The setting changed to on the ship where the crew of the ship was celebrating a birthday party of sorts.
Then two chefs who were portrayed by Chef Hatchet and Roger walked on the ship with a cake towards Luz.
"We baked you a birthday cake." Chef sang.
"If you get a tummy ache." Roger sang.
"And you moan, and groan, and woan." Chef sang.
"Don't forget we told you so." Chef and Roger sang at the same time.
Luz chuckled.
"Aw, you guys." said Luz.
Then King appeared next to her.
"Go ahead, make a wish." said King.
Luz looked at the cake.
"Here we go." said Luz.
She then blew out the candles, only for the entire cake to explode, causing the audience to laugh.
The smoke cleared up, revealing an annoyed Luz was covered in frosting.
Chef glared at Roger.
"I told you we shouldn't have used those trick candles for this scene." said Chef.
"Well you're the one who filled the cake with gasoline after deflating it like in that one Three Stooges short." said Roger.
Chef realized Rogers point and nodded.
"Good point." said Chef.
Luz wiped the frosting off her face before smiling.
"Aw, Chef Louie and Sous Chef Rich, you shouldn't have." Luz said before becoming annoyed again, "You really, really shouldn't have."
"Yeah, we know." said Roger.
Amity climbed up the side of the ship and saw what was going on.
She whistled.
"Wow, this is nice." said Amity.
But then she noticed King staring at her.
"Uh, what're you doing?" said King.
Amity shrieked and fell off the boat and hit the water.
"MAX, GET BACK HERE!" yelled Luz's voice.
King ran off and continued to party as Amity climbed back onto the ship and saw everything.
"At that moment, Ariel saw the most beautiful human she has ever set eyes on." said the narrator.
Amity then saw Izzy chugging down lots of soda from a barrel before tossing it away and burping so loud and cheered happily.
"I SAID BEAUTIFUL, NOT CRAZY!" yelled the narrator.
Izzy groaned and walked off dejected.
"Awwwwwww." the audience said sympathetically.
Amity then noticed Luz playing an accordion and became stunned.
"When Ariel saw Princess Erica, it was love at first sight, just like music." said the narrator.
Then suddenly; the Eminem song Ass Like That started playing.
Backstage; Crunch was looking at his phone in shock.
"Whoops, wrong kind of romance song." said Crunch.
He pushed an icon on the phone, changing the song to Sir Mix-a-Lot's Baby Got Back.
Crunch pushed the icon again, changing the song to Tenacious D's Fuck Her Gently.
The shark pushed the icon, changing the song to Kiss's I Was Made For Loving You.
He pushed the icon, changing the song to Lionel Richie's Say You, Say Me.
"That's better." said Crunch.
Interview Gag
"I really need to keep track of songs more often." said Crunch.
End Interview Gag
Amity kept on looking at Luz before sighing romantically.
"ARIEL!" yelled a voice.
Amity turned around to see that her surface friends had appeared on a boat.
"Hey Guys!" She called.
"Fancy seeing you here Kid!" spoke Scratch as he floated to her.
"Yeah, same here." said Amity.
The humans climbed up the side of the boat and looked at the party happening.
"This is a happening place." said Molly.
Amity sighed happily at the sight of Luz.
"Haven't you seen such a beautiful site?" said Amity.
Scratch looked around.
"You mean the orange haired girl drinking a barrel of soda?" said Scratch.
Amity glared at the Ghost.
"WHAT NO NOT HER!" She snarled.
Ollie looked around.
"That Meerkat with the Peg Leg?" He asked.
A tossing sound was heard before the peg leg hit Ollie in the face, knocking him into the water as the audience laughed.
"Not me either genius." said Roger.
"Is it the muscular unibrow chef?" said Molly.
Amity glared at Molly.
"Do I look like a middle aged woman?" said Amity.
She then held Molly close to her head and turned her towards Luz.
"I'm talking about her." said Amity.
Molly Scratch and Ollie who popped out of the water and saw Luz and the trio of Amity's friends whistled.
"Man she is a looker!" spoke Scratch.
"I'd date her if I wasn't already dating Molly!" spoke Ollie.
"Oh yeah, I know her!" spoke Molly.
Amity became confused.
"You do?" She asked.
"Yep, she's a Princess and an old friend of mine!" spoke Molly.
But then the curtains closed abruptly, making the audience groan in annoyance.
Amity became mad.
"Hey what's the big idea dropping the curtain like that?" said Amity.
Crunch chuckled nervously.
"Sorry, there was a dialog related mistake already." said Crunch.
"The mistake being?" said Ollie.
"You referring to Molly by her real name and not her play name of Millie." said Crunch.
Ollie groaned.
"Opps!" He said.
Crunch pulled a lever, making the curtains opened up.
"I'd date her if I wasn't already dating Millie." said Ollie.
"Oh yeah, I know her!" spoke Molly.
Amity became confused.
"You do?" She asked.
"Yep, she's a Princess and an old friend of mine!" spoke Molly.
Scratch noticed something behind Ollie and became confused.
"Are you still in possession of a peg leg?" said Scratch.
Ollie nodded.
"Yes I am." said Ollie.
He tossed the leg back on the ship.
"Wonder what this is all about?" said Amity.
"Princess Erica, as a way of commemorating your birthday, I present to you, this chocolate statue." Bump said before removing a blanket covering something up, revealing a half eaten chocolate statue and that Lana Loud was eating it.
Everyone gasped in shock while the audience laughed.
"DANGIT LANA, YOU'RE NOT SUPPOSED TO BE HERE!" yelled Luz.
Lana groaned.
"I smelled the chocolate and got excited." said Lana.
She stomped off as Bump chuckled nervously.
"Good thing I have a ceramic statue." said Bump.
He pulled down another blanket to reveal a ceramic statue of Luz looking heroic.
Everyone was stunned by the statue.
Even Amity who was blushing like a tomato and smiled before straightening her hair out.
But she realized that she let go of the ship and fell in the water, making the audience laugh.
Luz and King simply just looked at the statue in annoyance.
"That's a terrible statue." said Luz.
"Even I agree." said King.
Bump groaned in annoyance.
"Come on, I spent hours working on this thing." said Bump.
"It shows." said Luz.
"You already rejected a prince that I had found for you, your mother wasn't really happy about it either." said Bump.
Luz sighed.
"I know you mean well Grim, but I don't want to marry just for royalty reasons, it needs to be for love." said Luz.
She looked at the sky.
"When I meet the very guy or girl that I want to spend the rest of my life with, I'll know it, it'll strike like lightning." said Luz.
"DEATH TO THE CRAB!" yelled a familiar voice.
Everyone saw Sebastian the Crab shrieking and running on stage as Chef Louie started chasing him in anger.
Luz groaned.
"I said lightning, not a crazy French chef." said Luz.
Bugs shook his head and got the symphony to play the Can Can song again.
Sebastian tried to dodge Louie every turn but the crazed chef threw every cooking utensils, causing the cast to shriek in temper and hopping over board.
The audience was laughing.
"Yikes, we'd better get out of here. Odds are one of us is going to be a casualty." said Ollie.
Scratch chuckled and looked at Ollie.
"You worry to much. It's not like that chef is going to become so desperate to cook a crab that he'll set the entire ship on fire with a flamethrower." said Scratch.
He then smirked.
"And if it happens, THEN I'D BE STRUCK BY LIGHTNING!" He shouted.
Chef Louie pulled out a flamethrower and fired a huge stream of flame that set the ship on fire, shocking Scratch who was then struck by lightning, knocking him fat away.
"I WAS BEING SARCASTIC!" Yelled Scratch.
"HELP, HELP!" yelled King.
"This isn't how this scene was supposed to play out." said Luz.
Bump nodded.
"Obviously." said Bump.
Luz got on the burning ship and ran through it before finding King.
She grabbed King and tossed him off the ship and into a lifeboat that Bump was in.
Sebastian ran over to a propane tank as Louie had an ax out and swung at the crab.
But the crab jumped out of the way and the ax hit the propane tank, making propane leak out.
Louie became shocked and noticed the fire he created.
"Uh oh." said Louie.
The entire stage exploded.
Everyone in the audience was shocked.
"SOMEONE CALL THE FIRE DEPARTMENT!" yelled Hailey's Mom.
"SOMEBODY DO SOMETHING ABOUT THIS FIRE!" Yelled Steve.
Darryl McGee and Becker Denoga both came on stage with fire extinguishers.
But the two tossed them away and pulled out sticks with marshmallows on them and started roasting some S'mores.
Interview Gag
Daryll and Becker were in there.
"Like anyone wouldn't do that?" Asked Daryll.
"I'm surprised no one else is doing that." spoke Becker.
End Interview Gag
Roger and Luz shook their heads.
"Okay, change of plans." Said Luz.
"I agree." Said Roger.
The meerkat pulled a lever and the curtains closed as fire extinguisher sounds were heard before the curtains opened up, revealing the scene changed to a beach where Amity, Molly, Scratch, and Ollie were looking at an unconscious Luz.
"Well at least we saved Princess Erica from entering Davy Jones's locker." said Molly.
"I don't think so. She might be dead." said Scratch.
Ollie smacked Scratch on the back of the head.
But Luz started breathing.
"Wait, she's coming around." said Amity.
She sang some of Part of Your World as a wave crashed and Eddy, Gus, and Bria plopped down on a rock.
The trio gasped in shocked.
Scratch saw the trio and flew to them.
"Fancy seeing you three here." He said.
"Shut it you idiot Ghost!" snapped Eddy.
The group kept on watching what was going on.
"Awww, Ariel's in love." said Bria.
"Yeah, but I don't think Triton's going to be happy about one of his daughter's being in love with a human." said Gus.
Bria realized that and became worried.
"Yeah that's not good." said Bria.
Amity kept on singing as Luz opened her eyes and looked at Amity.
"ERICA, PRINCESS ERICA!" yelled a voice.
Amity and her human friends looked up to see Bump running towards the group.
"I'm out of here." said Amity.
She dived into the water as Bump appeared.
"Erica, are you okay?" Bump said as he helped Luz up to her feet.
"I don't know, but I was awoken by a girl." said Luz.
She then pointed to Molly.
"And definitely not her." said Luz.
Molly and Ollie sighed.
"Thank goodness for that." said Ollie.
"Did you get a good look at her?" said Bump.
"No, all I know is that she has pink hair and a very sweet and melodious voice." said Luz, "I must find out the identity of this girl who saved my life."
Bump groaned at this.
"That's nice. Listen, your mother heard about you nearly drowning, and has forbidden you from going out to sea ever again." said Bump.
Luz sighed.
"Of course." said Luz.
"You'd better get back to the castle before she worries about you some more." said Bump.
The two as well as Molly and Ollie walked off stage as Eddy looked at the others.
"Okay, we'd better forget about this whole incident and not tell Triton about it." said Eddy.
"Easy for you to say, I'm always on dry land." said Scratch.
He floated off.
"Wait, how do I know you won't be the one who spills the beans about Ariel's attraction to a human?" said Gus.
Eddy groaned.
"Because I've been keeping every human related activity of Ariel's a secret for years. Look, let's just head back for the castle before King Triton calls for a search party." said Eddy.
Gus and Bria sighed.
"Okay." said Bria.
The three went back underwater, but Amity was hiding behind a rock and finished singing Part of Your World as water splashed in her face, making Amity cough as the audience laughed.
Sonic and Shadow surfaced nearby watching the whole thing while smirking.
The setting changed to Ursula's cave where MacArthur was watching the whole thing from her crystal ball and bursted out laughing.
"I don't-I don't believe it." MacArthur said before she resumed laughing, "This is to good to be true. No, no."
She resumed laughing before stopping.
"I can't believe that niece of mine is In love and with a princess as well, oh brother dear will be angry about this!" She said to herself.
She then grinned.
"Besides." MacArthur said before turning to a whole bunch of kelp with creepy looking faces who were scared, "The favorite daughter of King Triton will make a fine addition to my collection."