The Mistake Chapter 4: Lucy vs Natsu, a fairy tail fanfic

Makarov's P.O.V

I started to cry when I heard the hooded figure say that they were my former child and had been gone for almost 8 years. I instantly knew it was Lucy but I couldn't believe I was actually seeing her again. I didn't even think she would want to return after what her guild members did to her so all I could say was

"L-Lucy is that really you"

She returned my question with a simple "yep" and took off her hood. Then she said " Now where's brother Laxus" with a cold emotionless voice.

I was quite surprised to hear her cheery happy voice replaced by a cold heartless one. I couldn't see her left eye because of the hair covering it, but I could still see her right eye and it was filled with hatred and despair. Then that's when I saw her little exceed flying besides her. That's when I also noticed her Yin and Yang bracelets. It hadn't occurred to me before ,because I was so overwhelmed with happiness, but when I saw her exceed and her bracelets it finally hit me.

" So you where in the Seirei realm this time? Of course you were how else could you have attended those legendary bracelets. I said answering my own question

She only nodded and then pointed at her exceed.

"This is my exceed Mocha" Lucy said

Mocha only smiled and said

" Nice to meet you Master Makarov" happily

"You can call me gramps" I said to the smiling Mocha.

I turned back towards Lucy and asked

"Are you planning on joining fairy tail again ?" quite seriously

"No I already have another guild in mind" she relied coldly

I only nodded my head and said

"Come on let's go down stairs. Laxus should be here any moment"

She nodded and Mocha and her followed me down stairs where the rest of the guild was. I looked around to see the guild members staring at us and Lisanna trying to get something that looked like Romeo's sticky purple flames off her mouth. Knowing he would never do anything like that and turning to the one person who would I said

"Could you please undo that" while pointing at the struggling Lisanna

"How do you know I did that" Lucy replied coldly

I looked at her and raised my eyebrow

"So what if I did. Her voice was annoying me" Lucy said dispassionately.

"Again back to my original statement, could you undo that" I said

She rolled her eyes, snapped her fingers ,and within 5 seconds the black fire was gone from her mouth.

"Thank you" I said

"Whatever... Just don't expect me to go easy on her next time" Lucy said harshly

I only nodded.

"Everyone this is Lu-" I started to say but was interrupted by Lucy herself

"I am Lutin" Lucy said

"Master you know this person?" Mira asked

"Yes, but this is no mere person, she actually was a guild member" I said

Everyone looked shocked for a moment.

Then all of a sudden Laxus burst through the door with the Thunder legion.

"I smelled her, is Lu-" Laxus started to say but was interrupted by Lucy

"Yes it is me, Lutin, dear brother.

Laxus looked confused for a moment, but brushed it off. Then all of a sudden someone yelled out

"There's no way gramps and Laxus is related to someone to like you"

Everyone turned in the direction they heard the voice only to see an angry Nastu.

Lucy's P.O.V

I looked towards the door to see Laxus burst through the with the Thunder Legion. I heard him say

" I smelled her , is Lu". I knew I had to stop him from exposing my identity so I interrupted him and said

"Yes it is me, Lutin, dear brother."

I saw he was confused but just brushed it off. Then someone yelled out

"There's no way gramps and Laxus is related to someone like you"

Everyone turned towards the direction of the voice to see an angry salamander.

"You got a problem with me salamander" I said coldly

"Yea I do. You just can't come in our guild and attack one of our members and expect no ones going to say anything, just cause gramps didn't.

"Natsu" gramps started to say

" No let him continue" I said unfeelingly

Gramps only nodded and Natsu only got angrier.

"Something's off about you. You smell familiar and why don't you take that stupid hood off your head"

"First of all I don't expect anyone to say anything about the way I do things. Secondly maybe I didn't want to take my hood off so I don't have to see your disgraceful face. I do get itchy when I see bugs and I'm pretty sure if I look at you I'll be scratching myself all day " I said heartlessly.

Natsu lit his hand on fire and tried to punch me but I quickly dodged with a careless backflip.

"If you two are going to fight than go outside" gramps said

"Sure, that is if he's ready to get a beating in front of his friends" I said emotionlessly

"If it's anybody that's gonna get a beating its going to be you for hurting my family member."

"Don't act like you actually care about family, because you didn't care when-" I said angrily

"Lutin" gramps said before I could finish my sentence

Then another holographic screen appeared from my necklace again but this time below the words mood meter it said angry.

"Just forget it. Can we hurry this up. I wanna beat you and go to my new guild." I said uncaringly.

"Sure if your ready to lose that bad" Nastu said

Everyone headed outside and started to place bets. 92 percent of the guild bet on Natsu while 8 percent bet on Lutin.

"I'm not going to take it easy on you just because your a girl" Nastu said smirking

"Good because your going to have to use all your power to even come a little close to beating me" I said coldly.

The smirk on Nastu's face dropped making him take on a serious expression. Everyone was crowded around us but not to close to where they could get hit. Me and Nastu stood there neither one daring to made a move first until Nastu came charging at me with his fist on fire. I quickly dodged it with a simple backflip. Nastu then came charging again but I dodged it by ducking and then gave him a strong punch in the stomach that sent him flying into the air. I vanished into thin air surprising everyone including Natsu because when he opened his eyes I was right above him. I kicked him so hard that when he landed he was in a crater 7 feet deep. I gently floated back to the ground waiting for him to climb back up. When he did not get up I simple turned around and started to walk away.

"Thanks for wasting my time" I said emotionless

"Don't think you've won just yet" I heard someone yell from behind me

I turned around to see the bruised salamander barely able to stand.

"Lighting fire dragon roar" I heard Nastu yell

Nastu's P.O.V

I had finally climbed out of the crater Lutin had left me in with a bruised body. When I got out I saw her walking away and I heard her say

"Thanks for wasting my time"

That's when I replied

"Don't think you won just yet"

I then shouted

"Lighting fire dragon roar"

A big fire stream mixed with lightning came hurdling towards Lutin. We both knew it was to late for her to dodge it so it just hit her head on. I turned and started to walk away when I said

"I guess I win now" while smirking

"What was it you said. Oh don't think you won just yet."

I turned around to see what I never expected to see. My flames were disappearing, no they were being eaten.

"Thanks for the meal" she said with a smirk

"That's the first time in years you have showed a different facial expression besides anger or no expression at all"

"Yea I know Mocha" Lutin said in her usual cold voice

" Ok salamander let's finish this" Lutin said

I only stood in shock because no one ever ate my lightning fire flames before

"Celestial dragon slayer roar" I heard Lutin yell.

I saw all different types elements in her roar , but then I blacked out.

No one's P.O.V

"Celestial dragon slayer roar" Lutin yelled

Everyone stood in shock as they saw Nastu fall to the ground unconscious. Wendy and Lisanna ran over to help heal him( Wendy did all the healing while Lisanna just yelled at Wendy to heal him)

"I guess this means I win" Lutin said coldly

Lutin started to walk away when her hood was pulled down off her head. There was gaps from everybody expect Laxus, master, and Gajeel.

"Who said you could pull my hood down and look at me with your disgusting face" Lutin said coldly

"L-Lucy" was all the pink headed dragon slayer could say

Everyone just stood in shock as they saw this new Lucy that they barely even recognized in front of them. The only people who came up towards her where Laxus, Gajeel and the exceeds.

"Lushe, I missed you" happy said while flying into her to give her a hug

"Bunny girl, nice to see you again" Gajeel said

"Good to see you little sis" Laxus said

"Yes I've missed you guys too" Lucy said in her usual emotionless voice

"Wait a minute we can't just forgive and forget how that useless, weak, replacement attacked me 8 years ago" Lisanna said

Everyone turned to Lisanna and then back to Lucy

"Come on Luce just apologize to Lisanna and admit you were wrong for what you did." the pink haired dragon slayer said still holding Lucy's hood.

"We should get away from her" Mocha said

" Why?" Gajeel asked

"Because when we were training in the Seirei realm when anyone ever said the words replacement, useless, or weak she would get REALLY mad." Mocha said

Gajeel, Laxus, and the exceeds took some steps back.

The words replacement, useless and weak circled in Lucy's mind as she recalled the events from the past.

The holographic screen appeared from her necklace appeared again, but this time it was different. The screen was flashing and under the words mood meter it said dangerously angry.

Lucy's right eye that was visible was now glowing red. The ground started shaking and cracks appeared in it. All the clouds turned dark and were now hovering above fairy tail. Lucy picked Nastu up from his scarf and threw him into a near by tree shocking everyone and leaving him unconscious. Everyone was even more shocked when her necklace reacted.

First hidden compartments stared to come out of the necklace. There were 11 compartments total. At first Lucy was a little confused but when she realized what was going to happen she was to late.

The first compartment opened and a bunch of vines tangled around her feet, hands, fingers, and mouth so she couldn't fight back

Then the second compartment opened and a lightning bolt struck her.

When the third compartment opened ice sickles struck her.

The fourth compartment shot a huge fire ball at her.

The fifth compartment punched her in the gut with a iron fist like Gajeel's.

The sixth compartment trapped her in a tornado

The seventh compartment shot skulls at her

The eighth compartment attacked her with holy white light.

The ninth compartment attacked her with shadows

The tenth compartment trapped her inside boiling hot water before popping.

And the last compartment attacked her with all the elements at once.

After that the first compartment opened again but this time instead of vines a flower popped out and let out a big cloud of purple, glittery dust that seemed to calm everyone down.

The vines went back into the compartments and all the compartments went back into the necklace. After a moment or two Lucy tried to rip the necklace off her neck but every time she tried it shocked her painfully even through she didn't make a sound.

"So Bolts you gave me this necklace for that reason huh. Wait until I see you again" Lucy said with her emotionless voice again.

(If you didn't just understand what just happened, Bolts the electric dragon gave her a necklace before she returned to Earthland from the dragon realm. The necklace was designed to help people understand how she was feeling since she never showed her emotions, but it was also designed to help keep her anger under control before she could do any serious damage. Each of the dragons put their element in the necklace which Lucy just got attacked with)

"Mocha let's go" Lucy said

"Aye ma'am" Mocha said

"Wait Bunny-girl are you ok?" Gajeel asked

"Of course those mere attacks were just to help calm me down and bring me back to my senses" Lucy said coldly

Lucy started to walk away but stopped and said

" When salamander wakes up tell him I didn't come back for people like him, or Gray, or Erza. I certainly didn't come back to rejoin this guild where the members are "supposedly" treated like family. I came back to see my real family like Gajeel, Laxus, gramps, and the exceeds. I also came back just to show you all how much I've changed in the last 8 years. Some of you might have already noticed how much my powers have increased and how I have lost my emotions. Lucy said coldly.

I continued.

"Also tell him he is not to refer to me as Luce or Lucy like we are friends. I have not thought of us as friends, but as enemies for 8 years. The next time we battle I won't go easy on him."

Lucy turned towards the members of the guild and said

"You all should refer to me as Heartfilia-San seeing as how we are no longer on a first name basis. You all have caused me much despair over the years so I will return the favor."

After she finished talking, Lucy and Mocha both started to walk away again only to become tiny figures in the distance until they were completely gone.

say that they were my former child and had been gone for almost 8 years. I instantly knew it was Lucy but I couldn't believe I was actually seeing her again. I didn't even think she would want to return after what her guild members did to her so all I could say was