Previously on The Story of our lives
"Come in…" I shouted while walking out of my bathroom to find a soaking wet Quinn Fabray shivering in my doorway.
"I-I broke up with Finn…."
Quinn's POV
"Excuse me?" Rachel asked me with a shocked expression on her face.
"I did it, Rach...I told him about us and then I left him." I explained while walking towards her.
"You told him?" Rachel asked in disbelief, but the thing is she doesn't seem happy.
"Yeah...what's wrong Rach, I did this for you...for us," I said while placing my hand on her arm.
"I'm just in shock I guess…" She said while walking away from my touch.
"But you're happy right?" I asked.
"Quinn what did you think would happen when you came over here? I would forget that you broke my heart and then take you back with open arms?!" She snapped at me, making me jump slightly.
"Rach, you have no idea how sorry I am for that...it's just that being with Finn seemed like the easier option at the time…but that didn't stop me from loving you!" I explained to her.
"I never stopped loving you either Quinn, but I don't know if I can handle another heartbreak…"
"Who said that there would be another heartbreak?!" I snapped back in frustration.
"What if you change your mind?! And you decide to go for the easier option again!" Rachel shouted at me.
"Rachel I want you! Not Finn, how many times do I have to tell you that?! I made a mistake with Finn and you can't keep punishing me for it!" I shouted at her this time, not caring that this wasn't my house or that her dad was probably asleep.
"I want you to Quinn, but I just can't trust you anymore...not yet anyway." She said quietly this time.
"Rach…you can trust me, I'm never going to do that to you again, you have to believe me when I say that." I pleaded with her, but she just looked away.
"I'm not ready Quinn, you should go home…" She said, quietly.
"Rach…"
"Quinn, please just go home!" She snapped at me before walking into her bathroom and slamming the door.
(The next day)
Quinn's POV
I didn't sleep at all last night; I couldn't stop thinking about Rachel. I know she has every right to react that way, it's just that I thought that me breaking up with Finn would fix everything, I defiantly didn't think that she would just kick me out like that and then ignore all my calls and texts.
I stood by my car for almost an hour wait for her to show up, but there was no sign of her, so either I've missed her or she's not coming in today, I'm hoping it's the first one. As I walk into school, I go in search of Finn. I know that he's hurt but that still doesn't give him the right to run his mouth off. After a few minutes of searching, I finally found him standing with Puck, Santana, and Brittany laughing at something he is saying. In a panic run over to him.
"What did you tell them?!" I yelled at a confused looking Finn.
"Finn here was just telling us about this hilarious video he saw last night, this kid was trying to jump off the roof onto a trampoline and he missed and fell on his sister! Priceless!" Puck said while laughing some more.
"What else would I have to tell them?" Finn asked, smirking knowingly at me.
"Can I talk to you for a second Finn?" I asked, without waiting on a response I pull him away to a nearby deserted hallway.
"What do you want Quinn? What part of get out of my face, don't you understand?!" He shouted at me, before trying to walk away again.
"I know Finn and I'm sorry that I've made you hate me this much, but I did you to promise that you aren't going to tell anyone what I told you last night." I pleaded with him.
"That's all you want? For me to keep your dirty secret?" He shouted once more, not caring if anyone heard us fighting.
"Finn please, if my dad found out about this he would go apeshit and you know it…I'm begging you Finn." I said while taking a step over towards him.
"Are you guys like together now or something?" He asked, calming down slightly.
"No…but that doesn't change how I feel about her," I admitted to him while tearing up slightly.
"No don't cry Quinn, I'm sorry. I promise I won't breathe a word to anyone…" Finn said while pulling me in for a surprising hug.
"I thought that you guys broke up? I knew that it was too good to be true!" I quickly pulled away from Finn to find a hurt Rachel standing at the end of the hallway.
(That morning)
Rachel's POV
I'm not going to lie; I feel kind of bad for blowing off Quinn last night. In reality, I wanted to grab her and kiss her right then and there, but I was afraid. I needed time to seriously think about what was going on with me before I would even consider a relationship with Quinn.
After a long sleepless night, I've finally come to a conclusion about what I'm going to do about Quinn. It's not secret to either of us that we clearly have fallen in love with each other and she did end things with Finn, so I've decided to give her a chance. I know that she broke my heart but I also know that she's doing everything in her power to fix so I'm going to let her.
"Moring Dad and Daddy!" I said while skipping into the kitchen.
"Someone's in a good mood today...even after that rather loud fight with Quinn you had last night." My daddy said while taking a sip of his coffee.
"Sorry if I woke you or distracted you from your work." I apologize to both of them while still smiling brightly. "And to answer your statement, I am in a good mood today. Things are finally starting to look up for me."
"Does this have anything to do with Quinn breaking up with her boyfriend and confessing her love for you?" My dad asked keeping his eyes glued to the paper in his hand.
"Maybe...I was really hard on her last night, but after taking the night to think about things I've come to the conclusion that I don't want us to be friends anymore..."
"Why not sweetie? You and Quinn have been friends for years." My daddy interrupts me, making me shake my head and laugh slightly at his cluelessness.
"I want us to be together daddy..." I said while smiling like an idiot.
"What are you doing here then? Go and get your girl sweetie!" My daddy said while smiling at me. After giving them both a kiss on the cheek I headed out to my car. I couldn't wait to find Quinn and tell her.
As soon as I got to school I went in search of Quinn, I headed towards her locker but she wasn't there, then I checked the gym thinking that she might have cheerio practice but she wasn't there either. I was about to give up when I overheard someone who sounded with Quinn shouting. Quickly I ran towards the noise only to find Quinn with HIM, and to make things worse she's hugging him!
"I thought that you guys broke up? I knew that it was too good to be true!" I shouted making Quinn pull away from Finn quickly.
"Rach, it's not what it looks like…" She tries to defend herself.
"She was upset…" Finn said while taking a step towards me.
"No one asked you!"
"Rach leave him alone!" Quinn snapped at me, I can't believe that she's seriously defending this idiot.
"So you're defending him now! I knew this would happen and to think I was looking for you to tell you that I wanted to give us a try." I snapped at her, making her smile slightly.
"You really wanted to give us a try?" She asked softly while taking a step towards me.
"I think I should go…don't worry Quinn, your secret is safe with me." Finn smiled at both of us before leaving the hallway.
"I'm sorry I snapped at you…but you have to see where I'm coming from. You tell me that it's over and then I come here to see you all over each other." I explained as Quinn started to walk over to me.
"You were looking for me because you wanted us to be together?" She asked when she finally reached me.
"Yeah…if you are still up for it?" I asked nervously, I'm not used to having her this close to me.
"Oh, I'm up for it…" Quinn said before pulling me in for an amazing kiss, that I gladly melted into.