The contestants began piling themselves into the Main Lodge. Blaineley was the first one there, because she was originally hiding in one of the two storage rooms.

"What's going on?" Devin asked, walking into the lodge.

"Chris called off the challenge," Blaineley simply stated. "I know as much as you."

"This is absurd!" Jazelle yelled, walking in. She then saw Blaineley and Devin. "Wait… did we win?"

"We have no clue." Devin said.

Jasmine and Sierra walked in, with Bridgette right behind them.

"It's only our team that's showing up!" Jazelle exclaimed. "I think we won already!"

"Really?" Jasmine asked. "It's already over?"

Scott ran into the lodge. "Guys! Something really weird is going on!"

"What is it?" Bridgette asked.

"I saw Gwen and Chef while I was in the woods! Gwen walked past me and Chef and I made direct eye contact!"

"How come he was only going for Gwen?" Jazelle asked. "That doesn't make sense."

The Jaguars walked in all at once.

"I knew Gwen wouldn't be here!" Heather exclaimed. "Do you think she's still in the bathroom?"

"Tell them, Scott," Bridgette said.

"I saw Gwen walk into the woods with Chef and she was caught."

"Crap!" Trent yelled.

"I asked if she could hold it," Eva sighed.

"Wait… you guys…" Sammy began, as she looked around herself.

"What's wrong?" Jasmine asked.

Sammy gulped, "Where's Dawn?"

"I'll tell you where Dawn is, Sammy!" Chris exclaimed, walking into the room from his office.

"Chris, what is going on?" Harold asked. "Dawn and Gwen are missing. Which is one from each team! Why were we called back?"

"You see guys, that was the first part of the challenge. This is a two part challenge!"

"Say what now?" Eva asked.

"I said a two part challenge!" Chris exclaimed. "You guys hid, and now you get your chance to seek!"

"Let me guess, we're seeking for Dawn and Gwen?" Harold questioned.

"You're right on the money, Harold!" Chris said. "Dawn and Gwen are both hiding together, and each team must work together to find them. The team that finds them first, saves their teammate. Meaning the other team will have to say goodbye to their teammate."

"You mean Dawn and Gwen are up for elimination?" Sammy asked.

"Yep! And it's up to you to see who is saved and who will be dunked tonight."

Trent Confessional:

"I have to get our team to win! There's no way we're losing Gwen on my watch."

Sammy Confessional:

"I need our team to lose! Because if we win, Dawn is out of the game! And I can't let that happen, I just can't!"

Chris smirked at each team and looked down at his watch. "So with that being said, ready or not… here you guys come!"

Heather Confessional:

"Sammy and Trent are in a tough spot. I know what's at stake for them, and I'm not going to get myself involved."

"Okay team, let's split up and look around. We'll be able to search more areas at a faster speed." Trent stated.

"No! Let's all stay together. Then we'll be able to look more thoroughly," Sammy argued. "Plus, Chris said that we had to stay together to find them."

"Uh, no he didn't," Mike said. "He only said that we had to work together. Which technically splitting up and looking is working together."

"But guys, what about the more thorough search I mentioned?"

"It's a good idea, Sammy, but I think we should just split up," Carrie said.

"Why don't we partner up?" Heather suggested. "Me with Sammy, Trent with Carrie, Lindsay with Eva, and Harold with Mike."

"I'm good with that!" Trent said. "Let's all get to searching."

The Eagles decided to split up into two groups. A group of four which was Devin, Jasmine, Scott, and Sierra. And a group of three which was Blaineley, Jazelle, and Bridgette.

"If I were Chris, where would I hide them?" Devin asked himself.

"Well let's brainstorm four different places and split up. Then we can meet back here." Jasmine said. "Scott, why don't you check by the shore. I'll check inside the Main Lodge's storage rooms. Sierra, you check the confessional, and Devin you can go check the cabins."

"That's good, and then we can meet up right here in the parade field." Scott suggested.

"I think we should head into the woods." Jazelle said. "The woods branch out to the entire island, so we could use it as a trail."

"No, let's split up!" Blaineley retorted. "If I stay here long enough, your heavy perfume will probably suffocate me to death."

Jazelle smirked. "That's the goal."

"You're a joke, Jazelle. So is your boyfriend, and that's why he's out of the game." Blaineley said.

"I know you had something to do with his elimination, Blainieley. I don't know how to prove it, but you're just way too sketchy."

"And you're just way too paranoid. I can't be the reason for all of your problems… definitely since you're so problematic yourself."

"I am not problematic, that's all you," Jazelle yelled.

Blaineley smirked. "Don't lose your temper now, I'm just trying to have a simple chat."

"Enough!" Bridgette yelled. "Jazelle and Blaineley, you are ordered by me to stay six feet away from each other at all times. Dawn is at risk of elimination and although Blaineley I know you have a cactus where your heart should be, I know that you don't mind Dawn. Therefore, I need you both to zip it and listen to me so we can save her! We're going to stay together as a group and hit up different locations. First, let's head to the elimination area and look there."

Jazelle Confessional:

"Bridgette was right! Blaineley and I fight way too much when it's not worth it. I can't let her get under my skin anymore!"

Trent and Carrie began walking to the shower house. They figured that Gwen and Dawn were probably at the furthest place from the Main Lodge.

"So, I know that Gwen means a lot to you, but I hope you're still okay with Sammy after this." Carrie said.

"What do you mean?" Trent asked.

"Well it seems like it's been a competition between you two." Carrie said.

"There's no competition." Trent laughed. "What would make you think there is one?"

"When I say a competition, I only mean for today. If we win this challenge, Gwen stays in the game."

"Right, that's a great thing." Trent responded. "Sammy should be on board as long as she's a team player."

"But Dawn is also at stake if we win. Sammy might try to lose to save Dawn and you are trying to win to save Gwen." Carrie said. "I hope you understand where she's coming from."

"There won't be any hurt feelings between us, I promise." Trent told Carrie.

"So where are we going to find Guntha and Dalilah?" Lindsay asked, looking over to Eva.

"I'm not sure, Lindsay. But their names are Gwen and Dawn." Eva said.

"Oh sorry, it's my memory. It's not what it once was." Lindsay laughed.

"Ah, I see. But I thought you regained your memory already." Eva responded.

"I know what you're trying to do Eva." Lindsay replied. "You're trying to get me to admit that I never lost my memory. Well guess what, I did lose it and then I got it back. And since I got it back, I remember how bad I was at remembering names. So either you can continue to accuse me of something that totally could never have possibly happened, or we can work together and win the challenge. Checkmate, Ava."

"Well sadly for you, you're not going to win this game. Because I still have a move to make. Because I have video evidence of you admitting your fault. But lucky for you I can't show anybody it without raising questions about a bigger plan. So tread lightly, Lindsay."

"What proof do you have? Huh?" Lindsay asked.

"You figure it out." Eva said, walking away, leaving Lindsay behind.

Mike couldn't change his personality to Manitoba due to him not having a hat with him. But he could use his old skills.

"What should we do first?" Harold asked.

"Let's look and see what our teammates are up to! We should keep track of each other somehow." Mike said.

"Oh, I'll call them in our group chat." Harold said.

"No need." Mike said. "Allow me to show you how it's done." He leaped onto a tree and began to climb up. They were on the edge of the woods, so he got a good view of both the woods and the different areas on the island.

"Do you have a good view up there?" Harold asked, calling up the tree.

"Yup, I see all of the team." Mike said, jumping back down. "Carrie and Trent are walking through the forest. Lindsay and Eva parted ways from each other. With Eva heading to the cabins and Lindsay to the lodge. Heather and Sammy are walking towards the trailers, and then there's us."

"So Sammy," Heather began. "I know you're in a tough spot right now."

"What makes you think that?" Sammy asked.

"You're kidding right?" Heather laughed. "The others may not have figured this out, but if we win then Dawn gets eliminated and we save Gwen. But if we lose, they get to save Dawn and Gwen gets eliminated."

"I'm willing to bet they've figured that out by now," Sammy said.

"What I was saying is, they may not have figured out the hard choice that you have to make," Heather said. "But I'm willing to help you out."

"How so?" Sammy asked.

"I have a plan," Heather smirked. "But first, we need to find them."

Devin and Jasmine were walking around in the PGA hideout. After searching once by themselves and all four of them coming up with nothing, Sierra and Scott went together to check the trailers on the island and Jasmine and Devin went together to check the hideout.

Jasmine looked around the hideout and sighed. "I don't know what makes me sadder, the fact that they're not in here… or the fact that the entire PGA was a huge flop."

Devin Confessional:

"Jasmine is practically starving for an alliance and I can't blame her. With Shawn and Emma out of the picture, she feels alone I'm sure. And that's where Carrie and I could hopefully help out."

"Speaking of the PGA… Jasmine, I was wondering how you'd feel about joining me in an alliance," Devin began. "I know we don't talk much, or really at all. That's why I think we'd be good when working together, because nobody would suspect a thing. Even though the PGA died hard, why not revamp it with just me, you, and Carrie?"

"That doesn't seem like too bad of an idea to me. And true, the alliance did kinda crumble for some reason. But I already told Carrie that it was the end of the PGA. We ended it a few nights ago."

"Then let's bring it back. We can even rename it if we have to. Perhaps the CJD alliance?"

Jasmine chuckled. "That's kind of hard on the tongue. I'm willing to talk to Carrie about continuing it though."

"Sounds great!" Devin exclaimed.

Dawn woke up in darkness, not being able to see a single thing around her. She felt the warmth of another aura next to her. It was Gwen. She looked around herself, letting her eyes adjust. Her eyes made out a small tinted window. She looked out of it, seeing Sammy and Heather approaching.

"Once we find Dawn and Gwen, we'll then go and find someone from Dawn's team," Heather explained. "From there, we'll give a subtle hint to where they are. Without actually addressing them."

"That should be enough to get the other team to check where they are and find Dawn." Sammy concluded.

They then heard a faint tapping sound, coming from one of the work trucks near the cast trailers. These trucks were being used for materials for Chris' mansion.

Heather and Sammy could see Dawn hand tapping on the glass. Dawn gave them a thumbs up through the window.

Sammy nodded and blew her a kiss.

Dawn Confessional:

"I knew what Sammy and Heather's plan was and I figured my best way to help them is by causing a ruckus. And the best way to do that is to use Gwen's fear."

Dawn shook Gwen awake. "Gwen, Gwen wake up. We're trapped!"

Gwen's eyes shot open, with her sitting up instantly. "WHAT? What do you mean trapped?"

Dawn began to feel around the walls. "It's a nine foot wide box at best… and metal."

Gwen's eyes adjusted somewhat and she tried to stand up, hitting her head on the roof. "OH NO! THE WALLS THEY'RE STARTING TO CAVE IN!"

"There's a back door to the truck…" Dawn began. "But it's locked."

Gwen dropped to her knees and hurried to the door, trying to push it open. "I CAN'T GET OUT! LET US OUT!" She pounded on the door, and began hyperventilating.

Sierra and Scott were walking through towards the trailers, with Sierra telling Scott about her favorite relationship moments between her and Cody.

"Then there's this one time Cody took me to the movies! Well… he didn't actually take me. I hid in the back of his car and followed him inside. Then I bought a ticket for the same movie he went to see and sat next to him in the theater," Sierra said.

"Wow, because that's not stalker behavior at all," Scott replied.

"It was worth it though. He ended up driving me home since he was my ride in the first place," Sierra added. "Did I mention that he and I were dating?"

"Yes Sierra! For only like the 24th time," Scott quipped.

Sierra chuckled, "Well, it's true haha."

They slowly approached Heather and Sammy.

Sammy looked over to Heather, with a slight not downwards nod as they passed by Sierra and Scott.

"Yeah Sammy, there's no point in checking that storage truck," Heather said. "Why waste our time on something that's locked with tinted windows. It's probably a trap."

As planned, Sierra and Scott overheard her, glancing at each other and then towards the cast trailers in the distance.

Heather Confessional:

"I know what I said, but helping out Sammy seemed to be the best idea overall. Trent and Gwen are a couple that have finally rode out the test of time. Sammy and Dawn are new and fresh, so it means more to me that they'd be able to get more time together."

While getting closer, they began to hear the screams of Gwen coming from one of the supply trucks. They ran over to the truck, with the pounding and screaming continuing.

"Gwen! Dawn!" Sierra called. "Are you guys in there?"

"OF COURSE WE'RE IN HERE!" Gwen yelled. "GET US OUT PLEASE!"

Scott looked at the padlock, realizing it needed a key and that they didn't have one.

"Sierra, open the truck door and look for a hammer," Scott ordered.

"HURRY!" Gwen bellowed.

"We're trying!" Scott replied. "Dawn, calm her down please."

"I have a hammer!" Sierra called, running from around the truck and handing it to Scott.

"Perfect, thank you Stalker- I mean Sierra," Scott said, taking the hammer from her. "Back up, Gwen! I'm breaking the lock!" He smashed the padlock with the hammer, and quickly opened up the door.

Gwen leaped out, with Dawn crawling over and carefully sliding out.

They both hugged and thanked Sierra and Scott, with Gwen regaining her breath.

"And with that…" Chris began from the loud speakers. "The Exaggerated Eagles have rescued Dawn and won the challenge."

"Wait… won? What challenge?" Gwen asked. "We lost?"

Chris laughed, "Oh that's right Gwen… you did lose. Not only your mind and not only the challenge… but the game as well. Everyone back to the Lodge! Pronto!"

Gwen looked around in disbelief, then directly inside the supply truck, "I-I lost?"