AN: This was the third story wrote for October, though it's the fourth one I'm posting.
AN2: So In the month of November I am going to be working on writing stories for December. I may only post like once halfway through November so I'm letting you know in advance. I know I have one story planned called December of Fun with a big twist. I just hope can get it finished in November. Not even sure how many chapters it will be. However, if you have any fun holiday ideas might want to see Brian and Justin do, let me know. The story will be AU.
Summary: Justin and Brian playing scare wars on each other since it's the first of October. Someone else drops in and Brian doesn't defend them like they thing should.
Title: Halloween Scares
There was a slight shriek that sounded, and Justin slid down under the covers pretending he was still asleep. He might have hung up the animatronic demon looking thing in the shower earlier. It was October and he loved Halloween. He was sure that Brian was going to get him a lot this month. Today was the first day and Brian didn't know how much he loved the month. He wished so badly that he could have been in there to witness it when Brian saw it. Though if the shriek that Brian let out was any indication to what he felt seeing it, he might be in for it.
"JUSTIN." Brian shouted. "You little twat." Followed the original shout of his name.
Yep, Brian was going to skin him alive probably. Though Justin stayed where he was at trying not to laugh. He hadn't been able to help himself when it came to wanting to put the spooky stuff up. He was living here after all, and he wasn't going to get to play scare each other with his sister. Molly was eight, but she was obsessed with Halloween like he was. Every year since she was five, they had played the game. See which one could get the most screams out of each other. It was what he would miss about this year. Though, he figured Brian might be a good victim of his scares if he didn't murder him.
Justin had his eyes closed and he could hear the water come on in the bathroom. He let out a breath figuring he might be safe. He started laughing not able to hold it in any longer. He had gotten Brian he knew he had. He had heard the shriek that had for sure sounded like someone that was freaked out. It had been high pitched too which meant it was an epic scare. He was going to have to hope he could lay there for a little longer to see if he could get another two shrieks from Brian.
He had put one of the screaming witches in the closet to come out when the door was open. That had not been easy, but Brian had passed out after they'd had two rounds of mind-blowing sex. There was also the demon that rose up when he lifted the toilet lid. That one had almost made him scream. He'd forgotten the thing was in there when he'd gone to the bathroom an hour ago. He had also put a skeleton in the fridge which he hoped would also get Brian.
He was fixing to turn over when the covers were yanked completely off the bed and Brian was standing there. He had thought he was in the shower; the damn thing was on. However, Brian was standing there looking at him. He let out a slight shout because he wasn't expecting it. He would never admit anything else. Brian had not scared him, nope, he'd surprised him.
"What in the fuck is this?" Brian asked holding the thing from the shower.
"It's October." Justin said trying not to smile. "You know Halloween's the last day of the month. My favorite holiday." He added. "I thought that I would hang some things in the loft since I'm staying here." He stated before he started laughing. "Was that you shrieking in there? Did I get you?" He asked.
"Oh, you love Halloween do you." Brian said as a smile started forming on his face. "You think you can become the master of scares, do you?"
Justin nodded because he had won twice against his sister. Last year she had gotten him good though. The snake had looked real in the toilet and the week before a neighbor had lost a snake. He had nearly broken his neck trying to get out of the bathroom, after he'd peed himself. The seat had been rigged where the snake had come up when he lifted it. He had screamed so loud that he'd woken their parents up. He'd declared her the winner because it had been the best prank. He could deal with spiders, but he couldn't handle snakes.
"This means war because you are not about to out scare me. Ask anyone, I'm the master at scares." Brian said with an evil smirk. "Might want to sleep with one eye open from now on." He added before he dropped the animatronic on top of the bed. "You got one scream out of me. I doubt you'll get anymore." He said before walking back towards the bathroom.
Justin wasn't sure if he should be worried or scared with that statement. He had forgotten about three days ago when Michael had asked Brian if he was going to give him the royal treatment for October. He hadn't known what they were talking about at the time. Brian had kicked Michael under the table when he'd sat down. He'd asked Emmett what it meant, but Emmett had only shook his head saying you don't want to know, baby. So, Brian was in love with Halloween like he was. He liked to scare people too. This might actually be fun this year with someone that could get up really good scares.
"Bring it on, Brian." Justin called out before he got up setting the animatronic in the floor.
He wasn't going to warn him about the other ones in the loft either. They were kind of tied at the moment since Brian had surprised him. It wasn't a full blown scare, but he had jumped slightly. Half a point he figured could be added to Brian's side on him. There was going to have to be some of his stuff gotten though. He'd need to see if Daphne couldn't get the stuff from his mom. He hoped that she might be willing to hand some of it over.
~BJ JB BJ JB~
Brian couldn't help the smile that was on his face through out his shower. He was going to have good competition this year it seemed. Every year he always got his friends with the Halloween pranks. Michael was always the one that freaked out the most. He wondered if Justin might help him with some of the scares for Mikey. The animatronic in the shower that had started moving when he stepped in waving its arms and saying welcome to your death had been cool. It had also freaked the living hell out of him. Justin hadn't let on that he even liked Halloween or even remembered it was October first. Last night he had said a couple of times he couldn't believe it was the last day of September. Justin had acted like he hadn't known.
He finished the shower and got dressed for the day. He was glad that it was a Saturday, so he didn't have to go into work. He hadn't had a chance to work on any ideas for this year's scares yet. He was going to pay Justin back for getting him. They were going to have a scare battle, but he was going to get Justin on his side. There was no way on earth he was going to let the wonderful talent for scares slip away. He needed something epic for this year's scares. He felt like he was the one actually doing all of the scaring. The pranks that were returned to him never did make him shriek like he had earlier.
Brian opened one of the drawers pulling out the special toothbrush he had remembered to get the other day. He went ahead and added the toothpaste to it as well then set it in the jar where Justin's was at. When wondered if he would get him or if Justin knew about the trick tooth brushes out there. He started brushing his teeth making sure he got everywhere in his mouth. He knew when Justin came in the bathroom. He could always tell when Justin was near, and he'd gotten used to it in the last two weeks.
When Brian went to spit, he noticed that the toothpaste had turned black. So, Justin did know about trick toothpaste and the brush. He had gotten him, but it didn't scare him. He also knew that it would come off with regular toothpaste or mouth rinse. He reached over grabbing the mouth wash turning it up and gargling. He saw Justin looking at him in the mirror with a smirk on his face. He shook his head spitting the mouth wash out before gargling another mouth full.
"Molly got me last year with that. It's cool, think your teeth are turning black with rot." Justin smirked before he picked up the toothbrush in his holder. "The one I used doesn't wear off as quick though. Even with mouth wash it's going to take a few hours." He laughed looking at the toothbrush he was holding. "You can't get me though with the same trick." He set the one he'd picked up on the counter and pulled out a new one just in case.
"You are so going to get it." Brian let out a slight growl when he saw that his teeth were in deed still black. "You best be lucky today's Saturday and I don't have to go to work." He was also slightly annoyed that Justin hadn't fallen for the trick. He should have been thinking and checked his own toothbrush. He'd been too busy hoping that Justin didn't know about it.
"I guess that is two for me and only a half of a point for you." Justin smiled.
"You didn't scare me with it so doesn't count." Brian stated.
"If we get the other with any kind of prank we do for Halloween. Whether it be a scream or shriek we let out or like the trick toothpaste. It will count because the other fell for it." Justin declared moving so he was standing in front of Brian. "The winner will get what he wants from the other." He said moving his hand down Brian's shirt.
"Does it last the whole month or day? I ask because if you're this good we should work together to get the others." Brian offered as a second deal.
"We can work together on getting them, but I am not about to give up getting you. I'm sorry that's not how I work. It's all month long too with the night of Halloween being the best night." Justin stated.
"Weekend long for us, month long on getting them. I'll even let you have access to my Halloween supplies." Brian replied watching Justin's face as he thought about it.
"We'll see after today if I want to join you." Justin said with a grin. "Now, why don't you…" He started but the sound of the loft door opening and Michael shouting for Brian had him letting out a groan. "Deal with him while I shower." He really wasn't in the mood for Michael right now. He'd wanted alone time with Brian today.
"I'll get rid of him because this conversation is not over. I also haven't rigged any good scares up yet for him." Brian said before he leaned in kissing Justin.
He moved his hands down to Justin's ass cupping both cheeks and pulling him flush against him. He got a moan from Justin and slipped his tongue into his mouth when he opened up for him. He was breaking all his rules already. He fucked no one more than once, He'd done that with Justin more than he could count since they met. He also did not live with anyone, yet Justin was now staying there. He didn't do boyfriends, which so far that was still true. Though Justin was trying to claim otherwise. He also hadn't let anyone team up with him on Halloween scares, but he'd just offered Justin that. A scream from the other room had him pulling away from Justin looking at him wondering what in the hell Michael had found and what Justin had done.
Justin started laughing after a moment. "Yeah, I might have been a little busy after you fell into a coma sleep at two this morning."
"BRIAN, what the actual fuck." Michael could be heard screaming again as the two of them left the bathroom.
Brian went down the steps finding Michael standing in the kitchen at the fridge staring at a skeleton that was hanging from a hook inside. It was clear that the thing must have swung down when he opened it up. That was genius and he hadn't thought of doing that before. Half the time when Michael showed up, he went to the fridge looking in it. Right now, he was standing there clutching his chest looking upset and he had definitely been scared. He hadn't missed the scream that Michael let out. Michael never did any good scares himself. He had a name of a horror movie character, and he was bad at scaring others. Though, Brian loved getting the other man with the pranks.
"Did you get a scare, Michael?" Justin asked with a laugh.
"Shut up, I wasn't talking to you boy wonder. Brian, really, it's only the first." Michael complained.
"You are looking at the wrong person, Mikey. This one's all Justin. I guess he got you instead of me." Brian said leaning over to Justin whispering something in his ear. "Go put the animatronic back up in the shower." He said to Justin then to Michael he looked at him. "Why are you here anyway? It's Saturday and I thought you were bitching about having to go to work?" He asked crossing his arms.
"Oh god, there can't be two of you that loves Halloween." Michael groaned glaring at the skeleton again. "You forgot I said I had to use your shower? Our water is off until tonight because of some stupid thing. I need to shower before work, and I didn't feel like going to mom's." Michael explained. "Are you two having so much sex that you hit your head on the wall? You do not need to teach him anything about this stuff." He complained pointing at the skeleton.
"Justin already has a love of Halloween, I found out this morning." Brian said with a smile before he took the skeleton down. "Don't go complaining either because you started this when we were fifteen. Though I'm better at it." He added before closing the fridge.
"Whatever, I'm going to use the shower. Can you please make me something to eat. I'm starving and don't have time to stop for breakfast." Michael asked.
"Nope, I'm not cooking for you." Brian said.
"It's my day off, I'm not your servant." Justin replied pulling out a bowl from the cabinet. "Though I can set out a bowl and cereal." He offered grabbing the milk from the fridge before he sat down.
Michael groaned before he went to the bathroom. Brian started counting in a low voice and when he got to six there was a scream. Justin and him both started laughing before Michael came running out of the bathroom and into the kitchen again. He had a towel wrapped around his waist glaring at them.
"You didn't forget I was coming this morning. Seriously, Brian. You know I had nightmares for months after we watched Psycho, and you would do that prank when we were sixteen." Michael shouted at him.
Justin snorted wiping his mouth when the cereal came back out. He hadn't know about that and he could total see Brian doing something like that. When he swallowed he grinned. "It wasn't Brian that did it. I got him earlier with it. He never told me about your fear of showers either." He said.
"Oh my god, I fucking hate you even more." Michael screeched. "Get the fucking thing out of there before I break it. You are pure evil. And you better not have anything else in that bathroom or else." He glared stomping his foot.
"Oh, I thought it was brilliant after all, he got me and I'm not easy to get." Brian said picking up the spoon from Justin's bowl and eating some of the cereal.
"I'm not about to say if there are other things in this place." Justin said getting off the stool. "You break anything, and you will be paying me back too." He added leaving the room after he grabbed Brain's hand and took the spoon full of cereal that was in it first.
"Don't you two share enough, do you really have to eat out of the same bowl and spoon?" Michael asked.
"Like you said, I already suck his dick and eat his ass. Might as well eat out of the same bowl." Brian said with a smirk. "You however cannot touch." He added.
"Like I want his germs." Michael grumbled.
"I'm cleaner than you are." Justin said coming back in the room. "There the thing is out of the shower." He sat back on the stool opening his mouth up in which Brian put a spoon full of cereal in before he took another bite too.
"You don't fucking do boyfriends, but you're spoon feeding him cereal? Really?" Michael complained before leaving for the bathroom.
"Fuck off, Mikey." Brian said when he finally swallowed. He didn't bother getting another bowl, but he did sit down on the other stool. "I don't do boyfriends."
Justin nodded grabbing the spoon before Brian could take another bite. "Right, I hear you." He laughed watching Brian take another bite too.
~BJ JB BJ JB~
"You want to watch a horror movie?" Justin asked after Michael left. "You been digging around in that closet for a while." He said wondering what Brian was looking for.
He had thought Brian would have made some kind of noise when the witch had started screaming, but he hadn't been phased at all by it. He had smiled and taken it down and he had gone outside the loft door hanging it up. When he had come back in, he'd said it was going to be another great one over on Michael. The toilet scare had also gotten the other man, which Brian had gotten between the two of them when Michael threatened to beat his ass for it. He'd almost dropped the toilet seat on his thing. It wasn't his fault Michael couldn't take a fucking joke like that.
Brian stood up pulling out one of the boxes that he'd had in the back of the closet. It had taken him some time to dig the thing out since it had gotten buried under some of Justin's stuff. It was the box that held all of his Halloween things. He had gotten a bag the other day of a few new things that he would add like more bats because last year Melanie had destroyed the ones he'd had.
"As soon as I finish this." Brian replied. "You can go pick on out while I look." He didn't bother turning around. He was holding a clown mask in his hands. "Why don't you put on IT, I think you said you liked it."
"The movie, not the fucking clown part. He fucking creeps me out, not scares, creeps me out." Justin said wanting him to know the difference. "I was also forbidden from ever watching it near Molly. Except, she loved the thing too and would laugh. I guess was probably a bad brother at showing her the stuff so early, but she loved it." He sighed because he missed her a lot, even if half the time she'd been annoying as hell.
"You weren't a bad brother, Justin. You still aren't the asshole is the one that's bad." Brian said putting the mask in the box and turning around to give Justin a hug. He thought he might need one.
"Thanks, mom said she'd bring her here Halloween night to let me see her costume. I want to take her out myself, but he'd probably have a bitch fit." Justin sighed holding onto Brian.
"Fuck him and as long as you hide the adult toys, she can come over some time." Brian offered before pulling back. "You were kicked out, not sent off to some fucking private island without visitation."
Justin smiled. "Okay, I'll go find the movie now." He leaned in kissing Brian before going towards the living room. "That clown mask isn't scary enough, just so you know." He added hearing Brian groan as he laughed.
Brian growled out before he looked in the box to see if there was anything else that he could possibly use to get Justin. He dug down and pulled on something that was wrapped around something else. He didn't even remember buying the mask that he was holding. It didn't even seem scary to him, but. Justin hated snakes and it was a mask that had snakes coming out of the holes of the face. He felt like this might work better than the clown one since Justin thought it hadn't been scary.
He got over near the TV finding Justin fixing to put the movie in. He had waited until he got closer since the eye holes in the mask sucked big time. He remembered why he had tossed it at the bottom of the box. You couldn't really see out of the thing or breathe either. He slipped the thing on when he saw Justin stand up. He was hoping that this time he could get him. He reached out touching Justin on the shoulder. However, when he reached forward, he was touching only air. Justin had been right in front of him he couldn't miss him. He felt around for a moment before turning. There was still nothing but air which should not be true.
~BJ JB BJ JB~
"Justin, you were right there. Where did you go?" Brian asked reaching up and pulling the mask off of his head. "Mother fucking shit." He yelled out moving backwards in a hurry. "Oh you are so fucking dead meat, Justin Taylor." He said turning around finding Justin laughing. "You better run because you are going to get it."
Justin let out a gasp before he took off running. He had the movie up to the moment where the spider came out. He'd hit play at the exact moment that Brian took the mask he'd been wearing off. He knew Brian freaked out at spiders and he had used it. Debbie had once told him the story of Brian standing on Michael's bed screaming until she came up to kill a spider. He jumped from the bed to the door and refused to sleep in the room for a week when she couldn't find it. He figured that Brian forgot about the spider scene in the movie.
He wasn't exactly sure where he could run since the loft didn't have anywhere really, he could hide. Brian was also fast when he wanted to be. He turned like he was going to the bedroom only to take a hard left and run for the kitchen. Though, Brian was on him in a matter of a second lifting him up off of his feet. He let out a squeal because he was quickly maneuvered so he was over Brian's shoulder fireman style. Brian's hand coming down on his ass which caused him to moan. He never had guessed he liked to be spanked sometimes during sex.
"What are you going to do? Put me in time out?" Justin asked. "Or fuck me?" He wasn't sure which one Brian would go for. He'd made him sit on the bed with a plug in his ass and a cock ring on the other day when he wouldn't stop teasing him.
Instead of answering Brian dropped him on the bed looking Justin up and down. He got on the bed himself and watched Justin move up the bed until he was at the top of it lying flat on his back. He smiled down with his hands on either side of Justin's head. He bent down kissing him running his tongue over Justin's lips until he opened his mouth up. He went in seeking Justin's tongue out. He fought him until Justin gave in surrendering to whatever he wanted to do. He thought about it for a moment as he'd been devouring Justin's mouth. He knew Justin thought he was going to fuck him. Instead, he started tickling him.
"This is what I'm doing." Brian said getting Justin to laugh and squirm. "Say you're sorry for the spider."
"Never." Justin squeaked out trying to roll, but Brain's legs were on either side of him and he was pinned. "Fuck, you have to stop. I have to pee." He laughed hoping that Brian thought he was telling the truth.
"You play fake out all the time with that one." Brian said with his own laugh watching Justin squirm. "Say you're sorry and I'll stop."
"I'm, I'm, I'm sorry." Justin finally got out between laughs.
"Thank you." Brian said moving back, but the second he did Justin was moving and had him on his back and he was the one being tickled. "Fuck no."
"See how you like it." Justin laughed knowing that Brian was more ticklish than he was. He was going to get him back that was for sure.
Brian squirmed rolling over trying to get away. Justin hadn't had a chance go pin him down like he'd done him. He was trying to get off the bed and away from Justin. He was going to have to get his own self for starting the tickle fight. Justin always won these too. He thought he was almost free, but Justin sat down on his legs and he couldn't go anywhere. Though, Justin was still tickling him. This time he was getting behind his knees.
"Mercy, I call mercy." Brain called out because unlike Justin's fake out he did have to pee. The moment Justin let up he was rushing into the bathroom. He was glad that he'd taken the demon thing out earlier because he had to go. He was going to find a way to scare Justin before the day was done. Then, they could work together on scaring the others.
"Admit defeat that you can't scare me." Justin said in a sing song voice when Brian came out of the bathroom.
"I will find something that will scare you." Brian declared before reached over getting his cell phone. "I'm going to order us pizza. I'll be back." He said going back into the bedroom. He was going to have to make a phone call for this. He only could hope that it was Mother Taylor that answered and not the asshole.
~BJ JB BJ JB~
The rest of the day had been spent watching movies and eating pizza. It had been a bad day with junk food, but a good day of just hanging out at the loft. Justin had ended up getting him twice more which hadn't been easy those times since he'd been expecting stuff. A remote control rat with red eyes had come out from under the couch. Justin had said he couldn't reach the remote when he'd dropped under the couch. He should have known it was a trap, but he'd fallen for it. He'd stuck his head down looking and the rat and come out squeaking and eyes glowing so bright. They'd had the lights off at the time and he'd fallen back on his butt about hitting his head on the coffee table.
That time he had given Justin more than a tickle fight on the bed. He'd made him beg for mercy while he'd been fucking him with different size dildos until he gave him his own nine inches. It had been more for both of them and not really punishment. Afterwards, they had taken a nap and he'd woken up without Justin beside him. He'd planned on putting the idea he'd gotten from Molly to use then. Though it hadn't happened.
Justin had been in the shower he thought, he figured maybe he could pull off trying to scare him. It was glass doors sure, but if Justin was turned he might could. It hadn't worked and instead Justin had jumped out at him. He hadn't gotten in the shower he had been waiting like Brian had thought of doing in one of his scares. He'd jumped at him, and he'd had a devil mask on with horns coming out the top. The eyes had also lite up and Justin had a fake ax that he'd swung at him. He had swore a blue streak and also that he was checking every where in the loft to see where Justin was hiding this stuff.
Now, it was almost one in the morning and Justin had won if they were going by the day. Yet, if they went by when they woke up he needed something epic to win. Molly had told him that Justin had been scared of something crawling under the covers and seeing it moving under them towards him. It took some doing, but Brian rigged up what he thought would work. He had made sure he didn't fall asleep when Justin did. Instead, he had gotten up and took the remote control mouse and added some fur to the thing. It was a lot bigger looking now with the wig he'd cut up and put around the thing.
He put it under the covers at the foot of the bed before leaving the room. He sat down right outside the door to make sure he was in range. He flipped the switch and watched it start making it's way up towards Justin. This was probably going to have him be the one skinned alive, but he hadn't gotten Justin once. He was the master of scares, but Justin kept getting him. He saw the mouse thing hit against Justin's leg. He hoped it was enough to wake him up. Sometimes he could sleep like the dead. He moved the mouse back to the edge of the bed before he started working it back up.
~BJ JB BJ JB~
Justin let out a grunt when he felt something touching him. He thought it was Brian's cock at first. He shrugged it off until it happened again. It felt like it was on the inside of his leg though. He blinked a couple of times looking down to try and see exactly what had touched him. When he did he could see something moving under the sheet. He turned looking towards the right of the bed, but Brian wasn't there. There was something moving under the covers towards him.
"Brian, you in the bathroom?" He called out hoping this might be some kind of dream. It was the one thing that freaked him out as a kid and kinda still did. The thought of something coming up from under the bed and feeding on him.
Brian didn't answer, but he let the mouse move farther up, but from his position he couldn't see where it was at. He heard Justin say his name again and he definitely sounded panicked. Another inch and then he heard Justin let out a scream and then there was a thump. He wasn't sure if it had been the mouse getting tossed or Justin falling. He got up dropping the remote going in the room finding Justin fighting the covers halfway on the step to the bed and half on the floor. He was also screaming to get it off of him.
"Why are you down there? Have a bad dream?" Brian asked as if he didn't know what the problem was.
"Something was under the covers. I know it sound crazy, but I saw it then it touched me." Justin said finally kicking the sheet free. When he did the mouse came out as well which had him letting out another shout. "SEE, I told you something was in there." Justin said getting back on the bed and in the middle so he was far away from whatever it was.
"You mean this?" Brian asked bending over and picking it up. When he did he threw it towards the bed which had Justin full out screaming again and he was off the bed and running out of the bedroom.
"Get it the fuck away from me." Justin yelled going towards the living room.
When he did, he was met by the animatronic he'd had in the shower the day before. It was not what he was expecting, and he jumped back letting out a shout. He was half asleep and didn't realize that Brian had set it up. He thought he was dreaming still and when he went towards the bathroom instead the screaming witch started screaming and cackling causing him to move backwards against, he wall sliding down it. When a snake started moving towards him he thought he was in hell until he heard laughing. Full on laughing like someone was finding this hilarious. He looked up and Brian was holding a remote controller in his hand, laughing. He wasn't dreaming, Brian had gotten him back instead for all the things he'd gotten him for the day before.
"Molly said you would freak out if something came up under the bed covers." Brian said between laughs. "Sorry, the rest was all me though. She's who I called yesterday for advice." He shrugged.
Justin groaned letting his head fall back against the wall. "Fucking hell, I thought I was having a nightmare." After a moment he started laughing because now that he knew it was funny. "How about we call it a tie instead? I got you, what five times and you got me three on your own and one with help."
"We got all month to try and do better on scaring each other. Though, I really do want to get the others. You are going to be a perfect helper. No one is going to suspect that you would scare anyone." Brian said holding his hand out to help Justin up off the floor.
"Deal." Justin said getting to his feet. "I have a book of ideas. Also, we are so going to a haunted house." He smiled.
"You got it." Brian replied leaning in and kissing Justin. "Let's go to bed it's after one and I'm tired."
Justin gave him another kiss before they went over to the bed getting in. "I'll have to come up with something epic for my sister after that. Halloween night will have to be a good scare." He said laying his head on Brian's chest.
"Okay." Brian said holding Justin close. He could feel his heart racing still and he knew he had gotten him good.
~THE END~
EN: I wrote this in like seven hours off and on while talking to my sister. I wanted one with mostly Brian and Justin. I love Halloween and I'm seriously sad that today's the last day of the month. Thanks in advance for reviews. This is my candy to you all.