Can't Help Who You Fall For.
By WorkingGirl22
Summary
When Rachel walked into Callbacks one night, she meets a girl who takes her breath away and they begin to talk then they become friends that move in together at some point. What if Rachel soon realizes that she might having feelings for her after they move into the loft in Bushwick together.
Will they be just friends or will it grow into a romantic relationship. Rachel can be with a girl or guy in this story. She's not putting a label on it.
How will Kurt and Santana react to Rachel being with a girl? How will Finn be when he shows up months later?
Kurt will be in the Second chapter and in the story from now on. Santana will move in a little later into the story.
Rachel and OC romantic story with friendships on the side. I hope you all like this new story. Rated T in the beginning but it will change Rated M lated into the story.
Alright Enjoy.
In Santana's POV.
When Kurt told me about Rachel Berry might be interested in a girl here in New York? I had to come here and see for myself. Now here I was in Berry's, Simone's and Kurt's place and it was pretty good. Simone was the girl that was replacing Finn? She was not a New Yorker, a badass, drop dead gorgeous but she was also a great singer.
"Simone is it? let's talk and get to know each other while Grandma Berry and Lady Hummel are out for awhile." She looked up with her adorkable glasses on. God even with glasses on she looked like a badass.
"Yeah that's me and did you really just call Rachel grandma Berry?" She chuckled. God her laugh was angelic. What the fuck are you doing Lopez? your girlfriend is Brittany. Well it wouldn't be the first time you stole something from Rachel Berry.
"Is that a problem? I'm sorry if I offended your girlfriend or fuck buddy." She frowns. Oops I think I insulted her future love interest.
"We are not fuck buddies. I don't really do that kind of thing anymore. I'm more of a relationship type of girl. Are you?" She asked smirking at me.
Damn Berry found a badass chick to chill with. If I lived in the City I would be best friends with this girl. She seems cool.
"Now I am. Before I use to hook up with guys and my best friend Brittany. Now me and Brittany are doing the long distance relationship." She nodded.
"Me and my girlfriend in high school decided that it wasn't for us. We broke up two months later last year. She's in California and I'm here in New York. We fought all the tme, jealous of each others friends because we just assumed they were sleeping around with them. Finally it just got the best of us."
"That's not going to be me and Brittany. We're soulmates. We worked so hard to finally be together. She's my dream girl and I would hate for her to be with somebody else. She belongs to me. Nobody can take my girl from me." She just shrugged.
"Good for you and I'm sure she's a beautiful girl. It just didn't work out for me and Eva. It works for some people." I need to ask her what's going on with her and Berry.
"Enough about my relationship with my girlfriend. What's going on with you and Berry?" She smiles.
"She's very dramatic huh? Rachel's something else and she's kind of crazy." I find her crazy annoying.
"I know why your here. Your here to try to figure out what's going on with me and Rachel? why do you care anyways?" Why do I care? oh right me and Berry sort of became friends towards the end of the year rather I'd admit it or not.
"Because I've seen what she's been through since I've known her. She's all types of cray cray and more. But she's got a sweet side about her. And as much as it kills me to say this. I would call her my friend." It's true.
"I asked her out today while we were in the bathroom. No we haven't been hooking up." She could have fooled me when I saw Rachel in her arms.
"You two went into the bathroom together. You didn't have sex in the shower?" She laughed shaking her head.
"No I waited until she was done with her shower. I wouldn't rush anything. No sex. We haven't had our first date yet and I'm sure she's not ready for that since her and Finn broke up two weeks ago." Oh right I forgot that the famous Finchel couple were broken up once again. Hopefully for good this time.
"Your treating her right I'm hoping?" She tells me yes.
"Good Simone because I was a bitch to her in high school and I regret it a tiny bit. She needs true friends who are there for her. I'll be around again." I said truthfully.
"Let me ask you something? are you really going to be her friend now that your out of high school?" Wow I guess will change my ways a little.
"Yes Simone I will try to be hers and Kurt's friend now that theres no need to stay on top. High school is over." She nods with a slight smile.
Simone and Rachel were on their first date while Santana and Kurt were chilling out.
"So how are you and Blaine? still making the long distance work like me and Britts?" Kurt sighs pouting.
"I miss my boyfriend so much but it's hard not answering his phone calls because I'm working. Who knew this would be so hard?" Santana understood what he was going through.
"Can I tell you something?" He said go.
"I hate the University of Louisville. I'm grateful for the full cheerleading scholarship but it's not what I want to do for the the rest of my life. I'm doing this to stay close to Brittany but I just can't do it forever." Kurt didn't know what to say.
"What should I do?" He shrugs really unsure. He can hardly keep up with his own relationship.
With Simone and Rachel.
Rachel couldn't take the smile off her face. This first date with Simone was going great so far. They are at a restaurant that had vegan options. Simone herself was healthy but she wasn't vegan. Rachel didn't care. As long as she didn't make her eat non vegan food she's was fine with it.
"I'm surprise your not trying to convince me to go vegan." Rachel rolls her eyes smiling.
"Your allowed to eat how you please. I'm just sticking to my own food choices." Simone stares into Rachel's eyes and grabbed her hand.
"Are you enjoying our first date so far?" Rachel kisses her hand.
"Yes I'm really enjoying it because it's with you." Simone blushed and kept on talking and finishing their dinner.
After dinner Simone paid for their dinner. They walked out holding hands and kept on talking as they walked down the street.
"Where are we going?" Rachel asked looking around. Simone just told her to relax.
They made it to park and saw a little band there. "Come on were going to dance." Rachel whispered okay as she gets pulled a little more into the park.
Simone pulled her close and Rachel rests her head on her shoulder as they slowed together. Both girls stayed quiet. Simone sighs softly as they sway to the jazzy music.
"Thank you for coming into my life." Both girls thought.
Simone pulled back slightly looking at Rachel.
"Can I kiss you or is that too much on the first date?" Simone whispered.
Rachel answers her by pressing her lips against hers. Simone smiles against her lips as they slowly pull back.
"Best First Date." They said at the same time then laughed and went back to dancing.
Find out what happens next.