In which a girl is reunited with her first love 25 years after they were separated by death.
"Cause after all this time
I'm still into you"
"I should be over all the butterflies but I'm into you, I'm into you"
"And baby even on our worst nights"
I'm into you, I'm into you
Let 'em wonder how we got this far"
"'Cause I don't really need to wonder at all"
"Yeah, after all this time"
"I'm still into you"
Sabrina Carpenter as Caitlyn Warren
Charlie Gillespie as Luke Patterson
Jeremy Shada as Reggie Peters
Owen Patrick Joyner as Alex Mercer
Jennifer Aniston as Natasha Warren
Timothee Chalmet as Micheal 'Mikey' Warren
Emily Rudd as Melissa 'Mel' Warren
Madison Reyes as Julie Molina
Jadah Marie as Flynn
Savannah May as Carrie Wilson
Booboo Stewart as Willie
Carlos Ponce as Ray Molina
Sonny Bustamante As Carlos Molina
Cheyenne Jackson as Caleb Covington
Sacha Carlson as Nick
Taylor Kare and Steve Bacic as Bobby Shaw/Trevor Wilson
The Rest of the cast as their respective characters