Disclaimer: I do not own Pretty Little Liars

Spencer (P.O.V)

I can't believe Toby! He is such a jerk. He has never done anything to make me want to slap him like this before. We never even had an argument! I am so pissed. I am walking in the rain and when I get home, Toby is already there.

"I was so worried! What happened? What did I do wrong?" He asks. The truth is, on my walk, I have given myself time to cool off. I will just pretend nothing happened and I will just avoid conflict.

"Nothing, Toby. I was just in a bad mood. I am going to go shower and change because I am soaking wet from the rain." I say with a smile. He smiles back and I go shower. I put on some pyjamas and decide to do my homework and sleep.

The next day

Toby (P.O.V)

Spencer confused me yesterday. I am so glad she isn't mad at me.

Spencer (P.O.V)

It is lunchtime at school. I am sitting with Hanna, Emily, Aria, Caleb, and Noel, or as I like to call him, brother #2.

I am sitting there, thinking about my relationship with everybody.

Hanna, Emily, Aria, and I are very close. We are always there for each other, and nothing could ever change that. They have been there every time they have seen me cry over Toby and his latest date, Emily when she was finally ready to come out of the closet, Aria, when she has a problem with Jason, and Hanna, for when she chips a nail.
(That might not seem like much, but when Hanna chips a nail, it's serious!)

Caleb is my second best guy friend. First place is Toby. Caleb is like another brother to me. We constantly insult each other, but it comes down to it, he would punch a guy in the face for me. In fact, he did. When Wren and I broke up, Toby was out of town for a job, and Wren wouldn't leave me alone. HE kept trying to talk to me, showing up at my house or even at school. One time, when I was walking home, Wren just came out of nowhere, grabbed me and brought me to the side of the school where no one could see us. Apparently, Caleb saw him grab me, and he followed us, and punched Wren in the face. We never mention it though. We are the type of friends who don't admit we are friends.

Noel and Jason are obviously my brothers. I am the youngest and they often are overprotective. They hated every second that I was with Wren, as if they were afraid he would hurt me. I love them both a lot and they are easy to talk to. Except when it comes to boys. I remember a time when there was some boy in my kindergarten class. Noel was in first grade and Jason was in sixth grade. I went home, trying to hide a mark on my neck where he hit me with a jump rope, and when Noel and Jason found out, they went to his house and told him that if he did it again, they would make him eat that jump rope. Even now, they still frighten him. think the boy's name was Andrew Campbell.

I am interrupted by my thoughts when Toby shows up at the table, with yet another girl.

"Hi guys! This is... Cathy!" He says. I look to my left and see Hanna rolling her eyes, and Noel and the girls looking at me sympathetically.

For a few minutes, I was stuck sitting across from Toby and Cathy. He had is arm around her and they were holding hands. I couldn't take it anymore.

I put a smile on my face and say, "Um, I'll be right back. I have to call Jason about... getting some pizza for later!" I walk out of the cafeteria and to the bathroom. I walk into a stall, and let the tears run down my cheeks. Five minutes later, I hear someone come in. They come into the stall I'm in.

"Jenna?" I ask. We have never really talked much, but I recognize her as Toby's older sister, Jenna.

"Are you okay, Spencer? In the cafeteria, I saw you leave and not come back. I know we don't talk much but is something wrong?"

"I'm fine." I say, trying to wipe away my tears.

"Your friends, including my brother are worried about you. "

"Just tell them that I have to ask a question from a teacher."

"Spencer, I've seen the way you react when my brother has a new girl to go out with. Do you like him?"

"Yes, but don't tell him. Can you please just leave me alone?"

"No." She walks closer to me, and says, "I'm sorry he does this to you. If it makes you feel better, he has never slept with anyone. He is too nice."

"I know he doesn't." She gives me a hug and leaves.

Later that day

Jenna (P.O.V)

I love Toby, but he can be an idiotic jack ass sometimes. I see him at his locker. Now, I don't know Spencer well, but I know her enough where I know she and Toby are best friends and she likes him. We always got along, but never spoke much.

I walk over to Toby, "Hey, sis." Toby says with a smile. I scowl at him.

"Jenna, what's-" I interrupt him by holding him by the ear and guiding him to another room while he yells in pain. When we reach an empty room, I let go.

"What was that for?" He asks, clutching his now red ear.

"That was for being a dumb-ass!" I yell.

"What are you talking about?!"

"Spencer! You bring a new girl to the table and every time it kills her."

"How would you know?"

"Earlier today, when she left the cafeteria to go to the bathroom."

"She went outside to talk to her brother, Jason!"

"No, she went to the bathroom and was crying her eyes out. You want to know how I know that? I was there!"

"Are you serious?"

"Dead serious." I continue, "Listen, Toby, I don't know Spencer that well, but I bet even a complete stranger's heart would break seeing her cry like that."

He leaves the room, saying tjat he is looking for Spencer.

A/N: I wanted Jenna included somehow, and I was thinking about who she should end up with. Also, feel free to leave me suggestions. Is there anything you want to happen in the story?