Can't Help Who You Fall For Chapter 8 Part 1, a glee fanfic

Can't Help Who You Fall For.

By WorkingGirl22

Summary

When Rachel walked into Callbacks one night, she meets a girl who takes her breath away and they begin to talk then they become friends that move in together at some point. What if Rachel soon realizes that she might having feelings for her after they move into the loft in Bushwick together.

Will they be just friends or will it grow into a romantic relationship. Rachel can be with a girl or guy in this story. She's not putting a label on it.

How will Kurt and Santana react to Rachel being with a girl? How will Finn be when he shows up months later?

Kurt will be in the Second chapter and in the story from now on. Santana will move in a little later into the story.

Rachel and OC romantic story with friendships on the side. I hope you all like this new story. Rated T in the beginning but it will change Rated M later into the story.

Alright Enjoy.

In Simone's POV.

I have to admit, going on dates with Rachel Barbra Berry is pretty interesting and amazing. She's nothing like the girl's I've been with in the past and that's perfectly fine by me. She's funny in her own way, she's an amazing singer and I know she's going to be on Broadway someday. She's got two dads while I have two moms(speaking of two moms, they want to meet Rachel.) Anyways, she's learning to stand up for herself alot more. She told me about her high school life and she's not the same person as she use to be.

She has her diva moments but I like those moments, there funny and dramatic and I'm not scared to call her out on it when it gets too far. Her friends are interesting and she gets along great with mine. Yes she finally met them finally. We aren't offically together but hopefully soon because I want to be able to call her my girlfriend, I want to hold her hand, kiss her, tell her that she's beautiful, walk down the street or at NYADA as a couple. But I'm not going to push her. If whatever we have going on, takes time then I have no problem with that, just as long as I get to kiss those soft plump lips of hers.

Santana left last week to go back to her school and work on her relationship with her girlfriend. We were going out tonight to have some fun.

"Do we really have to go to Callbacks tonight? I want to go to a real club and dance." I tell Kurt and Rachel while sitting on the couch playing with Rachel's fingers. Kurt was looking in the mirror staring at his outfit. Us girls weren't even dressed yet for the evening.

Rachel stares at me pouting. "I thought you liked Callbacks Simone? Besides Kurt has never been to Callbacks. I want to show it him. We have all night to go to a club."

I stared at Kurt, trying to ignore that sexy pout of Rachel's.

"Kurt Callbacks is a great club but it's nothing compared to actually going to a real club and dancing your ass off. Don't you want to do that?"

"Sure that sounds fun but I'm not dressed for dancing. I'm more dressed for singing and just chilling out. Can't we go to a gay club tomorrow night?"

This wasn't fair. I wanted to dance my ass off on a Friday night and they want to go to Callbacks. Sure it was a nice club but it could be boring. Besides I kind of promised my friends that I would meet up with them later after.

"You know you could always change, we not leaving for another few hours anyways. I think it would be fun. You two aren't in high school anymore. Your free to have some fun." I told them then stared at Rachel.

"Come on, don't you want to dance close to me babe?" I asked cuping her face with a flirty smile on my face. She stares at me pouting then glanced at Kurt.

"No Rachel don't give into her. I really want to have a chill night. We can get our groove on tomorrow night. Simone that's not fair." He whined.

Before I could say something, there was a knock on our door. Who knew where we lived besides my friends and Rachel's ex Finn. Was he back here trying to win her back already?

Kurt slides the door open and I see that it's a different guy wearing a bow tie. Was this the guy that Kurt was dating?

"Oh my god Blaine?" I guess I was right. Rachel gets up to hug him after Kurt hugs him. Blaine stares at me confused but I just give him a small smile.

"Oh right Blaine this is our roommate and Rachel's sort of girlfriend Simone Edwards." Kurt tells him.

Blaine looked at Rachel then at me surprised and walks over to me, sticking his hand out.

"Nice to meet you Simone. I'm sorry I haven't heard that much about you since Kurt and Rachel here are so busy to answer the phone." I smile back at him, taking his hand and shakes it. He seems nice.

"Likewise Blaine. Kurt here can't stop talking about you. I like your bow tie. Also don't worry about it. College and work can be pretty busy." I said to him truthfully.

"Thanks Simone. I just love them. I totally understand too. So you and Rachel?" I smile at him before glancing at Rachel to see her smiling back at me. God she's so beautiful.

"Well we're not offical but you never know right?" Blaine nods before walking back over to Kurt, giving him a kiss. I smile when Rachel joins me back on the couch, grabbing my hand once again, lacing her fingers with mine and I smile at her.

"Um I'm glad your here Blaine bacause we're going out tonight. You see Simone, going to Callbacks isn't a bad idea now. Kurt and Blaine can both see it for the first time. We can go to your club later." Rachel says after Kurt and Blaine pull away from each others lips.

"Um what's Callbacks?" Blaine asked us looking unsure.

"It's a piano bar that most NYADA students go to. You can sing and eat there, and drink of course. It's how I met Rae." She glanced at me with a smile on her face.

In Blaine's POV.

I stared at Rachel and Simone together as we walked into Callbacks. They seem like they really like each other but I know that Rachel is pushing back a little. Maybe the famous Finchel couple will get back together someday.

"Come on Rae, I want to see if you can sing first." I heard Simone say to Rachel as they walked away from us still holding hands. Or maybe not to Finchel getting back together.

"You okay? you seem a little- you know." I shook my head, giving him a fake smile.

"I'm fine really. It was a long rough flight." Kurt pouts rubbing his hand up and down my arm.

"Well I for one am glad your here. It was totally worth it. This is our first night in New York together. I want to remeber it." I smile at him. So do I.

"Yeah same here. I'm just surprised to see Rachel with a girl." Kurt smiles as the two as they talked to the piano guy. Simone's hand is around Rachel's waist pulling her close and whispered in her ear making Rachel glance at her with a smile on her face nodding.

"I know right. When I got here, I was surprised when she told me about Simone but I see them everyday and they seem like they really like each other. She's not putting a label on her sexuality. If she wants to be a with a guy or girkl then it's fine.I'm not judging her."

"I'm just surprised. Are you okay about Rachel with somebody else that's not your step brother?" He smiles at me.

"I don't have control over who Rachel dates okay. I'm just glad your here Blaine. Let's not talk about Rachel's new relationship or whatever it is with Simone. I'm just really happy your here in New York. I'm so glad I didn't have to be a third wheel to those two tonight."

I smile at him. He's just a great guy and I feel like I don't deserve him. We hardly see each other anymore since I'm still in high school and he's here. I can't wait for this night to be over so I can just tell him what's going on.

"Blaine are you joining us or not?" I sigh walking over to the table and sit down next to him. Rachel is standing on the stage and Simone is sitting with us with a smile on her face. I held onto Kurt's hand as we watched Rachel sing.

Hey, slow it down
Whataya want from me
Whataya want from me
Yeah, I'm afraid
Whataya want from me
Whataya want from me

There might have been a time
When I would give myself away
(Ooh) Once upon a time
I didn't give a damn
But now here we are
So whataya want from me
Whataya want from me

I glanced at Simone to see the proud look on her face as she watched Rachel sing on the small stage. I hate to admit this since I'm a huge fan of Finchel but Simone and Rachel do look good together.

Just don't give up
I'm workin' it out
Please don't give in
I won't let you down
It messed me up, need a second to breathe
Just keep coming around
Hey, whataya want from me
Whataya want from me
Whataya want from me

Rachel danced on the stage singing the next part of the song and everybody is enjoying it. She's where she's supposed to be.

Yeah, it's plain to see
That baby you're beautiful
And there's nothing wrong with you
It's me, I'm a freak
But thanks for lovin' me
Cause you're doing it perfectly

There might have been a time
When I would let you slip away
I wouldn't even try but I think
You could save my life

Simone is waving her hand in the air cheering on Rachel who smiles brightly as she sings the main part again.

Just don't give up on me
I won't let you down
No, I won't let you down

Kurt was nodding his head to the music and I smile at him before turning back to Rachel who was close to finishing up the song.

So
Just don't give up
I'm workin' it out
Please don't give in
I won't let you down
It messed me up, need a second to breathe
Just keep coming around
Hey, whataya want from me

Everybody clapped and cheered for her when she was done. She walked back over to us after her performance and smiles.

"Oh my god. That was so much fun. How was I?" She asked us sitting in her seat that was in front of Simone's seat.

"You were great Rachel." I told her. She grins.

"Yeah Rach you were fantastic as always Broadway twin." Kurt tells her making her grin leaning over to hug him then she glanced at Simone.

"Was I good?" Simone grins nodding her head. Rachel squeals wrapping her arms around her neck then she pulls back and kisses her cheek. Simone held Rachel by the waist after she turned around in her seat.

"Can I sing something or it for only NYADA students?" Both girls stared at me.

"Yeah since your with NYADA students. Just tell them what you want to sing." I say okay and get up walking over to the guy telling him what I wanted to sing and asked if I could use the piano. He gets up and I sit down telling everybody my name and what I'm going to sing.

After the small group left the Callbacks after singing a few songs. They walked around for a little bit before heading to the club to meet up with Simone's friends.

Kurt, Rachel and Simone were wondering what was going on with Blaine since he almost broke down in tears while singing.

"We'll just leave you two alone. Come on Simone." Rachel pulled her date/roommate away from the couple and smiles as they held hands.

"So. That was moving. I guess I'm kind of wondering why that was." Blaine sighs telling him that he really missed him and he just showed it.

"I missed you too. And I'm really glad you're here." He sighs as Kurt keeps talking to him.

"Yeah I know you've said that alot tonight." Kurt stares at him confused. They stop walking.

"I was with someone." Kurt stared at him

"It was Sebastian, wasn't it?" He shook his head no. They both talked close to tears then Kurt ran away from him.

Rachel and Simone watched Kurt run past them before glancing at Blaine. He was looking down.

"I'll be right back." Rachel gets up walking over to Kurt.

"Kurt what's wrong?" He looked up with tears in his eyes.

"Blaine cheated on me with some guy I don't know but he cheated Rachel." Rachel sits down next to him and hugs him.

Simone walks over to Blaine placing her hand on his shoulder.

"What happened just now between you and Kurt?" Blaine looked at her sighing and wiped his tears.

"I told him the truth." Simone sighs.

"So you did cheat on him? Trust me I know when somebody has cheated on a person. I've been through myself."

"What do I do?" Simone looks back at Rachel and Kurt to see Kurt crying on Rachel's shoulder trying to comfort him the best she could.

"I don't know if I can really help you since we aren't really friends but I will tell you this. Don't force him into forgiving you because he'll push you away. Give him some time okay. I know you two love each other but what you did wasn't cool. Being cheated on isn't fun."

"Now Rachel is going to hate me because I broke her best friend's heart. She's going to take his side." Simone sighs.

"You don't know that for sure Blaine. You two are friends too. She might not take anybody's side." Blaine didn't believe that anymore.

"Do you want to talk to her while I talk to Kurt?" He mumbles sure. Simone walks over to Kurt and Rachel.

"Um Blaine wants to talk to you Rae. I'll take your spot in comforting Kurt." Rachel looks at Kurt.

"Are you going to be okay if I talk to him?" He nods sadly sniffling. Simone kisses Rachel's cheek before whispering don't be too hard on Blaine. She sits down after that.

Blaine wiped away his tears once he saw Rachel making her way over to him. She didn't look to happy with him.

"Blaine I had such high hopes for you and Kurt. Why would you hurt him like that?"

"I was lonely. He wasn't around and Eli was just there." Rachel crossed her arms over her chest staring at him not pleased.

"So you were lonely and missing your boyfriend so you decided that the best way to handle that was to sleep with some guy name Eli?"

"I didn't want it to happen okay? but Kurt wasn't answering my phone calls and i just reacted badly. I regret the moment it was over."

"Blaine I cheated on Finn and trust me that was hell for me my Junior year. Going through the aftermath of that isn't fun. It's painful so I feel your pain but I regret it after it happened. Finn and I didn't talk for months and I had to see him move on with Quinn. It hurts badly know that your the reason your relationship is over."

Blaine sighs looking away from her.

"You're relationship with Kurt is something special. I see it and you two are lucky to find each other. Don't let it die." Blaine looked at her.

"What about your relationship with Finn? aren't you letting it die by seeing Simone?" Rachel stood there feeling uncomfortable.

"Finn and I let each other go because we knew it wasn't right anymore. We'll still be friends and you never know in future but right now it can't happen. You and Kurt still have time to make this work." Blaine was surprised when she hugged him.

"I'm not taking any sides Blaine. You two will work it out. I have faith in you." He listens to her and hugs her back.

"Thank you Rachel. I know what I did was wrong and hopefully he'll forgive me." Rachel nods pulling back staring into his eyes.

"I'm sure he will because you two belong together. Give him time." Rachel turns around seeing Kurt and Simone walking towards them.

"Do you two still want to go to the club with us or should we just go back to the loft?" Simone asked standing next to Rachel again holding her close.

"Let's go." Kurt says standing far away from Blaine. Rachel and Simone saw the hurt look on his face.

"Alright let's go then." Kurt wiped away his tears as they made there way to the club.

Find out what happens next and the song was What Do you want From Me from Adam Lambert.