Elena sat alone in the dimly lit corner of P3, a sense of melancholy washing over her. The pulsating music and laughter around her seemed distant as her thoughts centered on her connection with Paige and the recent events that had unfolded in the world of the Charmed Ones.

She traced the rim of her drink with a finger, her mind drifting back to that fateful night when she had first protected Paige from the Titan, Meta. The memory was vivid: the rush of adrenaline as she shielded Paige from harm, the power coursing through her veins as she vanquished the formidable foe. But as quickly as she had appeared, she had disappeared, leaving Paige with a sense of confusion.

Elena's bond with Paige ran deeper than anyone could fathom. She had made an unbreakable oath that not only granted her extraordinary powers when near Paige but also the ability to glimpse into Paige's thoughts and future. It was through this connection that Elena had witnessed the arrival of Chris Perry.

She knew that Chris had come to the sisters' house under the guise of saving Paige from danger. And through the whispers of Paige's thoughts, she had witnessed the turmoil it had caused within the Halliwell family when he told them of a dark future where Paige is gone. Leo, the man that the sisters trusted, had been made an Elder. With Leo working from above he had bestowed the sisters with the powers of the Greek Gods to fight the Titans.

Elena couldn't help but feel a pang of sympathy for Piper, who had been caught in the middle of these tumultuous events. She had seen through Paige's thoughts the devastation in Piper's eyes when Leo had left them and taken back their Godesses powers.

Elena knew that Paige had been struggling with the aftermath of these changes, torn between her heartbreak for her sister and the fear of death.

As Elena sat there, lost in thought, she couldn't help but wonder about her place in Paige's life. She felt like an outsider, a guardian bound by an unbreakable oath that Paige never signed up for. And now, with the Charmed Ones facing new challenges and a new whitelighter in the form of Chris Perry, Elena questioned how she should go about her role in Paige's world.

But one thing remained certain in Elena's heart – her unwavering commitment to protect Paige, and failing to do so meant the oath would kill her. She had to protect her no matter the cost.

As she gazed at her untouched glass, an unexpected presence pulled her from her reverie. A striking woman settled into the seat next to her. Phoebe had a way of making her entrance felt, and her eyes sparkled with intrigue as she took in Elena's presence.

Phoebe couldn't help but voice her thoughts, her words laced with playful allure. "You know," she began, leaning in slightly, "I couldn't help but be drawn to you the moment I walked in here. It's like there's some kind of magical attraction." She flashed Elena a dazzling smile.

Elena felt her cheeks warm under Phoebe's gaze and the flattering words. She felt stupid coming here tonight. Apparently from the 'magical' comment Phoebe remembers her from the night with Meta, but she decided to play dumb "You certainly have a way with words," she replied, her own smile a mix of flattery and surprise.

Phoebe continued her slightly flirtatious banter, leaning closer. "And speaking of magic," she said, her voice dropping to a sultrier tone, "you have the most beautiful dark caramel-colored hair. It's enchanting."

Elena chuckled softly, grateful for the compliment but mindful of the secrets she carried. "Thank you. You're quite charming yourself," she replied, her voice carrying a hint of warmth now.

Phoebe tilted her head, her brow furrowing slightly. "You know, you seem oddly familiar," she mused, her eyes narrowing in thought. "Do you come here often?"

Elena' heart skipped a beat but she couldn't help but notice that Phoebe didn't actually seem to recognize her. A wave of relief washed over her slowly. It meant that, at least for this moment, her connection to Paige and the events of that day remained hidden. "No, this is my first time here"

Despite her firm cautious approach, Elena found herself drawn into Phoebe's magnetic presence, pulled in by her charisma and magical powers, even if only for a fleeting moment. But she knew that the complexities of her duty stood as a lighthouse for her.

She focused her head, remembering that Phoebe possessed unique abilities as a seer. A simple touch or connection with her belongings could potentially reveal the secrets Elena was keeping. Additionally, Phoebe's empathic abilities meant that she could sense Elena's feelings.

With a polite smile, Elena started, "Thank you for the compliments. You're very kind." Her voice carried a hint of warmth, but also a sense of restraint she hoped would deliver the fake message that she was not available.

Phoebe, undeterred, seeing right through her, leaned in closer, her eyes sparkling with curiosity. "You're a bit of a mystery, aren't you?" she teased. "But I like mysteries."

Elena sighed internally oh-how-cliche but still she thought it made her feel warm and fuzzy inside, and she wanted nothing more than to flirt back, but her duty to protect Paige clashed with this silly undeniable attraction she felt for Phoebe. She struggled to maintain her composure, her mind a battlefield of conflicting desires.

Phoebe moved her hand to brush a strand of Elena's dark caramel hair away from her face, and Elena's heart raced at Phoebe's closeness. She pulled her head slightly back, pulling the hair away before Phoebe could touch it. "It's been nice talking to you, but I really must be going," she said, her gaze briefly flickering towards Piper who was far in the distance behind the bar.

Piper, had been watching the exchange with a raised eyebrow, and she couldn't help but intervene. She approached the two women, a friendly but authoritative smile on her face. "Phoebe, dear, I think it's time you give your new friend some space," she suggested, a subtle warning in her tone.

Phoebe reluctantly withdrew, shooting Elena a parting smile. "Alright, if you say so," she said, before sauntering away, casting a lingering glance back at Elena.

Once Phoebe was out of earshot, Piper turned to Elena with a knowing look. "Sorry about that," she said, her voice filled with understanding. "Phoebe has a way of being, well, very Phoebe."

Elena chuckled softly, grateful for Piper's intervention. "No problem at all. It was... interesting," she replied as she turned her attention to Piper, who had appeared to still be concerned. Piper's eyes held a touch of vulnerability, and Elena sensed that beneath her tough exterior, Piper was grappling with the recent loss of Leo's presence as he became an Elder.

Elena offered a warm smile to Piper, one that cannot reveal the true extent of her knowledge.

"I can tell you've been going through a lot," Elena began, her voice filled with empathy. "Life has a way of throwing us curveballs, doesn't it?"

Piper nodded, a hint of gratitude in her eyes for Elena's willingness to acknowledge her. "Oh. You can see it on my face? Yeah, it does," she admitted, her voice slightly tremulous.

Elena continued, her tone reassuring. "whatever you're facing, it's okay to feel the way you do."

Piper's shoulders relaxed, and she offered Elena a genuine smile. "Thank you," she said, her voice carrying a note of genuine appreciation. "It means a lot to hear that."

Elena reached out to touch Piper's hand, as a simple gesture of support and understanding. But when she brushed against Piper's, there was a subtle, electric jolt that coursed through her.

"You're not alone in this, I'm sure a lot of people love you," she assured her. "And no matter what, it will all be okay." Elena and Piper exchanged a lingering gaze, a silent understanding passing between them.

Elena knew that she couldn't stay, not with the secrets she carried and the duty that bound her to Paige. With a soft smile, she said, "I should get going. We'll see each other again."