Sam and Dean think it's all over. Cas will bring them back to their world and everything will be fine, if you consider dealing with the darkness 'fine'. Little do they know that Zachariah is alive and kicking. Looks like they'll have to stay a little bit longer than planned.

Sam sighed in relief. Cain was gone for good this time. He then rushed toward his brother and helped him to his feet. Blood still poured from his nose but Dean simply waved it off.

"I'll be fine, Sammy. Let's just tell Shawn and Gus the good news." Dean tossed his phone to Sam, who quickly dialed Shawn's number. He told him what happened and said that they would bring Lassiter back to the station.

Everything was going to be okay.

After arriving at the Santa Barbara Police Station, Sam and Dean let Lassiter out of the Impala and walked him inside. Shawn, Gus, and Juliet were waiting impatiently at the door for them, but Shawn was the first to notice their arrival.

"Lassie!" He yelled. Shawn quickly stood up, but after sitting for so long his legs were a little weak so he stumbled a little. Juliet and Gus looked up and when they saw their friend they arose, relief flooded through them.

"Oh Carlton!" Juliet sighed, "I'm so glad you're ok and back to normal." She wrapped her arms around him and gave him a hug.

Lassiter thought for a moment, "what do you mean 'back to normal'? What happened?"

Juliet didn't know what to say. She thought he would remember what he did. Remember how they saved him. "Uh - um..."

Looking at Juliet, Sam whispered, "Yeah he doesn't remember anything."

"Yeah I got that, "Juliet said sarcastically.

"O'Hara! What happened?!" Lassiter shouted. He was angry that no one was telling him why they were acting so strange and also a little bit nervous about what the reason is. Did I hurt someone, he wondered, or even worse, kill someone?

Juliet sighed, looking at Sam and Dean for approval of what she about to do. They nodded. She didn't want to do this but she didn't really have a choice. She knew Carlton would just keep asking if she didn't.

"Ok Carlton, "Juliet started, "you might want to sit down for this." She led Lassiter into the conference room and Sam, Dean, Shawn, and Gus followed.

After they all sat down, she took a deep breath and explained everything. Who Sam and Dean actually were. Why they're here. She explained the Mark and the spell and all it's crazy ingredients.

When she finished, Lassiter had a look of disbelief on his face, but his eyes seemed more understanding, almost like he knew it was all true, no matter how much he didn't want to believe it.

"O'Hara, I - I'm-"

"No Carlton, it wasn't you."

"But it was me. I tried to-"

"Stop it Carlton. Don't do that to yourself. It will only make it worse."

Shawn looked out the window of the conference room into the hallway and saw Woody walk by. He gave Juliet a quick kiss on the cheek and ran out the door to catch. Him up on the situation.

"Hey Woodster!" He called, but Woody kept walking.

"Hey Woodman!" Shawn tried again, but Woody still just kept walking.

When Sawn caught up to him he grabbed Woody's shoulder to get his attention. "Hey Woody, are you lost in your own little world or something? I've been trying to get your attention."

"Who?" Asked Woody.

"Are you ok?" Asked Shawn. Woody was acting a little weirder than normal.

"Oh, yes, I'm just wonderful, thank you," Woody replied uncertainly. He turned and quickly walked away. Zachariah assumed that 'Woody' must be the name of the vessel he was using, and that young man back there knew him.

As he watched Woody walk awkwardly away, Shawn realized something. That's not how Woody would have acted. Maybe he was just being paranoid but Shawn thought maybe the thing that happened to Lassiter is now affecting Woody.

At the moment Sam and Dean walked out of the conference room. "Well, Shawn, it's been fun but it's about time we head back to our own messed up lives."

"Uh yeah, sure, "said Shawn hesitantly.

"Something wrong?" Asked Dean.

"Uh no," replied Shawn, "Well maybe. Can the Mark affect another person after its removed?"

"Well in our world it released the Darkness which is affecting everyone, but I don't know how it works here, I don't see any dark clouds of smoke so I think you're safe."

Dean noticed a scared look in Shawn's eyes.

"Why do you ask?"

"Well I just spoke with Woody and and he seemed off. He didn't act like himself. I don't know maybe I'm just imagining it."

Dean looked at Sam then back at Shawn. "How different was he?"

"Well, he didn't respond to any of his nicknames, he didn't even seem to remember that his name is Woody. Also when I asked if he was ok he said 'oh yes, I'm just wonderful, thank you.'"

Dean was confused. That seemed like a normal polite response to him.

"No inappropriate jokes?" Asked Gus.

"Not one," Shawn answered.

"No awkward mention of a dead person?"

"He didn't even bring up his ex wife."

"Wow."

"Yeah. It was like Gillian's Island when the Russians thought there was a secret mission happening on the island so they sent Gillian's look a like to take his place. It looked like him, but it wasn't."

Dean and Sam exchanged glances. They were thinking the same thing. But it had to be confirmed before they did anything.

Suddenly Woody appeared around the corner, he was wearing a suit and tie this time, instead of his normal coroner's outfit. Fixing his tie, he walked towards the group. He stopped right in front of Sam and Dean.

Dean could tell this definitely wasn't Woody.

Zachariah tilted his head and smiled.

"Hello old friends, you miss me?"