Disclaimer: First Chapter
Story Start!

Cinder Falls.

There was no way that was her real name, Naruto could just tell that she named herself that when she decided to steal the powers of the Fall Maiden. She made herself way too obvious as well, and she was so cocky with herself that she came IN PERSON to the meeting just like Naruto had thought she would. She thought she was so untouchable, so perfect, that she came by herself and unarmed to the meeting place.

Well, now she was REALLY unarmed.

Illya had cut off her arms with Yor, the second Cinder walked into the room by herself with her guard down, she lost her arms and found herself pushed to the ground with a gag shoved in her mouth by Trevor.

"Mmmph!"

"Listen, this is your fault. Honestly, I thought that you would be smarter than this... did you really think you were so powerful you could do this alone?" Naruto asked Cinder as he grabbed her by the hair and lifted her head up. The wounds on her arms had already been burned closed, so she didn't need to fear death from bleeding out at least. Cinder was sweating from the agony that she was in though.

She was just a young woman.

Yet, there was a deep evil in her eyes, and her heart was as empty as a heart came. Her eyes were eyes that told a person that she thought she was better than anyone around her. She believed from the bottom of her black heart that she could walk into any situation and walk out easily.

"So, we kill her now, right?" Trevor asked as he looked at the woman, and his face showed he found this entire act to be repulsive. He wasn't a big fan of murdering women as a whole.

Yor stepped forward to do it.

"There is a chance her power won't go back to the previous Maiden if we JUST kill her. So-"

-Location: Under Beacon-

"-we need to do this here." Naruto shoved Cinder's face against the glass of the life-support system keeping Amber stable enough to live. Cinder was forced to come face to face with the woman who she put near death. "She needs to return what she stole... well Cinder... do you regret what you did?" Naruto ungagged Cinder.

"She will curse you out."

"I'm going to kill you when I escape... Salem can fix whatever you do to my body. There is no point in showing me this." Cinder had one of her eyes light up with a magical flame. Magical power started to gather around her body.

It stopped when Naruto gripped the back of her head and started to squeeze it. Her aura was already broken, so when he squeezed her skull, the bone started to crack under his strength. Cinder gasped in even more pain, and her eye stopped glowing. She was forced to stare at Amber again, and angry tears started to gather in her eyes.

"You... You needed to sneak up on me... you would have never beaten me in a fair fight."

"Ninja, Assassin, Evil Loli, and monster hunter... we don't fight fair... it's kind of in the job descriptions. Why would we EVER give you a fair chance to fight us?" Naruto asked her as he shoved her head into the glass with enough force to crack it. "So... who wants to be the one to kill her?" Naruto asked as he looked back at his team.

Cinder grabbed a piece of glass with her mouth.

She spat molten glass and killed Amber.

"Shit."

All of the magic in Amber shot right into Cinder, who gained two glowing eyes.

"I'm about to kill you no-" Cinder obtained all of the magic, but it ended up being pointless because Naruto nodded to Yor. Yor cut off Cinder's legs with a clean sweep of her hand. Illya then set her stumps on fire, leaving Cinder as an armless and legless husk of a woman. Trevor just wrapped his whip around Cinder's neck to cut off her oxygen. The magic faded from her eyes again, and even though she was now a complete maiden... she was still in a situation where her magic powers meant nothing.

There was a pause.

"Okay... this was a bad judgement call on my part. I should have trusted my gut feeling, and not listened to Ozpin." Naruto rubbed the back of his head. Ozpin was an older man, so Naruto had decided to listen to him. Ozpin believed that if Cinder was to be killed, the best chance of returning the powers to Amber and not a random woman would be to have Cinder looking at Amber when she died.

Naruto just thought killing Cinder would be enough, but he decided to put a little faith in Ozpin's planning and knowledge of magic.

"So... what do we do now, the magic will just go to some random woman now." Trevor asked Naruto.

"Yeah, this is a problem..."

"No it isn't... we have somebody who already has experience with a form of magic right here." Naruto grabbed Illya by the top of her head. She blinked a few times, before she nodded her head in understanding. Ozpin was in his office, because he didn't want to see Cinder getting killed with his own eyes. "Okay... Illya... me, Yor, and Trevor are going to head up to Oz's office... have fun."

"Oh shit." Trevor stated as he dropped his flask on the ground.

Naruto was giving Illya a free pass to do whatever her heart desired to Cinder, so long as Cinder's last thoughts were about Illya in some form the power would transfer to her.

"I can torture her?"

"Yep."

"I can do all the cruel and nasty things I want to her... no limits at all... you're giving me permission to have fun... have some real fun where I can be the evil loli you called me?" Illya asked Naruto just to be sure.

Genuine fear formed in Cinder's eyes as she started to cry out through her gag. The way that Illya was staring at Cinder with hungry eyes filled with a darkness deeper than her own filled her with an intense fear.

"As evil as you are, you are still... somewhat good hearted."

"I'm only good-hearted to the people I care about. That is a very small list, but I am very loyal to those people... so... you're saying I don't have ANY limits on what I'm allowed to do to her... I can do anything I want... be it torture... rape... humiliation." Illya seemed to be actually drooling over the thoughts running through her head. Yor backed away from Illya slightly, while Trevor was already in the elavator waiting for everyone else to join him. "I can peel her skin off... and unravel her muscles... oh... I can shove things inside her pussy and see how long it takes for something to break..."

Cinder was trying to crawl away from Illya at this point.

"Please... do not say anything specific about what you're going to do to her." Naruto raised a hand to stop Illya from talking. It already pained his heart to allow this behavior, but to make sure the power transferred properly, Illya needed to be the last person Cinder was thinking of.

"Maybe it would be a better idea for me-"

"Yor, you can barely control your own strength, the idea you could control magic is... not a pleasant idea. Illya has experience... and she's loyal to me. Lets be honest here... if Illya is the Maiden, she will be with us... and Salem can't touch her if she is with us." Naruto whispered to Yor. The two of them were more than strong enough to subdue Illya, even if she had magic powers. They were perfect counters for Illya, and Illya was already loyal to him.

As horrible as the idea was, it was still the best option at the moment than the powers going to some random girl.

"Still... Cinder might be evil, but don't you feel a little... eeep!" Yor paled and turned, before she started to run to the elavator. Illya had already started, unable to wait any longer before she began her torture.

Yor was okay with killing and torture, but what Illya was doing was... twisted.

Naruto looked at Illya and Cinder.

...

"You know... this actually isn't as bad as what I thought you were doing to do. It's still super disturbing how you aren't even hesitating... but... yeah... I was expecting worse." Naruto deadpanned with a pale face. What Illya was doing was still extremely horrifying, to the point that Cinder was the furthest thing from a lucky woman at the moment. Naruto tilted his head in confusion for a second.

"Okay!"

"That... wasn't me telling you to increase the level... I'm... going to go now." Naruto was a good guy at heart, and in all honesty, he felt horrible for what he was allowing to happen. "Illya... maybe... go a little easier on..."

"I mean, I can go easier on her... but who knows when the next time you give me permission to do this will be. I have got to enjoy this while I can. Don't worry... I'll stop the bleeding before she passes out." Illya's face was already covered in blood, and so were her hands. "This woman is a villain... that means no amount of torture is too much, right?"

"You're not wrong, she is evil... but you're a bad guy too... so... maybe have a little sympathy for her. This... is a bit too extreme, even for you." Naruto stated as he started around and started to walk away from what he was seeing.

"Okay then, I'll be a little more gentle... okay Cinder, you heard him. I'll stop shoving glass in your holes, how about I carve out poetry into your tits instead?"

-In the Elevator-

"That... girl scares me." Trevor shivered.

"I mean... I think she can be redeemed still. She's just got... to grow a... Naruto... a little help?" Yor asked Naruto, who stared at her.

"... Illya is evil, but she is still willing to do the right thing as long as the people she cares about benefit. As long as her loved ones are good people, Illya is on the side of good. Honestly, I've redeemed worse people than her before... but this is going to be... a project."

"You're the leader... but from now on, I'm sleeping with an eye open." Trevor trusted Naruto's judgement on the matter. "How are we going to explain this to Ozpin?" Trevor questioned Naruto.

...

"... Yor will break the news to him."

"Me!?"

"I might be the leader, but you are a very soft speaker. If any of us should break bad news to people, it's you... you're beautiful, and people won't get as mad if you tell them bad news." Naruto placed his hand on Yor's shoulder.

Trevor agreed and placed a hand on his other shoulder.

It was settled, Yor would break the news to Ozpin.

Chapter End!
Please Leave Me Lots of Nice Long Reviews, But No Flames Please!