Not-so Anonymously 4 - or 'Why is everyone calling me ANON?!' (MLP FiM, SI - Not!Anon)

Nightmare Night. I never once thought that a 'crisis' about its meaning would be kickstarted by an exchange between Twilight and Mayor Mare.

The former wanted for the Mayor to do a speech before Nightmare Night, the latter didn't. I decided, respectfully so, to not give much of a crap about this conflict. I mean, Twi had all the right intentions but trying to take the fight into the institutions when the Mayor had all reasons to be stubborn on the status quo without a push from a certain princess.

Speaking of Luna, she had been quite secretive over her costume. From my understanding, Luna was not going to employ a traditional mindset about the holiday. I explained to her that usually Nightmare Night was all about ponies just out there enjoying the fright, so they weren't exactly out to 'humiliate her and demonize her as Nightmare Moon' but they may be prone to think of her as still NM due to the expectation of terror and the fact Celestia hadn't done enough to explain her return to the denizens of Ponyville.

The only thing I knew about her expected visit was that she was not going as Nightmare Moon.

I am well aware of Our Subjects' caution-driven fear of that figure, so I will not try to 'normalize' it just yet.

And yet she refused to tell me what costume she had in mind to go with. Admittedly, that had me a bit curious as I really wasn't sure what kind of costume Luna could pick. If that had been a question from before she was overwhelmed by games, I would have said some obscure historical figures with a degree of terrifying reputations to make them 'fitting' for the holiday's theme.

Now, that may not be the case at all. Luna was now more aware of what other ponies liked and were familiar with, so it was now a matter of her knowing the limits of how much skin can be shown and how much should be covered. And I was rather nervous about it considering that it could backfire horribly if she picked something too skimpy for the common pony's taste.

Turns out that her decision was just the perfect middle point. Then again, the choice wasn't exactly a known character but one from a game that I introduced her during a 'dream-talk'.

Hsien Ko from Darkstalkers was definitely an unexpected pick, but the general theme was fitting and it wasn't threatening. In fact, I would say her costume confused Ponies. Instead of the scary Nightmare Moon, they got Princess Luna wearing a spooky costume of the silly kind.

She did some posing and gesturing as if mimicking a zombie, but it was the kind of 'silliness' that disarmed the worries of the crowd with ease. Hell, kids were soon flocking at her side to ask more about her costume. After she was done giving a speech about 'correcting past mistakes' and 'making sure that she is seen for who she really is', Luna decided to spent most of the night with me.

Sure, Twilight and Co. tagged along with what I could only assume being their attempts to 'help' Luna. But overall, the princess had been prepared enough to be able to play some of the games right. She even made friends with a little boy called Pipsqueak through the night. But as the celebrations were done around midnight, Luna had asked me to spend the night at my house as she had taken efforts to have Celestia help with the dream duty for the night as she helped with the day duty for the occasion.

I used this opportunity to ask a few awkward questions, specifically about-

"So, how did you get bigger?" After all, I could clearly remember her blue fur not being that dark of a shade, or her mane being ethereal looking.

"Oh, I had a serious conversation with Tia and we... we made more steps forward in mending what was broken of our bonds. I think my magic reacted to it... do you like it?"

"You look hotter," I bluntly remarked, causing her to blush. "I mean, not only you look more mature, but your frame has filled up just nicely."

She raised an intrigued frown. "You didn't like my curves before now?"

"Heh, I just said those were improved, not that they are 'only now' good," I argued, reaching out to pinch at her 'upper' cheeks. "You were gorgeously cute in that other form."

A tiny pout appeared on her face and soon we arrived to our destination. It was just the two of us, with the house quiet as the soft darkness of the night had shrouded it to some extent. Yawning, I took the lead as I went to my bedroom... with Luna following closely as she suddenly made her presence known by bolting for the bed once in sight and dive-bombing for it. She bounced a bit, smiling as she removed her hat. Her posture was telling of what she was up to.

"Hm, is this a request for something intimate, princess?"

Her lips twitches. "Lord Anon, you should know better than to assume a princess' interest but... yes. I want to take on that offer you gave me a while ago as I have taken precautions for... some intense coitus."

"So, you want to get pounded silly?"

Embarrassment made her stiff. "Y-Yes, but there's no need to-"

"You want to get her moonbutt drilled into a messy thing?"

The pout was back. "J-John!"

"Can't blame a guy for trying to get a preview of how cute you are going to get once you get flustered."

Removing more pieces of her clothes as I started to undress myself, Luna was soon shifting at the edge of the bed, ass aimed at me as her delicious moon buns were swaying left and right in an enticing manner. Looking over her shoulder, a tiny blush was burning on her cheeks and she showed how she was biting her lower lip in preparation.

"Your princess requires service."

Luna shuddered a bit as she felt my cock slap softly by her left cheek, and then as I leaned down to her back and close to the back of her head, I lined up my length and slowly penetrated her. The alicorn sighed in bliss once I was fully sheathed inside her, staring forward while my hands started to tease her now big breasts.

"So, princess, are you ready for a night of no sleep~?"

"O-Only if you can give me that, of course."

Challenge accepted.

The pace was slow at first so I could give her the chance to acclimatize with this first time of sex after her exile. It took me less than a minute to draw moans out of her, the princess clearly 'rusty' but quite able to feel pleasure through the soft thrusting.

Of course, the pace eventually picked up, with the alicorn's lewd noises growing in intensity.

PLAP~! PLAP~! PLAP~! PLAP~!

"D-Don't stop~!" Luna breathed eagerly. "This- hm~ this is so good~!"

Hearing this, I slowly retreated from her tits and took hold of her butt before starting to thrust even harder and faster. She was grasping at the mattress, moaning sluttily as I pounded her hungry cunt until it was time to give it a nice filling of cock-milk.

One last powerful thrust was all Luna needed to orgasm for the third time, while I ended up cumming deep inside her. She went stiff, then shivered and softly collapsed on the mattress. We cuddled up a bit to charge up, with Luna smiling eye-to-eye with this first round.

"I-It was amazing."

"Well, only the best for the best princess."

My words further delighted her. "Well, I suppose we should take a proper rest now and-"

"Hold on, did you forget what I said? No sleep tonight. We are going for Round 2."

...

"R-Round 2? Y-You are not tired yet?"

I frowned. "Nope."

"Y-You can go for- for more than a time?"

I slowly nodded. "Yeah-"

"Th-That means a lot. Many stallions can't do that."

...

That actually surprised me. Was that really a thing? I knew I was 'smaller' than most pony dudes, but I had a stamina advantage on them?

"Really?"

Luna nodded. "Yes, and... how long can you last?"

"Well, I can't say for certain but we have a way to test it out?"

Revitalized by the claim and offer, Luna earnestly shifted over me, straddling herself to my lap as she proceeded to impale herself and ride me for another hour or so. Round 2 then went to 3, then to 5 and finally to 7.

It was early morning when we decided to fall asleep. There was a day off given to workers after Nightmare Night to allow them to rest from any heavy partying. Luna and I definitely partied hard that night, and as we happily cuddled in bed, basking in the after sex glow.

Quite unaware that a certain pink pony had taken notice of Luna spending the night there and that... a certain princess on dream duty had picked up anomalies around me and her sister.


AN

John & Spike go and meet some dragons. One in particular makes an early appearance than she is supposed to. Headpats and crushes are inbound!