AUTHORS NOTE:

I know Andy isn't meant to be Casey's brother but for my story he is. Hope you enjoy the second chapter. Please let me know what you think, I would appreciate it greatly :)

Chapter 2 - Confronting Casey

ANDY'S POV

It was only the next day from finding out the truth about Dad that I wanted to get this news out in the open. When Josh had left for school I grabbed the baby photo of Casey and shoved it into my wallet. I couldn't help but smirk to myself as I headed over to the gym to put my plan of destroying the Braxton's lives into play just like they had done to us.

I knew it wouldn't take much as Casey was such a push over and so sensitive. He relied on his brothers for everything. Boy was I going to love wallowing in their misery. I still couldn't believe my Dad could stoop so low as going with Cheryl Braxton. It made my blood boil.

NORMAL POV

Andy walked into the gym and saw Casey helping out a customer. Casey noticed Andy glaring at him and he knew he was trouble from what Brax and Kyle would come home and brag about Andy coming into the restaurant and causing a stir. Casey approached Andy.

"What do you want Andy?" Casey asked.

Andy looked around with a smirk. "Ah I dunno, maybe I want to use the equipment, maybe I don't."

"Andy if you're not here to work out stop wasting my time and get out." Casey said firmly.

"Ah why the hostility...after all we are family." Andy laughed.

Casey stood back stunned. "What are you talking about?" Casey questioned. Andy laughed again and ignored Casey.

"Andy just leave, you have no real reason to be here. I have better things to do than stand here arguing with you." Casey pushed in a more firm tone.

"Ah but I do have a reason." Andy smirked and walked around the gym equipment taunting Casey.

Casey was beginning to get annoyed and just wanted to get on with his work, but Andy was making it hard and he did not want to start a fight and ruin his professionalism.

"Well what is your reason Andy?" Casey questioned, facing Andy and folding his arms.

Andy pulled the photo out of his pocket. "This...Remind you of someone?" Andy laughed. "Little bro."

Casey stared at the picture and knew it was him. "That's me." He said stunned.

"Yeah...smart aren't ya?" Andy taunted.

"What are you doing with a picture of me?" Casey demanded.

"Wouldn't you like to know?" Andy teased and went to turn away but felt Casey shove him annoyed.

"Stop messing around Andy! Why do you have a baby picture of me? What do you want?" Casey yelled, thankfully all of the customers had left by now so no-one saw Casey confronting Andy.

"Well...I guess I can tell ya...I have this picture of you because it was found in my Dad's belongings and do you know why that is?" Andy said moving in closer to Casey.

Brax had arrived at the gym where he was meeting Casey after work. He was surprised to see Andy talking to Casey and squinted his eyes to concentrate on listening.

Andy leaned towards Casey's ear. "Turns out you're not a Braxton. Ya Mum had it off with my Dad and then along came you." Andy whispered in an evil tone and pulled away laughing.

Casey didn't know what to feel, he was numb. This couldn't be true.

"You're lying!" Casey yelled. This alerted Brax and he moved in closer.

"Do you really think I want any relation to you at all Casey? I hate that we share the same father. I wouldn't mess around with this." Andy taunted.

Anger grew inside Casey and he shoved Andy hard. "Get out! Get out!" Casey yelled.

Casey started punching at Andy and Andy fought back. Brax quickly intervened and forced Casey off Andy.

"Casey! Casey! Leave it!" Brax shoved Casey away.

Andy felt his bleeding lip and laughed at Casey's reaction. It was exactly how he wanted it.

"This is priceless." Andy laughed. Brax glared at Andy. "Get out of here!"

Brax turned back to Casey who had shut down and stared at Andy. "Case, you okay? What was that about?" Brax asked concerned as he held a hand on his shoulder.

Casey didn't answer and only pushed Brax off and stormed out of the gym. "Casey?" Brax called as he was left baffled.

Brax stormed up to Andy. "What the hell are you doing here? Ain't it bad enough you've come into my town causing trouble you have to start fights with my brother?" Brax yelled.

Andy scoffed at the comment. "Hey I'm just having some fun, spreading the news."

"What news?" Brax demanded.

"Awe nothing, just that Casey ain't ya brother like you though he was." Andy explained.

"What? Don't you go around saying garbage like that!" Brax yelled.

"See for yourself if ya don't believe me." Andy gave an evil smile and showed Brax the photo.

Upon seeing the photo in Andy's hand Brax snatched it away. "This is Casey! What gave you the right to have a photo of Casey?" Brax yelled.

Andy laughed so Brax gripped his shirt tight. "Answer me!"

"It ain't my photo. It was found in my Dad's belongings...so yep that means Casey is the spawn of my Dad and your Mum." Andy said smugly.

Brax glared at Andy, not wanting to believe it was true, surely it was some sick joke he was playing to stir up trouble, there was no question that Casey was not his full brother.

"Get out and stay away from this family!" Brax ordered in a death tone.

Andy smirked and left the gym, with Brax watching him fiercely as he left. Brax stood staring at the photo. Brax shoved the photo into his jeans and stormed out.

Brax saw Casey outside the surf club staring at the waves. Brax gently touched his arm. "Case?"

"Brax that can't be true. It just can't." Casey said in shock.

"Yeah I know mate. Look why don't we go and talk to Mum and sort this out?" Brax suggested, only having Casey turn around and glare at him.

"What? You really believe all this?" Casey demanded.

Brax sighed not knowing what to say and that gave Casey his answer. Casey huffed and stormed off but Brax grabbed him.

"Hey Case, stop. Come on. I don't want to believe it, I swear, but we need to get answers." Casey sighed, still too much in shock to really fight.

Brax pulled Casey towards his car and the two headed towards Cheryl's house back in Mangrove River to confront the truth.