A/N- Wassup? It is TOBN here a new chapter of What If! Look! I am actually updating these stories. I am so proud of myself :)

So anyway, before doing today's idea, here are some shoutouts!

MBAV Fan- I know; Jesse may being having a secret friend affair! I may or may not have a sequel to that in the future, but who knows. Just wanted to let you know. I may need an idea though. Anyway, glad you liked the chapter; I never really liked Jesse/Ethan, but you know me when it comes to requests :) Review soon Fanfic Buddy!

tomo338- I know; who knew Jesse would change? I put some sort of clue in that chapter that might lead to a Part 2...but I dunno. It seems sorta cruel to change such a nice ending...I ask for reviews to change my mind if you want a Part 2. Thank you for the suggestion! As you might know, I am using it as we speak! When you said "Smells Like Trouble", gears started to turn in my mind. So I thought of this! I hope you like it and review soon!

And with that, here is the idea! Thanks for tomo338 for the idea that made me think about the plot the whole day:

"Can you make another ethan/sarah fic based of my favorite episode: smells like trouble? Would be awesome if you include a little bit of bennica in there :D"

So I hope you enjoy this, especially you tomo338! Reviews are welcome!

Disclaimer: I do not own MBAV or its characters. Just this cool plot we call Fanfiction! I also don't own The Fault In Our Stars!

ENJOY!

What If...

In the episode "Smells Like Trouble", the spell didn't affect all the girls in WC High? What if there was no part when Sarah and Erica don't hate Benny and Ethan? More importantly: What if they actually had a shot of a romantic day with the vampires of their dreams?

Pairing(s): Ethan/Sarah and hinted Benny/Erica

"Dude, this is not going to work."

Ethan and Benny were standing by Benny's locker, Benny grasping onto a small bottle of perfume labeled "Dusk", the bottle glowing a hazy pink. Benny rolled his eyes.

"You don't know that! I worked on it all night last night. And I made sure I read the instructions. I was about to do the one that will make them hate us afterwards!" Ethan's eyes widened as Benny stopped him. "I did the other one that will actually work. Stop worrying E!" Ethan frowned. "So how long is this gonna last?" Benny smiled.

"Well, it is 9 right now, so it will last 24 hours. And it isn't that strong; they won't go all stalker mode on us. They will fall asleep at exactly 10:00 pm and will remember nothing the next day. I made it so we can have one romantic day with the vamps of our dreams! We could take pictures so we will never forget this day!" Ethan hinted a small smile. Benny's eyes fell on something behind Ethan as he smiled.

"Anyway, here they come. Look husky and cool." Ethan rose an eyebrow, and before he could protest, Sarah and Erica came walking towards them. Benny popped up his collar, receiving a smirk from the two vampires. Sarah smiled genuinely as she pointed to the love potion in Benny's hand.

"Hey guys, what's that?" Ethan's heart raced when Sarah smiled at him. Erica smirked. "Who cares. C'mon Sarah, we got class to got to." They started to walk away when Benny smirked.

"Fine. If you do not want to try Dusk perfume, fine by me." Erica's hair flew as she snapped back. Benny grinned; he anticipated this to work. He smiled at Ethan as he started to sound like a TV commercial dude.

"Dusk perfume: Makes the dead smell nice! Wanna sample vamps?" Erica nodded eagerly as Sarah hinted a smile. "Yes!" Erica squealed as she grabbed it and sprayed it on her and Sarah. They inhaled the sweet scent as Benny and Ethan smiled. It looked like it was working! Sarah rushed to Ethan's side as Erica stayed by Benny's side. She smirked a seductive smile that could make a man faint.

"Hey sexy." She cooed as Benny wriggled a eyebrow at Ethan's direction. "Why hello foxy vamp!" He said as Erica giggled. Benny tried to get Ethan's attention, but Ethan was too busy trying to stay conscious.

Sarah literally leaned on his chest, her hair's scent filling Ethan with a small smell of vanilla. Ethan was trying hard to stay awake without fainting as she smiled. His heart raced as Sarah giggled in the most cutest way possible.

"Hi Ethie-kins! You. Are. So. Adorable." Ethan smiled, trying to look calm when inside, he was literally on Cloud 9.

"T-Thanks. You look nice t-too." He stuttered slightly as Sarah pulled his collar so she and Ethan would be inches apart. Ethan smelled Sarah's minty breath as she whispered in his ear.

"Here is something else that will make me look nice." She whispered seductively as Ethan was met with the most surprising thing ever.

Sarah pulled him in for a kiss.

It was like it was in slow motion, Sarah's soft lips against Ethan's lips. Ethan was stunned at first, but kissed back. They pulled back for air as Ethan had beads of sweat dripping from his head.

"W-Wow! I mean...um..Sarah..w-would you want..t-to go to the drive in movie t-to see The F-Fault I-In O-Our Stars at around 7:00?" Sarah smiled.

"Of course! Ethan...I love you!" Ethan nearly fainted.

"M-Me too. I'll pick you up..okay?" Sarah nodded. "Of course!"

Meanwhile, right behind Ethan, Benny was with Erica.

"Erica...um...I know you may not be a geek anymore, but do you think you can handle the arcade tonight at 7?" He tried to sound cool, when inside, he was just as excited as Ethan. Erica nodded.

"Of course honey! I may not look like a geek anymore, but I am totally ready for a night full of games..." She pulled Benny close.

"Especially if it is a game involving you." She purred as she kissed Benny, catching him by surprise.

It was filled with emotions as Benny kissed back, not believing what was happening.

They eventually broke apart as Benny smiled a goofy smile.

"Whoa. You are a good kisser." He smirked. "I hope you will continue tonight beautiful." He added as Erica swooned. "You have a way with words Benny!"

Soon, the bell rang, ending the moment for Benny and Ethan AND their new girlfriends. Sarah smiled faltered.

"Aw. That is us." Sarah kissed Ethan on the cheek. Erica did the same as Benny smiled.

"We will see you guys at 7!" They began to walk away when Erica stopped. She turned to face Benny one last time and smiled.

"Oh! Here." She tossed the perfume, Benny quickly catching it. It landed in his hand perfectly. Benny nodded.

"Yeah..seeya..." Ethan turned to face Benny, who was smiling ecstatically.

"Dude. That so worked. YOU KISSED SARAH!" He exclaimed. Ethan nodded, eyes dazed as he stumbled a bit. Benny rose an eyebrow. "Dude, you are a bit pale. You okay?" Ethan nodded.

"S-She loves me... " He slurred before slumping against the lockers, unconscious.

Ethan fixed the tie on his white dress shirt. He fiddled with the pink rose in his hand as he heard the doorbell ring. He threw on his blazer and walked out of his room.

He rushed downstairs. His mom peered through the kitchen and smiled.

"Have a good night Ethan!" Ethan nodded. "I definitely will." Ethan said as he opened the door and gasped. He held on to the edge of the door to keep from fainting once more.

Sarah stood there, wearing a stunning pink dress that fell to her knees. She smiled.

"You ready babe?" Ethan nodded as he gave her the rose.

"Of course. Let's go!" Sarah giggled as she held the rose in her hand.

They held hands as they walked to Sarah's car, that they were borrowing for the night. Ethan blushed in embarrassment.

"I don't..um..I.." Sarah laughed.

"Oh right! It is okay; I do not mind driving honey!" Ethan nodded as his palms felt sweaty. He hopped in the car as Sarah took off.

They talked the whole ride, talking about movies, scandals, and school. Ethan felt more relaxed; this felt like a normal day for him and Sarah.

They arrived at the drive-in theater as Ethan payed for the tickets, drinks and popcorn. They drove on when the movie started.

The movie was emotional and sweet. Ethan almost cried when Gus died, and he soothed Sarah when she was going to cry when Hazel said her eulogy. Ethan reached into the popcorn bag to grab a handful of popcorn when he felt another hand.

Sarah's.

They both blushed as courage started to fill inside of him. He stared into Sarah's eyes as he leaned in and kissed her.

Sarah was caught by surprise as she kissed him once more.

They stopped, dazed expressions on their faces. Ethan looked at his watch.

It was 9:30.

Benny had said they would fall asleep at 10, so he and Sarah left to go back to Sarah's house.

They sat in silence as both of them thought of the kiss.

Ethan had regretted nothing.

They finally arrived to Ethan's house. Sarah smiled.

"Tonight has been..nice." She yawned a bit. Ethan nodded, knowing the night was going to end when Sarah fell asleep. He nodded.

"I love you Sarah. I really do. I loved you ever since I spilled my lunch on you that day. And I know you might not remember tonight..but know that deep inside...you are absolutely beautiful."

Sarah teared up. "I love you too Ethan. I always loved you."

Ethan got out of the car. Sarah blew him a kiss and drove off.

Ethan looked at the car, driving off in the distance.

And when he made sure she was gone, he threw his hands up in victory as he walked off.

Sarah walked in her bedroom as she slumped against her door.

She quickly called Erica when she made sure it was 10:00 pm. Erica answered on the first ring.

"We did good Sarah." Sarah blushed. "Do we have to forget?" Erica sighed. "I know. Tonight was magical! Benny and I played all my favorite arcade games." Sarah nodded.

"I cannot believe they thought the spell worked! It is a good thing Mrs. Weir tinkered the spell so that it wouldn't work. We will remember this night forever!"

Sarah exclaimed as she flopped on her bed. Sarah could tell Erica was smiling.

"Someday Sarah...we'll date the boys of our dreams...and we will marry them!"

Sarah laughed as she stifled a small yawn.

"I actually feel tired now Erica. I'll see you tomorrow." Erica's voice answered.

"Will do! Seeya!"

And with that, Sarah was met with a dial tone.

She sighed as she took one last look at the rose on her desk.

One day...I will actually marry Ethan Morgan...and I will remember it forever.

A/N- I hope you liked it! Especially you tomo338! Suggestions and reviews welcome, and don't forget to drop a review about if I should make a Part 2 of the previous chapter. It won't be an actual episode, but it could correspond to the previous episode.

In Fangs, We Trust