Can't Help Who You Fall For.
By WorkingGirl22
Summary
When Rachel walked into Callbacks one night, she meets a girl who takes her breath away and they begin to talk then they become friends that move in together at some point. What if Rachel soon realizes that she might having feelings for her after they move into the loft in Bushwick together.
Will they be just friends or will it grow into a romantic relationship. Rachel can be with a girl or guy in this story. She's not putting a label on it.
How will Kurt and Santana react to Rachel being with a girl? How will Finn be when he shows up months later?
Kurt will be in the Second chapter and in the story from now on. Santana will move in a little later into the story.
Rachel and OC romantic story with friendships on the side. I hope you all like this new story. Rated T in the beginning but it will change Rated M later into the story.
Alright Enjoy.
At Club Starlight.
The small group walked into the club hearing the music blasting. Simone turned to Rachel.
"You want to dance?" Rachel stared at Kurt and Blaine seeing how they weren't even looking at each other.
"Are you two going to be like this all night?" Kurt shook his head no.
"No I need to dance." He grabbed Rachel's hand, pulling her to the dance floor and they start dancing. Simone sighs before turning to Blaine.
"I'll dance with you Blaine. It's a great for us to get to know each other better. I can dance with Rachel later." Blaine sighs.
"I don't know if this is a good idea. Kurt hasn't spoken to me since we left Callbacks. I think my relationship is over." Blaine says sadly.
"Come on anyways." Simone grabs his arm pulling him towards the dance floor.
"Simone come here." She heard somebody calling her name and saw Cree, Marlena, Ella, Jaxson, Jane, Max who was Jane's boyfriend and Esmee who was sort of her friend, waving her over with drinks in their hands.
"You go ahead Simone. I'm going to get a drink." Simone.
"Don't drink too hard, they actually don't card people here. Take it easy Blaine." He just waved her off and made his way to the bar.
Simone walks over to Rachel and Kurt whispering in Rachel's ear, telling her that her friends were here. Rachel nods and stares at Kurt.
"Kurt do you want to meet Simone's friends?" He shook his head.
"No I just want to dance for now. I'll be over later." Simone rolls her eyes.
"Kurt go to the bar and order a drink, they don't card people here so have fun but don't to crazy on the drinks." He nods shaking his hips.
Both girls laughed and walked away from him holding onto each other's hand. They made their way to the group and hugged them.
"It's about time you two showed up. Where is your roommate Kurt?" Cree asked both girls.
"He's on the dance floor acting like a fool. His boyfriend is in town, he confessed to cheating on him and now there not speaking to each other." Simone sits down and pulls Rachel on her lap.
"Are you two offical yet girls?" Ella asked hopefully. She liked to see her best friend happy and Rachel seems like the girl that would make Simone very happy.
"No we aren't offical yet Ella. We're taking it slow, there's no need to rush something that could turn out bad before it even starts. We're getting to know each other alot more and I'm not pressuring her into something she might not be ready for." Ella stares at Rachel.
"You okay with taking it slow Rach?" She stares at Simone and nods.
"Yes I'm very fine wiht taking it slow. You really can't rush it and sometimes I think that's why my relationship with my exs didn't work out. A relationship takes time and I'm glad Simone agrees to taking it slow with me." They all stared at them.
"At some point do you see Simone as a girlfriend type?" Jane asked her new friend.
"Hopefully at some point. But right now I think what we have right now is really good and I'm just going to enjoy it. They all nod and talk more.
"So what's the deal with Kurt and his man or soon to be ex man?" Jaxson asked. Jaxson was gay and had his eyes on Kurt, they met once.
Rachel leans against Simone's chest and smiles when she feels Simone kiss her cheek.
"Don't even think about it Jaxson. Blaine and Kurt belong together." Rachel tells him giving him a stern look. Jaxson scuffs.
"Not if I can help it. Later ladies. I'm about to get myself a new man." He gets up quickly before Rachel could say anything.
"You two want drinks?" Marlena asked standing, fixing her skin tight mini dress.
"Yeah you know what I like. You want something Rae?" Rachel stared at them.
"I'll have an amaretto sour, Virgin of course." Marlena stared at her.
"You sure you don't want a real one Rach? I could totally get it for you." She shook her head no.
"I'm sure Marlena. I'm not up for drinking until I'm the right age for drinking. I got drunk in high school and it was a really bad experience for myself. I'm talking all week drunk, evening during school hours and one my friends threw up on me." They stared at her surprised.
"Damn I wish I got to see Rachel Berry drunk off her ass." Simone says smirking at her. Rachel surprises her everyday.
"I'll be right back with the drinks. I want to hear more stories when I get back." Marlena walks away to go to the bar.
Rachel sighs wishing she never brought it up. She was still trying to win Finn back and it was just very bad. She even kissed Blaine. Not one of her finest moments.
"What else happened at your school Rach?" She glared at Simone and just pouted while the others laughed.
With Blaine and Kurt.
Blaine finally left the bar after three drinks. He saw Kurt dancing with some guy and that didn't make him feel good. He walked over to them and pulled the guy away from Kurt.
"Hey buddy I was dancing with him." The guy says getting angry.
"He's my boyfriend so back off." The guy stares at him and rolls his eyes.
"Whatever. I'll be back with the others Kurt." The guy leaves to dance with his friends. Kurt stares at Blaine.
"Kurt I'm sorry for cheating. I know it was wrong but please give me a chance to make it up to you please." Kurt just stared at him.
"I promise that I won't ever hurt you the way I did. Sleeping with Eli was a huge mistake." Blaine tells him.
"How could you hurt me like that? I thought you loved me?" He grabs Kurt's hands.
"I do love you Kurt. Your the guy I want in this world. I'll do whatever it takes to make you forgive me." Kurt looks at him.
"Blaine I just can't forgive you right. I know you were angry when I was talking to Chandler but that wasn't cheating, what you actually did was cheating."
Blaine stared at him tearing up again.
"I know okay? I hate myself for hurting you. Will you ever forgive me?" Kurt stood there unsure.
"So what's going to happen now? do we break up or take a break?" Kurt looked around him.
"This isn't really the place to talk. Can we go back to the loft and really talk about this?" Blaine nods.
"What about Simone and Rachel?"
"I'll go tell the girls that we're leaving and we'll just see them tomorrow." Kurt walks away and talks to the girls telling them that they were leaving and they will see them back at the loft.
He goes back to Blaine and they both leave the club and go back to the loft not really saying anything to each other.
Simone and Rachel really hoped those two work it out tonight.
"You want to dance Rach?" She just stood up, grabbing her hand and they went to the dancelfoor and danced together.
Rachel and Simone walked into a very quiet loft and they figured the guys were sleeping.
"Do you think they broke up?" Rachel whispered.
"We'll know in the morning. Come on I'm tired." Simone takes off her shoes.
"Your bed or mine tonight?" Rachel asked quietly.
"Let's sleep in my bed for a change. Your bed is comfortable but I want to be in my bed tonight." Both girls walked to her side of the bed closing the curtain. Simone strips out of her dress while Rachel strips out of her clothes and puts on one of Simone's long t shirts before going into the bathroom to wipe off her makeup.
After she was done, she made her way back to Simone's side of the loft and gets into bed. Simone changed already and did the same thing Rachel did before getting into bed.
"Good night Rae." Rachel snuggles up to her.
"Good night Simone." She held her by the waist as they fall asleep in each others arms.
The next morning, both girls woke up to movement. They stared at each other before getting out of bed, walking out to see Blaine pulling his suitcase towards the door.
"Blaine why are you leaving?" Kurt walked out staring at the girls then stared at Blaine.
"Give me my hug before I go." Rachel walked over to Blaine, hugging him.
"You okay?" He just held her for a little bit. Simone glanced at Kurt to see him close to tears and sighs.
"I'll see you again okay. I'll text or call you sometime okay Rach?" She pulls back nodding. She slowly wiped away a tear that was falling down his cheek.
"You'll always be a great friend of mine." He nods pulling away then stared at Kurt who looked away.
"It was nice meeting you Simone. I hope I get to see you again." She gives him a small smile, waving at him.
"Bye guys." Blaine turned around sliding the door opened and walked out with his suitcase. Rachel closed it after he left.
"You going to be okay Kurt?" He just ignored the question.
"I need to get ready for work." Rachel frowns.
"But it's Saturday. Don't you want to talk about what happened?"
"I got called in okay and no I don't want to talk about my breakup with Blaine. I'm going to eat breakfast then get ready." He walked away from the girls.
Simone stared at Rachel then looked back at Kurt. He was going to be one of those people that wanted to his breakup to himself. She was going to make sure Kurt actually talks to them but right he just needs some time.
Find out what happens next.