I just want to mention that every show mentioned in this collection are shows that I watch, with Supernatural being my second favorite show (It still loses out to Merlin) so if you think the characters wouldn't watch those shows, sorry, but I needed to give them something that I could talk about and that's not much haha

Category: Gen
Setting: Post-Horsemen
Characters/Pairings: Four Horsemen
Rating/Warnings: K+, spoilers for the pilot episode of Supernatural.
Summary: On the first rainy day, it is Henley's choice of show.

Disclaimer: Neither Now You See Me nor its characters nor Supernatural belong to me.

Rainy Day Marathons (Part Two)

Rainy Day One—Henley

They didn't have long to wait for the very next day was rainy. Henley drew the short straw and got to pick the first marathon. It was early when they started, that way they could get in the most episodes of whatever show Henley had picked. Much to their annoyance, she refused to tell them. She wanted it to be a surprise, though that surprise didn't last long when Jack expertly switched her DVD out with a same-sized book.

"What's Supernatural?" he asked, glancing at the title. "Are we watching stuff about ghosts?"

"Sort of." Henley replied, throwing the book his direction and taking her movie back. "No using your sleight of hand, Jack!"

Jack just grinned and plopped down on the couch, spreading out across it. He was forced to move, however, when Daniel sat down beside him. Merritt went to his chair and propped his feet up on the coffee table, rolling his eyes as Jack childishly stuck his tongue out at Daniel. Henley put the DVD in the player and sat down on the other side of Daniel. Skipping through the previews, she quickly pressed play and settled back, eager to watch her favorite show.

"What is this?" Daniel asked, looking between Henley and the screen where the mother was on the ceiling, bleeding and on fire. Of all the things he imagined Henley watched, this certainly wouldn't be one of them.

"It's good, now shut up." Henley replied, eyes glued to the screen even though she had seen it hundreds of times.

"She's going to die." Merritt commented the second he saw the blonde girl—Jess—appear.

"How do you know that?" Henley asked, frowning. She hated spoilers.

"Mentalist, remember." Merritt grinned, tapping his finger to his head.

They were silent for a few moments. Henley had settled back in after a few warning glances at Merritt. She didn't care if he could spot the spoilers, she didn't want it ruined for Jack and Daniel. The mentalist managed to keep his mouth shut for a total of one minute, but then the first shadowy fight scene came on.

"It's the brother." He announced.

"I swear, Merritt," Henley was practically seething. "If you don't shut up, I am going to hurt you."

"My lips are sealed." Merritt replied, miming sealing his lips and throwing away the key.

They managed to make it through the rest of the episode without another spoiler and as the credits rolled up, Henley turned to the three men eagerly.

"Well?" She asked. "What do you think?"

"I like it." Jack said first. "It's interesting."

"It's a bit…strange." Daniel replied hesitantly. To tell the truth, he wasn't too fond of it, but he wasn't going to say so with Henley directly beside him.

"Merritt?" Henley asked.

Merritt murmured something, but his lips were shut and no one could understand him.

"You can talk now." Henley said with a roll of her eyes.

Merritt mimed unlocking his lips and sighed.

"That's better." He took a breath before quickly giving his honest opinion. "Sam strikes me as a gentle giant who has major daddy issues and is a big baby. Dean plays the bad guy, but he's really just a big softie who is far too loyal to his father. As for the show itself, the content is interesting and it defiantly has potential, but I'll have to get back to you on what I think after a few more episodes."

The other three Horsemen just stared at the man. Merritt just grinned and threw a handful of popcorn in his mouth.

"Who's ready for the next episode?"

One last note, I don't want anyone to think I'm dissing Supernatural because of what I had Merritt say. That was just my honest opinion of the show when I first started watching it, but now I am hopelessly addicted and that opinion has changed completely...most of the time haha