Brandy was rehearsing for tonight as they had arrived in New York.
"We gotta win…" Brandy says.
Charity was in a department store, looking for an anniversary dress. But she still couldn't find anything she liked.
Leni makes Charity a dress for her anniversary, which would be tomorrow.
Brandy and Randy head out for lunch.
"Just so you know, I totally think I'll be in 1st soon." Randy says as Brandy sighed.
Luke was getting ready for the show. He was with Chalice, trying on an Alina-designed costume. He smiled.
Lucy was going to get the cake for tomorrow. She arrived at the bakery, picked it up, and left with it.
The triplets was rehearsing as they planned on beating Luke.
Luke overhears and hissed.
Later, Gemma and April take the stage at Madison Square Garden.
"Welcome, one and all, to Madison Square Garden! Tonight, you are here to witness a battlefield full of Broadway and Broadway-style performances!" April says.
"Again, this will be a quintuple elimination show, sending our top 8 teams to the Dazzling Disney show in Orlando, Florida! So, if you want your team of choice in that show, then vote, vote, vote!" Gemma says.
"Coming up first is the team that will really throw you for a loop! Presenting Oliver Fox, Cuphead, and Mugman!" April says.
Everyone cheered as they went on stage. They performed their rendition of "The Meek Shall Inherit" from the Broadway version of Little Shop Of Horrors. Mugman played a very convincing version of Seymour Krelborn.
The crowd was in awe of their performance.
Cuphead smiled. But Lucy made it clear she would choose Luke.
The crowd cheered as they finished.
The triplets were up next and they performed the song "Alexander Hamilton" from the musical Hamilton.
People cheered and clapped.
"Coming up next is the team that will give you a fantastic time! You may want an encore, give it up for the cosmic buddies!" April says.
They began their "Circle Of Life" performance as the crowd cheered.
At that point, Luke just screamed and left Madison Square Garden.
"Luke, wait!" Chalice says and runs after him.
"Why? I think I was just getting outdone by everyone else!" Luke sobbed.
"No, you aren't, you haven't even gone on." Chalice says.
"I don't have to go on to know that I'm being outdone." Luke says sadly.
"You're not. You're better than them." Chalice says.
"That isn't the point." Luke says. "Did you not hear what I just said?!"
"We can still win." Chalice says.
"I'm going to tell everyone that I just….just…." But Luke couldn't find the words as he began sobbing.
"No, Luke." Chalice says and comforts him.
Lori sees Luke in tears and runs to where Chalice and Luke are.
"What's wrong?" Lori asked.
"LUKE WILL ALWAYS BE OUTDONE WHETHER HE IS PERFORMING OR NOT!" Luke shouted and sobbed.
Lori holds him and reassures him that he isn't being outdone.
The cosmic buddies soon finish to loud cheering.
Alem tuber turned Super Saiyan as people cheered. He flew up and flew around as he soon reverted to normal and landed.
"Epic!" Alex says.
"Yep, we're the best, number 1!" Alem tuber says.
Luke was still outside the venue. He couldn't take it anymore. He took his costume off and walked away. The siblings try to comfort him.
"Hey, you can beat Oliver." Lucy says
"You can win!" Leni says.
"Positive thinking. You have to think positive." Luan says
"I'll just lose. On purpose. That's the only way anyone ever pays attention to me, anyway!" Luke screams.
"We do pay attention." Lisa says.
"I'm not going on, then! Let THEM win!" Luke was obviously frustrated and stressed. "That's what they want! They want ME out of the picture!"
"Luke, listen, you need to have thick skin. You're just hurting yourself by giving up." Lquan says.
Luke just screamed and hissed at the latest scoreboard. The cosmic buddies were in first. It made him very stressed out.
"It's okay, Luke. You know you're better than them." Lynn says.
"Yeah! Go out there and show the world that the Cosmic buddies are fakes." Lisa says.
"We can win. You have me…and Brandy, I think…nah, really just us." Chalice says as she helps Luke into his costume. Luke was still shedding tears.
Lucy gave him a tissue. Luke wiped his eyes and tried to smile, but it was hard.
Chalice leads him back inside.
"Coming up next are the stars of the show. The ones that you really came here to see…Luke Huntington, Mrs. Chalice, and Brandy Waterlash!' April says as the crowd screamed.
The trio appeared and performed "Fame" by Irene Cara.
As they performed, Brandy tripped due to his clumsiness and nerves. Chalice helped him up. Luke could feel his confidence falling.
"Sorry, I'm useless." Brandy says as they continue.
They soon finish and Luke just walks offstage, in tears.
"Unbelievable…how is Alem tuber in first?!" Troy asked
"We need to beat him once and for all! He has to be cheating!" Tristan says.
Brandy walked out as he hit himself over and over. Luke knew they were being eliminated. He began to cry again as he just left.
Gemma was not eliminating Luke, not at all.
But Luke just wanted to cry. He knew his performance was horrible tonight.
"You did amazing tonight." Leni says.
"Yeah, and you're still in this. We know you can win." Lori says.
Luke just walked off to be alone.
He was back in the hotel and he just ignored all the flowers, toys, candy, and fan mail as he cried on his bed. He then looked at his costumes and started to tear them off the hanging rack they were on.
Leni tries to stop him from tearing the costumes to pieces. Luke doesn't do anything except stomp them into the floor. He then kicks the hanger rack and screams.
Leni gave him his plush polar bear. Luke sniffed and held it close to him, taking in its toasted marshmallow scent.
Meanwhile, Angry Luigi ran up the walls outside the hotel and tried to run on a wire, but Alem tuber snapped the rope, shocking him.
Alem tuber smirked.
Later, Angry Luigi tried opening the window as Alem tuber slammed it on his hands. Angry Luigi fell down harshly.
Alem tuber began to relax when Angry Luigi came in, wrapped him in the blanket, tossed him out the window, and began to relax as he drank soda.
Alem tuber offered him a glass as Angry Luigi was stunned. He tried whacking Alem tuber with his mallet, but Alem tuber dodged each attack as the brawl continued.
The triplets recorded this.
"Better?" Leni asked Luke.
"I should just….just…" Luke says, shaking.
"What do you want to do?" Leni asked.
"Let me ask you a question. What do you want me to do?" Luke asked.
"I want you to be happy." Leni says.
"I'm happiest when I'm performing on stage. But after tonight, I just...I don't know anymore…" Luke says.
Lucy finished planning. But Charity was seen sitting with Leni and Luke.
"Sigh, I think the other teams are cheating…" Lucy says, but no one heard as Luke sobbed.
Skylia came to see the chaos as the Cosmic buddies had a brawl. She facepalms.
That night, Chalice reads Luke a bedtime story as he's crying himself to sleep.