Pre-Series/Teenchesters. When the Winchesters arrive to investigate some mysterious disappearances in New Mexico, John loses Dean (15), Sammy (11) loses his hunting cherry, and a cult loses their beliefs. [Shadows/Canon based - see note at start of chpt 1]

"The Sun loved the Moon so much he died every night to let her breathe." Dean and Mavis have made amends and the Winchesters are hunting with Mavis Singer in Part 6 in the Veridicality Series. It begins directly after Give Up the Ghost and will take us through the end of Season 2.

Sam's training Lucifer to tolerate being around people. If he's good, he gets rewarded.

For burnbrighterthannever’s prompt: “For the nsfw prompts, Lucifer domming Sam?”

"Adam," Michael pulls out his bossy tone and Adam raises an eyebrow. It's not his Command Voice, the one that once called Heaven to arms. It's the voice he uses when he wants Adam to stop eating on the couch or take his feet off the coffee table. "Get me pregnant," he orders. (post-canon fix-it of getting michael pregnant, ft. trans!michael & trans!adam)

For burnbrighterthanever's prompt: samifer, sam getting spanked

He wouldn't have called Lucifer a comet when he let him in. He was a planet, so set in his path across the universe, drawing Sam along with him like an orbiting moon. So vast that Sam could never have seen the whole surface of him. He still hasn't. They could be together another year, another two hundred years, and still, Sam won't know every crater-scarred mile of him.

Dean and Sam cross the street.

Let’s write a horror story. You and me.

For the anonymous prompt: whatever pairing and scenario would make you say "good they" when making the podfic version of it

Raphael does this every time he passes out. (Season 5 Raphael & Chuck)

For the anonymous prompt: "Lucifer, human, post canon, with Jack. In the kitchen trying to cook because he needs to eat now; Jack is sat on the kitchen island with his legs swinging."

For the anonymous prompt: Archangel Polycule getting drunk together for the first time

The one where Sam eats Lucifer.

Adam breaks the silence before it becomes so unbearable Sam might be able to use it as an excuse to get the bill. “Ghoul says you kissed him.” (Adam & Sam post-canon conversation, background wincest & midamoul)

Dean likes taking care of his baby brother after Sam's scored. Sometimes, he gets a little jealous and needs to make sure Sam still knows who he belongs to.

For the anonymous prompt: "Sam and Lucifer, apocalypse!world. Tense and calm all at once, sitting out under the stars."

For the anonymous prompt: “Castiel and Balthazar; both of them back from the dead. Post canon. ”

They'd taken the sheets from the beds, the pillows, the cushions from the shitty couch, and made a space on the floor where they're all piled on top of each other. (AU where Azazel's Special Children don't turn on each other.)

For the anonymous prompt: “Lucifer, on his own (in Nick), season five. Hundreds of miles into the wilderness, he spreads his wings in the physical plane for the first time in eons.”

Michael has felt the low ache of abandonment. It has carved its way into the core of his grace, and in turn, he has built himself upon its shaky foundations. (Cagefic)

Sam is sick, and Dean has some… unconventional methods to make him eat.

That time Michael fell into a black hole and none of his siblings could get him back out.

Dean takes Michael on and throws him and Lucifer into the Cage, instead of Sam doing it. He's in Hell now, and there's no way out for him. Nothing like a captive audience.

People are disappearing without a trace from a small town in Missouri. Is it a monster? A witch? A serial killer? And will Sam and Dean catch up to Dad there? Early season one case fic.