The setting changed to Ariel's grotto where Gus and Bria were leading Amity who had her eyes closed into the cave.
"Can I open them now?" said Amity.
"Yes." said Gus.
Amity opened her eyes and gasped in shock at the sight of the Luz statue.
"How did you?" said Amity.
"Flounder apparently found it where that ship sank and asked me to help move it here." said Bria.
Amity swam around the statue inspecting it.
"I love it, nothing can ruin this moment." said Amity.
"ARIEL!" yelled a voice.
Everyone gasped and saw a very angry Alador and a guilty looking Eddy looking down in sadness.
"Cheese it it's the king." Gus said as he and Bria swam off.
"I AM GOING TO DESTROY EVERYTHING IN THIS CAVE!" yelled Alador.
"Daddy?" said Amity.
"Don't you daddy me. You saved a human's life and fell in love with her?" said Alador.
Amity looked at Eddy who raised his hands regretfully.
"I had a feeling he'd be the one to spill the beans." said Gus.
"But Dad, she would have drowned, just like that one Hans Christian Andersen human some time ago." said Amity.
"That would have been one less human to worry about. Plus I let that one human slide." said Alador.
"This human Erica, she's different." said Amity.
"As if. This human thing has gone on long enough behind my back. If I must do what I must to make you see that, so be it." Alador said as the triton in his hands glowed.
"DEATH TO THE CRAB!" yelled a voice.
Then Sebastian screamed while running on stage as Chef Louie started chasing after him again, shocking everyone.
Bugs groaned in annoyance.
"Not again." said Bugs.
He then got the orchestra to play the Can Can song once more.
Louie pulled out some knifes and started throwing them as Sebastian.
But the crab avoided each knife which ended up hitting a globe, a coffee cup, a telescope, and other human objects as Alador and Amity swam around to keep the objects from being destroyed.
"NO, NO, I'M SUPPOSED TO DESTROY EVERYTHING IN THIS SCENE!" yelled Alador.
Chef Louie then drew out a machine gun and started shooting all over the place while laughing like a maniac.
Luz groaned and pulled out a walkie talkie.
"Security. Send someone who knows how to deal with Chef Louie." said Luz.
The chef kept on shooting all over the stage and hit the Luz statue, destroying it entierly minus the face.
"DEATH TO THE CRAB!" yelled Louie.
But then he was hit on the head by a rolling pin, shocking him as he turned to see Prince Eric's maid Charolette who was angry.
"Chef Louie, back home, now." said Charolette.
Louie sighed.
"Yes madam." said Louie.
He and Charolette walked off as Alador and Amity were stunned by what had happened.
"Well, there's no destroying this place again." said Alador.
But then a gas grenade was tossed on stage before exploding, releasing some gas that caused Amity to start crying.
Backstage; Roger was holding a gas grenade.
"Good thing I came prepared." said Roger.
Amity kept on crying as Alador acted remorseful before swimming out of the grotto.
Eddy approached the crying Amity.
"Ariel, I'm sorry, truly, I am." said Eddy.
But he was punched across the face by Amity.
"Oh get out of her tattle tell." said Amity.
Eddy sighed and left the cave as Gus and Bria looked on at what was happening in sadness.
"No point in ruining the moment by telling her about us." said Bria.
Gus shook his head before he and Bria swam off as well.
Amity kept on crying as Sonic and Shadow appeared and saw the crying mermaid.
The two hedgehogs smirked before swimming over to her.
"Poor, poor, child." said Shadow.
Amity looked at the two.
"She's got a very serious problem." said Sonic.
"If only there was something that we can do." said Shadow.
"But there is something." said Sonic.
Amity became confused.
"Who-who are you?" said Amity.
Sonic was about to answer when he tripped and fell and some of his quills went off and it almost hits Roger backstage.
The meerkat was shocked and felt around his body before sighing.
"Thank goodness that missed." said Roger.
Luz looked down and became shocked.
"Uh, not exactly." said Luz.
Roger looked down and saw one of the quills had got stuck in Roger's peg leg.
He groaned.
"Of course." said Roger.
Sonic stood up.
"We represent someone who can make your dreams come true." said Sonic.
"Just think, you and your princess." said Shadow.
The two hedgehog's got together.
"Together, forever." the two hedgehog's said at once.
"I don't understand." said Amity.
"Ursula has great powers." said Sonic.
Amity became shocked.
"Aunt Ursula the sea witch? She can actually-"Amity said before going back down to the ground and crying, "No I won't go to her. Leave me alone."
Sonic and Shadow looked at each other.
"Suit yourself." said Shadow.
The two began to walk off by the statue face of Luz.
"It was only a suggestion." said Sonic.
But Sonic kicked the statue's face over to Amity.
Amity saw this.
She looked at the face then at the two hedgehogs who were slowly moving to the exit.
"Wait." said Amity.
The hedgehog's turned to Amity with smiles on their faces.
"Yeeeeeeeeeeeeeess?" Sonic and Shadow said at once.
Outside the grotto; Eddy, Gus, and Bria were very sad.
"Poor Ariel." said Gus.
"She only did what anyone with a heart would have done." said Bria.
"And because of me, she's paying for it." said Eddy.
Then the group saw Amity swimming off with Sonic and Shadow, confusing them.
"Who are those guys?" said Bria.
Eddy swam over to Amity.
"Ariel, where are you going with this riff raff?" said Eddy.
"I'm going to see the sea witch Aunt Ursula." said Amity.
Eddy stopped and nodded.
"That's nice, that's nice." said Eddy.
Gus and Bria both became mad and slapped Eddy across the face.
The scammer groaned in annoyance before becoming shocked upon realizing what Amity said.
"WHAT!" He shouted in shocked and swam in front of Amity, "ARIEL YOU CANT DO THAT!"
"Well why don't you go tell father about it, you're really good at it." Amity said swimming past Eddy.
Gus and Bria swam next to Eddy.
"She's going to see Aunt Ursula?" said Bria.
"She must really be desperate. There's a reason that King Triton banished her." said Gus.
Eddy became serious.
"Yes, and that's why we've got to stop whatever her plan is." said Eddy.
The three swam off.
The setting changed to Ursula's cave where Sonic and Shadow were leading Amity towards the cave and Amity stopped nervously.
But the hedgehog's turned to her.
"This way." the hedgehog's said.
The two went off as Amity followed.
The group went by the screaming kelp faces while one of them burped.
"Come in, come in already. You mustn't lurk in entryways." MacArthur said before emerging from the shadows, "It's rude. Especially since you're my neice."
Ariel gulped.
"He...hello Aunt Ursula." said Amity, "I know it's been a while since anyone has last seen you, and I'm sure Dad is still upset with what all you've done."
"Oh, come, come now, it's all water under the bridge on my part. Besides, you're in love with a human princess, that's why you're here, isn't it?" said MacArthur.
Amity became confused.
"How did you know?" said Amity.
"I have my ways." said MacArthur.
She sat down in front of a mirror and looked at her own reflection.
"And I just happen to have the solution to your problem. You want to be with a human despite being a mermaid. The only way you can do that is by becoming a human yourself." said MacArthur.
"You can do that?" said Amity.
MacArthur smirked as the orchestra began playing music.
"My dear sweet child, that's what I do." MacArthur said before turning to Amity, "It's what I live for. Helping other merfolk who have nowhere else to go to make their dreams come true. I can help."
She then began singing Poor Unfortunate Souls as Eddy, Gus, and Bria appeared and saw what was going on in fear.
MacArthur eventually stopped singing the song and pulled Amity closer.
"Okay, here's what I'm offering. I'll make you a potion that'll turn you into a human for three days. Got that, three days." MacArthur said as she and Amity went over to a podium, "Now this is the important part, so pay attention."
The podium opened up and revealed three moon holograms.
"Before the sun sets on the-"MacArthur said before noticing the three moon holograms and became mad, "I said sun, not moon."
"Sorry!" said a tech person.
It changed into three pics of MacArthur in her many jobs.
The cop groaned in annnoyance before walking off stage where lots of punching sounds were heard before the MacArthur holograms changed to sun holograms.
MacArthur returned.
"Before the sun sets on the third day, you've got to get the princess to kiss you. But it can't just be any kiss. It has to be the kiss of true love." MacArthur said as a hologram of a heart and a crown appeared and changed to one of Amity walking, "If you pull it off, you'll be a human forever and live happily ever after with your human."
Amity smiled at the hologram.
"But should you fail, you'll turn back into a mermaid." MacArthur said as the Amity hologram changed into a mermaid and disappeared as Amity became shocked while MacArthur smirked evily, "Then you'll belong to me."
Eddy, Gus, and Bria both became shocked.
"No Ariel." said Eddy.
But Sonic and Shadow covered all three people's mouths.
MacArthur pulled Amity close again.
"Do we have a deal?" said MacArthur.
Amity did some thinking.
"If I become human, I'll never see any of my family or friends again." said Amity.
MacArthur acted shocked.
"That's right. But life is just full of disappointments, isn't it?" said MacArthur.
She then thought of something.
"But I just realized something. We haven't discuissed your method of payment yet. You can't get anything for free." said MacArthur.
"But I don't-"Amity said before being interrupted by MacArthur.
"Don't worry, I'm not asking for much. Just a little memento. I want your voice." said MacArthur.
Amity became confused.
"My voice?" said Amity.
"That's right sweet cakes. No talking, no singing, zip." said MacArthur.
"But without my voice-"Amity said before being interrupted by MacArthur.
"Don't worry, you'll still have your looks. And don't forget about the importance of body language." said MacArthur.
She resumed singing Poor Unfortunate Souls as she began tossing different sea creatures and formulas into a cauldron before a hologram of Luz appeared in front of Amity, making the witch smile.
But then the image disappeared when MacArthur made a contract appear in front of Amity as well as a pen.
MacArthur looked at Sonic and Shadow.
"Floatsom and Jetsom I've got her now boys." MacArthur whispered.
She then finished singing her song as Amity signed her name on the contract, much to the shock of Eddy, Gus, and Bria.
The contract disappeared as MacArthur smirked evily.
"BELUGA SEVRUGA, COME WINDS OF THE FLATULENCE SEA!" MacArthur chanted as the potion in the cauldron started bubbling up and winds surrounded the cauldron.
Amity became scared.
"LARYNXES, GLOSSITIS, AD MAX LARYNGITIS, LA VOCE TO ME!" MacArthur chanted as holograms of knarly hands appeared next to her.
She looked at Amity.
"Now, sing." said MacArthur.
Amity began singing.
"KEEP SINGING!" yelled MacArthur.
The hands approached the still singing Amity before grabbing her and reached into her mouth before a glowing orb which was singing was removed from Amity's throat, shocking the witch as the orb was put into a shell being held by MacArthur.
The cop started laughing evily.
Amity began changing as her fins changed into feet before the potion surrounding her disappeared.
Amity began gasping and flailing around.
Then Gus, Bria, and Eddy appeared and swam Amity out of the cave and up towards the surface before the setting changed to the surface of the water where Amity popped out of the water doing the signature Little Mermaid hairflip.
She went back in the water as Bria and Eddy held her in place.
"Flounder, get Millie and her friends over to the beach and let them know about this." said Eddy.
"Got it." Gus said before swimming off.
Eddy and Bria swam off with Amity.