Night has fallen and the boys' and I have really got to know each other a lot better. They are all very caring and sweet with not just me but with each other. Their bond is so strong, I want to be a part of it one day. It is nice to be able to just relax for a bit and reflect on myself as well. Mikey's words floated in my head all day, making me be more mindful in the things that I said. Donnie and I talked as if not bad happened between us, it felt wonderful to start slowly tearing down my walls. The only thing that slightly bothered me was meeting April, she sounds nice but the fact that there is some kind of history between Donnie and her kind of pokes at me. I want to just directly ask Donnie about it, but I am scared to come across as jealous or possessive. I should just watch how they interact with each other and maybe that will give me a clue.
"Hey Y/N, since you are our guest of honor tonight, what would you like for us to watch? I personally believe you would love Jupiter Jim!" Leo boasts about his love for Jim and how they have met him once. I got to love his charisma; he almost convinced me until Donnie stepped in.
"Leo, let HER decide. Don't try to manipulate movie night in your favor."
"Whoa, dear loving brother of mine; I WOULD NEVER. It is COMPLETELY up to her, I am just merely suggesting what you may call, 'Superior Cinema'." Raph comes up from behind Leo with his arms crossed, looming over the slider. Leo feels his presence and meekly backs down. The snapper than turns to me with a smile.
"Y/N, take your pick. It can be pretty much anything, as long as it is not 'Rated R' or too scary of a movie. Mikey gets nightmares easily."
"Hey! You didn't need to tell her that! I can handle it!"
"Mikey, little man, you slept in my bed for a week because you had an irrational fear of 10-foot spiders until Donnie had to prove to you that they don't exist...SCIENTIFICALLY! "Mikey rushes to cover his mouth.
"Stop talking! You are making me seem like a scaredy turtle!" A laugh comes from everyone until we heard footsteps approaching.
"Hey, guys! It's been a while! I have been so busy with college applications these days!" April has finally arrived, and I am not sure how to feel. I am not really upset about her, more nervous how we will interact. How much does she even know about me? Only one way to find out.
"April!" Mikey rushes to her to hold her tight. "I am so happy you can make it on short notice! We were just about to pick out a movie!" April smiles but the notices me between the rest of the turtles.
"Oh, I see, and this must be Y/N, the girl you and Donnie told me about!" Donnie talked to her about me? A worried look creeps up on my face and Donnie takes notice. He gentle places his hand on my shoulder and gives me a reassuring smile. He whispers in my ear.
"Don't worry, I didn't tell her everything. Just vaguely told her how we met and kept in contact. Go introduce yourself." I nod and walk over, holding my hand out for her to shake.
"Hey, yes, my name is y/n, nice to finally meet you, I heard a lot about you." She looks at my hand with a bit of a cautious stance but seems to let down her guard shortly after. She shakes my hand with enthusiasm and a small smile.
"Nice to finally meet you. It's nice to see that Splinter is willing to let more people in the circle. I would have figured he would be more upset."
"OH, HE WAS!" Chimed in Leo. "It was a bit tense at first buuuuuttt, he decided to let her stick around a bit and learn to train with us. Just so she can protect herself a bit better at least." Donnie loudly groans at Leo's careless mouth.
"Thank you, Mr. Exposition. I am sure y/n could have handled her own introduction."
"Geez Donnie, you have been getting on me hard lately. Just like THIS MORNING." Donnie and I had noticeable shivers, we knew what he was implying and quickly tried to change the subject.
"SO, APRIL! I heard you have known them roughly since they were tots."
"Oh, yeah! We go way back! Splinter has trusted me ever since. I have picked up on a few moves since knowing these knuckleheads, they are pretty much my brothers." Brothers, huh? Seems about as platonic you can get. I can do more casual probing later. Raph tries to get us back on track with the movie choice. April had a suggestion as well. "Well, if you guys don't mind, I did bring Donnie and I's favorite Jupiter Jim movie! I am sure y/n will like it." Leo's eyes go wide with glee.
"SEE?! Even April agrees that we should watch Jupiter Jim! Even if that is the less superior one." Raph side-eyes Leo, making him chuckle nervously.
"While I partially agree with Leo on the movie, as long as we watch it as a family, I don't really care what we watch!"
"Ditto!" Exclaimed Mikey. I admit, I felt a little on the spot, I mean, why did she have to say it was Donnie's and her favorite movie? Why specifically point that out? Maybe I am looking too hard into it.
"I guess we could watch it then." I smiled nervously and Donnie noticed once more.
"Are you sure? We have other options-"
"It's ok, really! I am sure I will like it! So, where do we go to view it?"
"I can guide you, just follow me." Donnie waves me on as April and Mikey follow just behind me. I could swear I felt eyes burning in the back of my head.
Once we got to the viewing room, there was already snacks laid out for some late-night viewing. Everyone was taking their seats. I took the edge of the couch, leaving plenty of space in the middle. April sits right next to me surprisingly, maybe she is more friendly than I thought. My mind was at ease until I noticed the only one not sat yet was Donnie and the last spot as right next to her. A felt my heart drop slightly, I was kind of hoping to have him by my side during the movie.
"Uh, hey April, do you mind if I sit in the middle?" Donnie meekly asks as she look up at him and shrugs, moving to the opposite end. "Oh, Y/N, do you need a blanket? It can get a bit cold in here sometimes." This guy really knows how to make my heart skip. I nodded as he left out the room quickly. April side glances a few times but I try to ignore it as I enjoy some popcorn. The boy felt some slight discomfort, so Mikey tried to break the ice.
"April, did you know that if y/n does well enough with training, she might get a weapon?! Just like you with your bat! Maybe y'all can spar one day!" I feel like even though he is trying to have well intentions, I think he is also sending me to the slaughter. April just laughs at Mikey.
"I guess we could one day, my bat can do some damage, fair warning."
"I am sure I could handle it; the bat is only as deadly as its owner. If you don't have power behind your swing than it is less effective." She gives a slightly twisted look as if I offended her. Oh no.
"What is THAT supposed to mean? Are you implying what you told Donnie earlier today?" Pause, DONNIE TOLD HER ABOUT OUR FIGHT?! No fucking wonder she is mad at me! She had just been playing nice this whole time. I am so sick of mental games today and decided to not keep it cute.
"Donnie and I got into it, yes but we made up and it is done. We are clearly cool."
"Uh huh, sure." April rolls her eyes at my response and Raph heavily sighs, hating to have to moderate once again.
"Uh ladies, please! We just want to have one night without drama! April, everything is fine now. No need to be defensive over Donnie and Y/N, I know you didn't mean anything by that statement, just be a bit more weary, ok?" Fair enough. Donnie makes his way back and notices the awkwardness.
"Um, did I miss something? I was only gone for like five minutes." I took charge to try to temper things down.
"It's nothing, Dee, we are about to start."
"Ok, well, here you go." Donnie provides a big enough blanket to cover all three of us on the couch. The movie finally starts and finally I felt the anxiety of everything go away. We all laughed and enjoyed the cheesy dialogue and provide our own. April even laughed at a few of my jokes, though I admit I did at some of hers as well.
Once the movie ended, I was pretty much dead to the world until Donnie woke me up.
"Hey, Y/N, you fell asleep, it's ok though. I will just tell you about the ending in the morning." I yawned and tried to adjust my eyes.
"Where is everyone?" The room was empty and clean, with just the two of us left behind.
"Everyone went to bed and April has gone home. Come on, let's get you to bed. Can you walk ok now?"
"Yeah, I think I am fine, just slight soreness."
"Ok, just hold my hand then so I can get you to bed-" I don't know what took over me, the fact that we were alone, the idea of having competition or just my raging desire but I just kissed him out of nowhere. It completely threw him off, but he didn't pull away either. He lightly reciprocated until he put a stop to it.
"W-well I wasn't expecting that. I am not complaining in the slightest but where did that come from?" What could I truly say? There were so many answers to that question. I just kept peppering his face in kisses, blaming it on my groggy state instead. Donnie never made me stop but he did not kiss me back either. If his face didn't begin to blush, I would have assumed he did not enjoy it. "That is not an answer, but you are clearly tired, if you like, I can carry you instead." I motion my hands for him to pick me up in a princess carry. I nuzzled my mouth into his neck, gently biting it as he walked. I could feel his body tense up every time I did.
"I am mad at you." I hummed into his neck.
He quietly responded, not breaking his stride. "Mad at me? Why?"
"You told April about our fight...jerk."
"Oh, I see...I'm sorry, I needed to vent, and I thought she would keep her feelings about it at bay. Is that why it was so awkward earlier?" I motioned my head in acknowledgment and he sighs. "You don't have anything to worry about, I promise. She and I are just good friends. She has been more understanding about me than my own brothers at times." We made it to his room once again, pushing us past the curtain. Once he knew we had privacy, he whispered in my ear.
"Let me make it up to you, tonight." My body reacted instantly to his warm breath in my ear, making me feel like I was melting in his arms. I played along.
"Oh? How do you plan on doing that?"
"Well, it is your last night with us until who knows how long, let me cater to you." He places me gently on his bed and looks down at me with care in his eyes. He caresses his hand on my face before leaning down to kiss my lips softly. We looked at each other with half-lidded eyes during the moment, taking in all in.
"What about keeping our distance?"
"Like I said, this might be the last time we can do anything like this for quite some time. I want us to be happy, even if it is just for one night." We sat in silence, knowing what may happen. Are we ready to take it so far? It has only been about three months, also, what if we got caught? "If you aren't ready for...THAT just yet, we can do other things." It was as if he was reading my mind.
"I do want to get closer, just not in that way, not yet. I think about it, ALOT, but we need to wait." He simply nods and continues kissing me softly. His lips were so soft and buttery from the popcorn during the movie. Soft moans escaped our lips as we knew our bodies were starting to crave for each other. He makes it so difficult for me to not just let him have me. He has catered to me in so many ways, yet he still feels like he should do more. I still want to do things at my own pace, but I need him. After a few moments, I finally told him. "I want you to taste me, Donnie." He lightly blushed and without saying another word, bite down on my neck. He sunk his teeth into me as far as he could, taking in that moment. I try to cover my mouth and he unhinged his jaw and peppers it with kisses. He keeps this pattern going for some time as he completely covers my collarbone in his mark. He looks at me intensely, as if hungry for more. He glides his hand under my shirt, gripping its edge and then looks about me for consent to lift it up. I nod and as if he has been waiting for years, he rips my shirt in half unexpectedly. I was a bit shocked.
"D-Donnie! That's not what I-"
"Do you not want me to taste ALL of you?" This smug S.O.B
"Y-yes but you j-just ripped my shirt!"
"I figured that I can just fix it later. For now..." He takes a finger and traces it down my body slowly. "Let me enjoy my feast." I have never seen him so ravenous. It was so erotic that I could feel my wetness seep out and soak my shorts. Donnie sniffs the air and chuckles. "Smells like you want this pretty badly, my darling." I could not help but blush profusely. Is this the same guy from the lunch, training and the movie?! He unhinges his mouth once more and stamps his teeth into my skin once more, working his way down my body. When he bit on my breasts and nipples, he spent more time there to kiss and lick the marks as if to help heal them faster. My body arched at every sudden impacted. I tried to hold back my excitement from escaping his room. He was teasing me, taunting me, while on the attack. Soon he made to the tight shorts I was wearing and nuzzled his beak in the fabric, licking the area slowly.
"A-ah D-Donnie!" I was remarkably sensitive to his tongue as he continued to glaze my womanhood. He looked up at me with a smug expression and that is when it hit me. He is trying to get back me for earlier. This was not just an apology, but retaliation towards my disrespect from earlier! Before I could speak, he takes me in one bite and sucks are hard as he could. Almost making me lose my mind! How could this guy know so much on how to turn a girl on?! A thought crossed my mind, but I did not want to spoil the moment...I can ask at another time. He takes the fabric between his teeth and pulls down the shorts; I raise my hips to help him. He takes a moment to look at my exposed lower region. He spreads my lips wide while groping my inner thighs, licking his lips and enjoying the scent of his incoming meal.
"You smell absolutely tantalizing Y/N, I can stay down here forever I could. You are so unbelievably wet, and your pussy is so pink-"
"S-stop!" I covered my face in embarrassment, he was analyzing my wet and wanting entrance, seeing it up close for the first time. His words were intoxicating, my body was heating up and my juices followed more freely.
"Oh? Why should I? It seems you have a bit of a praise kink, how cute. You are starting to soak my sheets, let us not waste more time." He takes a long stroke of his tongue deep inside me and wiggles it around, trying to taste me at every angle.
"D-Donnie! Please! If you keep going like that, I'll-" He abruptly stops to my dismay.
"You are right, I don't want you to finish just yet, darling." He takes a finger and circles my entrance, teasing it to open wider for him. He slides his thick digit inside an goes back to feasting at the same time. My hands grab for his head, tugging at his mask tails. I can feel the vibrations of a chuckle. He has me where he wants me, keeping me from going over the edge. What a sadistic creature, but I love it. He has an intensity that he is only showing to me, and I am so grateful for it. I can hear every sound he makes, even when my ears go hot. He hooks the finger inside me and rubs my top wall aggressively while pressing down on my abdomen to keep me from lifting too high. My body twists as I feel myself ready to give.
"P-Please! I need to come, Donnnnieee!" He stops once more and lifts his face, his mouth glistening with the reflection of his purple LED lights.
"Beg more for me." I am so getting him back for this.
"I- I need to come! Please, Dee!" I whimpered as he surprises me with inserting a second finger. "AH! NGH!"
"You sound so pretty when you beg, baby. You deserve your reward." He goes back down and works at full velocity to bring me back to my state of euphoria.
"I-I'm..AHHHH!" I climax right into his throat, and he does not move for a few moments, as if he tried to get every drop of me. My legs flop on the sheets while I heavily pant. I was unable to say a word, that was the strongest climax I have had in so long that I forgot that I could experience something that wonderful. Donnie sits up finally and laughs, he knows that I cannot say anything at the moment but speaks.
"Hehe, you got my mask soaked, so naughty of you. You are lucky that I have spares."
Remind me, why I like this guy again?
"Y-you are s-such an asshole."
"Maybe, but I am sure you will be able to have an even better night sleep now." He takes off all of his clothes and even his mask, tossing it in the hamper.
"You better hope that your brothers don't detect my scent."
"They might but I can always argue that it is your natural-at state scent. You have been in my room for two days now. They are perspective at times but still not as bright and I."
"I suppose, I will just have to trust you." Donnie picks up a washcloth and helps me with aftercare.
"Wow Y/N, I did not think it was possible to produce so much but you proved me wrong, you must have truly enjoyed yourself. Thanks to me, of course." I toss a pillow at his face because he was right. That experience was addicting, and I wanted more. He places the pillow back in place and motions for me to go under the covers. Once I was covered, he starts to turn around to go sleep in the chair again.
"Can you sleep with me tonight?" He slowly turns back at me with a slightly surprised look and then a gentle smile.
"I was hoping you would ask." He gets in the bed with me and cuddles. Once more, he bumps his head against mine.
"Why do you do that?"
"Oh, it's my animal instinct, my species does that to show affection." I look at him for a bit and then gently bump my head against his and he blushes, holding me close as we finally drift off to sleep.
Little did we know what trials will come between us.