All mistakes are mine.
As Brittany and Rachel looked at each other and back to the person who just walked through the door. Brittany couldn't believe it as Rachel looks on her ex boyfriend Finn Hudson.
"Shit!" Brittany said out loud while running her fingers through her hair and her classmates looking at her. She hasn't nothing against the boy but she really likes the short brunette. Yeah she knows she likes Charlie and everything but she doesn't want to mess up her friendship with the blonde just because she can't control her feelings for her. They all been friends since the third grade and just because little Brittany acts up when Charlie is presented is another story how she acts around her.
Rachel still can't believe her very own eyes as Finn was standing there in the flesh in front on the doorway of Glee club. Kurt never mentioned anything about him coming back home or when was the last time he talked to him.
"Oh, my god ladies and gentlemen Mr. Finn Hudson is back!" Mr. Schue said clapping his his excited as he went up to the tall boy and hugged him.
"Thanks, Mr. Schue it's great to back." He said with his signature goofy ass grin that he always does.
Every since he stepped into the room Rachel couldn't take her eyes off him yet and not even once she turns to looks at her girlfriend Brittany who was sitting right next to her and Brittany and everyone noticed this too. He still look the same to her as he never left almost a year ago and now all her emotional and everything else is coming back up about him. Everyone else greeted him including Shelby even though the tall giant boy broke her daughter heart she didn't want to be disrespectful as a teacher, but on another level she just wanted to choke the live out of him. Rachel was the last one to greeted him as she didn't trust herself to talk so she just hugged him instead.
She and Brittany never talked about if he ever comes back what was gonna happen to their relationship. Rachel knows Brittany likes the other twin blonde but settled to be with her instead of admitting her feelings for Charlie. he has a good thing going on with the blonde and she doesn't want to mess it up. Even if Finn does takes her back she doesn't want to hurt Brittany. After she pulled back out of the hug Finn started starring into her brown eyes that his missed so much as they were both still in love with each other since freshman year.
"Hey Rachel" he said still staring into her eyes while smiling with his arms around her small frame resting on her waistline. Rachel couldn't say anything as she starts to lean in a little to kiss him front of everyone including her mother and her girlfriend Brittany. They both were lost in their own little world while Rachel didn't hear when Santana started calling her name.
"Rachel?!" Santana called her name as she was pulling on her arm back away from Finn and looked over at Brittany and who had a serious hurt expression look on her face before walking out the door Finn just entered in.
"Brittany, wait!" The brunette called out to the blonde but Brittany just kept on walking. She looks between the door and Finn just as the first morning bell rang for first period and left. She couldn't believe she just let Brittany walked away from her like that. Just one look at the tall boy and she forgot all about her girlfriend while everyone was starring and looking on.
She looks over at Santana before grabbing her bag and walking out with everyone else. How can she be careless with Finn in front of the girl who was there to pick up the broken pieces to her heart? Brittany put her pride and reputation behind her just to date the theater geek nerd and showed the whole school she wasn't ashamed of the brunette.
"I'll see you later Rachel." He said smiling as he walked out of the classroom. After Finn left them standing there Rachel forgot about Quinn and Santana were still in the classroom.
"Rachel don't hurt Brittany just because he's back." Santana said stepping in front of her sister with a serious look on her face as Rachel was trying to leave."I'm so serious right now Rachel. Brittany was there for you don't screw this up ." Santana says as Rachel was looking at her before looking over at Quinn and walking out.
How can Santana be the one talking when she was the one wrecked Quinn's relationship with Drew? She just knew she has to fix things with Brittany before anything else can with Finn. By lunch time Rachel knew Brittany was avoiding her even in class she wouldn't at knowledge the brunette sitting beside her. She couldn't blame the blonde it was her fault she almost kissing Finn right in front of her and everybody else.
"Should I be worried about her?" Shelby says to Holly as they were sitting in the teacher lounge for lunch together. "I mean she acted like Brittany wasn't even there and almost kissed him, kissed him babe. I mean they were sneaking around over the summer and she was hiding the fact that she was seeing a girl but now she didn't even care Brittany was standing there. " Shelby was explaining to Holly why she couldn't figure out what was going through her daughter's head but she wants to find out. Not even two months ago she was lying and sneaking around with the blonde and now she throwing everything away just because Finn back in her life.
"Shelby you raised Rachel into this beautiful young woman. And I don't think she would do anything to mess up her relationship with Brittany. If she makes a mistake let her learn from her lesson. We gonna have to do the same thing with San, so don't worry too much about it. I'm gonna be right here with you when she's ready to talk." She says placing a kiss on the side of her head before she continued to eat her salad.
At least she doesn't have to worry about her daughter getting anyone pregnant for that matter. But than again if Rachel does stick with Brittany she won't end up pregnant like Shelby did in college. It's no secret that Shelby doesn't like Finn after all she can't blame herself her mistakes in the past. She was young and wild at one point in time and drinking alcohol at the age of sixteen which lead her and Holly to having sex for the first time.
"Stop it Santana!" Quinn said between her giggling as Santana was chasing her around in the gym during lunch period After Santana didn't come to the lunchroom after twenty minutes had pass she figured she would be in the gym practicing for the game Friday night, but that didn't mean she had to catch her off guard making her miss her shot.
"Say you're sorry!" She says running after the blonde. Quinn walked in and made her miss an easy basket by running her soft smooth hands over her exposed shoulders since she was wearing a light grey tank top and blue gym shorts. Quinn couldn't help herself as her girlfriend was looking sexy on the court. Wait, did she just say girlfriend? They not even really dating. Santana finally caught Quinn from her backside making her squeezing her tightly as Quinn continue giggling like a little girl as she accidentally pushed her backside back into her crotch. She knows she told Santana yesterday they were moving too fast even though they are not officially together but she can't help to wonder what will it be like to have sex with her? Not that she wants to anytime soon since the whole pregnant scary with Drew her sex life has taken a back seat and it's not fair to Santana.
"Hey can I ask you something without you getting upset?" She asks nervously as she turns around in her arms before looking into her eyes. She doesn't know how many times she gets lost looking into her eyes but she does she always gets lost looking into Santana's chocolate brown orbs that she fell in love with dreaming about their future together.
"Okay? I'm not really sure if I want to now. Judging by the look on your face it must be serious." She answered as she loosens her grip on the blonde waist before pulling away.
"No San, it's nothing bad or anything I just wanted to talk about us."
"Oh okay." Santana says with a confused expressing on her face. She knew this probably has something to do with her trying to cop a feel last night.
Quinn grabbed her hands and led them over to bench on the sidelines on the court. Santana was thinking why she let her hormones taken over last night in the heated make out session and now she's regretting it.
"San baby, you can relax." The blonde said chucking after they both sat down. Santana can feel her heart pounding out of her chest. After Quinn said that Santana took a deep relaxing calm breathed before looking over at the blonde and smiling and spoke before Quinn could.
"It's this about last night? I mean I'm sorry I took it too far and I know you said you didn't want me to think you're a whore, but you're not and I wouldn't never see you as one. And I don't know what made me think you would even have sex with me? I mean I know you said you're not ready to have sex and everything and I wasn't pressuring it's ju..."She stops and gets up up from the bench they were sitting on and started pacing" And trust me that should be the last thing on my mind but I can't help it that I'm a virgin and that's how my body acts around you. Cause I'm getting very sexual frustrated or activate or whatever it's called." She said out loud to Quinn as the blonde got up herself.
"San, it's okay I know I'm hot duh." The blonde says giggling as she was shaking her head taking what she said last night as a joke so Santana won't feel about bad herself for wanting the same thing as her" but I lied, I did wanted to go as far with you but I wasn't sure if I was ready and we never talked abo..." Santana cuts her off by kissing her soft lips which caused Quinn to let out a soft moan and was pulling her closer to her.
Santana swiped her tongue across her bottom lip begging Quinn for entry which the blonde accepted and their tongues started battling and Quinn gave up and let Santana took control. Since the Latina had her braces removed she actually became a better kisser since the first kiss at the mall a few months ago. Santana finally pulled away after a few minutes when air was becoming an problem while still holding the blonde around her waist close to herself.
"San, you gotta st..."
"Stop what? Kissing you?" Santana said between pecks and cutting her off again. Quinn couldn't help herself by laughing.
"Yes kissing me!" She says with her arms loosely around Santana neck and lean in a bit to kiss her again
So maybe the conversation didn't go as plan by at least she didn't have to ask Santana was she a virgin or not since she came out and said it for her.
"Well can I get a kiss too?" They heard a familiar voice say as they were still hugged up together. Quinn had her back towards the person as they walked in and started laughing and peck Santana lips once more again and caused her to smirk.
"I really don't think you're not my type Britt." Santana said out loud enough so Brittany could hear her as her lips ghosted over Quinn lips and both blondes started laughing.
As Brittany got closer to the couple and Quinn turned around in Santana arms to look over at her best friend. She could tell she needed that laugh which she did. Ever since this morning the tall blonde was quite almost all day since what happened with Rachel and Finn in the choir room.
"And yet this is why I like Charlie better then you."
"More than like." Santana said under her breath smirking so Brittany couldn't hear her only Quinn did and laughed as she nudged her in hee midsection.
"I'm sorry Lopez what's so funny?" Brittany asks lifting up her eyebrow to the Latina who had her arms wrapped around Quinn from the backside and her chin resting on her shoulder. "You know what Quinn? Watch your girlfriend get school and you can tell your grandkids all about it when we sixty something."
"Hey!" Quinn said getting very playful defensive.
"Bring it on blondie." Santana said unwrapping her arms around from and stood face to face with the tall blonde before busting out laughing As they couldn't take each other serious as they started playing one on one.
"Rachel will you please talk to me? You can't annoy me forever." Kurt was begging her as she was upset that he didn't tell her Finn was coming back.
"No! You're supposed to be my best friend and you didn't tell me Finn was coming and now I ruined my relationship with Brittany thanks to you!" She said turning around facing him.
Rachel knew she shouldn't blame Kurt for her mistake but she is. It's not his fault that her feelings came back for his step brother but she wants to blame everyone except for herself. She looks across the lunchroom and saw Finn talking to Noah and Sam and then the girl she felt in love with talking to Kitty, Charlie, Bree and two of their cheerleading friends Madison and Elizabeth. She even noticed the short brunette Madison sitting very closely to Brittany for her liking. It's like Brittany didn't even care Madison was basically trying to sit on her lap. Rachel excused herself from Kurt and walked over to the table where the blonde was sitting as she was still laughing at something one of the girls had said.
"Hey, Brittany you mind if I speak to you in private?" The brunette asked shyly as she was bitting on her bottom lip waiting on her girlfriend to answer her.
Brittany excused herself and followed Rachel out to the choir room to listen what she has to say. Finn saw the two girls leaving the lunchroom and follow behind them. He knew Rachel seem kind of off earlier when he showed up unannounced this morning and Kurt being hush mouth about Rachel whenever he asked about her seeing someone but now he's thinking there's something going on with Rachel and Brittany and he wants to get to the bottom of it.
After Brittany shuts the door she didn't waste anytime and got straight to the point. "So, what did you wanted to talk about?" She asked as she sat down in the first row of seat like she didn't want to be there.
"Hey you can lose the attitude! I tried to apologize but you avoiding me all day." Rachel said standing in between Brittany's legs as she uncrossed her arms. "You have a girlfriend and you just let that shank practically sit in your lap?!"
"And yeah I'm your girlfriend! But that didn't stop you from almost kissing Finn in front of me and our friends! " Brittany said getting loud with the brunette as Rachel takes a few steps back letting the blonde get up from her seat.
Brittany ran her hands through her hair in frustration while pacing back and forth while Rachel just watched on as she had tears in her eyes rolling down her cheeks.
"I want us to be together, I do. Finn is nothing to me I love you Britt only you." She stopping Brittany from pacing.
"What did you say?" Brittany said tilting her head and looking into her almond color brown eyes.
"I said I love you." Rachel said burying her face into Brittany's chest as the blonde wraps her arms around her.
Brittany thinking Rachel just saying it to provide her point or she does really love her. They been together for four months and the brunette is already in love her.
"I love you too." She said smiling as she pulls away and kisses her. Brittany didn't mean to fall in love with the brunette but she did and Rachel was the first to say it.
After awhile Rachel pulls away and looks Brittany in the eyes and said it again causing her to smile. Just because she said she loves her doesn't mean their relationship is fix just because Finn is back and everything is supposed to stay the same.
"I'll see you, I'm head to the gym for a little." Brittany said kissing her forehead and leaving the brunette behind.
Not even two minutes later Rachel sat down at the piano being to play a melody when she was cut off as the classroom door open. "Hey did you forget something?" She asked turning around to face the last person she needed to be facing right now Finn.
"I-I can't believe till I saw it with m-my own eyes and Kurt wouldn't say anything but you're dating Brittany?! Brittany out if all people." Finn said shouting at her like a two year old.
Rachel takes a deep breath before the tears start coming " you left me okay! " She said through her sobs " you left me after lying about you quit drinking. And I waited for you to come back, I even asked Carol and Burt." She said starring dead into his eyes Like he was a disappointment to her. She looks past the fact he got drunk one night and had sex with Charlie and lied about to her face cause he was serious about their relationship after secretly dating for a few months.
Finn pulled out his phone and scroll down to a familiar song he been listening to over the last few weeks. So maybe he was wrong and thought Rachel would wait for him. She never said anything in her few letters she sent that she was seeing anyone. Without a warning he grabs Rachel by her waistline and pulled her in the middle of the classroom and slowly start dancing.
You've got my heart
But I can't let you keep it, babe
Cause I won't be sure that I can stay
And don't waste your time
Trying to pull me in
Cause I'm just a mess
You don't wanna fix
Just promise me one thing that you won't forget
But for now kiss me softly before I say
Rachel knows she's making a mistake by falling for Finn ways again.
And don't be a fool
And wait on me darling
I know that you don't wanna hear this
But I'm always on the move
And don't be a fool
And say that you love me
Cause you'll find a man
Who will stand by your side
And will be there for you
"I'm sorry for leaving you without telling you, but it wasn't a day pass that I wasn't thinking about you Rachel. When you said you love me I panicked cause I wasn't ready yet." He explained as he spins her around and pulling her close again as his hands rested on her waistline.
I used to spend my nights out in a barroom
Liquor was the only love I've known
But you rescued me from reachin' for the bottom
And brought me back from being too far gone
Since the last time they ever slow dance Finn actually gotten better than before he left.
You're as smooth as Tennessee whiskey
You're as sweet as strawberry wine
You're as warm as a glass of brandy
And honey, I stay stoned on your love all the time
Rachel started smiling as Finn close the distance between each other and connected their lips together.
Baby don't be a fool
And wait on me darling
I know that you don't wanna hear this
But I'm always on the move
As the song was ending their lips ended up in a passionate kiss that turned into a heated make out session before Rachel realizes what she was doing.
"Wait, wait Finn stop." She tries to say but came out as a moan.
"What?" He asks trying to kiss her again but she pushes his chest as he backs up a little.
"No, Finn this can't be happen, this can't be happening." She said stepping away him while shaking her head. Less than twenty minutes ago she just told Brittany she loves her and now she's back to making out with her first time love. Finn was her first everything besides her first kiss.
"Is this cause of Brittany? You're not even gay!" He said stepping close to her again trying to grab a hold of her hands.
"It doesn't matter Finn! I love Brittany not you."
"Yes it does! I know you still love me." Finn said reaching his hands up to cup her face "Rachel I want you to look me in the eye and say you don't love me."
Deep down Rachel knew she couldn't look him dead in the eyes and say she doesn't love him. In fact she's would have waited forever but that changed when her and Brittany got close over the time. One look in his eyes the words slips out of her mouth before she realized what she said.
"I love you." She said smashing their lips together. After Finn breaks the kiss when oxygen was becoming a problem he let his hands drops down to her waistline before holding her close to his body.
"Let's get out of here." He said pulling her with him out of the classroom and made their way to the parking lot.
"Don't say anything Mercedes, I mean it. Brittany need to know first." Sam said as they were sneaking off to go make out.
Let the dream began!
Working two jobs is killing me. I know it's been over a month but I was having trouble with writers block again.
Who would have thought Rachel Berry would be unfaithful after telling someone you love them?
Okay so next chapter will go back to Quinntana with a little bit of the others. Do you think Quinn is ready for the next step in their relationship? But wait Santana lied about something but what is it?
Next update is Second Try and then every other update is Something Different. I have a few new ideas for stories so stick around for that.