Sorry for taking so long with this one. I've actually had this chapter done for a week, but I've been editing it repeatedly until I got it right. It contains the first smut scene, but I didn't want it to just be generic sex, I wanted character development. It'll make sense once you read it. I hope anyways lmfao.
I also reread the entire story to find errors so I could fix them. I then fixed those errors while also putting a little bit more detail into some chapters, particularly chapter 14.
Ok, I'll come clean: I was a nervous wreck as we walked to the dining pavilion.
Not only will I have to endure Annabeth feeding me like a baby, but also the inevitable intense stares and whispering from the rest of the campers after they discover that Clarisse is in my harem. I can't even imagine how embarrassing it will be, I might actually die tonight. Not from a monster, or a god, or even an injury, but from all the blood in my body rushing to my face.
I tried to delay the inevitable by telling Annabeth I was going to wait at the entrance of the pavilion for everyone else to arrive, but she naturally saw through my ruse and dragged me inside to get our food. The menu for tonight was similar to what it always was: barbecue, fruit, vegetables and the like. Specifically, it was barbecue bologna, cantaloupe, peas, potato wedges, and croissants. It looked delicious as usual, so there was that at least.
Since I went three whole days without food, I filled two plates up, my mouth salivating at the smell of it all. I then—very reluctantly—scraped a small piece of bologna into the fire for my dad before going to sit down. I was so hungry that I had completely forgotten about Annabeth's vow to feed me. I tried to shovel in a whole chunk of bologna into my mouth before it was slapped back down onto the plate by Wise Girl, who had sat down beside me.
"Ah-ah-ah, Percy. Remember—I'm feeding you tonight." She reprimanded me in a nauseating motherly voice.
"You're actually insistent on this?" I asked as my stomach rumbled.
She just smirked mischievously at me. "Yes, I am. I haven't been able to be with you in three days, just let me spoil you a little."
I do like getting spoiled by her, but something in the wind is telling me to be wary...
"What are you plotting, Wise Girl?" I accused her with narrowed eyes.
I heard her giggle naughtily. "Nothing special. I just want you to lay on my lap as I feed you."
I blushed and immediately pictured my head on her lap like I was a great ruler, with handmaidens fanning us as she fed me grapes.
"Uh..." I sounded out like an idiot as she laughed.
"Oh, don't worry, Seaweed Brain. We won't be doing that until the others are here." She flirted, winking at me.
"Your jealousy is spiking again." I mumbled.
"I'm just making sure they know what I can get away with since I'm you're favorite." Annabeth replied, resting her chin on her hand while locking eyes with me.
I sighed and put my face in my hands. "Are you intentionally trying to stoke the fire?"
"Nope, just letting them know who's queen bee." She chirped.
"They already know that, believe me. Before this harem, all of them except for Clarisse have cursed you in the past for taking me. They definitely do not need to be reminded of that."
"I know, Percy. That's what makes this all the more exciting. I want them to know that I'm the one who captured your heart."
"You're incorrigible, you know that? I'm trying to make peace between all of you but if you're going to keep taunting each other then that will never happen."
"Oh please, you know I won't take it too far, I'm not that petty. I'm just going to feed you and caress your face, that's it."
"I'll keep you to that."
We then went silent as we waited for the rest of the girls to arrive, the other campers coming in and fixing their plates before heading off to their respective tables. I was dying of thirst, so I grabbed my goblet and filled it with blue root beer before chugging it down again and again. Oh yes, I definitely missed the free infinite refills here at camp. I must have chugged down the equivalent of like, twelve cans of root beer before I let out a satisfying burp. Annabeth glared and crinkled her nose at me in disgust, but I didn't care. She wasn't dehydrated for three days.
I then wondered what was taking Clarisse so long considering she came here with us; did she decide to go to the Ares table instead? I glanced around the pavilion before indeed spotting her over by the Ares table, talking to that Sherman guy I met earlier. My guess was she was telling him about what happened since his face kept changing expressions like a cartoon character.
At least I know Sherman won't start any gossip, he's scared of Clarisse.
The rest of the girls then started to show up one at a time.
First was Rachel, who somehow knew she could sit at my table despite the fact I never told her. I just chalked it up to her Oracle powers. She sat down on my right with a smile, leaning over and pecking my cheek before digging in to her food.
Next was Calypso, who immediately started to sulk upon seeing that there were no spots available next to me. She leaned down to kiss my cheek as well before going to the other side of the table and sitting directly across from me. I then felt her bare feet link around my legs underneath the table, our eyes meeting. Her orbs had an intense longing in them, which made me shiver in a good way. She then started to gently rub her feet up and down my legs, making me laugh on the inside at how adorable she was.
She always needs physical contact! My heart...!
Last was Reyna and let me tell you, she sure has gotten bolder since the incident with Aphrodite. Just like Calypso, she was also miffed that she couldn't sit next to me. So, she walked up behind me, put her plate down, pulled my head back so I was looking up at her, then kissed me passionately before pulling away and picking up her plate to go sit down, specifically across from Annabeth. I should also mention she had a very smug smile as she sat down, earning glances from the others.
Calypso then turned her head towards Rachel, a warm smile lighting up her timeless face.
"I guess you must be Rachel. I'm Calypso, I'm enchanted to meet you!" The titaness beamed.
"Nice to meet ya, island girl." Rachel greeted her back with a grin.
"Hm, I suppose you still need to get two more by the end of tomorrow, Percy?" Reyna asked after nodding at Rachel.
Oh boy...
I coughed awkwardly, staring at my plate. "Umm, actually, I only need one..."
"Ah, you must have convinced Clarisse then, yes? Like I said, Percy—water and fire make steam." Reyna smirked at me.
"Normally, I'm a little upset when you add another girl, but this time is an exception. Clarisse deserves to be loved, she was so heartbroken about Chris earlier." Calypso smiled softly.
"Wait, you mean... that Clarisse? The one from the Ares cabin?" Rachel asked in awe, like I just tamed a dragon. "How the Hades did you pull that off? I thought she hated everyone but Chris!"
All things considered, they reacted pretty well to the news.Though, I was always more worried about how everyone else in camp would react to it.
I opened my mouth to reply before I felt an arm go over my shoulder. I turned to see it belonged to a grinning Clarisse, as if we summoned her by speaking her name.
"Oh, he has his ways. I was putty in his hands before long." Clarisse smirked, causing me to blush.
She then gave me a quick kiss before walking over and sitting next to Calypso, across from Rachel. The two of them hugged before starting to chat. As much as I should have admired them becoming fast friends, my mind was preoccupied with another matter. Something I had been dreading this entire time...
I felt a million eyeballs turn towards us as Clarisse sat down at my table. First, I heard mutterings, then gasps, followed by shouts of incredulousness. I didn't dare turn around, I couldn't look anyone else in the eyes as my face went from a light blush to a dark red.
"Holy Zeus! Percy and Clarisse?! It's doomsday!" I heard Travis Stoll shout amongst the increasing volume of gossip.
Thanks, Travis, but I don't think all of Olympus heard you, could you shout it a little louder next time?!
I hid my face between my hands, wishing I could disappear. Is this what every meal at camp was going to be like from now on? By the gods...
"What are you all staring at?! This isn't the circus or one of Lou Ellen's magic shows! Mind your own damn business before I introduce you to the wrong end of my spear!" I heard Clarisse roar at them, sounding even more pissed off than usual.
It worked though, as the pavilion went nearly silent after her outburst. This was yet another time where I could be thankful that Clarisse flew into a rage. I pulled my face away from my hands and looked at her gratefully. She was currently standing up, her nose flared as she glared out across the other tables.
"Thank you." I said quietly, catching her attention.
Her expression softened as she turned to me, sitting back down. "No problem, I won't let anyone heckle you on my watch."
This protective side of her is kind of cute...
I smiled appreciatively at her before I felt a small tug on my shirt to my left. I turned to see Annabeth giving me a look, one that told me what she wanted to do now.
"Please, can we not?! I just got done being humiliated!" I whispered quietly enough so that only she could hear.
"It's fine, Percy. Your head will be hidden in my lap anyways, you won't have to worry about anyone staring at you." She whispered back, clearly not wanting to take no for an answer.
"Grr...! Why can't I ever say no to you?!" I hissed-whispered, making her giggle.
"Because you love me. Now, lay down, Seaweed Brain." She ordered me smugly.
The rest of the girls watched us as I turned on the bench, bringing my feet up on top of it and laying my head down onto Annabeth's lap, my eyes closed. I then felt her gently caress the side of my face with one hand. I slowly opened my eyes to see her looking down at me lovingly, like I just made her week. My line of sight was now restricted to under the table as Annabeth was blocking my vision towards the rest of the pavilion, so I couldn't see how anyone else was reacting to this.
Ok, maybe this isn't so bad. No one is staring at me—at least from where I am. I get to be babied by Wise Girl, I'll get to eat finally, all is swell.
That was my thought process anyways as Annabeth started to feed me, but I then looked under our table and noticed the body language of the other girls.
Oh man...
Calypso's toes were curled up and she was gripping the bench tightly, Reyna's fists were balled and her foot was tapping the ground rapidly, Clarisse was repeatedly punching her palm, and Rachel—who I could actually see since she was next to me—was looking at us with an unreadable expression.
This silent competition between the girls is really becoming a problem, and Piper and/or Katie still aren't in it yet. I really need to fix this, but I'm not sure how... I'll figure something out, I need to.
Apart from that, it really was nice. The food was scrumptious and I ravenously ate everything Annabeth brought to my mouth. Once I ate everything off my two plates, Annabeth gently wiped my face with a napkin. I then sat up again and scooted directly beside her, our bodies touching. I wrapped an arm around her and we rested our heads together, the moment being so enjoyable that I temporarily forgot about the four girls glaring at us.
The rest of dinner went by without any further incidents—thankfully. As everyone started to file out to go back to their cabins, Annabeth got off the bench at our table and pulled me off it and to the side. She had a strangely nervous expression as she swallowed and looked me in the eyes. She then whispered something so quietly I almost thought it was my imagination that she spoke at all.
"Huh?" I whispered back, straining my ears. "I didn't hear you fully."
Her face turned scarlet before she leaned in right next to my ear. "I... I want to do it tonight."
"Do... it? You don't mean—" I gasped, my face suddenly feeling on fire.
"Yes, I do," She confirmed, her eyes locked with mine. "I don't want our first time to be tied to some hypothetical harem rule, I want it to be mutual. I also think that... maybe Clarisse had a point earlier. It would relieve our stress and... and maybe temper my excessive jealousy. I think part of the reason why I've been so out of line lately is because I'm nervous one of these other girls will try to steal your virginity from me."
I was dumbstruck, my brain just wouldn't work. I stared at her in shock for a solid minute before I finally pulled myself together, shaking my head like I just woke up.
"If that's what you want, then I'm all for it. But... I don't know if we can do it tonight, we aren't exactly alone in this camp. Not to mention that Calypso has to sleep in my cabin since she doesn't have her own, Reyna may have been sleeping in it too for the same reasons for all I know," I whispered, feeling uncertain. "Also, I'd never do it with another girl before you. I remember you telling me you wanted my first time and I feel the same. It just wouldn't feel right if you weren't my first."
Annabeth had a troubled smile, likely thinking about the first part I said. She was quiet for a moment before leaning in close again to whisper something.
"Just wait for everyone to fall asleep, then come meet me by the lake." She whispered.
"Why? Are we going to give the naiads there a show?" I whispered back with a slight smirk. "What about the cleaning harpies?"
"Who cares about the harpies? They won't actually hurt us, you know? Even if they did try, I'm sure we could handle a few obese bird women."
"Really? Ok—hey wait, you didn't answer the part about the lake! Do you know how many naiads live there? I'm all for this but I'm not an exhibitionist!"
"Ok, ok, you got a point. I forgot about the nymphs, give me a second," She muttered nervously, flustered. "Alright, meet me at the beach. I'll be invisible, so I'll come to you."
"Your cap is working again?"
"Has been since our adventure with the Kane siblings."
"Ah, right. I almost forgot about that. Nice that it's working again though."
"So, you'll be at the beach tonight, right?"
"Yeah, of course. I'll be there."
Annabeth smiled uneasily at me, grabbing my hand and squeezing it. We then turned to face the rest of the girls who were waiting on us, their faces a mix of annoyance and curiosity.
"You two done finally? The heck were you whispering about?" Rachel demanded, hands on her hips.
I quickly made up a lie. "Nothing important, just some family issues. Sensitive topic, don't concern yourselves."
"Yes, I have a complicated relationship with my father, I'm just uncomfortable discussing it openly. Forgive me for holding you all up." Annabeth said, adding onto my lie.
They seemed to have bought it, thankfully.
I then stretched and yawned. "I'm beat, I'll see you all tomorrow."
Maybe an hour or two of sleep won't hurt before I meet Annabeth tonight.
"Hold up, Percy. I just realized we never told you. Since Calypso and I don't have a cabin we've been sleeping in yours. You don't mind if we continue to do so, right?" Reyna asked as she put a hand on my shoulder.
So they both have been sleeping in there, I knew it. I'll have to be careful not to wake them when I sneak out later. Having two girls in my cabin is a little weird, but it could be worse.
"Uh—yeah, that's fine. I don't want you two to be sleeping out on the grass." I chuckled uneasily.
"Say, Percy—how many bunks does your cabin have?" I heard Clarisse ask, a cheeky grin on her face.
Why do I keep jinxing myself?!
I screamed on the inside, but forced a smile on the outside. "Yes, Clarisse, you and everyone else here can sleep in my cabin too, if you want."
Yeah, that ended up putting a wrench into our plans as literally all of the girls decided my cabin was now theirs. Annabeth also ended up coming to keep up appearances, but I could tell this was bothering her too. I mean—ok, under normal circumstances I'd be completely fine with it, I always hated being alone in there. But, it was going to be a lot harder to sneak out undetected with four additional girls in the same room as us.
Once inside the cabin, I had to move the giant dragon head I had on one of the beds into a corner to make room for the girls.
I really need to get a better place to put this thing...
I then went back to my usual bed near the front of the cabin. Luckily, Annabeth managed to claim the one opposite of mine. Closer we were to the door, the less we had to travel, which means the less likely we'd be heard. The others quickly chose their own bunks, but I wasn't really paying attention to which ones. I immediately got into bed, said a quick goodnight to everyone, and turned around in my bunk to pretend I went to sleep. In reality, my heart was racing for obvious reasons.
So much for wanting to get a little bit of sleep! I'm a nervous wreck, I don't even feel tired now!
I laid in my bed for what felt like an eon, time seemingly slowing down to a crawl. I wasn't sure if it had been minutes or hours, the thought of what we were going to do tonight was all I could think about—assuming we didn't get caught.
At some point I felt a gentle tap on my shoulder, which nearly made me jump because of how nervous I was. I turned over to see Annabeth standing over me, using her hand to tell me to come on.
With my heart beating at a million miles an hour, I slowly and carefully got out of my bed, creeping towards the entrance in an exaggerated fashion. The door was then gently pushed open by Annabeth and the two of us tiptoed outside, where I immediately let out a sigh of relief upon exiting.
"Mission successful." I whispered, Annabeth shaking her head at me.
"Come on." Was her only response.
We then channeled our inner ninja to stealth our way through the camp to Long Island Sound, keeping to the shadows as much as possible. Well, I did anyways, Annabeth just put on her cap and disappeared.
Wish I had something that useful...
Thankfully, the Sound wasn't too far from my cabin so we arrived in a few short minutes. On the other hand, I was so nervous I was shaking.
How is it that I can face down titans and giants yet the thought of having sex with my girlfriend freaks me out? Don't most guys dream of this? Maybe it's because of the circumstances...
As I was contemplating my cowardice, Annabeth reappeared next to me by taking off her hat. She must have noticed how jittery I was since she put a hand on my cheek and stepped in front of me, her grey eyes soft and warm.
"It's ok, I'm nervous too. I'm here for you, Percy. Always and forever." She whispered soothingly.
"I don't know why I'm like this, I should be excited that I'm finally going to lose my virginity, every guy dreams of it." I muttered.
"Most couples are like this their first time from what I've read. It's the first time either render themselves completely vulnerable to each other, it's the final test of trust between them. Do you trust me, Percy? Because I trust you with my life." She asked softly, her eyes shining with passion.
"Stupid question, Wise Girl. You know I'd crawl through Tartarus again for you in a heartbeat. Of course I trust you," I answered with a sweet smile. "So, how do we start this? Do we just kiss or—"
Annabeth chose to answer my question with her actions. She tackled me onto the sandy beach, her lips crashing against mine, an all-consuming hunger behind them. The intensity of her kiss was at such a degree that it stunned me more than her tackle, she's never been this... fierce. I'd be lying if I said I didn't love it, though.
Her hands started to roam over my body as she deepened the kiss. She put one hand under my shirt and pinched my nipple out of nowhere, making me gasp, which she then took advantage of by invading my mouth with her tongue. Instinctually, my own tongue rose to combat the invader, our muscles interlocking and wrestling for dominance. I won out, repelling the foreign object and counterattacking, exploring my newly acquired territory. I heard her moan sensually as my tongue mapped her orifice, going over every part of it.
I felt my reservations melting away, my desire for her increasing by the minute. I experimentally snaked a hand up her orange shirt, going over her smooth abdomen and tracing her slightly visible abs. My sudden touch caused her to gasp this time, a grin appearing on me as our lips separated for just a moment.
"Not as fun when it happens to you, huh?" I teased her.
"Shut up! Don't stop!" She furiously whispered before claiming my lips once more.
I chuckled to myself as she kissed me again, her efforts doubled this time. While we made out, I used my other hand to go over her body's curves, sketching her shape in my mind. Her skin felt like silk on my fingers, it was alluring beyond words. Despite all of the fighting and wounds she's suffered over the years, her figure was flawless, not a single scar or blemish anywhere.
Annabeth suddenly pulled away from me, straddling my waist as she looked down upon me with lust. She then reached down to the hem of her shirt and in one motion, pulled it up and over her head, tossing it down on onto the beach. My eyes drank in her form: her wonderfully tanned and smooth skin, her athletic body with the perfect amount of muscle, her gorgeous golden hair gently billowing in the nightly breeze, her breasts teasingly kept behind a grey sports bra. She glowed majestically under the moonlight, like my own personal goddess.
"You're beautiful, Annabeth. If I've never told you before, then I'm sorry for being such an idiot. You could make even Aphrodite jealous..." I whispered in awe, helplessly smitten by her.
"You're so sweet," She softly whispered. "You're also not an idiot, Percy. I know me and the others like to joke about you being one, but you're not. I wouldn't have fallen so hard for you if you were." She replied sultrily, leaning in to kiss me gently as her hands went down to the edge of my shirt.
I then heard her growl cutely as we made out once again, her frustration becoming evident as she tugged on my treacherous article of clothing.
"Let me take this damn thing off already!" Annabeth hissed.
I laughed and sat up, letting her pull my shirt over my head and toss it away. Her eyes roamed over my bare chest, the desire in them increasing exponentially. She then pushed me back down onto the beach and delicately traced my muscles with her finger. It seemed she was particularly fond of my abs, which were now fairly defined after years of training, fighting, and adventuring.
"Like what you see, Wise Girl?" I asked smugly, unable to resist teasing her again.
"Mhm," She hummed, enraptured by my body. "I've never realized just how muscular you were, Percy. I knew you were in shape, obviously, but... by Athena..."
I'll be honest, I never felt better in my life than in that moment. Seeing Annabeth go speechless at the sight of my physique made me feel something indescribable, like I just won at life.
"And tonight, Annabeth, you have me all to yourself," I purred into her ear as I sat back up. "No monsters, no quests, no prophecies or meddling gods, and no other girls. Just you and me."
"When did you become such a smooth talker, Percy?" She whispered in a husky tone. "I love it."
I smiled warmly before leaning in and kissing her fervently. I then raised my hands up her back and stopped as I reached the strap of her bra. I made my intentions clear by slipping a finger under it.
"May I?" I murmured in her ear, trailing kisses down her neck.
"Yes!" Annabeth breathed out, her body ever so slightly shaking; whether it was from the wind or excitement, I didn't know.
I then fiddled with the back of her bra until it finally unclasped and came loose. I leaned back just a little, and with bated breath I pulled it away, exposing her breasts to myself for the first time. They were round and supple, a few shades paler than the rest of her skin. Her nipples were hard and erect, almost resembling sharp points.
I was expecting some life changing event when I finally saw her breasts. I've heard other guys talk about how amazing boobs are for years, but nothing crazy like that happened. They were just... there, as part of the girl I loved. That was my thought anyways until Annabeth grew impatient, grabbing one of my hands and pressing it against her naked breast.
In that moment, it all made sense. My breath hitched as I felt her flesh mound, the sensation really was life changing. It was so soft and squishy, but somehow firm at the same time. Annabeth softly moaned as I gave her breast a squeeze, her back arching in pleasure as she gripped my legs for support. I then raised my other hand to fondle her remaining breast, her moaning becoming louder and more enticing.
I was consumed by the feeling of her mammaries, kneading them with my hands that were rough from years of swordplay. I then took a leap of faith and gently pinched one of her nipples. Annabeth gasped in shock and her body shuddered, which initially made me think I crossed a line. I let go and looked at her in concern.
"Why did you stop?" She asked with a ragged breath.
"Oh, I—uh, I thought you might have been in pain or something..." I mumbled, feeling silly.
"I'll tell you if I'm in pain, believe me. Now, get back to it, Seaweed Brain!" She commanded me in a needy voice.
I obeyed greedily and resumed playing with her boobs. They perfectly fit into the palms of my hands, like as if they were handcrafted for me specifically. Without any hesitation this time, I pinched both of her nipples, eliciting a moan from her that almost made me lose control to the lustful beast rising within. I gently twisted her nipples, her moans hitching.
"Use your mouth." She suddenly gasped out to me.
I didn't need to be told twice. I removed my right hand and leaned forward until my mouth was around her soft flesh, my tongue playing with her nipple.
"By the gods!" She screamed in ecstasy.
I quickly removed my mouth and moved up to her face, silencing her with my lips. The kiss was sloppy, mostly because Annabeth seemed to have temporarily lost control of herself, but it worked in silencing her. I then pulled away after a minute, leaning my forehead against hers.
"Shhh, we're trying to be discreet here." I whispered.
"I'm sorry, it just feels so good," Annabeth apologized, her breathing uneven. "I'm ready to move on, Percy."
"You're ready to go all the way?" I asked softly as I planted kisses along her jaw. "I'll do whatever you want, Wise Girl."
"I want... to do a bit of foreplay first, get acquainted with each other while... nude." She murmured nervously.
I sensed her unease and pulled her against me, gently rubbing her back. "No need to be afraid, we're both going to be fully exposed to one another. We'll go nice and slow, we have time to spare."
She sighed softly, relaxing in my embrace.
"Ok." She whispered before pulling back from me.
Annabeth then stood up and with a deep breath, unzipped her pants before pulling them off along with her shoes and socks. The only piece of clothing she had left were light grey panties with owls on them. There was also a noticeably darker and damp spot in the lower middle of her panties.
"Those are some cute owls." I said with a smirk.
Her face went red at my comment, trying to cover herself in embarrassment. I softly chuckled before standing up myself and repeating her actions, laying my pants, socks, and shoes on the beach. The only thing I now had on was a pair of dark blue boxers with sharks on them. Unfortunately, it did nothing to hide my erection, which made me blush as I saw Annabeth lay eyes on it. To complete our role reversal, I then covered my crotch in embarrassment.
"Looks like your friend wants to play. The sharks are cute too." She said mockingly after seeing my reaction, getting her revenge.
"O-Oh yeah?! Well, you're not squeaky clean down there either!" I taunted back.
"Oh, you...!" She growled before rushing over and kissing me, wrapping her arms around my neck, her bare breasts pressing against my chest.
I instantly forgot about our little spat, immediately reciprocating her kiss and placing my hands on her hips. A moment passed and we were back on the sandy ground of the beach, lost in each other. Another moment later and we separated for air, our faces inches apart.
"I'm ready. Pull it off me, Percy." She purred into my ear, an intense desire in her voice.
My friend downstairs throbbed at that, but I didn't care. I hastily slid a finger down her panties and started to gently slide it off, leaning forward to pull them all the way off her legs. The first thing I felt after doing so was a wet sensation dripping down my leg. Her arousal was evident, to say the least, which was making my own arousal painful. A part of me just wanted to take her then and there.
"Do we have to do foreplay?" I whined like a child. "It's... becoming painful."
Annabeth placed a finger down my boxers, indicating she wanted to yank it off as well. "I can tell, believe me. Your friend is poking my thigh. Don't worry though, we don't have to do much, just a little. It'll be good experience for next time."
Next time? When did she get so kinky?
"Fiiiiine." I grumbled, relenting.
I then raised myself slightly off the ground so she could take off my boxers. She grinned seductively before pulling them down my legs and off my feet. My engorged cock now stood tall and proud before her, free from any and all constraints. Annabeth's eyes locked onto it hungrily, like she was a predator who just found her prey.
"Go on then." I urged her with a needy tone.
Annabeth smirked at me and placed a hand around my member, making me shudder. Her smile disappeared as it was replaced by a look of wanting, her hand beginning to stroke my length slowly. It was basic at first, but she seemed to somehow know where all of my sensitive spots were.
She would tease a part of my rod with her thumb, gauging my reaction before taking note of it for her to go back to later if I reacted in the way she wanted. Annabeth especially liked to tease the tip and head, along with a particularly delicate part at the base of my cock. How this girl found my weak spots so quickly is beyond me.
Wait—actually, it might be because she's an owl girl. Her brain must be treating this like a battle, analyzing her opponent's body for weaknesses. That makes sense, right? I think so—
My thoughts were soon interrupted as the pleasure from her touching me became overwhelming. My breathing became labored as she handled me, my self-control slipping away. I then involuntarily bucked my hips, making her giggle.
"You seem to be liking it, Percy. Guess I'm doing a good job~." Annabeth whispered, her breath hot on my ear.
"Gods, Annabeth! If you keep that up, I'm going to lose control of myself!" I whimpered, my choice of words being poor as a mischievous grin then appeared on her face.
What she did next almost made me burst on the spot.
She lowered her head to my base and licked the full length of my shaft, slowly and sensually. I had to close my eyes and grip the hard part of the ground while thinking of repulsive things to not immediately orgasm.
"Holy shit, Annabeth!" I gasped out, blinking hard and taking deep breaths.
She raised her head just slightly, a smug grin on her face. "Too much for you already, Seaweed Brain?"
I nodded weakly. "You almost made me come undone just with that one act."
Her grin grew wider, which made me shiver.
Oh no, I've created a monster!
"That's what I want, Percy~." She purred before lowering her head and this time enveloping my length into her mouth.
I couldn't help but moan as she started to bob her head up and down, her tongue swirling around my manhood. I tried to hold on for as long as possible, but I could feel my loins ready to spill out at any moment. My cock then started to twitch, signaling to Annabeth I was close, making her double her efforts. Within moments it became too much, I let out a loud groan as I released into her mouth.
She gulped down my seed before pulling her mouth off my penis, a satisfied smile on her face. She then put a finger over my lips, smirking.
"We're trying to be discreet, remember?" She giggled. "This is also going to sound corny, but it tasted like salt water." She added.
I was breathless, my orgasm leaving me in shambles. I didn't even fully register what she said until a minute later, when I finally caught my breath and came down from the mind-blowing release.
"You sure you're not a daughter of Aphrodite?" I quipped as I laid my head on the ground, her soft laughter filling my ears.
"I'm pretty sure I'm not, just a hunch though," She joked before grabbing my hand and pulling me back up. "Hope that didn't wear you out, you still need to please me. Then, we can get to the main act."
"I don't know, I'm feeling pretty spent after that. I'm seeing stars..." I said tiredly.
"Come on, there's no way that tired you out." She said with an eye roll.
"I'm sorry, but it's true. I can barely lift my head. Maybe we should stop..." I mumbled.
"You want to stop? We've barely even started! I'm still plenty horny, Percy! Don't be unfair!" Annabeth protested.
"You're insatiable." I muttered.
Annabeth looked hurt by what I said. "Can you blame me? You disappeared for months, Percy. I was worried sick, I didn't know if you were even alive. Then, when we finally reunited, we barely had any time to spend together because of that stupid quest and prophecy with Gaea. And after that, once we finally thought we caught a break, we wind up with this harem..."
My eyes widened in horror at how big of a mistake I just made. I cursed myself for being so callous and careless. She missed me horribly, how could I say something so stupid? Could I really not be assed to spend a single night with her now? I almost opened my mouth to talk but she continued before I could speak.
"For the past week you were forced to scramble around and try to get girls into your harem, barely able to spend any time with me because of it. Hades, you spent more time with other girls than me! Then to top it all off—you were drugged, turned crazy, and incapacitated in a dank cellar for three days," Her voice started to crack as her eyes watered. "I-I've barely been able to be with you for an entire year, the most amount of time we've had together since this all started was when... was when we fell into Tartarus, Percy! Tartarus! Can you believe that?! Us fighting and running for our lives in that hellscape was the closest thing we had to a date in a whole year!"
I never felt so ashamed of myself as I did then. I promised her earlier I'd never neglect her, but I've been doing it unintentionally for a whole fucking year! Gods, I wanted to punch myself in the face for being such an asshole! How could I have the audacity to complain about being tired earlier?! I even wanted to stop!
"I'm so sorry, Annabeth! I didn't mean it, I—fuck me..." I said, growling at myself as I sat up and hugged her tightly. "I'm such a dickhead... You're right, we haven't had any time to ourselves in so long. I've been so preoccupied with current events that I forgot how much you missed me. Forgive me..."
Annabeth silently cried against my chest, clinging to me like a teddy bear. I whispered apologies into her ear as I held her, massaging her head and back while rocking us ever so slightly. Annabeth then dried her tears after a few minutes and pulled back to look at me, her eyes red.
"Do you want to stop?" She asked in a voice that shattered my heart.
I shook my head rapidly. "No! This is what you wanted. This is our special night together, I don't want it to end like this. I was just being an inconsiderate jerk, I'm sorry. Please, let's continue."
Annabeth's eyes went down, uncertain. It tortured me on the inside. It made me furious, but not at her, but at myself.
I am NOT letting it end like this! I'm going to make this a night she'll remember forever! I swear it on the Styx!
Thunder rumbled above as I swore my oath, causing her to look back up at me. I cupped her cheeks before kissing her hungrily, putting everything I had into it. I then moved my hands away from her face and down to her chest where I started to knead her breasts as sensually as I could. It took a minute for her to respond to my actions, but I heard a soft moan escape her lips soon enough.
"Let me love you," I whispered into her ear. "I want—no, I need to make up for all the time I spent away from you. I need to make you feel loved, it's clear I haven't been doing that lately."
"Oh, Percy..." Annabeth murmured, her breathing becoming heavy again. "I've missed you so badly... please, don't ever leave me alone again. My heart can't take it..."
"I won't. The gods themselves won't be able to tear me away from you again, I won't allow it." I vowed with conviction.
She smiled joyously before giving me a quick kiss. Then, she laid back onto the sand and spread her legs, exposing her wet slit to me with a needful look on her face.
"I need you."
Her voice was desperate and pleading, like if I didn't satisfy her she'd die. I then crawled over to her, looking down at her shaven vagina.
"You shave down here?" I asked in surprise.
"Mhm, I did it right after I escorted Katie back to her cabin. I've been planning this since you returned to normal." She told me softly.
"I guess I'll shave mine before next time then..." I muttered, a little embarrassed.
"Percy, please! Stop talking! I need you!" Annabeth begged me desperately.
"And you'll have me, Wise Girl." I cooed, lowering my hand down to her slit.
First thing I did was run a finger over her entrance, eliciting a shiver and soft moan from her. I then saw her pussy shine anew as she got even wetter, which made my previously flaccid cock start to harden once more.
"Does that feel good?" I asked, wanting confirmation.
"Yes...!" She gasped. "Don't stop!"
I then began to gently rub her second set of lips with my fingers, her soft moans melodious to me. I next tried slipping a finger inside her, causing her to buck her hips and moan loudly while arching her back. I grinned, taking pleasure in knowing I just found her weakness.
I used two fingers to slide in and out of her folds, her moistness drenching them instantly. Her breathing became labored and her insides became tighter, which I figured meant she was close to releasing. I didn't want that just yet, so I pulled my fingers out of her, a groan of agitation escaping her as she glared at me.
"You fucking tease, Percy! I was so close!" She hissed.
"I know," I whispered softly as I leaned down and kissed her quickly before pulling back. "I'm sorry, but there's one more thing I want to try first. I'll let you cum this time though, don't worry."
I then lowered my head between her legs, moving my arms under and linking around them so I could pull her closer. I then gave her an experimental lick, which caused her to moan in such a way it made my newly erect cock pulsate. Feeling emboldened, I continued to lavish her sex with licks, swirling my tongue against her folds, her moaning getting louder and more high pitched. Once I stuck my tongue slightly inside her and nibbled on her clit, she met her end.
Annabeth convulsed and screamed my name as her juices squirted out onto my face. I closed my eyes instinctively, shrinking back at the sudden, unfamiliar liquid. Once she finished, I blinked a few times and hesitantly licked my lips, unsure of how her cum would taste.
"Mm, it's kinda sweet, like honey." I mused as I sat up, watching Annabeth heave for air.
"That was... intense," She gasped out as she breathed. "Give me a minute before we go on, please."
"Of course, Annabeth. Take all the time you need." I said as I gave her hand a squeeze.
I then laid beside her as she caught her breath, waiting patiently for her to recover before we sealed the deal. While waiting, I would play with her hair and plant kisses on her shoulder, collarbone, neck, and face. I would whisper sweet nothings into her ear while gently massaging her breasts. I then followed that up with putting my arm over her stomach and hugging her as I nuzzled her neck.
My actions were having an effect on her as she let out a sigh that was a mix between contentment and annoyance.
"Percy, you're making it really difficult to calm myself. I appreciate the affection, but please let me concentrate." Annabeth griped cutely, her hand intertwining with the one I had over her belly.
I hummed against her neck. "I don't want you to calm down, I'm all excited again."
"Boys." Annabeth muttered, and while I couldn't see her face, I could tell she had a big smile.
I laughed softly and raised my head to look her in the eyes. "You told me I needed to accept that we would be having sex in the future. Well, I have, and this boy wants to make love to his girl. I also need to make up for neglecting you for a year." I whispered the last part with a stony expression.
"Oh Percy, do you really feel that way about yourself? You didn't neglect me, nothing that has happened is your fault." She whispered with concern, putting a hand to my cheek.
I gritted my teeth, my vision turning blurry. "I promised I would never neglect you back at the Big House. Yet, I failed to realize I've been doing exactly that for a whole year, even if unintentionally. I had the gall to complain about being tired earlier, making you cry. I made you cry, Annabeth! I can never forgive myself..."
"Stop it," She growled, grabbing my chin and forcing me to look into her angry eyes. "It's—not—your—fault! Stop blaming yourself for anything that goes wrong, it's not healthy! I got emotional because I missed you. You then chose to make me feel better. How can you be upset with yourself for that? I'm not. Do you need me to say I forgive you? Ok then: I forgive you, Percy. There, now stop hating yourself this instant!"
I smiled weakly at her, wiping the tears out of my eyes. "I don't know what I could have possibly done to deserve you, Annabeth. You're too good for me."
Her expression softened considerably. "You saved the world twice, Percy. That's what you did. Even if you didn't, it wouldn't matter to me. I'm going to tell you what you told me: it doesn't matter if you think you deserve me or not. I love you, and that's that."
I didn't know the words to express how happy I was. I instead just leaned in and kissed her passionately. This girl is my whole world; gods I am so lucky. No wonder all the other girls are so jealous of Annabeth.
She's perfect.
Once we separated, I looked longingly into her grey eyes as she stared back yearningly into my sea green orbs.
It was finally time.
"You ready?" I asked softly, caressing her cheek.
She fidgeted for a moment before looking back at me. "Can I... make a request, Percy?"
"A request? Um, sure." I said, wondering what it could be.
Please don't tell me she's into some weird fetish...
Annabeth took a deep breath. "I'd... I'd like our first time to be underwater. One of my best memories is when we kissed under the lake and I want to repeat that, to make an even better memory."
I widened my eyes in surprise, but a radiant smile quickly grew on my face. To be honest, it was heartwarming. That was one of my best memories too.
"That sounds perfect, Annabeth." I said happily.
I then stood up and offered her my hand, which she gladly took. I pulled her up and took her by the hand towards the water, where I dipped my toe into it to see if it was cold or not, which it wasn't. If it was, I would have had to decline her request as I didn't want her to freeze. But, since it was lukewarm, we could go ahead without issue.
"Good news, the water is nice. You'll still need to hold your breath for a moment so I can make an air bubble, though." I told her as I lead her by the hand into the Sound, getting deeper by the second.
"Just tell me when." She requested softly as we swam further from the shore.
Once we were deep enough, I nodded at Annabeth to go ahead. Annabeth then took a deep breath before submerging, I followed her right after. Once we were both under, I willed a bubble to form and expand until it was big enough to envelop her head.
"Ok, you are good now." I said, Annabeth immediately exhaling and breathing in new oxygen.
Annabeth looked around in amazement before her eyes settled on me. I saw many emotions flash in them, from happiness to love to desire. There was no more delaying, nothing else to be done or to stop us.
Annabeth swam over to me, putting her hands on my shoulders. The look in her eyes made me want to go wild, like I was nothing more than a savage beast that needed to mate with a female. She then straddled my waist, her pussy hovering just above my aching member.
"Are you ready?" I asked, a fire burning in my loins.
She simply nodded. She didn't even give me a reply before she grabbed my cock and lined it up with her entrance before gradually sinking down onto my throbbing manhood. We both moaned at the feeling of our sexes conjoining, the sensation unlike anything we've ever experienced.
However, as my shaft started to slowly plunge into her depths, I suddenly broke through something, making Annabeth hiss in pain. I then felt my heart race as I saw blood enter the water from her womanhood.
"What's wrong?!" I asked in a panic, thinking I hurt her.
"You broke my hymen, Percy. It's natural, don't worry. The... pain will pass after a moment." She explained, her face contorted in agony.
I gently rubbed her cheek in hopes of making her feel better faster. After a minute, she started to relax and breathed in before meeting my eyes.
"You just took my virginity, Seaweed Brain," Annabeth purred, making my cock somehow harden even further inside her. "Hold nothing back. Take me."
That was all it took for me to let loose.
I fully gave in to the temptation, the beast within me taking the reins. I started to thrust up into her as she eagerly met my thrusts with her own. We started slowly, but rapidly quickened our movements as our desire for each other was growing immeasurably. My hands went to her hips, gripping her tightly while her hands had a death grip on my shoulders, her nails starting to dig into my skin.
"Fuck me harder, Percy! Please!" She begged me out of pure lust, her eyes glazed over.
I wordlessly complied, changing our positions so she was on her back instead. I then started to ram into her like my life depended on it, our breathing becoming frantic as we made love. The water around us rippled, but we were deep enough in that the surface remained unaffected.
I was totally lost in the heat of the moment, her velvety, hot pussy walls were constricting my cock so perfectly that I craved more. It was like her pussy was trying to push out my intruding organ, but I refused to let it, instead reshaping it to suit me.
"Percy!" Annabeth moaned out, her legs locking around my waist while her nails dug deeper into my skin. "I can feel you holding back! I don't care about the water strengthening you, destroy my pussy!"
Her words brought me closer to the brink. I could feel my balls burning like magma, my release approaching at an alarming rate. I decided to give it my all, slamming into her with everything I had, the water empowering my thrusts even further.
"I'm close, Annabeth!" I grunted out as my balls smashed against her from how hard I was thrusting.
She didn't respond, lost in the throes of passion. She clung to me fiercely, her legs wrapped around my waist like a boa constrictor, refusing to let me go. Not that I wanted her to, I wanted this more than anything.
I then heard her scream out my name as her walls started to squeeze the life out of my dick, her body shaking hard as she orgasmed.
"Annabeth!" I roared as I slammed into her one final time, going all the way and cumming hard, far harder than before.
White hot seed erupted out of my cock and into her womb, thick ropes shooting out one after another. She was filled up by the time I finished, both of us panting from exhaustion.
Ok, she was panting from exhaustion, I was just a little tired due to the salt water reinvigorating me.
I then pulled out of her and carried Annabeth out of the water and back onto the beach, where I dried her off and sat her down on the grass at the edge of the sand.
"That... was... amazing... Percy..." She panted out in pure bliss.
I smiled adoringly at her. "Yeah, it was. Best thing I've ever experienced, and I got to do it with you."
She didn't have the strength to respond, instead she smiled weakly while continuing to pant. I waited beside her until she regained enough energy to stand up again. When she eventually did and tried to walk, she nearly fell over before I caught her, her legs all wobbly.
"Woah, easy there. Let's just rest for a while longer." I said gently as I sat us back down, bringing her onto my lap.
She leaned back against me, a contented sigh leaving her lips. I rubbed my cheek against hers lovingly, never feeling so happy in my life as I was in that moment.
"I love you." I whispered softly into her ear.
"I love you too." Annabeth whispered back, nuzzling her head under my chin.
We sat there in euphoric silence, enjoying each other's warmth and listening to the gentle ocean tide as it lapped at the shore of the beach, basking in the soft moonlight.
With the high of our first time dwindling, I had a strange feeling come over me—like I had forgotten something. I thought hard on it before something caught my eye. I saw the tiniest bit of white liquid leak out of Annabeth's nether regions, making my eyes widen. I then had a sudden panic attack on the inside.
We didn't use protection earlier!
"Annabeth..." I said, my voice struggling to remain even. "We—we didn't use protection, and I came inside... I-I know you might be upset, but... if you do wind up getting pregnant—"
"You'll take responsibility? I know you will, you don't need to tell me that, silly," She said with a small smile, reading my mind. "I... don't mind if I get pregnant, Percy. I already told you I want kids, and I know you won't abandon me, so..."
I felt like crying tears of joy, but I suppressed them. "I'm so happy to hear that, honestly, but... I don't know if we're ready to be parents yet. We're so young, plus we still have to deal with the harem and the shadow people after us. Throwing a baby into the mix would just complicate things further. I'd be so worried about you and our hypothetical kid. You'd become a prime target for our enemies..."
"I understand your concerns, Percy. But, I know that we'd make it work if it were to happen, which we don't know if it will," She soothed me, placing a hand on my cheek. "Releasing inside doesn't instantly lead to conception, you know? The chances are low for us, but I'll make sure to take a pregnancy test when I can. The Aphrodite cabin likely has some stashed away."
Her words relieved me greatly, but I was still just a little worried. What would I do if she does end up pregnant? How would I explain that to the others, to my mom?
Oh shit, my mom would probably be so pissed at me!Maybe I should make an offering to Aphrodite and ask her to make sure Annabeth doesn't get pregnant... yet again, it's Aphrodite, so she could just do the opposite because it would be "exciting". I'd ask her that only for her to make Annabeth fall pregnant with quintuplets or something...
"Let me know the results of the test immediately, ok?" I gave her hand a squeeze as she nodded. "Do you think you can walk again?"
"One way to find out," Annabeth replied before getting off my lap and standing up, hesitantly taking a step. "Yep, I'm good now."
"Let's get our clothes on and head back then, I'm exhausted." I yawned as I also stood up.
"Mhm." She hummed in agreement, too tired to speak.
We then scrounged up our clothes off the sand and put them back on before trudging back to my cabin. I really hoped the others were in a deep sleep, because there was no way I could be as stealthy as I was when we left.
Lucky for us, that seemed to be the case, because we managed to sneak back inside and go to our respective bunks without disturbing anyone else. As soon as I got on my bed, I passed out.