A/N: I only own the OC.
Thank you for the reviews!
I woke up to see some light coming into the room and felt a body snuggled up to me. I glanced over to see Finn asleep with his arm draped over my stomach. I fought back tears of disappointment because I couldn't believe that I had let myself do this. I quietly got out of the bed, dressed, and slipped out of the room. I walked out to see that it was only 7:30. I hadn't slept much and Karl was asleep on the couch. I shook him and motioned for him to get up. He nodded and we left Finn's house.
"I didn't mean to drink so much." he said and I shook my head as I headed back to my place.
"It's ok, as long as you had fun." I said and he nodded.
"Did you?" he asked me and I shrugged.
"I didn't go for myself." I said and he chuckled.
"I guess you will be happy to see Dash today after I forced you to see Finn for a whole 12 hours." he said and i forced a smile. I had been fighting with myself over how I was going to deal with Dash. I knew that I could either tell him everything, and hope for the best... or tell him nothing. We made it to my house and Karl went to the second bedroom to sleep some more. I went into the bathroom and took a hot shower. I wanted anything that was related to last night off of me. I shouldn't have done it because I had a boyfriend. I don't know how long I sat in the shower with my thoughts, but I finally turned off the water when I realized that it was now very cold. I got ready to crawl in bed when I heard someone knock on my door. I was praying that it wasn't Finn, and he wasn't going to bother me right now. I looked through the peephole and it was Dash. I took a breath to steady my emotions and opened the door.
"Morning." I said and he pressed a kiss to my forehead.
"I wanted to see since you didn't get back until late last night." he said as I let him in the door.
"Yeah, we got back this morning... Karl was having fun, and I didn't want to drink and drive." I said and he nodded.
"I would have rather you been safe." he said and I smiled at him.
"I am going to go back to sleep. You can join me or we can do something later." I offered... knowing which I hoped he picked.
"I wouldn't mind a nap." he said and I gave a small smile. I locked the front door as we both crawled into my bed. I fell asleep in Dash's arms, but couldn't miss the feeling I had when I was in Finn's arms. It just wasn't the same.
Finn POV
I woke up the next morning and smiled at remembering the night before. I reached out for Leela, but I found cold sheets. I opened my eyes and found nothing there. I ran a hand over my face and sighed. I guess I couldn't blame her. We had fought against that for so long. I don't know why, but waking up and finding her gone actually hurt. She was the first woman whom I had fallen asleep next to that I wasn't dating. I had enjoyed many one night stands and left or made them leave once it was over, but Leela was the one person who I wanted to wake up next to his morning.
I got up and saw Tonga making coffee.
"You look bummed did your Cinderella leave on you?" he joked and I flipped him off.
"She really did." I mumbled and he looked at me with a confused expression.
"I was joking about Leela." he said in a whisper and I nodded as I sat down at the breakfast bar.
"So was I." I said and he sat his stuff down to walk closer.
"Did you...?" he asked me without actually asking me.
"I finally told her how I felt and things happened... and when I woke up this morning she was gone." I said and looked up to see his jaw hanging open.
"I am surprised that you told her, but I would be more worried about what Karl is going to do if he finds out." Tonga said.
"He's going to kill you." Luke said as he walked up and I looked at him strange.
"I saw her leaving your room this morning still trying to get dressed." he said and I put my head in my hands.
"Why didn't you tell her to stay?" I asked Luke as he sat next to me and Tonga started to hand us coffee.
"I knew it was either a mistake or something you two needed to figure out. I wasn't going to get involved in that. She woke Karl up and they left." he said and I let out a breath.
"I doubt she already told him." Tonga said and I knew that he was probably right.
"So, now are you going to after her?" Luke asked me and I shrugged.
"She has a boyfriend." I said and Tonga shook his head.
"If you love her like you seem to... then at least talk to her about it. She knows she has a boyfriend, and could have said no last night. You owe it to both of you to talk to her, but if she says no then that is it." he said and I knew that she was right.
Leela POV
I woke up later to hear talking. I walked out to see Dash and Karl talking about whatever was on ESPN. I changed and walked out as they both smiled at me.
"I didn't want to wake you." Dash said when I saw that it was now closer to 2pm. I nodded and Karl hugged me.
We talked for a little before Dash had to leave to meet Scott for something and Karl was going to work out with Luke and Tonga. He told me that Finn wasn't feeling great and wasn't going. I instantly hoped that Finn was ok, and knew that I needed to talk to him. We had to figure out what was going on.
I left and headed for his house. I knew that I needed to just get this out of the way. We would only make things worse if we didn't talk about it. I knocked on the front door and a half dress woman opened the door. I was glad I hadn't just walked in.
"What do you want?" she asked me.
"I... um... needed to talk to Finn. I forgot something last night from the party." I said and she shook her head.
"We were about to shower." she said and I felt my stomach sink.
"Oh, well, I didn't mean to bother you all. I can get it back later... just tell him that Leela stopped by and it was good to know that she was right." I said and the girl nodded before I made it back to my car. I felt tears threaten to fall as I sped back to my apartment.
Finn POV
I walked into the foyer as Christina shut the door.
"Put some clothes on." I said and she smirked. She was Luke's fuck piece from last night and I didn't want to see her like that.
"Oh, Leela just stopped by." she said and I quickly turned around.
"Where is she?" I asked her and she pointed to the door.
"She left when I told her we were all getting in the shower." she said and I ran a hand over my face. I knew that there was no way she didn't take that wrong... it didn't sound right.
"She said that she would talk to you later and that she was happy to know that she was right." she said as I grabbed my keys and slipped on sandals.
"Luke, I'm leaving... get rid of her." I said to him and pointed at her. She gasped, but as I was leaving she was being told to get out. I sped off towards her apartment and hoped that I could talk to her.
Karl POV
I got done working out and was back at Leela's apartment. I was getting some water when Leela came busting in the door and had tears streaming down her face.
"Leela." I said as she sank down the door crying.
"What happened?" I asked her as I pulled her off the floor and to the couch.
"I fucked up." she said between sobs. I let her cry and grabbed a towel for her as she sat there upset and shaking. I was going to kill who ever upset her.
"What happened? I can fix it." I said and she shook her head.
"I should have listened to you." she said and I pulled her in for a hug.
"It's ok, it's fixable." I said and she looked at me.
"I did something dumb." she said and I nodded.
"What did you do?" I asked her.
"Finn told me that he liked me, and one thing lead to another... I slept with him. I went talk to him this morning, and a girl was there... she told me they were about to shower together... and I knew that everything he told me last night was a lie." she said as more tears poured out. I hugged her again and knew that no matter how good of friends I was with Finn... he was dead man.
A/N: Please review.