They arrived at victim number one's home. Mary Topper. When Dean rang the doorbell, an older lady answered the door.
"Yes?" She stood there asking them.
"Yes hi we are with the Tribune and we are doing some research on water and if its safe." Dean was telling her.
"And we know Mary had died and we would like to ask you some questions about how she died, if we may? Sam was then asking her when he was helping Dean out.
"Um—sure come in." She said when she was letting them into her house.
Lexi was just listening to her brothers do all the talking.
"I'm Dean. This is Sam and Lexi." Dean said as he was introducing them to Mrs. Toppers.
"Hello. So what did you want to know?" She asked while she wondered what they needed to know.
"Where was Mary when she drowned?" Sam was asking her.
"Mary was taking a bath." Mrs. Topper was saying giving an eye towards the ceiling.
"What can you tell us?" Dean asked her.
"Mary drowned in 2002 she was sweet-." Mrs. Topper was saying when Sam knew she was leaving something out.
"But what?" He asked her when he was wondering.
"Well sometimes Mary was very jealous of certain girls." Her Mom was telling them.
"Did she know the two other victims?" Dean was then asking her.
"Yes actually. They didn't get along much." Mrs. Topper was saying when that caused Dean to give Sam a look.
"Why is that?" Sam was asking her.
"Mary thought they were beautiful. The other 2 had boyfriends and Mary's broke up with her." Mrs. Toppers explained.
"What did these other girls look like?" Lexi piped up.
Dean and Sam gave her look of why she would ask that.
"Um. They were both –like your hair color." Mrs. Toppers said to Lexi.
"Where is Mary buried?" Sam was then asking her.
"Millers Cemetery." She told them.
When Lexi heard that it upset her and she was more scared now. Lexi stood up and Dean knew they had to leave.
"Thank you for your time." Dean said to her as they were then leaving.
While walking to the car, Lexi was really out of it.
"Lexi what are you thinking about?" Dean was asking now asking his sister.
"I'm gonna be next." She told her brothers when she really had this scared and worried look to her face.
"Look we will be with you every second." Dean said to her when he made her face him. Dean saw the look in her eyes and felt bad for her.
Dean took his sister and just held her. He knew he had to do whatever it took to keep her safe.
"So now since we know more of why, we don't need to talk to the other victims family?" Sam was asking his brother.
"Yeah probably not. " Dean was saying when he agreed with Sam.
Sam kept an eye on Lexi. He was making sure she was ok.
"We need to find her body, salt it, burn it." Suggested Dean, when they were then getting into the car.
Sam had made her sit up front with them.
"Look she cant hurt you." Dean said to his sister while looking over at her.
"Cant or won't?" She asked her brothers.
"Both." Sam told her when she was looking down at her hands.
"I know you're scared but you have nothin to worry little sista, big brothers are here." Dean said trying to make her smile.
"Thanks Dean. You too Sammy." She told her brother with a scared tone in her voice.
"Its gonna be over soon." Sam was telling his sister.
"I can't help it. No one was trying to kill ya while you showered." She told them when Sam understood where she was coming from.
"Lets just get this evil sons of bitch." Dean said when he put his foot down on the pedal and the Impala raced to the cemetery.