Juliet agrees to Sam and Dean's plan but still thinks it's crazy. They all go over the plan again and figure out a few things, but certain important details still remain unknown. How do the boys get the wacky ingredients for the spell?

"Alright, I'll do it. Let's just hope this plan of yours works."

"Ok," said Dean, relieved that she agreed. "Now we need to find the ingredients. Does anybody have a forbidden fruit?" He said smiling. "No? Well how about a piece of gold from the calf that Moses destroyed over 3,000 years ago?" He chuckled softly.

They all looked at him with vexation. He could feel the mood tense up.

Dean shifted positions, "Ok... well do you where we could find any of these items?" He looked around the room and nobody said a word. "Ok look I know this sounds insane, but we have to do this, alright?"

Shawn, raising two fingers to his head, looked up and said, "I'm seeing objects, old rusty objects, statues, one of them is broken," he waves his hand in the air, imitating putting it back together. "It looks like some sort of animal, kinda like Gus if he gained 100 lbs and grew horns-"

"Shawn!" Yelled Gus. He punched his shoulder.

"Maybe a cow?" Said Shawn.

"Yes! That's what I said, 'gold calf from the Jesus period,'" stated Dean,"do you know where we could get some of it?"

"At the Santa Barbara History Museum. In the room right next to Zippy."

"Zippy? Who's Zippy?"

"My dinosaur I discovered."

"OUR dinosaur that WE discovered, Shawn, WE!" Gus explained angrily. "I was there and I helped dig it up. So therefore, WE discovered it."

"Alright fine, WE," Shawn smirked, " Bruton Gaster."

"Don't call me that, Shawn." Gus was getting annoyed. "You know I don't like that."

Shawn opened his mouth to say something but Dean cut him off. "Enough! Ok, enough! Gesh you two are acting like a couple of damn 8 year olds! Come on! This isn't Daycare! This is real-life monster hunting. Now cut the crap so we can get this done."

Dean stared at Shawn, who he could tell wanted to make some sort of smart-ass remark.

Shawn's expression changed. "Ok, what was that other thing? A forbidden fruit?" Tapping Gus on the shoulder he asked, "doesn't Woody have that Encyclopedia of Strange and Incredible Foods?"

"Yeah," Gus said, "he showed it to us last week during the autopsy of that one red head, what was her name? Celeste Middleton?"

Sam and Dean looked at each other in shock, With a look of sadness on his face, Dean choked up, "Cel- Celeste Mi- Mi- Middleton?"

"Yeah, why? Did you know her?" Gus responded.

"Yeah, yeah we knew her. Only in our world she went under the alias Charlie Bradbury. She was such a nerd but you couldn't help but love her," Dean felt a tear form in the corner of his eye. He wiped away the memories and continued with the plan. "So do you think that the book that this 'Woody' character has might have info on God's special apple?"

"I think it's worth a shot," said Shawn.

Pointing at Shawn and Gus, Dean said, "Ok, well you two go get that and Sam and I'll get the gold." He started walking away and Sam turned to follow.

"Wait, what about me?" Juliet asked.

Dean stopped and said, "you need to come up with a plan to get Cain, or- I mean Lassiter, alone and away from people."

Juliet, taking a long, deep breath, replied, "Alright, I'll get creative."

Dean smiled, nodded, and he and Sam walked out of the Psych Office and over to the Impala. Resting his hands on top of Baby, Sam asked, "what about the blood, Dean? The amount of blood we need would kill whoever we get it from."

"I know," said Dean, "but we'll cross that bridge when we get there. Don't worry Sammy, we'll think of something."