At Tolkien's farmhouse...
Nate: Who wants to tell the last story?
Brimmy: Tolkien is the owner of this house, so he can tell it.
Tolkien: You guys want me to tell the story?
Francis: Sure. You can tell it.
Douglas: Yeah.
Kevin S: Since this is your house, you can tell the story.
Tolkien: Okay. I'm gonna tell it.
Nate: Okay.
Tolkien: Okay. It all started in a thrift shop.
It transitions into the story.
Tolkien: I wonder what I should get for Nichole. (He sees a makeup kit.) Perfect.
He then grabs it and unknown to him, it starts glowing from inside.
Thrift Shop Employee: Is that all you're getting?
Tolkien: Yeah.
Thrift Shop Employee: Okay. I'll go ahead and ring it up for you.
Later at Nichole's house...
Nichole: Tolkien, I'm glad you came over to my house.
Tolkien: Me too, Nichole. Oh, and I bought you something.
He pulls out the makeup kit he bought.
Nichole: Cool. Thanks, Tolkien.
Tolkien: You're welcome. I hope you enjoy it.
The next day, Nichole starts putting makeup on her face.
Nichole: I think I look cute.
The girls entered.
Bebe: Wow. You look awesome, Nichole.
Millie: I agree. Where did you get it?
Nichole: Tolkien bought it for me.
Jenny: Cool. But I do wish Wendy, Red, Samantha and Sophie were here to see this.
Jessie: Are they dead?!
Kal: Oh no!
Lola: No, dummies. They're in space!
Jessie: Oh...
Kal: What's space?
Annie: Yeah. We don't know what Space is.
They all facepalmed at their stupidity.
Nichole: How about you all look it up on the internet?
Her face starts glowing and her eyes turn red.
Bebe: Uh... Nichole?
Nichole (Demonic Voice): No! I'm a makeover monster!
She laughs evilly.
Tolkien is walking through the neighborhood with Clyde, Tweek and Jimmy when he got a text.
Tolkien: I gotta take this. (He pulls out his phone and reads the text.) Oh no. Guys, come on. Let's head to Nichole's house!
Clyde: What for?
Tolkien: Just come on!
They all head there.
When they got to Nichole's house, they entered and noticed a demon possessing Nichole.
Clyde: This is just like what O'Malley did to me!
Tolkien: We gotta get that demon out of Nichole!
Tweek: How?! The only person who knows how to deal with demons is in space right now!
Jimmy: We'll just have to do it ourselves.
William: Save our daughter from that monster possessing her!
Tolkien: Okay.
Nichole (Demonic Voice): You can never stop me! I am unstoppable! (She laughs evilly and grabs a knife.) Now prepare to die!
Clyde: We gonna get that makeup off her face!
Tweek: But how?
Clyde: Dude, you're a robot now. Just shoot water at her face.
Tweek: Oh yeah. (He turns his robotic arm into a water pistol and starts shooting water at Nichole's face, but keeps missing.) What the fuck?!
Bebe: Do something, asshole!
Tweek: I'm trying!
He continues to shoot water at her face, but to no avail.
Nichole (Demonic Voice): You can never stop me. I am the most powerful demon in the world and nobody can stop me! (She laughs evilly until Kelly PT splashes a bucket of water on her.) No! What have you done to me?! I'm hideous!
She screams and the girls wipe the makeup off Nichole's face until it was completely gone. The demon frees itself and disappears for good and Nichole collapses.
Tolkien: Nichole, are you okay?!
She wakes up.
Nichole: What happened?
Tolkien hugs Nichole.
Tolkien: That makeup possessed you and a demon took over your body. I am so sorry this happened. I didn't know it was cursed.
Nichole: I forgive you. Now let's get rid of this makeup.
The cursed makeup was thrown in a trash truck the next day and it drives off.
Tolkien: There. Now we have a repeat of this.
Nichole: Yup. Wanna go one a date?
Tolkien: Sure.
Story Ends.
It transition back to reality.
Tolkien: The End.
Clyde: That was a cool story.
Nate: Yeah. Anyways, let's go to sleep.
The boys went to Tolkien's room and went to sleep.
Happy Early Halloween, and stay tuned for season 2 of Cartoons in Space.