Chapter 25
Friendly Banter and Drunken Crowds (Part 1)
The rest of September and most of October went by rather quickly for everybody. Trevor had officially asked Casey to be his girlfriend a few weeks after Elliot's party, with Casey gladly accepting. Elliot and Kathy continued their budding romance, Kathy basically living with Elliot, Olivia and the guys even though she had her own apartment. Amanda had even finally given Johnny a chance, and was set to go out with him on a second date sometime around Halloween.
And then, there was Olivia and Alex. These two were incapable of letting nearly any time pass without talking, texting, kissing, holding, laughing, touching, joking, or being with one another. Their adoration for each other continued to blossom and grow, falling harder for one another with each passing day. They agreed to do study dates every Wednesday at the study hall, followed by dinner afterwards. Alex would spend the night with Olivia on Fridays, and spend her day with Casey on Saturdays. They were having so much fun, they barely remembered to make plans for Halloween.
"Why is the block party the 25th and 26th?" Elliot asked, chomping on an apple as he surveyed the bright orange flyer laying on the counter.
"Because Halloween is a Thursday," Kathy answered, grabbing Elliot's apple and taking a bite.
"So? They could've just had it Thursday night then."
"No, they couldn't. That's encouraging students not to go to class the next day. And you can't have a Halloween block party in November. So it's gotta be the weekend before," Kathy tried to explain.
Elliot sighed, laying the flyer down. "Liv, what're we doing for this?"
Olivia wasn't paying attention. She was smiling dumbly at her phone, replying to whatever it was that Alex had sent her.
"Olivia!" Elliot spoke, loud enough to hopefully break her of her trance.
Hitting send, Olivia whipped her head over to look at Elliot. "What up?"
"What are we doing for Halloween?"
"Shit. I don't know." Olivia shrugged. "We headed to the block party? We'll need to pre-game. The bars are going to be ridiculous."
"What about your girlfriend?"
"What about her?" Olivia raised her eyebrow at Elliot, turning further on the couch to face him.
"She's 18, Liv. She can't even get in the bars."
Olivia sighed. "Well, that's just another reason to pre-game then. Even if she had a fake ID, I am not about to stand in those overcrowded bars."
Elliot pursed his lips and nodded, palms flat against the counter as Kathy wrapped her arms around him from behind. "Yeah, okay. I get it. So, what's the plan?"
Oliva brought her knees up to her chest, wrapping her arms around her legs as she rested her chin on her knees, deep in thought. "How about we double date that day? Go grab lunch, come back here and pre-game, then get ready and head up to the block party?"
Elliot looked at Kathy, sharing an unspoken conversation, with both nodding before turning back to Olivia. "Alright. Sounds like a plan! Just us, or are we inviting anyone else?"
"Hmm. Alex will probably want Casey there. Should we invite Johnny and Amanda?"
Elliot laughed and shook his head. "I don't get why she's giving that dumbass a chance. But I'm alright with it if you are."
Olivia shrugged in response. "I'm cool with it."
"Cool. I'll text Johnny and let him know the plan. You get Blondie and Red on board."
Olivia gave a thumbs up as she returned her attention back to her phone. She had 2 texts from Alex.
Alex: U are killing me Liv, lol.
Alex: I miss u btw. Can't wait for our study date on Wed (:
Olivia: Hilarious, right!?
Olivia had sent Alex the YouTube video "How Animals Eat Their Food." She swore it was the funniest video to ever exist.
Olivia: Also, me too baby. I miss u too! Just wanna cuddle. We should watch that Orange is the New Black show on Netflix everyone is talking about. I heard there's lesbians in it lol.
Alex: very funny lol.
Alex: really? That's the only reason why u wanna watch lol.
Olivia: maybe lol. Also, got any plans for the block party?
Alex: ur such a pervert Olivia! Lol. But ur my pervert :p. But no, don't think so. Why?
Olivia: (; ok cuz we were all thinking we could go on a big double date? Then pre-game at my place n then hit the block party. U and Casey in?
Alex: oh okay! Sounds fun (: we r in!
Olivia: great babe, I'll send u the details ltr (:
Alex: k (:
Early Friday afternoon, everyone met up at Mel's Burger Bar for lunch, grabbing the large table outside. Olivia, Alex, Casey, and Trevor sat on one side while Elliot, Kathy, Amanda, and Johnny sat on the other side.
"You know," Johnny said. "This isn't really a double date. It's like a quad date."
"Nice observation, genius," Olivia teased, which then caused her to have to duck a straw wrapper being blown her direction. Alex gave a light chuckle as she gently slapped Olivia's thigh under the table, warning her to be nice.
"I'm surprised Blondie agreed to burgers," Elliot said, skimming over the menu.
"Elliot…" Olivia warned.
"I don't hate burgers, Muscles," Alex challenged. "I just prefer pizza."
"What're you gonna get then? I need to see your choice in burgers. Then I can decide if we can be friends." Elliot gave her an innocent smile as Olivia sighed next to Alex. Olivia was always on the defensive for Alex, but Elliot and Alex had their own friendship with each other in friendly banter; they picked on each other all the time.
"Hot Mess burger with fries and a chocolate shake."
Elliot nodded his head as he pursed his lips. "Alright, alright. That's a lot of heat Blondie, sure you can take it?"
"Probably better than you can, Muscles." Alex gave a devilish smile as the others at the table gave some laughs and "ooohhs."
Elliot ran his tongue across his bottom lip and sat his menu down, before intertwining his fingers together and looking at Alex. "Fine. You're on, Cabot."
Alex extended her arm across the table for Elliot to take. "Shake on it, Stabler?" Elliot proudly returned a strong handshake, signaling the deal.
"So, what do I get when I win?" Elliot asked.
Alex pondered for a moment before responding. "Next weekend, I won't come over. You can have Olivia all weekend for the Xbox."
"Hey!" Olivia said, turning to look at Alex. "I don't agree to this."
"What, you don't think I'm going to win?" Alex challenged back with a wicked smile that immediately made Olivia bite her lip.
"Good point."
"And what do I get when I win?" Alex challenged Elliot.
"I'll make sure the house is clear next Friday so you and Liv can let your freak flags fly."
Olivia nearly choked on her drink. "Jesus, Elliot! Seriously?"
Alex only stuck her hand out again, Elliot gladly taking it in his and shaking firmly.
"Great. I'm sure we'll have lots of fun in your bed Elliot, won't we babe?" Alex grabbed Olivia's hand in hers as she looked over at a shocked Elliot.
Olivia was actually choking now. Casey had her head back laughing hysterically against Trevor and Kathy and Amanda only smiled and laughed. Johnny wasn't paying attention to what just happened.
"Alex I fucking love you," Casey said, wiping stray tears away as she wrapped her arms around Alex's shoulders.
Alex leaned her head against Casey's, laughing back as she said "I love you too, Casey."
"Alright!" Elliot said, clapping his hands together and rubbing them before reaching down and grabbing the burger. "Damn, these are huge. Sure you can even put it all away, Blondie?"
"You've obviously never seen her eat," Casey said, picking up her single cheeseburger.
"Yeah, she definitely eats a lot," Olivia said with a smirk, Alex turning to look at her before immediately blushing and shaking her head. It took the others a minute to get the joke before laughing – Elliot hanging his head in his chest.
"Alright alright, come on Blondie. Let's see who can win this thing." To set the stakes a little higher, Alex and Elliot ordered extra jalapenos and extra hot sauce on their burgers.
Alex gladly picked up her burger and started diving in; the quick heat of the jalapenos and hot sauce comfortably burning her tongue. She declined to mention to them before her wager that she was a big fan of spicy food, and had a high tolerance for spice. Casey knew this, but didn't say anything either – she wanted Alex to win, and figured she would.
After a few minutes, Elliot let out a breath of air as he took a sip of his milkshake. Alex only smiled as she continued to eat her burger.
About halfway through, Elliot's forehead was starting to sweat, and he quickly adjusted the collar of his t-shirt before guzzling down half of his drink.
"You doing alright there, Elliot?" Amanda asked, watching intently between Elliot, who was struggling, and Alex, who was completely un-phased.
Elliot only nodded and he breathed in through his nose to suck up some of the mucus that was threatening to escape. He then looked up at Alex who was nearly done with her burger; not a sign of discomfort, nor a bead of sweat on her. He groaned before setting his burger down to chug more of his shake.
Olivia was intently watching Alex eat. She couldn't explain it, but it was so hot seeing tiny, shy, skinny Alex out-eat her 6-foot-tall muscular best friend.
"I feel like I got hustled," Elliot breathed out.
Alex only laughed as she finished the rest of her burger, dipping it into a pile of hot sauce as if to add insult to injury. "Why is that?" She said after swallowing her last bite and wiping her mouth.
"I really didn't think you could… how the hell did you finish it already?!" Elliot exclaimed, groaning as he looked over to Alex.
Casey started laughing again. "I tried to tell you, dude. You've obviously never seen Alex eat. She could out-eat all of us."
Alex only smiled as she dipped her fries in hot sauce.
"You're insane. I give up. You win, Blondie." Elliot held his stomach as he drank his milkshake.
Olivia couldn't help but squeeze Alex's thigh under the table before turning to her. "You are literally so hot," she quietly said with a smile. Alex turned to her and leaned down for a kiss.
"But please promise me… don't fuck on my bed next week."
Alex couldn't help but laugh. "I won't, I promise. I was only teasing you."
Elliot gave her a smile and nod as everyone started conversing about the block party that evening.
"I can't believe we binged-watched that show in like 3 days," Alex laughed, throwing on her orange jumpsuit before taking a few swigs of her Smirnoff Ice Blueberry Lemonade.
"Right? Not to mention, we finally figured out a good Halloween costume. I also can't wait for season 2!" Olivia threw on her tan jumpsuit and black-haired wig before rolling up the fake arm-tattoo sleeves, and then chugging half of her Jack and Coke.
"Yeah, it actually really wasn't bad. I'm excited for it!" Alex took her glasses off and threw in her contact lenses before clipping the prisoner badge to her shirt pocket. She quickly fixed her hair before turning around. "Well, how do I look?"
Olivia slipped on the lens-less glasses to compliment her costume as she turned around to look at Alex.
"Wow. You look just like Piper," she said with a smile.
Alex walked over to Olivia and helped her adjust some strands on the wig. "And you look just like… Alex." She laughed after the sentence. "That's a weird thing to say."
Olivia laughed as she wrapped her arms around Alex's waist. "It is, isn't it? But you look great, babe. I miss your glasses though."
"You like them that much, huh?" Alex teased, tracing her fingers along Olivia's shoulders.
"Mmm, I do," Olivia growled, leaning up to give Alex a hungry kiss. "They make you extra fuckable."
Alex only giggled as she bit her lip. "Liv… you better stop. We just got ready."
"Hey, no one said anything about getting un-ready." Olivia gave Alex another hungry kiss as she pushed her backwards against her bedroom door, sliding her hands down Alex's front.
"Liv…" Alex warned, leaning her head back against the door as Olivia kissed her neck and ran her hand across Alex's left thigh. "You better… mmm… Liv, we – we don't have… mmm… we don't have time for – ahhh!"
Alex couldn't help but gasp as Olivia slid her hand inside of Alex's pants and underwear, immediately sliding two fingers inside of her lips up and down along their length.
"Just a few minutes," Olivia husked, lightly biting Alex's neck which made her shiver. "Come on, baby. You're already so wet for me."
Alex moved her hand over her mouth to stifle a loud moan as she closed her eyes and pushed her legs farther apart. "Olivia… you know I… mmm… I can't take it when you… mmmm fuck… you talk to me like that!"
Olivia only smiled as she continued to nip at Alex's neck, palming one of her breasts with her free hand as her hand in Alex's pants worked fervently against Alex's clit. Within minutes, Alex's hips were already starting to grind forward as her breathing became shallower.
Olivia, so unbelievably hungry for Alex, wanted to drive her over the edge immediately. She kissed up to Alex's ear to whisper, "You're such a good girl, Alex. Now I want you to cum for me."
The reaction was instantaneous. Alex clamped her hand over her mouth again as her legs trembled and her hips bucked forward; muffled moans escaping her mouth as she climaxed against Olivia's hand.
Olivia dipped her fingers lower to scoop up the juices before taking her hand out of Alex's pants and bringing it up to her mouth to suck off the wetness; giving a small moan of her own as she tasted Alex. All Alex could do was watch breathlessly, her bottom lip between her teeth again.
"I love how easy you cum sometimes, Alex. It's so hot." Olivia bit her lip as she turned to grab her wallet so they could leave, but was stopped by Alex grabbing her arm and spinning her around, pinning Olivia to the door, who chuckled.
"Babe, we gotta get going."
Alex pressed her lips hard against Olivia's in a bruising kiss. "Not so fast. You're not getting away with this that easily."
Olivia let out a shaky breath before responding. "We're supposed to all be leaving in like 2 minutes. We can continue this later."
Alex didn't care. She swiftly got down on her knees as she grabbed the waist of Olivia's pants and underwear, pulling them down to her ankles.
"Alex!" Olivia said with a laugh, watching as she bit her lip. "What are you doing?!"
Alex shot Olivia an icy stare from down on her knees as she pressed her mouth directly onto Olivia's already wet sex. Olivia put her hand on Alex's head, lightly running her fingers through her hair as she spread her legs further apart.
"Fuck…" Olivia breathed, her own head hitting against the door. "Babe, they're gonna be calling for us any minute to get down there."
Alex broke away with a pop as she husked up to Olivia, "Then you better cum quick for me then, Olivia," before driving her tongue directly back to Olivia dripping folds.
Olivia let out her own soft moan as she grabbed tighter onto Alex's hair, keeping her pressed to her center. Alex continued to lick and lap at Olivia's clit ferociously, with Olivia's legs soon beginning to shake above her.
Just as her climax was building, there was a knock on the outside of her door.
"Liv, Blondie, you ready?" Elliot asked.
"Uhhh….." Olivia let out a few shaky breaths before continuing. "In… in a minute, El."
"You alright?"
"Ye.. ye-ahhh!" Olivia looked down at Alex who was clearly trying not to laugh against her lover as she continued to lick. "Just… just… mmmm!... fine, El!"
"Are you?... Oh God. Hurry up damn it!"
"Are they ready?" A voice that sounded like Casey's was now outside the door.
Olivia shot a look down at Alex as she shook her head back and forth. Alex only winked as she reached two fingers up and slid them into Olivia, coaxing a loud moan from her lover who now also cupped her hand over her mouth.
"Alex!" Casey called from outside the door. "Are you guys serious right now?!"
Alex growled as she reluctantly tore her mouth away from Olivia, but still kept her fingers pumping inside of her. "Casey, Elliot, just… 5 minutes and we'll be down." Olivia's eyes were fluttering closed as she was breathing strongly through her nose.
"Nope, not leaving. If we do you guys will be in there all night. So come on!" Elliot said, clapping his hands together to hurry them up.
Alex stood up and bent down to whisper to Olivia, fingers still slamming inside of her. "You're going to need to cum for me, I'm afraid. We've got plans." She then retreated her fingers from inside of Olivia and drug them up to her clit, rubbing ferociously. She wanted Olivia to cum like she made her cum moments before. Olivia pressed her hand harder against her mouth, struggling to stifle the moans.
Alex then whispered a few more words that she hoped would send Olivia flying. "Come on, be my good girl and cum for me, Olivia."
As Alex had hoped, the words had the desired effect. Olivia's breathing quickly picked up as her own hips bucked forward into Alex's touch, riding out her climax. She let her hand drop from her mouth and held Alex close to her as she moaned rather loudly through the end of her orgasm.
"Jesus, Olivia!" Elliot groaned.
Casey only laughed. "Hey, she had to finish!"
"What is taking so long?" Kathy said, now standing with them outside of Olivia's door.
"Our lovebirds can't seem to get enough nectar," Elliot groaned.
Kathy raised her eyebrows at him before laughing. "Liv, come on! You guys can fuck later!"
"What are we waiting on?" Amanda said, now also upstairs.
Just then, the door to Olivia's room opened, everyone turning their attention to them.
"Seriously? Do you guys want a show? Next time we'll just go down to the couch since we can't ever have any shred of privacy in this house!" Olivia was trying to sound aggravated, but honestly, she couldn't of cared less. All she cared about was throwing Alex down and doing the same things to her. She made her way out of the room, with Alex following behind who was wiping her chin on her shirt.
"Damn, Lex!" Casey beamed, a wicked grin on her face. "Didn't get enough to eat at lunch, huh?"
"Oh God!" Elliot groaned, turning to head down the stairs, Kathy following behind laughing.
Alex immediately turned red and Olivia closed her eyes and laid her head against the wall in the hallway.
"Wow," was all Amanda said before chuckling and turning to head down the stairs, leaving Olivia, Casey, and Alex still in the hallway.
"This is your fault, you know," Alex said to Olivia. "You started it."
"And you surely finished it," Olivia purred, smirking before heading downstairs.
Casey couldn't help the belly-laugh that came. "You guys are my fucking favorite. Now come on, let's go to the block party!"
