Returning home, Cupid wrapped all of her gifts. She put each of her friends' gifts into a gift box. She also put the letter she wrote for Alistair (with which she rolled up one of the pink glittery plumages of her wing) with the pendant into a small box and slipped it into the box for Raven, leaving a note to her to give to Alistair. Then, she put all the gifts into a brown paper box and took it downstairs to send it by airmail.

On Christmas day, Raven and her friends received the package from Cupid. Raven, Apple, Blondie, and Maddie all sat on their rug in front of their fireplace and opened it together.

"Oh my Grimm! Raven, this bracelet is totally hex!" Apple squealed.

"Oh, wicked." Raven said, tying the chain around her neck. "Wait, what's this?" she unfolded the little piece of paper. "Dear Raven, my father is against my relationship with Alistair, and I am deprived of all communication methods to everyone at Ever After High. Please give this package to him for me."

"Oh, that is so sad!" Blondie said.

"Let's go and give it to him right now!" Maddie said.

The four went to Alistair's door.

"ALISTAIR OPEN THE DOOR!" Maddie yelled, banging the door. Alistair emerged from behind the door. "What is it?" he asked.

"Cupid sent you a package." Apple said. "Here, Raven, give it to him!"

Raven handed Alistair the paper box.

"Cupid's father doesn't approve of you… and Cupid's been deprived of all communication methods… so she hid this into the package for me so that I could give it to you." Raven said.

"Oh… thank you." Alistair said. He went into his room to open the gift by himself.

He opened the little box, and saw a heart pendant as well as a letter. He clutched it and read the letter:

My dear Alistair,

My days spent with you at Ever After High has been a great pleasure to me.

However, my father has seen us making out and he's not happy about us.

He has taken away my MirrorPad so that I couldn't contact you, and I sent you a letter as well, but I saw the carrier bird called down to his room.

Still, I want you to know how much I still care about you, and how much I miss you.

If I get caught going out with you again, I will never be able to get back to Ever After High, so please understand if I don't send you any letters after this.

I send you one of my plumages as a token of my love for you.

I'm looking forward to seeing you again at school.

Love from Cupid

xoxox