DISCLAIMER: I UNFORTUNATELY DO NOT OWN ONCE UPON A TIME. IT WOULD BE TOTALLY AWESOME BUT I DON'T

THANKS SO MUCH FOR ALL THE COMMENTS! I WOULDN'T BE WRITING WITHOUT THE CONSTANT REVIEWS SO KEEP REVIEWING! IT MOTIVATES ME TO KEEP WRITING THIS STORY!

I STILL NEED MORE VOTES TO DECIDE WHO WILL BE SHIPPED WITH MORGAN. PAN OR FELIX! I NEED RESULTS SOON OR I WON'T BE ABLE TO PUT THE NEW CHAPTER UP

SO SORRY IT TOOK SO LONG TO GET THIS CHAPTER UP. I WAS SUPER BUSY TODAY AND IT TOOK ME A WHILE TO REMEMBER WHAT I WANTED TO HAPPEN IN THIS CHAPTER.

I'll shut up now. Enjoy this chapter :)


Last time...

"I want you to live here on Neverland, with me and all the lost boys".

"No way am I going to live with a bunch of lunatics, the very people who kidnapped and brought me here. You would have to be out of your mind to think that I would want to stay here".

"Cute, you think you have a choice. No one leaves this island without my approval and I'm telling you that you're not leaving this island".

"Really, who is gonna stop me. You may look threatening, but I'm not afraid of you".

"Even if you go home, what do you to look forward to; growing up, betrayal, being all alone? Or would you want to live here, where you never have to grow up and you'll have brothers to look after you".

"Two things, one, I can take care of myself. And two, my answer remains the same, I don't want to live with you or the other lost boys".

"You think I've been asking you. What part of you have no choice don't you get? Saying you're still being stubborn, I guess you left me with no choice".

"What do you mean?".

"COME ON OUT BOYS!", Peter shouted

About a dozen boys came out of the woods, including the one wearing the black hood.

"One way or another you will join us, so what will it be?".

"I guess you'll have to make me then. Cause I'm not going down without a fight".

"In that case, boys tie her up!", Pan commanded.

"With pleasure", Felix, the lost boy with the black hood said.

"I tried to fight the lost boys, but it was no use, I was outnumbered and couldn't win this battle.

"Stop fighting girl. Come to us nicely and we won't have to hurt you", Pan said.

"I won't stop. I will NEVER give up!", I retorted.

While Pan distracted me, a lost boy snuck up behind me and tightly tied my arms to my sides. Not fair, I have to take on over a dozen boys. At that point, while I was trying to break my arms free, someone tied my ankles together. I was defeated, and the boys had won.

"See now we wouldn't have to go through all that trouble of tying you up if you had just come quietly", Pan said.

"Put a sock in it".

"What a great suggestion", Pan snapped his fingers and a green bandana covered my mouth, preventing me from speaking.

"Mmh! Mmh!", I tried.

"Ah, much better, I like you better when you can't talk".

Pan and the other lost boys laughed.

I just shot Pan a dirty look.

Felix picked me up and slung me over his shoulder. Pan and the lost boys, with me in tow, began walking in the direction of Pan's camp. Great, so my adventure begins.


Chapter 4- The First Lost Girl

Peter Pan's POV

Finally, we got the girl and are bringing her back to camp. Felix was right, she likes to cause trouble. But, who doesn't love a challenging game. Turning her into a lost girl will be some challenge. She is more than capable of becoming a lost girl, but listening to what I say is the real challenge. She'll come around, they always do. She isn't the first to put up a fight or to disobey me, but in time she'll learn, and we have all the time in the world, this place is called Neverland for a reason you know.

We arrived at camp after a long day of hunting for our first lost girl, ever. Felix set the girl down, he seemed happy that he no longer had to carry her, I can't blame him, the girl was desperately trying to get out of Felix's grasp by squirming and kicking. It was quite funny actually, even though the girl knew she lost the game, she still tried to keep playing, despite her odds.

"BOYS! Meet the very first lost girl", I said.

The boys hollered excitedly, I couldn't blame them; she was the first girl to prove herself worthy of being called a lost girl, unlike other girls who were accidentally brought here.

I shooed the lost boys away, there was some business I needed to take care of, with the girl. I walked up to her and took off the bandana covering her mouth. It was time to have a little chat with her.

"Someone looks happy now don't they", I told the girl.

"Shut up", she said.

This girl was going to take a lot of time and effort, but one day we'll all laugh at how difficult she was.

"You know, I never got your name".

"It's Morgan. I did something for you now can I go home".

"You see, Morgan, you're here for a reason. You're the very first lost girl the shadow has brought back to Neverland. I don't think it's a coincidence; the shadow only brings boys to Neverland, or children who are truly lost. Wherever you may be from, there's NOTHING for you there. But here, you have a family, dozens of brothers who are patiently waiting to welcome their sister".

"What family? I'm trapped here because my so-called brothers kidnapped me".

"Listen, we can either do thinks the easy way, or my way, what will it be?".

"Why should I listen to you?".

"It really isn't your best move to do something that upsets me while you're tied up, now is it?".

"Just because you can make me become a lost girl, doesn't mean I'll like it".

"What you don't realize is that you're not the first to be difficult or to refuse to listen to me. You think all of these boys wanted to come here at first? They grew to love Neverland, and so will you".

I turned to find the two closest lost boys, I couldn't have are sister sleep with some precautions, now could I, that would be terribly rude and inconsiderate.

"You two, come with me", I said to the two lost boys.

I led them over to where I left Morgan. Her position hadn't changed at all, not that I'm surprised; after all she was tied up good.

"You are to make sure our sister is safe throughout the night. You are not to untie her, no matter what she says. Keep a close eye on her, she's trickier than you would expect".

"You mean to tell me that I have to sleep all night like this", Morgan said.

"If I knew I could trust you, you wouldn't be in this situation".

I walked away; I'd deal with her tomorrow. In the meantime I'm going to get some shut eye; I'll need all my strength to tame this lost girl tomorrow.

Morgan's POV

Why am I always getting treated like a prisoner here? Yes, I won't listen to what their leader says and I made them go on a scavenger hunt to find me, but come on, show at least some decency. I was getting tired of this, I came here thinking I would be free, not to get tied up by the lost boys and being forced to live in Neverland for the rest of my life.

I will figure a way to escape the clutches of Peter Pan. I don't want to go home, but at the same time I don't want to be a lost girl. Unfortunately, it seems impossible to achieve this goal. Lucky for me in Neverland, I will never grow up, which means I have my whole life to find a way to achieve my goal.

I closed my eyes; I had to get some sleep after everything that has happened today. Plus, who knows what lies in store for me tomorrow. Pan is definitely going to try to make me pay for all that I have put him and the lost boys through just today.

Peter Pan's POV

I woke up to the bright sunlight in my eyes. I knew I had to get up, even though I didn't want to, today was the day that I begin to teach Morgan how to be a lost girl. Man, today is going to be long; I will have to find a way for this fiery girl to listen to me and do what I say, easier said than done. This is going to be one challenging game, but then again, who doesn't love a little challenge to mix things up.

I got up and went to over to where Morgan was sleeping to wake her up. I dismissed the lost boys who had been watching her that night. I approached Morgan; I wasn't surprised to see her struggling to get out of the ropes, even in her sleep. I gently began to shake her, trying to get her to wake up. Her eyes flickered open, but she just rolled onto her other side, guess she's not a morning person. But who cares, she needs to wake up so we can actually do something productive today, instead of playing hide-and-go-seek with her.

"Come on Morgan, you need to wake up. The lost boys are waiting for us", I told her.

"In a minute. They can wait a little bit longer", Morgan groaned.

I smirked, she reminded me of me in the morning, but I would actually get up because I had duties to take care of. But I knew one thing for sure, she was getting up whether she liked it or not.

"Well you asked for it", I picked her up and sprinkled some pixie dust on us. I took high up into the air, and then dropped Morgan from the sky.

"WHAT THE HELL PETER!", Morgan shouted while falling from the sky.

The look on her face was priceless, I wish I could somehow capture her expression.

Just before she hit the ground, I swooped in and caught her. I would never put her, or any of the lost boys in real danger, I just like to cause a little mischief for them. This may have been an unpleasant awakening, but it works. I got to remember this for future reference; this would be an awesome prank to pull on Felix in the middle of the night. Just because he's my second-in-command doesn't mean he's off the hook for all of my pranks I like to play on the lost boys.

"So not cool", Morgan said.

"Oh come on. Who doesn't love a little fun".

"Falling from the sky isn't fun, it's terrorizing".

"Well, now that you're up, let's start training".

"Training for what?".

"To be a lost girl, you'll need to be able to survive on this island".

"I can survive on this island myself, I just don't know if I can spend another second with you".

I ignored her response. She was trying to play me by getting on my nerves. I know that kind of game, I'm a pro at this game and there is no way I'm going to let a girl beat me at my own game.

I untied her arms. "Come on, the boys are waiting for us to come to breakfast".

"Hey, what about my ankles, they're still tied up", Morgan said while rubbing where the rope had been tied on her arms.

"I know, that's because I want to ensure that you won't run away. As I said last night, I will give you the freedoms the boys have as soon as I know I can trust you. But I think you won't make any mistakes for me having untied your arms. Now will you?".

With that, I picked up Morgan and started walking to where the lost boys were eating breakfast. Of course, she struggled in my arms, trying to get free. I don't see what she would accomplish if she managed to get out of my grasp. I mean her ankles are tied together so she can't exactly run away. Then, an idea struck me. I finally knew a way to get her to join us.

I stopped walking and set Morgan down.

"Not that I object or anything, but why did you put me down?", Morgan asked.

"I have a challenge for you".

"Why should I accept this challenge?".

"If you win I'll set you free"

"Okay, what's this challenge of yours?".

"You must become a lost girl'.

"How can I trust that you'll live up to your end of the bargain?".

"I might not be the most well behaved boy on the island, but I always keep my promises".

"Fine, deal, when do we start?".

"You'll find out soon enough".

I picked her up again and continued walking to the fire pit, where the boys were having breakfast. Yes, I could have untied Morgan and let her walked herself, but what's the fun in that?

I walked up to the boys, of course while holding Morgan. Immediately, all eyes were on me.

"Boys, what should we teach our sister first so she could reach her full potential of becoming a lost girl?", I asked.

Things were shouted at me like archery or combat, but she wasn't ready for anything extreme, yes she had lots of fire, but I was unsure about her skills. We had to take baby steps to get her to where she needs no be.

"I have a better idea boys. Let's teach our sister how to have a little fun", I told the lost boys.

They all cheered in agreement.

I couldn't wait to see Morgan's face when she found out what the fun surprise was. This was going to be epic. I love me some fun, I boy will it be fun to show Morgan how to have fun like a lost girl.

Normally, with the newly arrived lost boys, I would immediately start training the newcomers archery or combat, but I knew nothing about girls.

Today is going to be the best day ever; I'm finally going to be able to give Morgan payback for all the trouble she had caused us when she escaped the grasp of Felix and Mark, the other boy who had tied her up the first time. She was a real challenge to catch and now this challenging girl is about to face a fun, yet brutal challenge of her own.


A/N What did you think of this chapter? PLEASE REVIEW!

DON'T FORGET TO TELL ME WHO YOU WANT SHIPPED WITH MORGAN SO I CAN PUT UP THE NEXT CHAPTER ASAP

UNTIL THEN BANDIT OUT!