A/N: I only own the OC.
Thank you for the reviews!
Adult content... enjoy.
I wanted to leave, but Karl was having fun. I knew that he needed these night some times so I avoided Finn for the rest of the night. I had been texting Dash, and telling him things were ok, because I didn't want him to just show up at Finn's. I knew that could go wrong in a whole lot of ways since most of the guys were were NJPW Bullet Club guys and best friends with Finn. I was talking to Tonga and Luke most of the night until I realized that it was 1 am and Karl had fallen asleep on Finn's couch. I really wanted to wake his ass up and go home, but I knew that I shouldn't just because I didn't want to be here. Finn still had a few friends over, so I resigned myself that we were staying here, grabbed a beer, and walked out to the small pier that was behinds Finn's house. I was drinking and listening to nature. I could actually see the stars and the moon.
"You look like you are trying out for a Disney princess part." Tonga said as he walked up and I laughed.
"Thanks, but I just prefer this better." I said and he nodded as he sat beside me. Tonga was the one I had a crush on, but he got married to a wonderful girl; I was always just going to be Karl's little sister.
"Or you are avoiding Finn." he said and I chuckled as he opened one of the beers I brought.
"Why would you say that?" I asked him and he smirked.
"Because it's obvious... he keeps looking at you or for you, and you keep running far away from him." he said and I sighed.
"We aren't really friends anymore... or ever I don't guess. I am just here for Karl." I admitted and he nodded.
"I am surprised you guys were ever friends. He has been in love with you for years." he said and I looked at him surprised.
"No." I said and shook my head as he laughed at me.
"You can deny it all you want, but you can't change his feelings. He has always liked you. I thought he was dating you instead of that Cathy idiot when he said someone from the WWE." he said and I didn't have much to say.
"He is an asshole to me." I said and he smirked.
"You remember in school when boys would pick on you and it usually meant they like you?" he asked me and I sat there... it clicked. He was jealous of Dash.
"No..." I said and he chuckled.
"He is so hot and cold though... he doesn't know how to talk to a woman." I said and he chuckled.
"I forget how to talk to my wife, even after all these years, because she blows me away daily." he said and I smiled because that was such a nice thing to say. Tonga really did cherish his wife, and I wanted something like that. I wanted to be like Karl and Tini.
"I just wish that he wouldn't turn everything into fucking." I admitted as Tonga roared with laughter. I kind of chuckled to, but it was like his defense mechanism.
"It's a defense thing... if I can get sex with nothing attached then ok, but if I have to get attached it may not be worth it. You know this can be a lonely career, so get the attention while you can." he said and I shook my head.
"You do that?" I asked him and he shook his head.
"Hell no, I love my wife. My wife is worth much more than one one night stand. You just have to find that person that I worth more than that." he said and I nodded. I was surprised, but it certainly made sense. We talked a little bit longer before we got up to leave. I sat there and thought about everything he had said, and he was right. I could see it all now, but from what I had seen Finn still wasn't the person that I wanted right now. I heard footsteps and figured it was Tonga looking for more beer.
"I'm out of beer, Tonga, you drank them all." I said and I heard a familiar chuckle. I turned to see Finn walking up holding a six pack. I shook my head as he sat down and offered me another beer. I looked at it and took it... if he was going to sit this close then I was going to need something. We were sitting there as lightening was hitting in the distance and the faint sound of thunder was far away.
"Tonga said you were out here trying out to be a Disney princess." he said and I smirked.
"I'm just out here because it's more comfortable that being in there." I admitted and he sighed as he opened a beer. I was surprised when we sat there and didn't say a word. I had many good memories with Finn, but many more bad ones. He was so hot and cold to me.
"I am sorry if I came on strong earlier, but that doesn't change my feelings." he said and I sighed... there it was the elephant in the room that we were addressing.
"It doesn't change the fact that I have a boyfriend either." I said back and I heard the can crush under his grip a little.
"You can do better." he mumbled.
"I know, and I know that I can do worse, but I am happy where I am now. I know how you feel about me, but you haven't really considered my feelings towards you, Finn. I value you because I have seen you be a good person, you are my brothers best friend, but I can't ignore the fact that you used to be a man whore. You are known to not have a lot of lasting relationships, and that scares me more than anything. You were already in bed with someone else before you had gotten your stuff out of Cathy's place. You are amazingly funny, gorgeous, and a nice person... but you aren't someone I want to date. I can't be with someone whom I always worried will be looking for the next best thing, or a quickie. I want a love that will last a lifetime, not a fuck that will a good time." I said and laid it all out there. He was looking at the water and nodded.
"I can do that." he said and I chuckled.
"Finn, I have a boyfriend... who cares for me, and I care for him. I really like him, and I'm sorry that you don't understand that. I am not going to break up with him because you admitted how you feel about me. I wouldn't expect you to do the same." I said and stood up. He quickly stood up and I started to walk away, but he grabbed my wrist.
"I know there is something between us." he said and I gently pulled my wrist from him.
"Lust isn't something I want to be between me and the love of my life." I said and he started to walk away. I heard him behind me as I walked back to his house. Karl was still asleep and I sighed.
"There is a guest bedroom." he said and I shook my head no.
"I will call Uber." I said and he sighed.
"Just stay Leela. I'm not going to come after you." he said and motioned for me to follow him. I looked to see that it was now past 2:30am and knew that I really didn't want to fall asleep in the back of an Uber. I finally relented and followed him, but all the guest rooms were taken with drunk people passed out everywhere.
"Fine, come on." he said and pulled me with him. He pushed me into his bedroom and I shook my head.
"No, you need to sleep." I said and turned to leave, but he stopped me.
"I can be an adult." he said and looked at me. I was so tired that I was willing to just agree to get some sleep. I finally relented and accepted a t-shirt to wear. I changed in his bathroom and came out to him coming out of the closet. He was in boxer briefs. He really did look good.
"What side of the bed do you like?" I asked him and he shook his head.
"I usually sleep in the middle, by myself." he said and I nodded as I crawled onto the side that was closest to me. He crawled under the covers as thunder sounded overhead. I hated thunderstorms as I felt his hand rub over my back.
"You aren't alone." he whispered and I nodded as he kept rubbing my back, but the thunder was growing louder as the lightening lit up the room. I wasn't scared of thunderstorms, but I wasn't a fan of them. He finally wrapped an arm around me and pulled me flush against him.
"It's ok, Leela... I won't let anything happen to you. I have liked you for too long to stop protecting you now." he whispered and I looked over my shoulder at him. He was looking down at me. I was looking at him as lightening lit up the room; he slowly pressed his lips to mine, and I couldn't resist him anymore.
I shifted in his arms as he carefully hovered over me. I slid my hands up his arm as his one hand wandered down my side.
"I can't be a one night stand." I said when I broke the kiss and he started to drag wet kisses down my neck. I moaned at the feeling as I felt him bunch the shirt up at my waist.
"You won't ever be just a one night stand for me... I want you for a lifetime." he said and I was taken back as he leaned back to look at me. He got ready to say something, but I knew he was right... there was something between us. I pulled his lips back to mine as he pushed the shirt up and squeezed my breast. I arched my back into his touch and moaned.
"You are so fucking beautiful." he mumbled against my lips as he kissed down my throat and started down between my breast.
I let me hands slide down his defined muscles and he grunted in response as his kissed went from my stomach to my breast. I gasped when I felt his tongue flick over my nipple. He bit it lightly as I ran my hands under the waist band of his boxers. He pulled away and sat up a little. He tugged on my shirt, and I sat up and as he pulled it over my head with one quick tug. He kissed me again as I pushed on his briefs. He rid himself of them and laid back down next to me as I turned to kiss him. He was intoxicating to me. He began to kiss down my neck as I ran my hand lightly over his shaft. He growled and nipped at my neck in response. I gasped as I felt his hand tug on my bottoms and I let go of him to scoot them off. They were discarded quickly as he pushed me to lay back. I did as he kissed me and his fingers lightly slid over my opening. I gasped as he gently slipped two fingers inside and he chuckled against my lips. My breathing instantly picked up, and my eyes slipped shut.
"Does that feel good?" he asked me and I opened my eyes to see him watching me. I was biting my lip and gripped the sheets with one hand. I nodded and he kissed me again. He continued to kiss me as his fingers worked magic. I moaned loudly when his thumb pressed against my clit and I was squeezing my thighs to draw his hand closer to me.
"I got you, Leela. I'm not going to tease you." he whispered as his fingers started to curl up. He kissed me as I moaned loudly and felt myself coat his fingers. I whimpered at the lost of contact with him. He pulled them out and stuck them into his mouth. I was surprised as he let out a small moan on pleasure before crawling on top of me.
"You taste so sweet." he said and I didn't have time to react as he placed a kiss to my inner thigh.
"I'm going to make sure you taste good." he mumbled against the other as his beard tickled and I bit my lip. I gasped when his tongue slid over my opening and my hands dove into his shot locks. He was making small humming noises as I arched my back and tried to squeeze my thighs to keep him in place. My breathing was erratic as he was teasing me when I felt his teeth graze over my clit. I started to scream when his hand clamped over my mouth.
"Shh... Leela..." he said as he slipped two fingers into my mouth. I let my eyes slip closes as I sucked on them while he brought me closer to another orgasm. He finally slipped two fingers inside again and my whole body shook as he kissed up my stomach.
"Are you ready?" he asked me as he pulled his finger out of my mouth and places his hands next to my head.
"I didn't get to make you feel good?" I whispered and he chuckled as he dropped kisses up my neck.
"Tonight is about you, love." he whispered as I felt him move. I heard him rustling with a condom as thunder shook the house. I heard him roll it on as he hovered back at my entrance.
"Are you sure?" he asked me and I leaned up to kiss him.
"Please." was all I said as his tip pressed against me. I expected him to rush into it, but instead he slowly pressed into me. I gasped as I arched my back welcoming him into me and heard a satisfied grunt once he was fully inside of me. He was much wider than Dash as I adjusted to his size.
"You ok?" he asked me and I nodded as I kissed him. He was caring, and now rushing this... he wanted me to feel good.
"Please fucking move." I begged him and he chuckled as a hand slid down to pull my legs up higher on his hip as he started at a lazy pace. He was sucking and nipping on my neck as our hips met each other.
"You are so fucking beautiful. I have always wanted you, Leela." he whispered as he kissed my softly. I took the time to roam my hands up and down his back, until I gripped his perfect ass in my hands. I squeezed and pushed him further into me as he groaned from the feeling.
"You want more?" he asked me in a husky tone.
"I want it all." I said as he chuckled in my ear before pulling all the way out and plowing back into me. I felt him lean back on his knees more as he clamped a hand over my mouth. I was moaning loudly into his hand as he met my hips with such force that I knew my orgasm was coming closer with every thrust. I gripped the sheets as he his finger tips dug into my hips. My eyes slipped shut as his hand stayed over my mouth and I arched my back as stars exploded through me. I screamed into his hand as my legs shook from the intensity. He wasn't far behind me as he thrust a few more times and collapsed beside me. I was left with a feeling of needing more, and regret as I listening to our ragged breathing and the thunderstorm outside.
A/N: Well, what will happen now?