A/N- Wassup? It be TOBN here with a brand new episode to twist! Jokes!

So. This one is from Justme2491 who requested this...

"What if you did the "smells like trouble" part when the girls first get influenced by the spell and have Sara fall for Benny and Erica fall for Ethan."

Amazing idea once more! Thanks so much!

A bit of role reversal, now I do shoutouts! Ha...

MBAV fan66- Is that a idea I here? LOL! Yup. That is totally something I will do! You might have not meant it to be a idea, but hey! It inspired me, so you are welcome ;) Of course, it is on the waiting line, and I might just finish another one today, but who knows! Schedules are schedules. Thanks for the review fanfic buddy!

tomo338- You better! Or else...*death glare*. Jokes! Just kidding; your ideas are fantastic, and fantastic ideas take time ;) So glad you liked it. It even deserved "super duper"! Those are my favorite compliments :) Thanks for the review fanfic buddy!

Melbelle & 123456789vampire- You both had the same idea [sort of]! So basically, I am doing a Rethan in your honour next chapter! I dunno if you guys are the same people, but hey! You thought of the same thing, so I deliver. Thanks for the reviews!

And with that, let's get started! I hope to finish this before school. That would be awesome.

Pretend that there were no "I hate you!" in the end of this. That might just ruin it. So there is no hatred part. Okay? Okay.

Drop a review and make sure to...

ENJOY!

What If...

In the episode "Smells Like Trouble", Benny forgot a certain part of the spell? What if it affected Sarah and Erica in a different way? What if Sarah fell for Benny and Erica fell for Ethan? Would love blossom?

Pairing(s)- Ethica and Benarah!

Erica and Sarah spritzed themselves with the perfume. A thick scent filled the air and Erica and Sarah sighed in pleasure. That is when Benny's thoughts drifted to Sarah.

Sarah actually looked pretty nice. Her brown hair, her friendly persona, he could all in all see why Ethan likes her.

Ethan's thoughts however drifted to Erica. She was a sexy goddess if Ethan had dared say. Her eyes drew him in and her blonde hair was luscious, making Ethan want to run his hands through her hair. So he could see why his spellmaster's affection went towards her.

But if one or the other found out, their friendship would be ruined.

"Ethan..." Erica murmured, staring into Ethan's chocolate brown eyes. Benny gasped as Sarah pulled him in for a tight squeeze. Benny gasped; this was not going to plan. And it all hit Benny like a huge rock coming at him.

"Ethan. I may have forgot to put the hormone stuff in there. And since we both looked at Sarah and Erica...they may have been in role reversal."

Ethan gasped; this was exactly what he wanted, but why was he feeling so guilty? It was time to clear it up with Benny.

"Benny, don't take this the wrong way..but..I uh..."

"I love Sarah." Benny blurted out. Ethan's eyes widened.

"I-I love Erica." He responded. Benny grinned. "So maybe this worked after all." He said gleefully. Sarah squealed.

"Oh my gosh Benny. You are so adorable when you smile." Sarah gushed. Erica looked into Ethan's eyes, and saying nothing (Like the Erica she is) kissed him passionately.

Ethan gasped as Erica continued to kiss him as his thoughts raced.

Benny isn't in love with her any more...so I guess this means I can..um...

Ethan slammed Erica against the locker and started kissing her, running his fingers through her soft hair. Erica swooned once they were done, Benny looking at Ethan in shock. He grinned.

"Did not know you had that in you buddy. You got until midnight." He said, walking away with Sarah, hand in hand. Ethan grinned.

"This is going to be so awesome." Ethan stated. Erica smiled.

"You ready for a hot night?" She asked seductively. Ethan grinned.

"Yup. So ready."

Benny and Sarah were at the pizzeria, munching on some pizza and fries. Sarah smiled as she looked at the watch. It was 11:55 pm, and Benny enjoyed every taste and every second he had with Sarah. They went to the mall, the carnival, and it was splendid indeed. Benny pulled out a rose.

"I know you aren't really in love with me, but I can tell you this. Sarah Fox, I love you to deepest ends." He said truthfully. He pulled her into a kiss before she could respond, the clock striking 12.

Sarah's eyes dilated a bit as she zoned out of whatever Benny originally said. Benny winced; back to pretending to be crazy of heels for Erica. But instead, Sarah shook her head dizzily.

"What happened? Benny..um..why are we even here? My head really hurts." She moans as Benny rubbed her back.

"It's fine Sarah. We uh..just went out for pizza." He said, which wasn't a exact lie since they did. Sarah gave him a disbelieving look. She wasn't buying it, Benny could tell.

"Benny...do you think Ethan likes me?" Benny groaned softly; the statement wanted to make his heart shatter. He seriously didn't know what he was thinking. There was no way that Sarah would ever find feelings for him. And this is just a small piece of truth that proved it.

"I honestly don't know Sarah." He said as truthfully as he could strain. Sarah grinned.

"Because would it be so bad that I didn't like him?"

Benny stopped mid-bite of his pizza, a piece of cheese hanging of the cheesy pizza.

"Wha?" He said, his mouth half full of pizza. There was only one other person she could love. "You like Rory?" He assumed so; Sarah did not like him. Definitely not. But instead of saying her confession, Sarah laughed.

"No. Definitely not. No offence of course." She said between giggles. Benny laughed nervously. "So what? You like some jock?"

And that is when Sarah pulled Benny for a kiss.

It was passionate and so real Benny couldn't take it. He was amazed. Sarah pulled back and smiled.

"I saw everything Benny. You may have thought that I was under a spell, but really, I wasn't. Well, yeah. I was actually part of the spell. But my own feelings were used. I really do love you Benny Weir." Benny grinned a lopsided smile that made Sarah laugh.

"I do too Sarah Fox. I love you."

Ethan and Erica walked into Ethan's house, Erica dazedly walking into the house. She looked around confusingly as Ethan saw it was indeed midnight. Erica shot a look at Ethan.

"Dork? You..um..why am I in your house? Seriously. So weird." She said, throwing her bag on the couch. Ethan groaned as he waited patiently for Erica to leave. He knew it clearly; now to swoon over some jock whom she might be head over heels with. But instead, Erica plopped onto Ethan's couch in a huff. Ethan sat beside her in confusion.

"Aren't you going to leave and tell me that I am a boring geek?" Erica half smiled.

"I would if you didn't have to explain. Why did you and the dork put us under a spell. And do not deny it. Seriously." She said carefully, as she searched for signs that Ethan could be telling the lies or truths. Ethan sighed.

"All B's idea. And it role reversed, so you ending up liking me instead of Benny. But to be honest, we sort-"

"You know," Erica interrupted. "I really am glad you ended up with me." She said as truthful as she could. Ethan took a double take.

"R-Really? You aren't playing me?" He asked in surprise. Erica smiled.

"I love you Ethan. Benny is weird, Rory is annoying, so I naturally preferred you to anyone else. But those prefers may have turned to something way more. I am serious. I love you as much as I love Dusk." She rushed out. Ethan grinned.

"And I love you as much as I love Galaxy Jump." He said back, kissing her cheek. Erica grinned.

"Wanna play then?" She asked quickly. Ethan looked at her in shock. "You got Galaxy Jump?" He said in disbelief. Erica scoffed.

"I'm not that much of a anti geek. Let's go." She said. Ethan grinned as he watched Erica set up the video game.

Benny watched as Sarah talk animatedly about a musical and their new found relationships.

Ethan smiled.

Benny grinned.

It was a bit of a role reversal, eh?

But to be completely honest, they were glad fate turned them around.

It was nice to see a newer light to new love.

A/N- And that is that! Thanks to Justme2491 for the idea. Love ya!

Anyway, I hope you liked it! If not, I don't give a fuck ;)

Drop a review and thanks for reading!

In Fangs, We Trust