Jared doesn't know what to do, not with this Soul looking at him with Melanie's eyes, like he's the only thing holding her to Earth.
He doesn't get it. Because this Soul looks at him likes he's going to save her, like if Kyle tries to shoot her that he's going to rescue her.
Sometimes he forgets that it isn't Melanie anymore because Melanie used to watch him like that, like he could give her the moon and fix the world at the same time, make everything back to how it was before.
This Soul in her body has no reason to look at him like that.