This chapter is all smut. The second half has anal in it, so if you don't want to read that you can read up until you see "xXx".
Chapter Nineteen: A toast you won't forget- Part One
Lucy put the ham in the oven, setting the timer for an hour and a half. She then checked the temperature once more before heading to the bedroom. Natsu was already setting up, a bottle of lube and a thick towel at the edge of the bed. He glanced up when she entered, then gave her a nervous smile.
"H-hey," he swallowed, his face feeling abnormally hot due to the blush coating his cheeks. "I-I think I got everything ready..."
Lucy's eyes flitted to the items on the bed, then back up to her boyfriend. "You're forgetting one thing." She didn't mind his raised brow as she walked over to the nightstand. "I picked these up yesterday. I figured they would help with clean up."
Lucy turned around to face Natsu, a single condom in her hand. "Oh, yeah I guess that would help." He nodded, wondering if he was shaking as badly as he thought he was.
"Are you nervous?" She asked, seeing the slight tremors in his arms.
"A little," he admitted. "I've never done this before."
"Me either," Lucy said, though they both already knew this information. "I'm sure it'll be fine. You read the same pages I did. If we go slow and be careful it should all work out."
Lucy was referring to a few online sites on how to prepare and have anal sex. Neither had tried it before, so this would be a first for them. Lucy already prepared herself a little bit. She never heard of an anal douche before, and definitely never thought she'd use one in her life.
Luckily for them the discrete sex shop in Magnolia was opened yesterday, letting them get everything they thought they might need for this event. The lube was a thick consistency that was guaranteed to stay slick for the entire duration. The last thing they would need was for the lube to dry out halfway through.
Lucy prepared a little that morning too. She shaved the area in question -without any thoughts of cutting herself, then took a long, relaxing bath. It helped loosen her muscles and prepare her for the long day ahead of them.
"Do you really want our first Thanksgiving together to be associated with anal sex?" Natsu asked suddenly.
Lucy raised a brow before her face softened. She lightly shrugged, saying, "it could be worse."
"Y-yeah... How much time do we have?" Natsu sat on the bed, bottom lip caught between his teeth.
Lucy couldn't help but think he looked cute. She'd never seen the fiery man so nervous before. "An hour before the guests are supposed to arrive. An hour and a half before the ham is done."
"Okay," Natsu nodded. "Plenty of t-time."
"Here," Lucy sat next to him on the bed, wrapping her arms around his shoulders to lace her fingers behind his neck. "How about we start with something else to make you more comfortable?"
"What'd you have in mind?" Natsu asked, liking the idea of playing with her beforehand. He was a nervous wreck. This was the only real 'first' they were going to share together when it came to sexual acts. He didn't want to mess things up.
"This," Lucy said before leaning in to place a kiss on his lips.
Natsu responded immediately, applying his own pressure as his head tilted so their noses wouldn't bump. Lucy's fingers loosened, only to curl against his neck. Natsu's hands came up to gently rest on her full thighs just as he parted his lips. His hot tongue came out to swipe against her bottom lip.
Lucy opened her mouth to invite him in, instantly getting swept away when he took control of the kiss. In no time Lucy found herself being guided downwards until she laid on the bed. Her eyes fluttered shut, letting Natsu take control of her body, trusting him with everything. Natsu crawled between her legs to settle against her body. He made sure not to apply too much pressure to her torso. He didn't want to hurt her after all.
Lucy's tongue slid against his as she made her way into his mouth. It was hot, moist, and tasted suspiciously like the ham she told him he wasn't supposed to nibble at yet. She decided to ignore the brown sugar flavor and focus on her fingers tracing over his strong shoulders.
Lucy was always fond of Natsu's body. Who wouldn't be? For as long as she could remember he was built like a warrior. She especially loved the firm and toned muscles. They were much more appealing than bulky muscles.
A hum escaped her mouth when she felt something hard against her thigh. Natsu was already aroused, his nervousness fading the longer they kissed. He bit at her bottom lip, only to roll the pink flesh between his teeth before tugging until it was released. Lucy couldn't get enough of it. Her hips instinctively bucked against his body, but it wasn't enough to relieve the dull ache that had worked its way into her core.
"Mmm, N-Natsu," she moaned into his mouth.
Natsu opened an eye to see the pleading look she gave him. He smirked, realizing she already wanted more. His lips moved away from hers, a thin trail of saliva connecting between them until it snapped when he jerked his head to her neck.
Lucy hummed when that hot mouth bit at her throat. "Don't leave a mark," she warned. Any other time she wouldn't mind so much, but their friends and family were coming by later today. She wanted to at least look decent and not like a woman who just got fucked.
Natsu restrained himself as he nipped at her flesh. It left small pink marks, but they would fade soon. His hot tongue came out to drag against her neck up until he reached her ear. There he gently sucked on her earlobe, drawing a whimper from his girlfriend. "You like that?" He asked before sucking again. Her reactions showed she clearly enjoyed his ministrations, but he preferred verbal confirmation.
"Y-yes," Lucy could hear herself losing control. Her voice sounded shallow and breathy, a tell-tale sign she was aroused. If that wasn't enough, feeling Natsu's hand venture until he cupped her clothed core was! She mewled when he roughly palmed at her crotch, the heat building between her legs at his touches. "Don't tease me," she begged, desperately wanting more pleasure.
Natsu chuckled in her ear before saying, "as you wish." He started moving downwards, lips kissing at her neck until he got to her shirt. With a groan he lifted himself off her to get rid of the offending garment.
Lucy blinked in surprise when Natsu lifted her up. With careful but quick movements he removed her shirt and bra, leaving her clad in only her jeans. Natsu frowned for only a second when he saw the slight pudge sticking out from her jeans. It wasn't that he was upset she'd gained some weight -he actually enjoyed seeing Lucy a little fuller. He was just concerned she was still trying to fit into her clothes she bought three months ago. They looked uncomfortable on her body.
Natsu pushed that thought aside to undo her jeans. Lucy helped him get them off, then watched as he leaned forward, teeth clenching around the waistband of her thong before pulling it downwards. The smaller article of clothing rolled up on itself the further he dragged it towards her ankles. By the time he slipped them off they were just a wad of material, easily tossed across the room since she wouldn't be needing them anytime soon.
Natsu went back up to her neck where he last kissed her. "You're so fucking sexy," he growled before seizing her collarbone in his teeth. He bit at her flesh, getting it a little pink before venturing down. Lucy let out a gasp when he licked over her nipple. A fire roared in her belly when he lapped up the perky bud again, then twitched when he proceeded to suck on her nipple.
"Ooooh, yeeess," Lucy closed her eyes, humming in appreciation. "K-keep going!" Some days her nipples were too sore to touch, but others they were extremely sensitive in a good way. Today was one of those days.
Lucy arched her back to get closer to that scorching tongue. Natsu groaned when her large breasts were pressed against his face, but he made no effort to stop playing with her nipple. He licked over it slowly, watching her squirm from his touches before sucking the nipple into his mouth. There he moved the tip of his tongue against the pink skin mercilessly until she was begging for more. "Aaaaahh, nnnggh!" He licked, flicked, circled, even tugged on her pink bud before switching to the other. Everything he did made Lucy moan louder, her body jerking with pleasure.
The real kicker was when she grasped his pink locks in her hands. She wanted to make sure he didn't leave before she was ready. Natsu forgot all about why he was nervous as he sucked on her breast. One of his hands moved to touch her delicate sex once again, this time uncovered. She was slick, ready for a good pounding, but he wouldn't give her that yet. He still had a lot more he wanted to do.
Fingers traced over her lower lips, fingertips getting wet before dragging over her clit. He felt her jump from the sensations before a mewl escaped her parted lips. His lips stayed over her breast, lightly biting at the nipple while he plunged a single finger past her folds and into her heat. She was soaked inside, her inner walls trying to squeeze over his finger.
Natsu moved over to her side so he wouldn't put any pressure on her body. Lucy didn't seem to notice, her head thrown back and her eyes shut tightly. He pulled his dripping finger out so he could massage her clit. The nub slowly grew harder the longer he played with it. "Na-Naa-" Lucy couldn't finish, her body convulsing as he brought her to climax.
Lucy gripped his hair tighter, her back arching and her hips bucking as she felt tremors course through her heated body. Natsu didn't stop for a second. He continued to suck on her swollen nipple while his fingers rubbed fervidly over her engorged bundle of nerves. Lucy never stood a chance.
Just as one orgasm ended, another began. The way Lucy screamed in pleasure made it sound like she was in pain. Her thighs tightened around his hand, her body shaking as she tried to catch her breath. "Na-Natsuuu," she whined, hips bucking to let him know what she wanted.
Natsu felt her loosen the grip on his hair. He slowly lowered down her body, pressing kisses against her heated skin every few inches. He licked over her belly, kissed her belly button, then dragged his lips against her blonde curls.
A second later Natsu's mouth covered her core, his tongue coming out to thrust into her juices. She was sopping wet, moaning as he fucked her with his tongue. Lucy felt that scorching wet muscle move around the entrance of her core before he pulled out. He didn't wait before spreading her pussy lips apart with two fingers, exposing the glistening pink skin beneath before flickering over her clit.
Just as Natsu was thinking he couldn't smell anything better than Lucy's arousal, he was proven wrong. Drifting into their bedroom came the smell of the Thanksgiving ham. He felt a little silly when his cock throbbed with need, his mouth watering more from the delicious combinations of scents. He buried his nose into her core, getting his nose nice and soaked so she was all he could smell.
"Th-there!" Lucy whimpered when he sucked on her clit, pulling it between his pressed lips to give her a thrilling sensation. He did it again, earning a better reaction the second time. "Aaahhhh! Feels... soo good!"
Natsu decided to slow things down. His tongue moved languidly over her wet folds until he brushed over her bundle of nerves. She squirmed, trying to get him to go faster or apply more friction. Natsu stayed patient, lapping up her juices to savor her unique taste.
Before Lucy could say anything he began kissing her pussy, mouth moving against her lower lips to ease the fire burning between her legs. Natsu smirked. He could feel her breathing slow down, her hands twisting into his pink hair. He had her right where he wanted her. Once she got used to the slow, deliberate movements, he sped up. His tongue aggressively sucking her clit while two fingers entered her eager pussy.
Lucy could only gasp for air as he urged her body into another climax, all her senses heightening before she was thrust into a blissful state. Natsu slowly pulled away from her body, letting her ride it out before moving off the bed to get ready.
Lucy was barely aware of his actions until she felt the tip of his cock press against her sopping pussy. 'When did he get naked?' She wondered before feeling him pump into her body.
"W-wait!" Lucy shouted just as Natsu started to push back into her body. His movements came to an abrupt halt when he heard her command.
"What's wrong?" Natsu asked, doing his best to keep perfectly still. He felt her pussy pulsing around his leaking cock. He desperately wanted to fuck her, but he wouldn't do it without her permission.
"I thought we were going to try..." Lucy trailed off, her face lighting up with a new blush. She looked to the edge of the bed where the towel and lube sat.
Natsu followed her line of vision until he saw the items. He nodded, realizing he'd messed up. "Sorry. Got a little excited." He started pulling out slowly, earning a moan from his girlfriend.
"Well," Lucy's hands came out to grab his hips. "Maybe you can do this..." She couldn't meet his gaze due to her embarrassment. "Just for a little bit?"
Natsu couldn't be happier. "Sounds awesome," he said while plunging back into her sweet body.
"Nnnggh, aahh!" Lucy moaned while Natsu continued his thrusts. Her pussy was hot and wet, the perfect combination for fucking.
"I wanna try somethin'," Natsu said as he grabbed one of Lucy's legs to hoist it over his shoulder. Immediately the angle of penetration changed so he could go deeper. "Fuck! That's good!" He rubbed over her clit with messy movements, trying to draw her closer to the edge.
One eye closed while the other stayed trained on Lucy's expression. He wasn't going to risk letting her slip into some dark flashback. It would only ruin the moment and upset her. He watched for any indication she wasn't enjoying herself, but so far he saw none. It definitely helped that she kept moaning his name.
"Naatsuu! Aaahh, yes! J-just like th-that! Naaa-" Lucy started shaking. He felt her clenching around his member when she met her end.
Despite only starting he felt himself getting close as well. Not wanting to end it too soon, he pulled out, letting some of her juices leak from her swollen pussy lips to collect on the sheets. Natsu got lost in the sight for a moment before he found himself leaning down towards the mess.
Her leg fell from his shoulders as he got closer. His tongue came out to lick at her spilled juices. Lucy's skin tingled where his hot tongue touched. She wanted to reach to hold onto some part of him, but she already felt weak in her limbs.
He lapped up her wetness for a few more seconds before feeling her jerk away from the sensations. Natsu lifted himself up until he was on his knees between her spread legs. "I'm glad I'm the only one who's tasted your sweet pussy," he said while wiping some drops of her juices from his mouth with the back of his hand.
xXx
Lucy gave him a weak smile, her eyes hooded with lust gleaming in those brown orbs. "Are you ready?" She asked, grabbing a pillow to place under her lower back to prop herself up.
Natsu gulped, looking down at her spent core. He gently spread her ass cheeks apart, revealing the small puckered hole he was supposed to enter. The nervousness from earlier came right back, as if nothing had happened in between. He gulped, fingers slightly shaky as he nodded. "Y-yeah."
Lucy merely shook her head. "You know this is going to hurt me a lot more than it's going to hurt you, right?"
Natsu frowned, his hands stilling in an instant. "I'm going to make sure it doesn't hurt," he vowed, but he wasn't sure he could keep this one. He'd never done this before, so he didn't know what to expect besides what he read online, and that was only somewhat helpful. Doing it in real life seemed a lot scarier.
"Okay..." Natsu turned to grab the bottle of lube and towel. "Lift up a bit?" When she did he placed the towel over the pillow to act as a barrier for the sheets. Worst case scenario they would have to wash the sheets, but at least this way there was a chance it wouldn't be so bad.
As he applied a little lube to the tip of his finger he realized she already got her pussy juices on the sheets. He decided not to worry about it. They had a spare set of sheets in the closet anyway.
Before Natsu capped the lube, Lucy spoke up. "Can you add more?" She looked at the amount on his finger. "The site said to use a lot."
"Oh, yeah," he blinked, then poured some more over his pointer finger. Luckily he already trimmed his nails down so they wouldn't catch on her inner walls. He didn't want to accidentally tear her skin after all. "Do you want me to put some here?"
Natsu gently circled her anus with his finger, leaving behind a wet trail of lube. She was already a little wet down there from when her pussy juices slid down her body, but it was drying up already.
Lucy nodded, then watched as he added more and coated her asshole with the thick liquid. He could feel his heart hammering out of control, but by the looks of it Lucy was just as nervous. Her eyes kept flitting from his eyes to his hand, trying to decide where to look.
"We don't have to do this," he reminded her. This was Lucy's idea. She was the one to bring it up again since the road trip. She even drove them to the sex shop to get the items needed to make this experience more comfortable. "I promise I won't mind."
"I want to," Lucy said firmly. "I'm just a little nervous too, I guess..." She felt confident when they started, but now that her ass was wet and his finger was pressed against her tight entrance she was feeling a little weird in her stomach. "I do want this though."
"Okay." That was all Natsu needed. "If you change you're mind-"
"I'll let you know," she finished. "Okay. I'm ready."
Lucy took a deep breath, then felt her lower half relax. Pushing aside her fear -and the smell of ham that slowly got stronger the longer they played, she nodded to him. He settled between her legs by sitting criss-cross, his shining cock standing proudly against his body.
With a silent gulp, Natsu pressed. The pad of his finger pushed through her ring of muscles rather easily since she was keeping herself relaxed, but as soon as he entered an inch she clenched up. Instead of moving, Natsu stayed perfectly still. He wanted her to feel good, so he waited until she loosened up again before going further.
Lucy's heart raced as he slowly worked his finger until he was completely in. He didn't move, allowing her time to adjust to this much. He could imagine it'd feel weird having a finger up the ass. He'd never thought about it before, but he didn't think he'd be opposed to the idea of her playing with him in this manner. However, that was a thought for another day. Right now he needed to stay focused on Lucy's breathing, her reactions, and the feeling of her pulse that throbbed around his finger.
"How are you feeling?" He asked, his free hand settling on her thigh. He was pleased to see no fresh cuts. Not even a scab adorned her flesh. There were still many scars, but there wasn't much they could do about that. She was rubbing a cream on them every day. It was supposed to make scars fade. She'd only been at it for a month, but he didn't see much improvement. Of course it would take a while. The scars had been a work in progress for many years.
He just hoped she didn't feel bad about herself. Natsu knew Lucy was strong, but even the strongest people can feel pain in their hearts.
"Feels weird," Lucy said honestly. "But it doesn't hurt."
"Well that's good," he smiled at her. Her ass felt different from her pussy. It wasn't as spongy, and the temperature was a lot hotter than her core. The main difference he noticed was the tightness. He had no idea how he was supposed to fit his cock inside her ass at this rate. "Do you want me to move it now?"
"Yeah." She smiled along with him. "Go slow?"
"Of course," Natsu eased his finger out of her body until only the tip remained. It was wet with lube, making her inner walls slick for penetration.
Natsu pushed back into her ass, feeling her slightly tense before relaxing again. This process lasted about a minute before he started angling his finger to loosen her up around instead of just back and forth. Lucy noticed immediately, reminding herself to breathe deeply and accept the intrusion.
"I think I'm ready for another finger," Lucy said just as she felt a bead of sweat roll down her forehead. Despite the cold air outside their house was very warm. The heater was on, along with the oven in the other room. She realized they should have turned it off before getting started, but it would be odd to stop now.
Natsu nodded, removing his finger. It was weird pulling completely out. He expected to see something gross at the end of his finger, but the only thing he saw was the lube. He guessed her preparations really did make a difference.
He remembered the site saying to apply lube to each digit inserted, so Natsu coated two fingers with the thick substance. He took his own deep breath before placing his fingers by her anus. Natsu whispered, "ready?"
"Yeah," Lucy shifted against the soft sheets to get more comfortable. She felt one tip push past her ring of muscles before the second one joined it. Immediately there was some discomfort from the spreading, but it wasn't enough to cause alarm. Lucy breathed, hands lightly rubbing at the sheets to keep herself relaxed.
Natsu's gaze stayed on her face, judging her reactions to his ministrations. He was halfway in before he finally looked down, his cock twitching at the sight. Lucy's clean ass was being penetrated by his wet fingers. She looked so naughty, but he wouldn't tell her that. It wasn't exactly a rule he couldn't say things like that, but he didn't want to risk triggering her. Now was definitely not the time.
"Tell me if you want me to stop," Natsu reminded, his eyes fixed on his fingers entering her.
"I will," Lucy said, her voice growing breathless. "Keep going."
Natsu pushed again, going in slowly until his knuckles touched her ass. He could feel just how tight she was now that he had two fingers inside. The heat only increased the longer he was in. He didn't know if it was from his body temperature being added, or maybe it was from the slight friction she received from him entering her. Either way he liked how it felt. His cock throbbed, a desperate need coming from it to be inside her narrow passage.
When Lucy was okay being dilated that much, she told him to move. With steady fingers he began to fuck her ass, making sure to watch for any signs of distress. When he felt like she had enough in and out he moved on to scissoring her passage. She whimpered a few times, but every time Natsu stopped, she told him to continue.
Lucy wasn't the only one sweating. Natsu soon began to feel beads drip down his neck and shoulders. He stretched her anus as gently as he could. He started pushing outwards against her anal ring to loosen her up there as well.
Her hand came down to slowly massage her clit. She found it took her mind off the slight discomfort she felt with him prepping her ass. After a few minutes she told him to try three fingers. That was by far the weirdest feeling Lucy had felt thus far. Even with all three fingers soaked in lube she still felt her body resisting.
Natsu clenched his teeth when he got three fingertips inside her. He really didn't want to push her too far, but she hadn't told him 'no' yet. Still, he could tell she couldn't be enjoying this. "How ya doing?" He asked in a whisper, barely pushing into her body.
"G-good," she panted, not realizing how heavily she was breathing until she tried to talk. "Kinda hurts, but I can keep going." It took everything in her power to keep her lower half relaxed. Every instinct was screaming to squeeze around those invading fingers, but she didn't listen.
"Okay," Natsu felt wary, but moved further into her ass. His free hand kept massaging her thigh. His efforts combined with her rubbing her clit seemed to be the only thing keeping her going in that moment.
When he was halfway through she finally clenched around his fingers, a gasp coming from her parted lips as she felt that weird sensation. "Sorry," Natsu mumbled, trying to stay perfectly still. He felt like if he jerked out now he would only hurt her.
"It's fine." Lucy took a deep breath. "This is just really... different."
"Yeah," Natsu nodded. "Do you want me to stop?"
"No," she wasn't ready to throw in the towel yet. "I think I want you to try to really... umm, have sex with me... there..."
"Are you sure?" Natsu asked incredulously. "I haven't even gotten them in all the way."
"I know," Lucy could feel how deep he was in. "I just think I'm ready for the real thing. Just make sure you use lots of lube."
"Definitely," Natsu slowly pulled his fingers out of her hole when he felt her relax again. She let out what sounded like a cross between a gasp and a whimper, but other than that she stayed quiet.
Natsu got to work after that. He put a little lube on his hand, then rubbed it over his length. It felt great getting some attention after ignoring his cock for a while, but he couldn't dwell on touching himself for long. Next he got the condom and tore open the package. It felt weird slipping the condom over his shaft. He hadn't worn one in over three months. He had no idea what he was even supposed to do with the other ones she bought.
Once the condom was secure, Natsu coated it with a lot of lubricant. He remembered reading lube was extremely important when it came to penetrating the ass. It wasn't possible to use too much.
"How do you want it?" He asked when he felt prepared. Lucy looked down at his cock, then back up to his emerald eyes. "The site said missionary was best for beginners, so I think that way."
Natsu grinned. "Perfect," with a rise in confidence, he said, "now I can see your face when I fuck your ass."
Lucy's face flushed crimson, but she wasn't the only one affected by his words. Despite his calm demeanor, Natsu's face and chest lit up in a blush. He didn't mean to sound so dirty, but it felt right telling her what was on his mind.
With no other words he touched the tip of his cock to her puckered hole. He used both hands to spread her ass cheeks apart to get a clear view of her hole. Natsu pressed, only to slip. He didn't realize how much concentration this act was going to require. He had to use one hand to hold onto the base of his member as he guided himself back to her anus. Aiming at her hole, he pushed in.
Lucy hissed when the head of his cock entered her ass. It felt almost like a burn. When he stopped moving the pain slowly subsided. She did everything in her power not to clench or tighten up around him. Despite her efforts Natsu felt how incredibly tight she really was. He couldn't imagine fucking her like this. He'd surely come undone in no time.
Natsu waited a full thirty seconds before pushing in again. He felt Lucy's body trying to accommodate his thick cock. The lube helped him ease in, but he could tell she felt some discomfort from him spreading her wide. His hand moved back to her cheek, spreading them apart to make penetration easier.
"Luce?" He started, working in another inch into her hot hole, "you good?"
"Y-yeah," she wanted to nod, but her neck felt stiff. She couldn't move any part of her body in fear it would cause her pain in her ass. She didn't even rub at her clit for this part. "Didn't think it would feel like this." Lucy did her best to not clench her teeth or her body. She had to remain relaxed to avoid pain.
Natsu looked down at where their bodies joined. He was about halfway into her narrow passage. He saw her ring of muscles stretched around his length. His breath caught. She looked so fucking amazing. He gave it another push before retreating.
Lucy gasped when she felt him pulling out. He stopped once his tip was the only thing in, then eased himself back in. "Is that okay?" He asked, voice straining with desire. She felt impossibly tight and hot around his cock. For a second it felt like her body was actually trying to suck him in.
Lucy massaged her bundle of nerves again. It did well to curb the slight pain. Now all she felt was pleasure from her touches and slight discomfort from her ass. "I'm good," she gave him a weak smile. "I promise I'll let you know if I'm not."
"Please," he would beg if it was needed. He wanted to know her limits so he wouldn't accidentally push past them. "I'm gonna try to go in deeper, okay?"
Her reply came in a whimper when she purposely pinched around her clit. Natsu thrust in a little harder than before, enough to gain another inch or so. At this rate it was going to take minutes just to get to the base of his cock, but he would be patient if it meant not hurting Lucy.
This little routine of thrusting in a little at a time kept up until he finally worked himself all the way in. His balls slapped lightly against her cheeks, signalling him he was fully submerged. Natsu slowly released her cheeks, then moved to hover over her with his hands on either side of her body.
"Tell me when to move," he instructed, keeping his cock in place to let her adjust. His pink hair matted against his forehead, a bead of sweat falling to land on her left breast. He hadn't realized he was so overheated until now, but he honestly didn't mind. As long as he was inside Lucy he could put up with anything. She felt so hot and tight around him. Just resting inside her felt amazing.
"Hey Natsu," Lucy pulled her hand away from her clit to place it on his cheek. She felt the sweat beneath her fingers as she caressed his face. "We finally had a first together."
A large grin tore at his face. "You're right." He leaned into her touch, finding comfort in the simple action. "I really really love you," he closed his eyes as a purr built up in his chest.
"And I really really love you too," Lucy decided not to play the 'I love you more, I win' game. Right now the moment felt too sweet to taint it with childish games. Although, Natsu's childish antics was just one of the many things she fell in love with him for.
Lucy purposed clenched her anal muscles around his member, finding his cock hot, thick, and very wet. Natsu groaned at the action, his brow furrowing in the process. She squeezed on his cock two more times before deciding. "I'm ready. Just go slow."
"Y-yup," Natsu forced out. There was no way he was going to tell her he already felt close. He couldn't help it. Her ass felt fantastic wrapped around his cock.
Natsu shifted his hips back, slowly pulling out of her body before plunging back inside. "God damn!" His fingers grasped at the sheets. "Fuck you feel so tight." His head dropped, pink hair falling over his shut eyes.
Lucy moaned when he thrust into her again. The pain was fading, replaced by a strange pleasurable sensation now that she was stretched out down there. Her hands fell over her breasts, kneading the globes of flesh to keep her relaxed. Natsu might be having the time of his life driving in and out of her ass, but Lucy wasn't feeling the same sensations she normally did with vaginal sex. Her ass had less pleasurable nerves than her core did, but it still felt oddly good being stretched like this.
As long as she wasn't in pain and Natsu was enjoying himself she didn't see a problem with letting him fuck her ass. Prepping definitely helped. She couldn't imagine how this would feel if he just went right in without fingering her first.
"F-faster!" She started writhing beneath him. "Aaahhh," Lucy twitched when Natsu pounded a little faster into her body. Her ass didn't resist him anymore, accepting every inch he had to offer. It actually started feeling a little good after a while, especially when her fingers tugged at her nipples in an effort to increase her pleasure. She felt his thrusts stutter for a second, so she said, "k-keep going!"
"Okay," Natsu breathed, his eyes still shut as he fucked into her narrow passage. His brain still couldn't comprehend how tight and hot she was. He never thought he'd feel something so tantalizing after feeling her amazing pussy. "Gaah," he dug his nails into the sheets. He was already so close. He thought the condom would help him last longer, but it wasn't enough.
"L-Luce," Natsu definitely felt her body sucking him in now. "I-I don't know if-if I- Damn!" He felt her squeezing around him. He didn't know if she was doing it on purpose or not, but it felt fantastic. "I might c-come soon." He felt embarrassed admitting it, but he figured he'd rather give her a warning.
"That's okay," Lucy moaned when he buried himself completely inside her, only to pull out almost all the way, then repeat his movement again. "Too bad you can't, nggh, come in my a-ass."
Natsu growled, forehead falling to land on her shoulder. "Fuck," he thrust in a little harder, feeling her inner walls tighten around him. "I-I don't think I can last if you talk like that." Lucy rarely spoke like that, but when she did it ignited the fire in his belly.
Natsu didn't ask before biting roughly at her shoulder, his hips snapping against her body to pump into her ass a few more times before releasing his load into the condom. "Ggaaahh," he groaned, her flesh caught between his teeth in a bruising grip.
Lucy shuttered, eyes staying open to focus on the pink hair in her face so she didn't forget where she was. She was at home, their home, the home she shared with Natsu. After taking a few deep breaths, she calmed herself. Of course she was still in pain. It was hard not to be with her boyfriend biting at her skin while his cock was spreading her wide.
Thankfully Natsu let up after a few more seconds. First to get some relief was her shoulder. He muttered an apology, hair still covering his lustful eyes. He slowly worked himself off her, making sure to keep his cock firmly in her so he didn't hurt her. Natsu carefully extracted his softening cock from her ass when he was steady.
The clean up was a lot easier since his cum was currently resting at the tip of the condom. Natsu shuffled to his feet, his head a little light as he stumbled over to the bathroom to dispose of the condom. When he was finished he went back to help Lucy stand up. Her legs were shaky as she walked to the bathroom. After what they went through she would be walking funny for the rest of the day.
Natsu gave her privacy to let her 'deal' with the aftermath of anal sex. He decided to walk to the second bathroom, dick swaying as he went down the hall. He had to resist the urge to drift towards the kitchen, that heavenly aroma of ham lingering in the air and calling his name.
Natsu managed to make it to the bathroom without any detours. There he washed his privates with the sink, laughing to himself at the silly scene he made in the mirror. When he deemed himself suitable, he went back to the master bedroom to see the door to the bathroom was open.
He smiled, already wanting to see Lucy again despite already spending the entire morning with her.
Thank you for the favorites, follows, and reviews! Shout out to those who reviewed: Mae Winterwraith, sthokatrina, quite-a-riot, LovelyLovelyLove, Shunakoo25, Tenma360Warrior, Margherine, BloodRedRubies, PrincessSarahDragneel, andy24amk, Lodemai04, turtle3334, FlameDragonHime, kimmyambrose, FairyTailLover04, ThatOneFriend-3, katiekat2001, Grizzly98, Jellal Frenandes, celestialmagex777, Anon, Soul-of-glass, SakuraStar1862, sarara1.8, sidjr100, Animemama328, fire854, CelestialMageLucy, Argo0, Crimsonlink310, Ashnmarley, L.E.N.D.56, lkityan02, xXPokeFictionXx, Matt427, Abdltf, and BiscuitQueen!
Up next, Chapter Twenty: A toast you won't forget- Part Two
If you have time will you let me know what you thought of the smut? Even if you didn't read the second half? I hope I was able to write a realistic first time experience, so thanks in advance if you review.