I haven't really read Ticci-Toby's or Eyeless Jack's story yet but my friend's told me about Toby so I hope I got his personality right, If I didn't I am really sorry. Also I didn't really know what Masky's personality would be, so I just made him shy. Anyway I'm thinking about writing my own little Creepypasta. It might not be all that great but if I do decide too I'll give you all a link to it! So enjoy this chapter!
ALICE

"So Jeff doesn't know you're here?" I ask looking at the three intruders sitting casually in my living room. I pull my knees up to my chest and rap my arms around my legs.

Eyeless Jack is the first to speak up, "No, he doesn't and if it weren't for Toby's impulsiveness we wouldn't be here," he shoots and annoyed look at the… twitching… boy. He continues as I eye the twitching murderer in front of me. "I am truly sorry for the intrusion."

I peel my eyes away from the boy and say, "So why did you stay all night? Couldn't you two have just dragged him away?" I lay my cheek against my knee and let my long thick black hair spill over my legs.

"They were as curious as I was to see the beauty Jeff has been keeping to himself!" Toby opens his mouth before Jack. My eyes dart back to Toby then to Masky. 'The masked one hasn't said anything for a while.'

"So what is his deal," I nod toward Masky, "He hasn't said a word since I woke up."

"Oh! He's just shy!" Toby gets out again.

"Sure has a snarky mouth for someone so shy," I say narrowing my eyes.

Toby pipes up again,"That's just his defense mechanism, Jack comes off intelligent and I twitch."

"Oh," 'I guess these kids aren't so bad.

JEFF

I bust through the door and scream, "I'm going to kill you three if you've done something to her," but I fall short as I reach the living room and see all four of them sitting down casually drinking tea. "What's going on here?"

Of course Toby is the first to speak up, "Oh we were just having a drink with your lovely female friend," I see the corner of his lips perk up into a grin under his mouth mask.

"Jeff, how do you know where I live?" Alice asks uncurling herself from the sofa.

"Oh… Uh… I followed you home one night. I was going to kill you, but decided against it."

A look of confusion passes over her face before she says, "Well that's romantic." Her lips turn pouty and I can't help but want to press mine to hers and embrace her. "Glad you decided against it though."

Toby snorts before saying," You're way to honest Jeffey!" He almost skips over to me then throwing a hand on my back.

His grin annoys me so I punch him in the stomach, "Shut up! You guys are so dead."

"Aw, c'mon we just wanted to see your girlfriend you've been hiding," Toby grins even more.

A heavy blush forms on my face as I say, "Seriously shut up." I take a peek at Alice and her face is bright red. She's so cute.

"Uh… we're not dating… yet," Alice speaks up squirming.

"Aw, but that's no fun," Toby says.

"We are very sorry for going against your wishes, Jeff," Jack speaks up calmly but there's a faint hint of a smile in his voice. I scowl at the three of them.

"Leave," I say dangerously.

"Yes sir," Toby says sarcastically as Jack and Masky pull him out of the door.

"Sorry," Jack whispers.

I sigh after the door closes. "So…" I hear Alice's sing song voice and I look up to see her emerald green eyes glowing in confusion.

[Type text]