A/N: Italics are flashbacks to the Party/ Bruce Explaining. The rest are in modern time. Enjoy! ~E

"I can." Bruce slowly stands up, taking a look around the room. His eyes met with those around him, each one seemingly worried for Pamela, and now Harvey.

A few moments before Midnight, Bruce sat across from the punch bowl watching everything. On one side of the room stood both Pamela near the left wall, and Harvey and Rachel near the right. Pamela and Harvey were sending each other glances, which made Bruce think they were planning something. He took notice, but remained seated. Rachel finally observed one of these odd looks, noticing Pamela's devil like smile. While Pam quickly turned away, Rachel moved on to address the situation to Harvey. "Harv did you see-" She asked softly, pausing to notice Harvey focused on his phone.

He looked up, just as his phone buzzed in his hands. "See what?"

"N-othing." Rachel said, shaking her head. Halloween had her all suspicious.

Bruce paused, hearing Harvey groan as he sat back up. Rachel started to become a little nervous, staying by his side. Selena caught sight of Rachel's concern and laughed. "Have something to share with the class?" She taunted, giving a sly grin.

Bruce eyed Selena, he told her numerous times to not pick on Rachel. He gave a small sigh,"Selena.." His voice spoke warningly to stop, yet she did not heed his advice.

"Come on Rachel, spill, was this all your plan. Get revenge on Pam for winning, and stealing your boyfriend."

"What are you talking about?" Rachel acted confused.

"Selena." Bruce spoke sternly at the same time as Rachel answered. "Since you want to hear about plans so much, maybe I should go on to say what you have done."

Selena's eyes dart to her purse for a second, uncrossing her arms. She proceeded to act like she had not a clue to what he mentioned.

"Go on Bruce.." Harleen whispered, she still wanted to hear what happened to her friend.

Selena Kyle predicted the lights would go off at midnight. She had been timing the pattern perfectly all night. Her hand slipped from Bruce's arm as she moved swiftly through the crowd. Everyone upset, and unaware made it easy for her to snag wallets, cash and even jewelry from the girls. The lights stayed off this time, much to her amusement. As the lights came back on she tossed her prospects in her purse by the door, and proceeded to move back beside Bruce as everyone's eyes adjusted to the light. "Looking for something?" Selena purred, right next to him. Her hand gently placed itself on his shoulder as if she had been their the whole time.

"And Pamela was the perfect distraction from the robbery so no one would notice what was stolen." Barbara interrupted, misunderstanding Bruce's story. She knew very well Selena's record, which made it hard for the redhead to understand why Bruce dated the criminal.

Selena frowned, upset that Bruce just ratted her out to all their friends. She punched him in the shoulder. "What the hell?"

"Nice act, really Bruce but I'm not buying it." Rachel says, a bit uptight. She had helped Harvey so he sat upwards with a blanket wrapped around him. His thoughts were dazed, yet he seemed unharmed.

Rachel paused, crossing her arms. "I mean how are we supposed to believe you?" She asks, making Bruce a bit upset that she questioned him. Bruce and her had been good friends for years, he did not expect her to question his judgement. "I mean you're probably just covering for your girlfriend."

"I don't need a man to cover me." Selena growls, making Barbara roll her eyes.

"Check the purse underneath the punchbowl." Bruce adds as evidence to his case.

Harleen dumped out the contents of Selena's full purse. Insanely, it looked like she hit up almost every teen here. Harleen tilted her head, noticing her locket fall from the pile. Did she even wear that today? The nurse hardly remembered. "Hey!"

"I was going to give it back, it was just a Halloween trick." Selena insists.

Rachel Dawes shrugs, "I don't get how a thief is better than a murder. She still could have played a part-"

"Stop interrupting, cause if you had not noticed he still has not said who done it yet." Selena eyed Rachel as she spoke. Obviously, she believed Rachel was guilty. "Maybe you should be quiet until your boyfriend, who came from the room she was attacked in and covered in Pams blood, is proven innocent."

Rachel went silent.

Barbara nodded, "Yeah maybe everyone should be quiet until Bruce's explanation is finished."

Harvey started to come to, noticing how many people surrounded him. "Where's..." Confused, he rubbed his head. "Why is everyone in here?"

A text came across Harvey's phone 10 minutes before Midnight, all night him and Pamela were getting on each other's last nerves. How dare she come here, dressed like that. What did she expect of him? Unjustly, Pamela preyed on his weakness, and likes. He wanted to show her what she was, humiliated her. All he could image was having her strip, and leaving her as the vixen she was. Why was she obsessed with him? No, Pam is never obsessed. She needed something, that's the only time she would appear. He longed to humiliate her, and leave her with nothing, no upperhand. Harvey tried to ignore her at first, but the more he thought of it. The idea started to grow on him. What if he could humiliate her? The lights were going off, if he could figure out a way for them to stay off maybe that would be it. Leave it to Midnight, like the legend says, and sneak away. The devilish side of him loved the idea of humiliating her, tricking her like she tricked him. Maybe he could even get her to resign or be forced out of office. He smiled back at Pamela, receiving a smile in return. Little did Harvey realize that Rachel caught the exchange.

"What is she smiling about-" Rachel asked softly, pausing when she notices Harvey go to his phone.

"Hmm, see what?" Harvey asked, pretending to be on his phone. His phone buzzed in his hands, it was her.

"Nothing." Rachel said, shaking her head. She must have been seeing things as these rumours about the two were starting to make her see. "I'm going to grab a drink, want one?"

"Yeah, sounds great." Harvey said, not really paying attention. His fingers slide against the keypad.

'Back hall, Midnight.'

"That can't be true." Rachel interrupts Bruce's story. She started to get really loud, like she could not believe such a thing and this was her first time hearing about it. "You're making this up, I mean Harvey would never-"

A guilty look passed by Harvey as he looked down."Rachel quiet down, it's okay if they know."

"He's right, I wanted to humiliate her. I had a conversation about it with Ed once before. It was an idea, and I did sneak off with her. I think I can fill in what happened after that. It's only fair.

Bruce nodded, "Go on."

"We had left the room the moment the lights went off. We had no clue how long they would stay off but I texted Ed if he could take care of it for me. Ed had no clue what he was doing. I told him it was a halloween surprise. As we slipped off in the back room..." He bit his lip, remembering what actually happened. Little did Harvey know Ed had never opened his text. To worried over his friend Jonathan to do such. Harvey paused, remembering how his instincts, and her way of controlling him turned the situation around. He knew personally he fail at his attempt to just embarrass her. No one need to know that part, especially not Rachel. "My plan was to take off our clothes, like we we're going to do something. Once I convinced her to take them off I was going to text a friend to walk by and grab her clothes, as I got redressed."

Rachel had been biting her lip the whole story. A couple of people took note including Bruce, Selena, and Ed. "I thought Rachel said Harvey was beside her the whole time." Selena crossed her arms, glaring at the girl beside her.

"That's because she did not want to confess to following them." Bruce sighed, giving Rachel an apologetic look. He knew she did not have the heart to pull this off.

"I saw them leave together out of the corner of my eye...I-I" Rachel started to tear up. "It was dark, I wanted to make sure.." She started to shake, breaking down because she never knew what type of man her boyfriend was. Rachel felt like a fool to realize it in feels bad, hugging her.

"So she did it!" Selena smirks.

"No! NO!" Both Rachel and Bruce replied. He felt bad for Rachel, letting her continued on.

"I heard them, but I did not want to go in and see it. I left them in frustration I did not touch anyone."

"Touch anyone? Guys I am not hurt. This is not my blood."

"We know, it's Pamela's."

"What? No.." The blood rained down on us as we started to make out, it came in through the ceiling tiles... What happened to Pam?"

Bruce went to explain Pamela's condition to an even more confused Harvey. Everyone looked perplexed. In the confusion not one person noticed the glare Ed gave Jonathan. He knew they were close. Jonathan felt safe still. He injected Pamela as soon as her hand hit the door handle. Once she got out of the room, she was affected. Harvey did not see anything.

"Then who did it?" Barbara looked confused, tilting her head.

A laughing voice came from behind them all. A terrifying, lovely laughter that made Harley turn around quickly.

"Jack?" Harleen's eyes shot over to the window, where the jokester leaned up against the frame. A strike of lightning made his flashy smile all the more terrifying.

Her heart dropped.

"Would you like me to tell ya kiddies the best joke ever?" Jack snickered.