LISA

..

..

Jennie took my hand. The doctor had just done an exam and said everything seemed fine. But since it was our two-month checkup, he wanted to do a sonogram to see if he could hear the baby's heartbeat.

I watched as Dr. Warren squeezed a dollop of gel onto Jennie's flat stomach and started to move a wand around. Shadows flashed on the screen across from me, and all three of us stared at the monitor. The doctor zoned in, pushing down a little more firmly on the wand, and suddenly a sound began to echo throughout the room.

A heartbeat.

My baby has a heartbeat.

Jennie had been reading to me from her What to Expect While You're Expecting book, which said the early months of pregnancy produced a surge of hormones that made many women more emotional than usual. But the damn book failed to mention that it would get all choked up.

My eyes welled, and it was impossible to hold back the tears, no matter how hard I tried. Jennie squeezed my hand and smiled.

Fuck it. Who cares if I'm a total pussy? I didn't want to fight it anymore. I let the tears flow as I leaned down and kissed my girl's forehead. Seven years ago, my own heartbeat stopped, and today mine found its purpose again. I wanted to take Jennie in my arms and dance with her to the rhythm of our baby's magical beat.

The doctor pressed a button and a few inches of the heartbeat printed out from the machine. "Heartbeat sounds good. Strong. I'm just going to do a few quick measurements and I'll have you out of here." He turned a knob on the machine, and the heartbeat disappeared. I felt a stab of panic.

"Could you…leave it on until you finish the exam?" I asked.

Dr. Warren smiled. "Sure thing."

He clicked around and printed out a few more sheets over the next five minutes. When he finished, he gave Jennie a paper towel to wipe off her stomach. Nodding, he said, "Measurements look really good. We can see you back here in a month, and hopefully you'll continue to have a morning-sickness-free pregnancy." He extended one of the little slips of paper with the baby's heartbeat he'd printed from the sonogram machine. "Thought you might like to keep this."

"I would. Thanks. Sorry about getting emotional."

He waved me off. "No need to apologize. This is a big time in your life with a lot of change. Give in and go with the moment. Enjoy the happy times, even if they come with a few tears."

"I will. Thanks, Doc."

Dr. Warren closed the door behind him, and Jennie started to get dressed. I'd been doing a lot of thinking lately and decided the doc's advice was spot on. I needed to go with the moment, and this moment had never felt so right. The fact that I had the box in my pocket made it seem like destiny, if you asked me.

Jennie buttoned her pants and wadded up the paper gown she'd been wearing. She turned to toss it in the garbage, and when she turned back around, I was…

…down on one knee.

Her eyes grew wide and her hands flew up to cover her mouth. "What are you doing?"

I dug into my pocket and pulled out a dingy, old white box. "I'd planned to give this to you in a few weeks, not today. But you heard what the doctor said—'give in and go with the moment'."

"Lisa…oh my God."

I took her hand and held up the box. "This was my grandmother's ring. I was going to get the stone reset for you and put it in a nice, new box. But…" I shook my head. "But I didn't want to wait. The moment feels right." I opened the old box and showed Jennie the contents. It wasn't the biggest ring or the shiniest, but it was filled with so much history and hope. "Last week, after we went to tell Pops about the baby, my grandmother called the next day and asked me to come by alone. The two of them sat me down and told me they wanted me to give this to you when the time was right. It was my great grandmother's, then my grandmother's, and then my mother's."

"It's beautiful, Lisa."

"The funny thing is, I never knew my mother, grandmother, and great grandmother had all shared the same ring. My mom had passed away before I married Lily, and they hadn't given me the ring then. I was curious why now, so I asked. You know what the response was?"

"What?"

I held up the tiny paper the doc had given me. "Pops said you had given me a heartbeat again. And he knew you were my forever."

Jennie started to cry. "That's beautiful."

I took the ring out of the box. "Jennie Ruby Jane, I know we've known each other for less than a year, but I never thought I'd find someone to love the way I love you. I didn't just fall in love with you, I fell in love with life with you by my side. So will you marry me? We can get a different ring, or set a date a year from now if you're not ready. None of it's important. All I want to know is that you'll spend the rest of your life with me."

Jennie practically knocked me over wrapping her arms and body around me. "Yes! Yes! I will. And the ring is beautiful. I don't need anything else. And I don't need a year. All I need is you."

..

I sat on the back deck of Leilani by myself. The bay was eerily quiet this afternoon, which seemed fitting right about now. I felt the same strange calm as the water, even though I'd expected to feel just the opposite on this day. Saying goodbye to this boat was so much more than leaving a place I'd lived for years. Though she wasn't going anywhere—not as long as Pops still wanted to visit her. But it was time for me to move on. Time to stop starting and ending my day with the memories that would forever haunt me, and time to start making new ones—ones filled with happiness. There was just one more thing I needed to do.

I took a deep breath and picked up the pen and paper I'd left out when I packed the last of my things. A sealed envelope sat on the bench seat next to me, one of thousands I'd received and thrown out over the years. But today when my daily letter arrived, I tucked it into my pocket rather than tossing it into the trash. I didn't intend to read it, but I needed the return address today.

More than three thousand of these envelopes had to have come and gone since I first met Lily at fourteen. I'd had the power to stop them at any time—yet I never did—and now I wasn't sure why. Maybe I wanted the daily reminder as part of my punishment. Maybe I wanted Lily to have the same daily reminder of what she'd done every time she picked up a pen. Maybe I was just so fucked in the head, I was afraid I wouldn't think about my daughter without that daily letter. I don't know. But whatever the reason, today was the day it came to an end.

I looked around one last time, imagining Lily standing on the deck that night. I had seen that image in my mind a thousand times before. Squeezing my eyes tight, I swallowed back the taste of salt in my throat before finally lifting the pen to the paper.

Lily,

I don't know how to forgive you.

Maybe by now I should have found God or something—found some way to accept what you've done and make peace with the idea that it wasn't your fault. But I haven't. That's not what this letter is about.

I need to tell you I'm sorry.

I'm sorry I fell asleep that night.

I'm sorry I didn't see the depth of what you were going through and take Leilani far away.

I'm sorry I put what you needed above what our little girl needed.

I'm sorry I didn't see it coming.

I'm sorry I didn't protect our little girl.

I fucked up. I fucked up, Lily.

I've spent the last seven years avoiding anyone I might love. Because I thought when you fall in love, you become blind to that person's flaws and only see what you want to. I was afraid of not seeing who someone is again. I thought I could control who I loved.

Until Jennie.

Jennie made me realize we don't have a choice who we fall in love with. We fall in love by chance. But staying in love and making it work isn't something that happens by chance—that's a choice. And I've chosen to love Jennie.

Because of that, I'm writing today to tell you I've fallen in love with someone else and to ask you to stop writing. Who knows, maybe it will help you move on, too.

I wish I could tell you I found a way to forgive you. But I haven't yet. Maybe someday that will happen. It's not something I can force. I have a long way to go and a lot of healing to do, but I've decided that forgiving myself might be the best place to start. So while I'm not able to fully open my heart and grant you forgiveness, I'm asking you to forgive me. I need to move on. I want to stop hating myself and work toward finding peace. That starts with us.

Please forgive me. Someday I hope to return the gift of forgiveness.

No more letters.

Goodbye, Lily.

Lisa

..

..

..