your body."

"Really?"

"Yeah very slowly."

"John, are you deliberately trying to torture me?"

"No Riley." "I'm trying to turn you on."

"Just the sound of your voice does that to me."

"What else do you want me to do to you?"

"I've never done this before."

"Neither have I." "Come on." "It'll be fun."

"Ok."

"Ok." "Let's try something." "Close your eyes."

"Ok." She closed them. "They're closed."

"Imagine your hand, is my hand." He said seductively. "Feel my hand glide down your body." "Starting for your neck and going down slowly." Riley started to do what John was describing. At first she felt silly but she was getting into it. "I can feel your skin." "Every curve of you." "Your breasts."

"Ohhhh." Riley moaned.

"Ooh, someone's enjoying herself." "It's so hot when you moan." "Riley, I want you." "Do you want me?"

"Yes."

"Say it."

"I want you John." Riley's other line started to beep. She ignored it.

"Where do you want me to touch you next?"

"Anywhere you want."

"Well you know where one of my favorites place to touch you is?"

"Where?" Riley's other line kept beeping. "John hold on I have another call."

"Ok."

Riley clicked over.

"Hello?" She said.

"Hi Riley, this is Courtney." "I wanted to talk to you about the staff meeting."

"Ok hold on."

Riley clicked back over.

"John I gotta go." She said.

"Now."

"It's my boss."

"Damn."

"I know." "I'm sorry." "Let's try this another time."

"Ok." "Bye."

The next morning John was going to an autograph signing with Randy Orton. Randy was driving.

"John wake up." He said. "We're almost there."

"Ok." John opened his eyes.

"John, who's Riley?"

"What?"

"The chick you were fucking in your sleep."

"I don't even remember dreaming." "I don't even know a Riley."

"That's not what it sounded like to me. "Oh Riley, baby." He said in a mocking tone.

"Weird." "I have no idea why it'd dream something like that."

Riley and Ashley were at lunch.

"Riley my friend Janey said there's this really cute guy where she works." "We were thinking about setting you two up."

"A blind date?"

"Yeah."

"Hell no."

"Why not?"

"I'm not going on a date with someone I don't know." "Forget it."

Riley's softball team won there game. She went home and took a shower. She sat down on her couch to watch Raw. She was catching it in the second hour. When she turned it on she saw Nikki and Brie in a tag team match. Riley hated Nikki and she knew that wasn't fair because she didn't even know her. She hated the fact that Nikki got to see John every day. Be around him whenever she wanted, kiss him whenever she wanted. After Riley watched John's part she began to think of the night her affair with John started. Right on the very couch she was sitting on.

Flashback

It was around eight o'clock at night on a Friday. It was a chilly night. Riley was covered up with a blanket wearing sweatpants and a t-shirt. She was grading papers. There was a knock at the door. She answered it and was very surprised to see John standing there in a blue sweatshirt.

"Hey." She said happily.

"Hi." "Come I come in?"

"Sure." He went in. "Well this is a surprise." "Wanna sit down?"

"Sure." They sat on the couch. "Riley, we need to talk."

"Ok."

"I took Nikki back."

"I see."

"I'm sorry."

"I understand." "She's way prettier then I am." "Of course you'd go back to her."

"It's not that." "I really like you." "I didn't wanna do this." "We've had fun these last couple weeks haven't we?"

"Yeah." "Like it matters now."

"Listen to me Riley." "You are beautiful."

"Yeah."

"You are." "I loved spending time with you." He took his palm put it on her cheek and turned her head towards him. "I mean it." "Part of me wishes I didn't have to stop." He kissed her. She kissed him back. She knew it was wrong. That she should tell him to stop. She didn't want him to. He laid down on the couch pulling her on top of him. He took off her shirt. She took off his sweatshirt. As they were kissing she reached down and unzipped his jeans. He sat them both up. She took off his t-shirt. He took off her bra. He laid her back so she was under him. He took his jeans off. They kissed. He slowly kissed her down her body. She moaned. He took off her sweatpants. "Ohhhh." She moaned loudly as she felt his tongue enter her most sensitive area. "John." She moaned loudly and repeatedly. She moaned louder as he went faster. "Ohhhh, ohhh, ohhhh, John!" She screamed out giving in. He came back up to her mouth. They kissed. He slipped inside her and started to move. "Riley." He groaned. "John." "Oh god that feels so good." She moaned. "Mmmm, but we shouldn't, mmmmm, mmmmm, be doing, ohhhh, this." "I know." John groaned. "I can't help it." "Me either." She kissed him. He kissed her back. "God Riley, uhhh, I want you." He groaned against her lips. They started moving faster. "Oh John, yes, yes, ohhh my god, John ohhh, yes." She moaned giving in. "Riley." He groaned giving in.

Afterward they were catching there breath. She was laying on his chest.

"I don't wanna stop seeing you Riley." John said.

"I don't want that either." "Can you stay the night?"

"Yeah."

"Good." "I'll make us breakfast in the morning." They kissed.

End Of Flashback

Ever since that night Riley had been John's in the closet lover. She realized now it was a bad idea but there was no way she could break it off now. She was in to deep emotionally. She decided to go to bed. She went to her bedroom closet and got John's blue sweatshirt out of it. He'd left it there accidentally. She laid on her side and held it close to her. It was her way of being close to him. She thought of the lose-lose situation she was in. She thought several times about telling John to choose but if she did that she knew who he would pick and it wouldn't be her. She'd thought several times about walking away, telling John it was over. She knew she wouldn't. All because of the one thing she swore to herself she wouldn't let happen. She was in love with him.