Chapter 2: Truth or Dare Part 1
"Wow so you really joined Saber Tooth" asked Lucy as she looked at her long lost younger brother. Smiling proudly at Lucy, Jay made sure his guild tattoo was on full display as he started to speak.
"That's right! Just like you I went and joined the strongest guild around. The thing was that by the time I mastered my magic, Fairy Tail wasn't number one anymore" responded Jay with a proud smile.
"If you are a part of Saber Tooth then that means you are our enemy" responded Natsu in his usual tone before Lucy hit him over the head as she started to speak.
"Hey, don't talk about my brother like that, Jay isn't our enemy" responded Lucy in an annoyed tone. Smiling at Lucy, Jay started to speak.
"It's alright Lucy, he's right in a way. I will be representing Saber Tooth in the Grand Magic games and I don't intend on taking it easy against Fairy Tail even if my sister is a part of the guild" responded Jay with a confident smirk. Lucy had an amused smile on her face as she started to speak.
"Of course, I understand that. You have to fight for your guild just like we have to fight for ours. Although you are going to be in for a shock, people tend to regret trying to fight against Fairy Tail" responded Lucy with a smile.
"Sure but trust me when I say that you will be shocked with how powerful I've become. I've spent the past seven years training and now I am one of the strongest wizards around" responded Jay with a smile. Before Lucy could respond to Jay, Juvia who was nearby started to speak.
"Hold on Juvia remembers hearing that Saber Tooth came out of nowhere serval years ago and claimed the number one spot thanks to serval powerful wizards joining the guild. Are you one of these wizards" asked Juvia in a curious tone. Turning his attention towards Juvia, Jay was stunned for a moment as he admired her beauty. In Jay's eyes Juvia looked amazing and it took him a moment to gather himself in order to speak.
"That's right beautiful. You're looking at one of Saber Tooth's best" responded Jay with a confident smile. Juvia blushed slightly at Jay's words before she started to speak in a panicked voice.
"Oh no Juvia has attracted someone other than her beloved, this is terrible" responded Juvia in a worried tone as she then went on ranting about some sort of love maze. Jay looked over at Lucy as he started to speak.
"Um Lucy can you explain" asked Jay in a curious tone, slightly put out that his attempt at flirting had given a poor response. Lucy smiled at Jay as she started to speak.
"I'll tell you later" responded Lucy in an amused tone. Jay still had a confused look as he nodded his head. For serval hours Jay talking with Lucy and her friends, enjoying the stories she had to share while he shared a few of his own. As Jay was recounting one of his recent jobs, a clearly drunk woman sat down next to him.
"Geez Lucy you never told me that your little brother was such a hunk" stated Cana in a slurred tone as she leaned against Jay. Jay could feel Cana's breasts press into his side with how close she was. Before Jay could form a response, Lucy started to speak.
"That's because when I last saw Jay, he was seven years younger than me" responded Lucy in an annoyed tone but looking at Jay she could not deny that he had grown up handsome.
"Well, he's a hunk now. Do you want to spend the night with me Jay" asked Cana in a flirty tone. Again, before Jay could respond, Lucy started to speak.
"Cana! That's my younger brother! Show some restraint" responded Lucy with a blush as Cana shamelessly propositioned her brother.
"Aww come on Lucy don't be like that. I can't help it when your brother is this cute" responded Cana in a flirty tone as she winked at Jay. Smiling at Cana, Jay started to speak.
"I'm flattered Cana, and any other night I would gladly take you up on your offer, but I think I should spend the night catching up with Lucy. We haven't seen each other in over seven years" responded Jay with a smile. Smiling back at Jay, Cana started to speak.
"Alright big boy but next time you won't be able to get away from me so easily" responded Cana in a teasing tone as she leaned forward. Lucy blushed crimson as she watched Cana kiss her younger brother. Jay was surprised at the sudden bold move but quickly returned the kiss. Wrapping his arms around Cana, Jay pulled her closer against him as he made out with her. After a short while Cana leaned back from Jay and stood up.
"A hunk and a good kisser? Your brother is definitely a keeper Lucy" responded Cana in a teasing tone that made Lucy blush even more as Cana walked away after winking at Jay. Jay smiled and waved goodbye to Cana as he started to speak.
"Cana seems nice" stated Jay with a smile as he turned his attention back towards Lucy. Seeing the annoyed look on her face, Jay continued to speak.
"What" asked Jay, worried that he did something to make Lucy mad.
"What do you mean what?! You just made out with my friend in front of me" responded Lucy with a blush. Smiling back at Lucy, Jay started to speak.
"In my defense Cana was the one who kissed me, I just didn't stop it" responded Jay in a joking tone.
"That is so not the point! Next time don't do it in front of me" responded Lucy with a blush. While Lucy was embarrassed to see her brother making out with her friend, she could not deny she felt a tiny bit of jealousy. Jay was quite handsome and with his muscled arms showing, Lucy had to admit that if he wasn't her brother than he would be just her type.
"Haha sorry Lucy, I can't help it if I attract the ladies with my charm" responded Jay with a joking tone. Groaning with annoyance at Jay's cocky response, Lucy decided to talk about other things. The two siblings continued to trade stories for another hour before Mira walked up to them and started to speak.
"Sorry Lucy but we are closing up in a few minutes" stated Mira in her usual sweet tone. Smiling back at Mira, Lucy started to speak.
"Oh, wow I didn't even notice how late it had gotten. Thanks Mira, we will get going soon" responded Lucy with a smile before she turned her attention back to Jay as she continued to speak.
"Do you have somewhere to stay" asked Lucy. Shaking his head, Jay started to speak.
"Not yet. When I heard you had returned I kind of raced over here without thinking about that. I'm sure I can find somewhere to stay the night though" responded Jay thinking that Magnolia must have a hotel or inn he could stay in for the night. Shaking her head, Lucy started to speak.
"Nonsense, you can stay with me for the night" responded Lucy with a kind smile thinking it would be fun to continue catching up with Jay.
"Are you sure Lucy? I wouldn't want to be a burden or anything" responded Jay.
"Don't be silly, you're my brother not a burden" responded Lucy with a smile as she stood up before she continued to speak.
"Come on let's get going" stated Lucy with a kind smile. Smiling back at Lucy, Jay stood up and started to speak.
"Thanks Lucy" responded Jay in a grateful tone. Together the two siblings walked out of the guild hall and were soon walking into Lucy's home. Taking a look around, Jay started to speak.
"Not a bad place you got here Lucy" stated Jay with a smile as he looked around Lucy's home. Just like Lucy, Jay didn't like living in a spacious mansion. This sort of home appealed to Jay much more than his old childhood home. Smiling back at Jay, Lucy started to speak.
"Thanks! I sometimes have trouble getting rent money but it's a good place to live" responded Lucy with a smile. Showing Jay to her bedroom, Lucy started to speak.
"I don't know about you, but I could use a bath after today" stated Lucy with a smile. Smiling back at Lucy, Jay started to speak.
"Sounds good. Go on and take a bath, I will see what you have to cook" responded Jay with a smile. Giving Jay a curious look, Lucy started to speak.
"Wait you know how to cook" asked Lucy since they were both raised in extreme wealth and were never taught how to cook for themselves. Smiling back at Lucy, Jay started to speak.
"I had to learn once dad lost his fortune. That and I thought knowing how to cook wouldn't hurt my chances with the ladies" responded Jay with a perverse laugh. Lucy sighed with annoyance as she started to speak.
"Geez, when did you become so obsessed with something like that" asked Lucy. Laughing lightly to himself, Jay then started to speak.
"Around the time I hit puberty" responded Jay in a joking tone. Shortly after saying these words Jay told Lucy to go ahead and take a bath while he cooked dinner. After taking a look around Lucy's kitchen, Jay found the ingredients to make fried rice and started to prepare dinner. Humming a tune to himself, Jay prepared the dinner and just as he was platting the meal Lucy walked into the kitchen.
"Wow it smells really good" stated Lucy in a happy tone as she walked into the kitchen. Smiling at his sister, Jay thought Lucy looked cute in her pajamas as he handed a plate to her. Soon the two siblings were eating the meal that Jay prepared, Lucy had a pleased look on her face as she tasted Jay's cooking.
"And it taste great" stated Lucy in a happy tone as she ate the meal that Jay prepared. Smiling at his sister, Jay started to speak.
"I'm glad you like it. I made plenty so eat as much as you want" responded Jay with a smile as he also enjoyed the meal he prepared. The two siblings made small talk as they ate their dinner. After finishing eating and cleaning the dishes, Jay and Lucy were hanging out in Lucy's bedroom.
"I only have the one bed" stated Lucy as she thought about where Jay was going to sleep. Smiling back at Lucy, Jay started to speak.
"I can take the couch" responded Jay with a smile. Lucy felt somewhat guilty for making her brother sleep on the couch as she started to speak.
"Are you sure, that doesn't sound really comfortable" responded Lucy in a guilty tone. Laughing lightly at these words, Jay started to speak.
"It's fine Lucy. I spent a lot of years sleeping in much more uncomfortable places once dad lost his money and I ran away from the school he sent me away too" responded Jay with a smile.
"I didn't know your life was that tough" responded Lucy in a guilty tone.
"It was for the best, besides I'm happy with how my life is now. I trained really hard and became a really strong wizard and now I am a part of the best guild in the entire kingdom" responded Jay with a smile. Lucy smiled back at her brother; she was glad that Jay had found a happy life. After saying these words Jay took a glance around Lucy's bedroom and something on her desk caught his eye. Walking over to Lucy's desk, Jay picked up a stack of papers and started to speak.
"What's this? Some sort of book" asked Jay in a curious tone as he began to read the first page. Before Jay could read a single sentence, Lucy snatched the stack of papers from him and started to speak.
"Hey, hands off" responded Lucy in a defensive tone as she clutched the stack of papers. Laughing lightly to himself, Jay then started to speak.
"Sorry Lucy, I was just curious what it was. Is that a book you are writing" asked Jay in a curious tone.
"Yes it is, and before you ask no you can't read it. I promised my friend Levy that she would be the first one to read it when it is finished" responded Lucy. Smiling at Lucy, Jay started to speak.
"Come on, I can't even read a little bit of it" asked Jay with a smile. Shaking her head, Lucy started to speak.
"No you can't. I don't want anyone to read it until it is finished" responded Lucy. Nodding his head in understanding, Jay started to speak.
"Alright I get it. No need to be so defensive about it" responded Jay with a smile. Lucy moved towards her desk and put the stack of papers into a drawer before closing it and locking it. Turning back around to face Jay, Lucy wondered what they could do to pass the time. Seeing that the night was still young and that neither of them were tired, Lucy tried to think what they could do. Suddenly an idea came to her, and Lucy smiled at Jay as she started to speak.
"Hey let's play truth or dare" stated Lucy with a smile. Giving Lucy a curious look, Jay started to speak.
"What the game we used to play as kids" asked Jay, remembering the times he and Lucy would pass the time in the lonely mansion they grew up in as kids. Nodding her head Lucy started to speak.
"Yah come on it'll be fun, or are you scared you are going to lose like you always did" responded Lucy in a challenging tone. Giving Lucy a determined look, Jay started to speak.
"Hey, I'm not going to lose. Rember that I'm technically older than you are now. You can't push me around so easily anymore" responded Jay with a confident smile. Soon the two siblings were sitting on the floor across from each other as Lucy started to speak.
"I'll go first" stated Lucy in a happy tone before Jay cut her off.
"Hold on why do you get to go first? Shouldn't we draw straws or something" asked Jay in an annoyed tone.
"I'm going first because this was my idea so deal with it" responded Lucy in a bossy tone while Jay thought that not much has changed since their childhood since Lucy was just as bossy as ever.
"Alright fine, you're up first then" stated Jay deciding to not argue with Lucy since she could get fierce when trying to get her way. Smiling at her younger brother, Lucy started to speak.
"Truth or dare" asked Lucy with a smile. Not needing to think about his response, Jay started to speak.
"Truth" responded Jay to the annoyance of Lucy.
"Come on really? You're picking truth? How lame" responded Lucy in an annoyed tone.
"You can't fool me sis, I don't want you making me do something stupid right away" responded Jay with a smile.
"Alright fine, let me think for a second" responded Lucy as she thought about a question to ask Jay. After taking a moment, Lucy smiled at Jay as she started to speak.
"What is Saber Tooth like" asked Lucy with a smile. Jay's smiled faltered as he started to speak.
"Lucy I don't think that's a fair question. I won't reveal information about our fighters since we are competing against each other" responded Jay thinking that Lucy was using this opportunity to gather information about the fighting power of Saber Tooth. Shaking her head, Lucy started to speak.
"No, I didn't mean it like that. I was curious what Saber Tooth is like as a guild" responded Lucy. Smiling back at Lucy, Jay started to speak.
"Oh well in that case I suppose it couldn't hurt to let you know how Saber Tooth functions" responded Jay as he thought about his response. Seeing that he still had Lucy's attention, Jay continued to speak.
"Saber Tooth is the best because we only take the very best as members. In Saber Tooth we all live by the motto, might makes right. If your strong then your are deserving of respect" responded Jay in a proud tone. While Jay seemed proud of the way Saber Tooth ran things, Lucy frowned at his answer. Seeing Lucy's frown, Jay continued to speak.
"Is something wrong" asked Jay in a curious tone. Lucy frowned at Jay thinking that his description of Saber Tooth sounded all wrong to her.
"Is that all? What about friendship in the guild" asked Lucy in a curious tone. Jay gave Lucy a look that told her that he thought she was talking crazy as he started to speak.
"What friendship? What does that have to do with being in a guild? In Saber Tooth I have allies, there is time for friendship when you aim to be the very best" responded Jay in a confused tone. Again, Lucy gave Jay a sad look, thinking that Saber Tooth didn't sound anything like Fairy Tail. While Lucy was thinking about what to say next, Jay continued to speak.
"It's my turn now. Truth or dare" responded Jay with a smile. Deciding to think about Jay's experience with Saber Tooth at another time, Lucy smiled back at him as she started to speak.
"Truth" responded Lucy with a smile. Jay inwardly sighed with annoyance at Lucy's response. Lucy had made fun of him for choosing truth, but she did the same thing. Taking a moment to consider his question, Jay thought of one as he started to speak.
"Did it really bother you that I made out with Cana" asked Jay in a curious tone. Lucy seemed taken aback at this question. With a slight blush on her face, Lucy started to speak.
"It's not that it bothered me. It's just weird to see you like that since the last time I knew you, you were only eleven" responded Lucy with a slight blush on her face. The truth was that Lucy was jealous of Cana at that moment. Jay was very handsome and if he wasn't her brother, he would have been exactly Lucy's type, so it made her jealous of Cana to see her kissing Jay.
"So, it wouldn't bother you if I asked her out or any of your other friends" asked Jay in a curious tone. Shaking her head, Lucy started to speak.
"No it wouldn't bother me, it would just be weird at first but what do you mean my other friends? Just how many of my friends are you eyeing" asked Lucy in a curious tone. Smiling at Lucy, Jay started to speak.
"Sorry Lucy but you will have to ask that during the game if you want the answer to that" responded Jay with a smile. Huffing with annoyance, Lucy started to speak.
"Fine, truth or dare" asked Lucy. Smiling at Lucy, Jay started to speak.
"Let's go with dare" responded Jay with a determined look. Lucy huffed in annoyance; she was hoping he would choose truth. Thinking for a moment, Lucy smiled at Jay as she started to speak.
"I dare you to tell me which of my friends who are interested in" responded Lucy with a satisfied smirk.
"That's cheating isn't it" asked Jay thinking what was the point of choosing dare if Lucy was just going to dare him to tell the truth. Smiling back at Jay, Lucy started to speak.
"No it's not cheating. I'm just playing the game better than you. Come on out with it" responded Lucy with a smile.
"Alright fine" responded Jay before he stopped to think about Lucy's friends. After thinking for a moment, Jay continued to speak.
"Well other than Cana, there is Mira. I've always been a fan of her modeling career and seeing her in person was great. Erza's hot in a she could kick my ass sort of way if I'm not careful" responded Jay with a smile. Hearing these words Lucy blushed thinking that her brother was a pervert.
"Geez is there anyone else" asked Lucy as Jay nodded his head.
"That blue haired chick was cute, her name was Juvia right" asked Jay with a smile. Sighing with exhaustion, Lucy started to speak.
"Yes her name is Juvia but I'm telling you that is a lost cause. Juvia is in love with Gray, you don't have a chance" responded Lucy. Jay thought back to his observations of Lucy's friends before he started to speak.
"Really? They didn't seem like they were together. From what I saw Gray looked kind of annoyed with Juvia" responded Jay.
"Yah well Gray hasn't returned Juvia's feelings but that hasn't stopped her from trying" responded Lucy.
"Damn really? Gray is an idiot then" responded Jay thinking that Gray must be either an idiot or gay if he ignored such a beautiful woman.
"Hey, don't call my friend an idiot" responded Lucy in an annoyed tone.
"Sorry Lucy but it's true. If I was Gray, I wouldn't be ignoring Juvia" responded Jay with a smile. Sighing in agreement Lucy started to speak.
"Yah some of us don't know what Gray is thinking but I still think you should give up on Juvia" responded Lucy.
"Maybe but I think I won't give up just yet. Juvia is stunning, I can't give up on her just yet" responded Jay with a smile. Sighing with exhaustion, Lucy started to speak.
"Just know when you fail that I warned you" responded Lucy thinking that Jay was setting himself up for failure. Thinking that they were getting off track from their game, Jay started to speak.
"It's my turn now. Truth or dare" stated Jay with a smile. Not wanting to be shown up by Jay, Lucy was determined to take a dare as well.
"Dare" responded Lucy with a determined look. Smiling at Lucy, Jay thought of a sure fire way to win their game as he started to speak.
"I dare you to take off your top" responded Jay thinking that he just won their little game. Lucy blushed crimson as she started to speak.
"What?! Why the hell would you dare me to do that" asked Lucy with a blush as she moved to cover her chest with her arms. While Jay laughed, he started to speak.
"Hahaha I guess this means I win" responded Jay with a victorious smile. Seeing the smug smirk from Jay, Lucy was determined not to lose. Without thinking about her next move fully through, Lucy took off her top. Jay stopped laughing immediately as he watched Lucy remove her top in front of him. Smirking at the dumbfounded look that Jay was wearing, Lucy started to speak.
"What cat got your tongue" asked Lucy with a smirk as Jay stared at her. Jay was left speechless at the sight of his sexy sister in just her pajama bottoms and her bra. Try as he might Jay could not look away from Lucy's large breasts that were barely contained in her bra.
"Damn Lucy I didn't actually expect you to follow through with that" responded Jay unable to look away from his sister's barely covered breasts. Looking at Lucy, Jay could feel his cock begin to harden. He knew that it was wrong to get aroused by his own sister, but Jay could not help it as he stared at Lucy. Lucy's smirk faded when she realized that her big brother was staring at her chest. Moving to cover her barely covered breasts with her arm, Lucy started to speak.
"Umm truth or dare" asked Lucy in a somewhat shy tone. Unable to meet her brother's eyes, Lucy looked down and she instantly wished she hadn't. Looking down Lucy's eyes went wide as she saw Jay's tenting erection. Jay was still left speechless, unable to focus on anything other than his sexy sister, her arm doing nothing to cover her bra covered breasts from his eyes. After another moment Jay realized where Lucy was looking, and only then did he notice he was hard. Moving to cover his crotch, Jay started to speak.
"Truth" responded Jay with a blush thinking that he had to get his hormones under control. Jay knew that his sister was smocking but he couldn't be getting hard at the sight of her, it was just wrong. Lucy was still blushing crimson, unable to get the image of her brother's tenting erection out of her mind. Despite Jay now covering his tenting erection with his hands, Lucy could not unsee the lewd image. She knew that she should move on to something else but something in Lucy needed to hear the answer to the question that was in her mind.
"Are you umm hard because of me" asked Lucy, finally able to meet her brother's eyes. Jay faulted at Lucy's question, unable to scope out what she was thinking about as he tried to look into her eyes instead of her barely covered breasts. While Jay knew that the smart move would be to forfeit the game before this moved any further, his competitive side wouldn't allow him to do so.
"You promise not to get mad" asked Jay in a nervous tone not wanting Lucy to get pissed at him. Lucy shyly nodded her head as she blushed crimson. Taking a deep breath, Jay continued to speak.
"Yes. I couldn't help it. I didn't expect you to actually take off your top, but damn Lucy. I feel awful but yah seeing you in just a bra got me hard" responded Jay with a blush.
Feeling her blush deepen, a whirlwind of emotions was running through Lucy. Lucy supposed that she couldn't blame Jay for getting hard, he was after all a guy. While Lucy knew that she should feel some sort of shame or embarrassment from Jay's words, she was shocked to find herself feeling pride and arousal instead. An intense heat was growing between Lucy's legs, despite her better judgement she could not help but be proud that she had that sort of effect on such a handsome guy even if that guy was her brother.
"I guess I can't blame you. You are a guy, and I did take off my top" responded Lucy with a crimson blush. Nodding his head, Jay was relieved that Lucy wasn't pissed at him or disgusted with him. A brief moment of silence followed before Jay started to speak.
"Truth or dare" asked Jay while still covering his tenting erection.
"Truth" responded Lucy that maybe if she played it safe that things would cool down before they made some sort of huge mistake. This time it was Jay's turn to ask the burning question in his head that he knew he shouldn't ask.
"W-what did you think about it? You know my uhh" responded Jay unable to finish his sentence but it was clear to both of them what he was talking about. Lucy took a moment to respond before she started to speak.
"Umm it was big. I didn't know those things got that big" responded Lucy in an embarrassed tone. Despite the wrongness of the situation Jay could not help but feel pride swell up inside him. It didn't matter that Lucy was his sister, hearing a sexy woman that was nearly topless say that he had a big cock made Jay smile with pride. While still covering her bra covered breasts with her arm, Lucy continued to speak.
"Truth or dare" asked Lucy, the heat between her legs growing as she thought that it was getting really hot in her bedroom. Despite his better judgment telling him to pick truth something in Jay forced him to make the other decision.
"Dare" responded Jay, his face blushing crimson as he waited for Lucy's response. Lucy still had the image of her brother's tenting erection fresh in her mind and before she could think about the consequences, she started to speak.
"I dare you to let me see it" responded Lucy in a shy tone. Jay was left speechless for a moment, shocked that Lucy would dare him to do such a lewd thing.
"W-wait Lucy you don't mean" asked Jay thinking that he must have misunderstood Lucy. This was a crossroads Lucy thought. Jay was giving her the opportunity to back out and say something else. She knew that she should backtrack but the growing heat between her legs spoke for her.
"Y-yes. Take off your pants and show me your uhh thing" responded Lucy with a crimson blush. Jay was silent for a moment thinking if he could really take off his pants and show his sister his fully erect cock. Lucy could see the indecision in Jay's eyes, and she thought that he was about to lose the game. Instead of feeling victorious at her near victory, Lucy felt panic instead. She needed to see Jay's erect cock.
"Unless you want to lose the game" Lucy stated with a challenge in her voice. Knowing her brother, Lucy knew that Jay's competitive nature would override his reluctance to show her his erect cock. Giving Lucy a determined look, Jay stood up as he started to speak.
"You're not going to make me lose that easily" responded Jay as he moved his hands towards his pants. Lucy's eyes were locked onto Jay's tenting erection, her heart beating out of her chest as she waited for him to flash her. Taking a deep breath, Jay removed his pants and underwear in front of Lucy.
End of Chapter 2