Can't Help Who You Fall For.
By WorkingGirl22
Summary
When Rachel walked into Callbacks one night, she meets a girl who takes her breath away and they begin to talk then they become friends that move in together at some point. What if Rachel soon realizes that she might having feelings for her after they move into the loft in Bushwick together.
Will they be just friends or will it grow into a romantic relationship. Rachel can be with a girl or guy in this story. She's not putting a label on it.
How will Kurt and Santana react to Rachel being with a girl? How will Finn be when he shows up months later?
Kurt will be in the Second chapter and in the story from now on. Santana will move in a little later into the story.
Rachel and OC romantic story with friendships on the side. I hope you all like this new story. Rated T in the beginning but it will change Rated M lated into the story.
Alright Enjoy.
Rachel couldn't sleep. After her date with Simone a few hours ago. She couldn't stop thinking about it. Santana was sleeping in Simone's bed. She felt a arm pull her close and she smiled knowing that it's Simone.
"Can't sleep either babe?" She turned her head smiling at her. She shook her head no.
"I just can't stop thinking about our date. That kiss was something else." Simone moves closer to her and cupped her face.
"Your so beautiful. You deserve the best in life rather it's broadway or a family. You deserve it all. I really enjoyed that kiss." Rachel smiles tiredly and closed her eyes.
"What are you thinking about?" Rachel opened her eyes shaking her head.
"Nothing just getting tired. I really enjoyed that kiss too." She blushed.
"You want to try it again?" Rachel bit her lip nodding. Simone sits up a little slowly pressing her lips against Rachel's. She deepens the kiss as they lay on the bed.
Rachel moaned softly so she doesn't wake up Kurt and Santana. Simone smiles as they kissed a few times. She loves that she made Rachel moan because of her touch.
"We should get some sleep." Simone whispers pulling away, seeing Rachel pout.
"None of that beautiful, we'll finish this in the morning. I want to take you on a second date tomorrow, does that sound okay to you?" She nodded tiredly.
Simone lays down next to her pulling her close. Rachel snuggles up to her closing her eyes and falls right to sleep.
Simone stared at the beautiful girl now sleeping against her in her arms. She moved some of Rachel's hair out of her face just watching her.
"I'm going to make sure your not feeling down again. You deserve to be happy. Hopefully I can make you happy." She whispered kissing her forehead then goes to sleep herself.
The Next Day.
Santana and Kurt woke up before the girls did since it was Saturday and Kurt had to get to work. They slowly walked over to Rachel's side of the apartment and peaked in to see both girls snuggled up to each other sleeping peacefully.
"Do you think they became a couple last night?" Kurt whispered to Santana while staring at the girls sleeping against each other.
"No Lady Hummel. They probably just got there mack on for a little but then cuddled together before falling asleep. Berry's changed from I've seen. I really don't think she's up for rushing things with Simone, this might be her first relationship with a girl." Kurt nods because he's never heard Rachel talk about being with a girl before.
This could be a brand new experience for his best friend Rachel. He's been gay his whole life. Rachel hasn't been or so he thought.
"Go away. Your too fucking loud bitches." Simone tells them in her sleep before snuggling more into Rachel's neck.
"Oops we got caught." Santana whispers moving away.
"I guess we should leave them be." Kurt whispers going into the kitchen area. Santana follows him.
"So what are you doing today while I'm at work?" Kurt asked making himself some breakfast.
"You hungry for some breakfast?" Santana nods tiredly. She really didn't have any plans.
"I don't have plans. Maybe I'll hang out with the lovebirds today. Did you ever think that Rachel would be with a girl her first year at college? do you think this is one of those straight girl exploring type of things?" Kurt shrugged.
"Probably I've never seen Rachel interested in any body but Finn or Jesse. Simone is somebody totally different and I think she should see where it goes."
Theres a knock on the door. Kurt walks to the door sliding it open. He sees a very pretty girl with jet black hair, pale skin, dark blue eyes, wearing skinny jeans with a green crop top showing off her very slim figure. She on green heels.
"Um hello can I help you?" The looked at her paper then looked back at Kurt.
"Is Rachel Berry here?" Kurt stared back at Santana who rasied an eyebrow at the girl. He looked back at the beautiful stranger.
"Um she's sleeping right now. Who are you?" The girl stinks her hand out.
"I'm Meena Carter. An old friend of Rachels, can you give her this number and tell her to call me when she wakes up?" Kurt takes the paper saying sure.
"Thanks um?" Meena says unsure who this guy was. She knew he was gay. Anybody can tell.
"I'm Kurt Hummel, best friend and Roommate of Rachel's." Meena nodded giving him a light smile.
"Alright bye Kurt." She walked away sighing. She'll speak to Rachel hopefully soon.
Kurt closed the door staring at Santana who walked over to him and takes the number from him.
"What are you doing?" Santana smirks.
"Giving it to Rachel of course. Don't you want to know who that Meena girl is?" Kurt sighs nodding. Santana opens the curtains shaking Rachel.
Simone and Rachel both wake up.
"What are you talking aborut Santana?" She hands Rachel the number. She rubs the sleep from her eyes before looking at the name and number.
"Where did you get this?" Rachel asked her.
"She stopped by a few minutes ago. Who is this Meena Carter chick?" Simone sat up now interested in knowing who Meena Carter was.
"When me and Finn broke up Junior year, I met her at the Lima Bean and we started hanging out. We became great friends then we tried dating but I still wasn't over Finn and she noticed. She told me to call her when I was interested in just her. I totally forgot about her. I wonder how she knew where I lived."
"She's friends with my best friend Ella. I've seen her around. She goes to NYADA. She's in her second year aswell. I get the feeling that I'm going to have to fight for your effection with this girl. She seems like the type of girl that wouldn't give up so easily." Rachel frowns.
"I don't want anybody fighting over me. I'm not even interested in her." Simone glanced at Santana and Kurt.
"Can you two leave us alone while we talk?" They both walked back into the kitchen area and had breakfast.
With Simone and Rachel talking.
"Simone do you honestly think I want to be with Meena?" She shrugged.
"Meena is gorgeous, her boobs are huge. She's everything a guy or girl would want." Rachel rolls her eyes.
"She's not who I want. Your the girl I want even if it was only our first date last night." Simone looked at her.
"You mean that?" She asked softly while running a finger down Rachel's leg.
"Yes I really mean it. I like you Simone and I want to see where this goes. You have nothing to worry about." Simone smiles feeling a little better.
"Fine you convinced me for now. So you ready for our second date?" She smiles nodding.
"Are you going to tell me what were doing?" She shook her head no.
"No I want it to be a surprise." She lays back down.
"Get your sexy butt up so we can start our day. Remeber you promised me a second date or do I have to do the date planning for today?" Simone groans opening her eyes seeing the girl she wanted staring at her.
"Fine your lucky I like you. I'll get my ass up since you find it so sexy. No to the date planning. Let me blow your mind with how much of a romantic I am. You can plan our dates when were offically together." Rachel blushed biting her lip.
Simone leans over pecking her lips before getting out of Rachel's bed.
On Their Date.
Rachel felt sick to her stomach. Was Simone serious right now? she can't be doing this right now.
"I don't want to do this. How could you pick this as our second date?" Rachel asked trying not to cry right now.
Simone stood behind her holding her by the waist and whispers in her ear.
"I'm going to be right with you the whole time. Do you trust me?" Rachel looked down from where she was standing.
"Look at me Rach." She looked at her fighting her tears.
"I haven't done this either. It's new for both of us. Are you ready to share it with me?" She looked at her taking a deep breath.
"Yes I'm ready." She smiles as they held onto each other tightly.
"Alright you two, you can jump off when your ready." The guy tells them. They were bungee jumping together for the first time.
Simone held onto Rachel tightly making sure she's good and ready. Rachel sighs wiping her tears then nodded.
They both scream when they jump down still holding onto each ohter and they feel relieved when their line didn't break. They were breathing hard and stared into each other's eyes not believing they actually did that.
"Are you okay Rach?" Simone whispered wanting her date and roommate to be okay.
"Oh my god that was exciting and scary at the same time." Simone laughed before placing a soft peck on her lips. Rachel kissed her back then pulls back.
"Okay I want to stop hanging like this." They were brought back up after Simone gives them the signal.
Rachel couldn't stop staring at Simone as they had lunch in the park in New Jersey where they went bungee jumping. It was still nice out. The first part of their date was life changing and excited all together. Finn would have never done that.
"I can't believe you got me to bungee jump. I would have never done that if it weren't for you." Simone smiled taking a bite of her salad.
"Isn't great to try nice things? who wants to live life doing the same thing everyday? I sure don't." Rachel stared at her in awe.
"You live so different then I do. I would have never thought of that in my life for a second date. I like living alot more." Simone grins.
"Don't worry it's more to come. I love being care free." Simone grabs her hand and laced her fingers.
"I'm proud of you for jumping with me. That was very brave of you." Rachel bit her lip.
"Can I plan the next date?" Simone thought about it then answered her.
"Fine you can plan the next date. It better be great Berry. I hate boring date." She gasped.
"Are you saying that I'm boring?" She shook her head.
"No I would never say that about you." She said sarcastically. Rachel threw a grape at her.
"Did you throw fruit at me Berry?"
"No." She lied before throwing another one at her giggling. Simone throws one at her and they both start throwing grapes at each other laughing and they run around having a great time.
Simone wrapped her arms around her waist stopping her from running away and is about to kiss her when it starts raining. Rachel screams and they get their stuff together and run to the train laughing while holding hands while trying not to get really wet.
Rachel kisses Simone in the rain anyways once they made it to train station not giving a damn about how wet they were getting.
Find out what happens next.