"I didn't lie when I said I don't know her." Chris said, gesturing towards Melinda. Then he pointed towards P.J.and said, "Her I do know and she can't go in the club: She's only 19." Although he wasn't willing to divulge they were cousins and he doubted she would either. He didn't like having to tell anything and would have rather kept the 'I don't know you, you don't know me' game up longer in front of the sisters and Leo, but that went out the window when they heard Melinda say she was his sister.

P.J. scoffed and said, "As long as we don't order alcohol we can."

"I can't risk my license. How old are you Melissa?"

"I'm 19 too."

"I see. In that case, if you plan to talk to Chris just beam into his room in the back office of my club P3 and don't come out." Piper said.

The girls weren't happy - Piper let them do it in their future - but they didn't argue. The girls were surprised to hear that Chris was living in the backroom of P3, though.

Piper and Paige stayed up and talked to the girls a little. Piper and Paige were surprised that the girls were a bit more forthcoming with a lot of things than Chris and even joked about it. After an hour or so of talking they got the girls settled and changed. Piper and Paige turned in.

Melinda and P.J looked up and at the sound of orbs and saw a letter form on the bed. Mel picked it up and read, "We need to talk in private. Meet me in the park near Golden Gate bridge. Chris."

"Let's go." Melinda said.

"But if we tell your mom or Aunt Paige they'll want to come too or forbid us from going. Wait what's on the other paper?"

Melinda then noticed another page, "Here's a spell to make it appear as if you're sleeping."

"Wow, he thought of everything." P.J. said.

Melinda said the spell and they beamed to the park. They didn't see anyone at first so they jumped when they heard Chris speak.

"I'm glad you came. Are you going to tell me why you're really here? What does Wyatt hope to accomplish by sending you and this girl here, P.J.? He knows I won't join him."

"Join him? What do you mean? You and Wyatt are always together fighting demons." P.J. questioned. She also found it strange as the Chris she knew always called her Ladybug.

Chris raised an eyebrow, "Why would Wyatt fight demons with me? He rules the demons."

"What no way! Wyatt is way too good to do anything like that!" P.J.said.

"He rules the demons, how?" Melinda asked, shocked. "Ladybug's right - Wyatt would never do that. Mom and dad would never let that happen."

"Yeah, you know Piper and Leo who don't seem to know you're their son." P.J. added.

"If this is a bid to try to convince me like you did the others that you're from a different future, then you're going to have to do better than that. Practically every mortal and witch knows who me and Wyatt are. One trip to the Halliwell museum will tell you that and more."

"We have a museum about us? How, why? Wait, are you saying mortals know about magic?" P.J.asked shocked.

"Wait, this isn't going to get us anywhere. You don't believe that we're from an alternate future. You said earlier you would agree to a modified truth spell. Why can't we use it for all of us? Then maybe you'll finally believe us." Melinda said.

Chris thought about it and had to admit it wasn't a bad idea. If they were really from an alternate future then there'd be no harm telling them things, and if they were telling the truth then maybe there was hope for his mission. "Fine, agreed. Let's form a circle. For those who want the truth revealed, open hearts and secrets unsealed, from now until the hour ends, after which the spell ends. Those who now are in this circle, will hear the truth from other's mouths. Okay let's start, who sent you?"

"No one sent us." P.J. said and once again repeated what happened with Melinda and the demon.

Chris was surprised it was exactly what had been said earlier, "Who are you?" Chris asked Melinda.

"I'm Piper and Leo's daughter, Melinda. I'm also yours and Wyatt's little sister. I'm three years younger than you. I really don't exist in your world?"

"No, Wyatt was kidnapped while mom was still pregnant with me and the shock sent mom into labor. I heard it was touch and go and we were both almost lost. I can only guess that's why she never had another. Plus, with Leo spending more time as an elder, and everything with Wyatt they never found the time for another child. "

"Wyatt was kidnapped by who? "

Chris sighed, "I was hoping you being from another future you could tell me. If I knew I'd have already taken care of it and not continued to deal with the distrust of mom and the aunts."

"Um, sorry but if they ever knew I don't remember them ever telling us." Melinda said.

"Great."

"Dad didn't look like he trusted you either."

Chris scoffed, "Like I care what he thinks.

Melinda blinked in surprise, "But…"

"Mel stop, don't tell him."

Melinda looked at her, "Why not? He's trusting us with his life story by agreeing to a truth spell."

"It might change the future."

Chris glared at P.J. "So are you finally ready to admit it?"

"Admit what?"

"You don't want her to talk because then I might actually start to believe you. Your guilty conscience over being forced to work for Wyatt got to you. So the spell or whatever you used to defeat the truth spell was all one big lie. I should have realized it sooner: I started to believe you, I almost let my guard down, and when you finally knew you had me you'd spring your trap and find a way to trick me into going back, or just knock me out and beam me back."

P.J. sighed, "No that's not it. Aunt Piper and Aunt Paige said you never tell them anything about the future. So why would you expect us to tell you?"

At that Chris sneered, "Fine don't tell me." He knew he shouldn't have let his guard down. He did understand the need for future consequences, but if they really were from a good-Wyatt alternate universe then where was the harm in telling him? It's no different than him telling them his future. Telling them things they can't change.

P.J. sighed, happy he understood and they could move past this.

Her happiness was short-lived when he said, "I'm sure Wyatt gave you a spell to return home. Use it and go back and tell him you failed. You might want to mention your little friend's lies about pretending she was our sister. I'm sure Wyatt would just love to hear someone using our mother's name in vain like that!"

Melinda frowned "How can we use our mother's name in vain? That usually only applies if they're dead, and mom's very much alive."

"Okay you know what, now I know you didn't bother to read up on our family history before you came and that's your mistake. Lying about my mother having another child was one thing, but now trying to tell me that she's… No, I'm done with this and you." With that he orbed out leaving both girls confused.