Chapter 5: Sister from another Mister

Spencer stands and starts to gather her things but Amelia notices her, "Hey, it's Spencer, right?" She blurts hold a coffee cup in her right hand. Spencer looks up at her but doesn't say anything, "Um, hello?" Amelia continues. Spencer, still ignoring her, straps her bag over her right shoulder. "I know you know who I am." Amelia almost snotty.

"Oh? And who is that?" Spencer stabs.

"I don't think we've formally met. I'm Amelia." She says as she holds out a hand to Spencer.

Spencer turns to walk away, "Hey, I just wanted to let you know, Toby and I aren't dating." Amelia says knowing that it will stop her.

"What?" Spencer turns.

"Toby and me. We aren't dating." Amelia continues.

"Then why did he say you were?" Spencer questions.

"I'm really not sure but trust me I had a long talk with him after that." Amelia says.

"Why were you two meeting for dinner?" Spencer looking confused.

"Toby's been staying with me while working on his case in Philadelphia."

"So, you are?" Spencer still confused.

"His sister." Amelia says blankly as if no big deal.

Spencer's jaw almost hits the floor, "Sister?"

"Yeah, well step sister. I'm Jenna's twin sister." Amelia says gesturing with her hands. Spencer stays silent, "In the divorce our mom got Jenna and our dad got me. So, I stayed in Philadelphia with our dad and Jenna moved here with our mom."

'Toby never said anything about Jenna having a twin' Spencer thinks.

"I decided to make a visit to Rosewood for Jenna's graduation party." Amelia continues.

"Don't take this rude our anything, but why doesn't anyone know about you? That lives here anyways." Spencer asks her.

"Well, I was supposed to come and visit my mom and Jenna a lot more. But, after Jenna's accident our father took custody away from our mom. It was just easier on Jenna and my mom if she just stayed here, in Rosewood, all the time instead of coming to Philly every weekend. But, that also meant me not coming here." Amelia tells Spencer.

"Why didn't Toby ever tell me about you?" Spencer asks her.

"I guess my parents did everything secretly so Toby's dad didn't even know about me. Toby just found out a couple months ago." Amelia says.

"Wow, I feel like you just told me your whole life story." Spencer says through a sigh.

"Yeah, sorry I tend to do that a lot." Amelia says shyly.

"I can't believe he didn't know. Not even him, nobody knew." Spencer says out loud, almost to herself.

"Yeah, well hey I have to get going. I'm meeting with Jenna for lunch but how about I give you my number and we can get together sometime." Amelia suggests.

"Yeah that sounds good." Spencer tells her.

After the two of the exchange numbers, Amelia leaves the brew and Spencer calls Aria to tell her the whole story.

"Wait so Toby didn't know at all?" Aria asks.

"No, nobody knew." Spencer tells her.

"So how did Toby find out?" Aria questions through the phone.

"She didn't say, hopefully we will get together for lunch or something." Spencer says to Aria through the phone.

"Am I free to tag along on that lunch date?" Aria asks.

"Sure, if you tell Ezra about you know what." Spencer says nonchalantly.

"Hey, aren't you supposed to be my best friend? You're supposed to support me not push me into something I don't want to do."

"You're right. But I can push you into something you need to do." Spencer says just before hanging up the phone.

So, what did you guys think of this chapter? I feel like I'm getting back into my old writing style. I feel like the only hard thing is me trying to start new story lines, so if anyone has any suggested story lines they think I should try please PM or just review here! I'm open to anything! One more thing, do you guys think I should try writing some of my story in other people POV? I write in third person already so I'm not sure. PLEASE REVIEW!