The day after Valentine's Day, it was the day of the big party at Fairway University. It was going to be an "Enchantment Under The Sea" party to celebrate Shane's Grammy nominations, and also Luke's.

Luke sighed as Lucy pats his back.

"Are you okay?" Luan asked Luke.

"Yeah." Luke says.

Lucy came to help Tabby set up the party for the boys. She was amazed by the undersea- themed decorations.

"Hey, Luce." Tabby says, blushing. "Thanks for coming."

She kissed Lucy's cheek as Lucy blushed a little.

"Tabby, look, what we did was a one time thing." Lucy says.

Tabby looked down.

"Maybe I can help you find a boy or girl." Lucy says as she used magic to set everything up.

With Luke, he was all packed for Los Angeles. He was now getting ready for the party later.

He sees his party outfit. "If they ruin my night, I'll never forgive them!" Luke hisses.

"This isn't just your night, Luke." Shane reminded him as he brushed his curls. "It's my night, too."

Luke sighed and nodded, not used to sharing his night. But if he wanted to be a changed person, he had to do things he wasn't used to doing.

Soon, the party was beginning as Shane just wanted a small party, so he could save the big one for the Grammys victories that he would get.

But he was half-asleep when Tabby asked him questions about the party a week prior, due to him pulling an all-nighter as he studied for an English test. So he was shocked when he saw the "Enchantment Under The Sea" theme everywhere.

"This is big…" Shane says.

"Just the way I like it. Good job, Lucy." Luke says as Shane walks out.

"Hey!" Tabby says. "We need to get your entrances ready. Shane, you're getting the best entrance!" She says, holding his hand.

Shane looked at her, unconvinced.

She shows him the bigger parade float. "Look, I worked hard on this. If you two can't share, then that's your problem." Tabby says

"Sorry, I didn't realize how hard party planning was." Shane says and sees a statue of him on the float.

He realized that even if it was his night, he couldn't just disrespect what Lucy and her friend did for him. He got on his float and smiled as he was ready.

Luke decided to appreciate what Lucy did for him.

"Ladies and gentlemen!" Tabby says.

"Tonight is a night for two special boys. Between the two of them, they're nominated for 15 Grammys! It gives me great pleasure to introduce the boys of the evening, Shane Loud and Luke Huntington!" Lucy says as everyone cheered as they came out on their floats.

Shane's was a bit better as he smiled and waved to the guests.

Lucy plays her piano song "Aren't They Amazing?" for their entrance.

As the party began, Shane just looked around. Luke was enjoying himself.

Penny came out and started singing a song for Shane specifically as fans cheered. Shane smiled at her. There was a lot of people now they clapped for Penny when she finished

"Wow, Shane, she's really like you. Also, she's my rival" Lisa says.

Shane sighed. "I know!" He says.

Later, Charity gives Shane a gift. He took it, but refused to look at it.

"What's wrong?" She asked.

"Nothing. Nothing is wrong." Shane says, still trying to grin and bear it.

"Is the party too big? I tried to make it the right balance for both of you…I'm sorry if I screwed up." Lucy says.

"This is too much!" Shane says.

"I'm sorry. It was hard. You like small and simple parties and Luke likes big parties. I'm really sorry. Next time, I'll just let Mom do it." Lucy says.

"Shane, sweetie, are you okay?" Sharon asked him after taking him outside for a bit.

Shane began talking to Sharon, feeling a bit overwhelmed.

Sharon comforts him. "I'll get Charity to tone it down for you. But do you want to stay for a bit longer, just long enough to see the treat your siblings made for you?" She asked.

He nods and goes back with Sharon. He then sees the treat that Shiloh and Shelby made with Charity's help.

"Oh, my gosh! It's a fruit tart made to look like me!" Shane says. "My hair is made of blackberries, my favorite berry!"

"Um, Shane, would you like to, um, sing with me?" Penny asked. Shane was eating his tart as she asked this, savoring the blackberry "hair" as he smiled at her and nodded.

They soon got on stage and sang a duet, singing their own rendition of the song "Remind Me" by Brad Paisley & Carrie Underwood. Fans were recording this as this was trending.

After that, Shane loosened up a little, dancing with everyone and smiling.

Luan really wanted her boys. Oliver and Benny are dancing with Shane as she watches them.

She was blushing as her body was hot.

"Do the song! Perform it!" Luna says to the band. They began playing "Johnny B. Goode" with Oliver taking the stage and singing lead.

Shane smiled and continued to dance as they thought of making his own band in the future. Luke had too many people and he didn't want to upstage Luke.

Luan blushed watching Oliver. She went to the bathroom. "I need him and Benny…" She moaned.

"Hey, Penny, wanna start a band?" Shane asked.

"Sure!" Penny says. "But after the Grammys. You still have to accept your solo awards if you do win them, you know."

"Right, of course." Shane says, smiling as he twirled Penny.

Later, it was piñata time. Shane insisted that Luke hit it as he just walked off. Penny looked confused and concerned. She saw Shane on the Fairway roof.

"Shane?" Penny asked. "What are you doing up here?"

"It's more about Luke. I thought he had changed for the better. I guess I was wrong." Shane says.

"I know how you feel. My boss took our paychecks once." Penny says. "I thought he'd change."

She hugged him as he looked down at the party through the skylight.

"Look, when you win your awards, we will celebrate just you." Penny says reassuringly to Shane.

Shane watched through the skylight and sniffed. "Look down there and tell me, Penny. What do you see?" He says. "And be honest…"

"He hasn't changed. He lied to you about accepting the fact that he wanted to share the party with you." Penny sighed.

Shane felt a lump in his throat that was hard to swallow as he teared up. He then cried as he struggled to swallow it. She hugged him and ended up taking him back down. But they kept their distance.

Later, she decided to give Luke a taste of his own medicine. She did some finger language as Kat and Ana squealed. Penny basically told them it was cake time. He and Shane had their own cakes. Luke screamed seeing Kat and Ana eating his cake, but leaving Shane's alone as he shot ice at them, but they leap away. Their butts were on fire.

Everyone screamed as Penny gasped. "Luke, stop!" Penny says. Luke slapped her aside as she was knocked out

Emila had a spell to calm him down. Shane left the party and went home to finish packing. He knew this night couldn't be about him anymore.

Charity froze Luke using her magic. She was livid and so was Sharon.

"Shelby, we need to go!" Ana says.

"Right! Come on, we have consoling to do!" Shelby says.

"Ana..." Kat says, looking at Penny. She was really knocked out.

"Dr. Crygor is really going to be upset. He might kill Luke." Ana says.

Later, Shelby, Kat, and Ana comfort Shane, who sobbed. Every time he tried to celebrate ever since he met Luke, Luke would sabotage it.

"Every time! I wish we never moved…" he sobbed, wanting to go back home to Petoskey Falls.

The cousins and siblings gasped. Luke had done it again. And this time, a lot of them were done defending Luke.

"I don't think we're going to be together much longer." Leni sniffed. Luna had finally snapped mentally and knew Luke was wanting Shane gone. Well, the joke was about to be on him.

"Ah!" Penny sobbed, waking up. She was holding her jaw. There was blood and bruises on her face.

"Quick, Mushroom!" Kat says.

"Um…" Ana stammered. "I forgot to get it."

Penny rushed past them, leaving the house.

"He's crazy! Ow, my jaw!" Penny says. He slapped her just for a cake.

Luke came back to the manor to face some angry faces.

"I'm done with you. I only have 2 brothers." Lucy says.

"You treat your parties better than you treat others." Leni says.

"You couldn't share. For one night, you couldn't stop being greedy." Luna says.

"You don't deserve a birthweek after what you did to Shane." Lola says.

"And now he wants to move back to Petoskey Falls!" Luna cried.

"Maybe it's better for them to move. There, they won't have to worry about you hurting them " Lola says as Shiloh sniffed.

"Oh, I have a better solution. Garrett, how would you like to take Luke's place in the quarterfinals?" Luan asked.

"Heck no, Penny deserves it more!" Kat says.

"Yeah!" Ana says.

"You can't do this to me!" Luke says.

"And what's wrong with me?" Garrett asked.

"No offense, but Penny and Shane are nominated for a best duo performance. They work well together." Lisa says

"That was just tonight." Luna says.

"Yes, I must admit I was stunned to see Penny rise up the ranks that fast. She's already good on her own, but with Shane, they work in harmony." Lisa says as Luke tossed ice, freezing his siblings

He flew off, turning into the Dark Blizzard Prince. But before he could do anything, Charity angrily froze him instead. The siblings were freezing as Lana sneezed.

Charity dragged the frozen Luke inside and screamed at him while he was frozen. Lola sighed, thawing him, knowing it was a waste of time to yell at a block of ice.

"How could you force Lucy and Tabby to do this?!" Charity asked.

"It was their fault!" Luke says. "They set up the party!"

"We were trying to find a right balance for the both of you. Really!" Lucy says.

"She's lying, she just wants me to herself!" Luke says.

"That's not true! I've been busy with the mortician club, organizing pop-pop's funeral" Lucy says, before covering her mouth.

Charity stared silently at Luke before speaking again.

"How could you? You know the only reason you're even getting famous again is because Lucy found you. She did everything for you and you're throwing her under the bus?!" Charity screamed before Luke could try to get out of it.

Lucy sniffed. "Did I make a mistake?" She asked before teleporting to be alone.

"And you broke her heart. You were the one person keeping her from committing suicide and you broke her heart." Lynn says. She rushed to find Lucy before Lucy ended her life.

"Couldn't share the spotlight for one night. Couldn't think of anyone other than yourself." Luna said coldly to Luke. "To think, I was gonna sing for your half-birthday. But I guess I'll be singing for Shane instead."

Suddenly, Crygor came in with a blaster. "You!" He says, pointing at Luke.

"Holy moly!" Luan shrieked.

"Can we not use violence? It's not healthy!" Leni says.

"He hurt my granddaughter! I found her by the streetlights." he says.

Penny walked in. "Grandpa, please, no…" She says, teary-eyed.

"All right." Crygor says as he notices Penny clutching her jaw.

"Where's Shane?" Penny asked. Leni led her to him. Penny holds him, and Shane knew he had to stay here for her if he was staying for anyone.