Carl will appear as he does in Chandler Riggs's portrayal of him in season 8 of The Walking Dead and Ellie will take after her appearance in The Last Of Us Part II during the Seattle chapters.
XXXXXX
(A young adult female with short, brown hair and jean jacket with an overall dirty appearance takes her bow and arrow and aims at the camera.)
Ellie Williams: The sole immune human to Cordyceps Brain Infection who may very well be the cure for mankind.
(Ellie is seen laying in tall grass in a Seattle neighborhood. Stringing an arrow onto her bow she takes aim at a WLF soldier and shoots an arrow into her face.)
vs.
(A slightly younger boy wearing a brown sheriff's hat aims his Colt M1911 at the camera and fires.)
Carl Grimes: The rowdy but hardened teenager who without any remorse kills all walkers and humans who threaten his loved ones.
(Carl is seen alongside his father in a shootout with some Saviors. He takes one of the extortionists down with a shot from his Colt.)
WHO IS DEADLIEST?!
To find out, we've assembled a team of world class fighters to test history's most lethal weapons. Using 21st century science, we'll see what happens when two warriors go toe to toe.
No rules. No safety. No mercy. It's a duel to the death to decide who is...THE DEADLIEST WARRIOR!
Here in our elite fight club we have gathered doctors, medical scientists and weapons experts to test out the lethal arsenals wielded by each of our combatants to determine who would win a fight between two hardened teenage survivors from their respective and unforgiving worlds.
Ellie Williams
Appearing from: The Last of Us Part ll
Age: 19
Height: 5'5''
Weight: 113 lbs.
Enemies: Washington Liberation Front, Seraphites, Rattlers, Infected
Carl Grimes
Appearing from: The Walking Dead TV Series (Season 8)
Age: 14
Height: 5'7''
Weight: 125 lbs.
Enemies: Saviors, Walkers
''Welcome back to another installment of our fictional DW folks!'' DeadAliveManiac exclaimed excitedly, ''We're coming back with a battle between two young survivors of the apocalypse with Ellie from The Last Of Us Part ll and Carl Grimes as he appears in season 8 of The Walking Dead tv show.''
''It's gonna be a great match as these are two youngsters who basically spent their childhood fighting off hordes of infected and walkers. In Carl's case he lived a part of his childhood as a regular kid before the walkers starting walking and for Ellie, the poor girl was born into a world of hell and that what makes them different, yet the same.'' Zivon96 explained.
''Yeah you got that right. Not only are these two fending off the infected they also have to fight off scores of hostile human survivors and that alone makes them very vicious and deadly in combat, infected or humans alike are just game to these two.'' MKDemiGodzilla-Warrior seconded.
''These were have no problem surviving in their respective worlds, they are vicious, they are hard, and they are tough. Can Ellie redeem her game's previous loss in Saviors vs. Fireflies? Or will Carl put her down like he's done many walkers? Let's do this!" Rice Man concluded.
Ellie was born sometime between 2018 and 2019, by which time fungal pandemic had spread throughout America. As a result, she grew up in an oppressive military Quarantine Zone in Boston, Massachusetts, with little knowledge of the world before infection. Sometime in 2033 she comes into contact with Joel and despite their rough relationship at first, Ellie and Joel would come to form a bond that very few would understand. However, when a group known as the Washington Liberation Front intercepted and murdered Joel this would set a heartbroken Ellie on a path of revenge.
''She grew up in such a harsh world she had very little experience battling the infected. When she comes across Joel she gained someone she could truly love as a family member and with his death at the hands of the Washington Liberation Front Ellie became a vicious killer and all WLF who crossed her were doomed. Carl has a handful this time and this isn't walkers or Saviors coming at him.'' Rice Man explained.
To aid her in her quest for revenge, Ellie brought with her a deadly arsenal of improvised and high powered weapons that put down anyone who crossed her, be it infected or human.
Short Range: Switchblade
Mid-Range: Beretta 92F
Long Range: Remington 700
Special: Bow & Arrow
However, how will she compare to another young survivor who had to adapt and grow in a world overrun by the walking dead?
Carl Grimes is the former deuteragonist and a survivor of the outbreak in AMC's The Walking Dead. He is the son of Rick and Lori Grimes and the half-brother of Judith Grimes and R.J. Grimes. During the initial outbreak, Carl believed his father to be dead, so he and his mother joined Shane Walsh to travel to Atlanta to the refugee camp. Following the end of season 6 they came across a group known as the Saviors who made Carl and his fellow survivors submit to their rule and during the war against them he would make the sacrifice that aided the militia in defeating Negan and his Saviors.
''While he ended being bitten and committing suicide shortly after he left a huge impression even on someone like Negan and his legacy continues to live on with his half sister Judith. I wonder how Ellie will handle a kid as tough as Carl?'' Rice Man explained.
To take down all Saviors and walkers who dare to harm his family and friends, Carl brought with him an arsenal that enabled his survival.
Short Range: Gerber Epic
Mid-Range: Colt M1911A1
Long Range: Marlin Model 1893
Special: Colt Python
When these two teen terrors came face to face with infected and hostile humans they used two simple blades to get the job done. Up first will be Ellie with her switchblade.
''The switchblade Ellie would use was a basic tool, it had a blade that was made of stainless steel and measured 4 inches in length and in all weighed just under a pound. It was the perfect weapon for Ellie when she wanted to dispose of infected or hostile survivors with stealth and precision.'' Ellie's close companion and father figure Joel Miller explained.
To test out the killing potential of the switchblade, Joel will attack several stand ins resembling Runners, the first stage of CBI infected and one hostile human survivor.
''Alright Joel, we're gonna time you to see how fast you can take out those targets, the Runners will be charging right at you via zipline and the human survivor you'll sneak up on to take them out. Ready to go to work?'' DAM asked.
''You got it.'' Joel said as he got into position.
''Okay Joel your first 3 targets are coming up, 3...2...1...release!''
Demigod releases the first zipline target and it goes zooming toward Joel who eagerly awaits the runner. When the infected stand in comes within range Joel delivers a hard punch to the face of the runner stopping it dead in its tracks and he goes to stab it several times in the face before slicing the throat open. With that done Joel sees the second runner coming right at him and this time around he grabs the target and rips it from the line and slams it into the ground and stabs it right through the head. Demigod then releases the final target and Joel stands his ground as it comes to him and proceeds to grab it and quickly wraps an arm around the neck and stabs it in the throat several times. With the runner targets dealt with Joel then sets his sights on the human target and slowly creeps toward it and grabs it by the head and stabs it just once in the side of the head with a crunch.
Zivon then walks over to assess the damage.
So after inspecting all the targets for the runners I'm seeing stab wounds in areas such as the neck, head and eyes. That knife is big enough to where if you struck the head or severed major arteries you'll be causing death and that's what I see with all the runners and the human target. For the human target you targeted his jugular vein and stabbing into it and pulling out you've caused a really quick bleedout and then death.'' explained the doc.
''So Rick what do you think?'' DAM asked.
Carl's father Rick Grimes walks up to Joel's display and shrugged.
''I admire the handiwork here Joel but in our show we would usually take care of walkers and saviors in stealth but sometimes we'd prefer to take both head on.''
Carl responds to Ellie's brutal stealth attacks with a simple deadly knife of his own.
''The knife my son used before he left the series was the Gerber Epic which had a stainless steel blade that measured just about 3 inches. It was a modified sheepsfoot, partially serrated blade that weighed under a pound.'' explained the Sheriff.
''It's definitely thicker than Ellie's knife but let's see if that makes a difference so we're gonna have you do the same test Rick only this time you're facing a Negan stand in wearing his signature jacket.'' DAM said with a smirk.
Rick only chuckled in amusement before nodding at DAM and gets into position.
''Alright Rick, on 3...2...1...kill that sick baseball bat loving weirdo!"
Rick lunged at the Negan torso and viciously stabbed the target multiple times in the stomach.
'' DAMN YOU SCOTT GIMPLE!'' Rick yelled as he stabbed into the torso.
The panel stared at Rick and they each chuckled lightly at how the Sheriff was feeling about the final episode of season 8 of The Walking Dead.
''UNLIKE THE COMICS I SHOULD'VE KILLED NEGAN.'' Rick said before slicing the throat open and tosses the knife aside and walks toward the panel.
Zivon then walks over to evaluate the damage.
''You turned his insides into mush...you pretty much disemboweled Negan here and good lord you really laid it in on this guy. You stabbed the heart a few times as well as the lungs and all those combined would be a kill and just like the finale of season 8 you sliced his throat open leaving him to bleed out and if he doesn't get treatment like he did when you told Siddiq he would die very quickly. So this is a guaranteed kill on all fronts if medical attention is factored out.''
''Damn you got so riled up stabbing just one guy by the time you killed him you would be lunch for the infected or killed by his buddies.'' Joel commented.
''I made this man a promise that I would kill him at the end of season 8 but Scott Gimple's writing says otherwise.'' Rick said.
After testing out the two knives of these teen survivors which one does the panel believe takes the edge?
''I think I'll call it even here since both knives aren't two different from each other in size.'' DAM started off.
''I'm agreeing with you there since both are capable of frontal or stealth attacks and they could switch knives and do the same work.'' Zivon seconded.
''The damage was similar across the board, no edge in my opinion.'' Demigod added.
''Ellie and Carl could also switch their usual tactics and do the same work so whoever stabs the other first gets the kill.'' Rice Man concluded.
In short range weapons, the edge is even.
When knives weren't an option and these two teens required a simple fire arm to take down all threats they brought with them two of the best pistols available to them. For Ellie she carried the Beretta 92F and Carl brings in the trusted Colt M1911A1.
Since we've seen these two pistols before in previous episodes the team reviews footage of them in action and an edge was decided rather quickly.
''The Beretta wins automatically because one, it is the more modern weapon and two it has more rounds.'' DAM explained with the other three nodding agreement.
For mid-range weapons, the edge goes to Ellie for her Beretta 92F.
Coming up, two deadly long range firearms are brought for carnage and then later two teen terrors duke it out!
XXXXXX
Ellie Williams, the vicious survivor hell bent on revenge. Carl Grimes, the young and rowdy teen who fought to protect his loved ones. If these two teen survivors clashed who will remain standing?
When long range combat was needed our two teen survivors brought with them two legendary rifles that allowed them to pick off infected or hostile humans with ease. Up first will be Carl Grimes with the lever-action Marlin Model 1893.
The Marlin Model 1893 is a lever action rifle that was produced by Marlin Firearms. It differed from the Winchester in that it was side-ejecting, the main selling point originally being it was better protected from weather and debris than the competing top-ejecting Winchester. Marlin would later convert the 1893 from square bolt to round bolt with side ejection port as the Model 336. It fired the .38 Smith & Wesson special and weighed 7 lbs.'' Rick explained holding the weapon for all to see.
To test out how Rick will perform with the weapon, the team has set up a scenario where he will engage a small horde of walker attack bots will make their way toward the expert in a last stand scenario.
''Okay Rick, let's see how well you perform backed up against a wall with walkers coming at you so let's see if you can take out the group before they can reach you.'' DAM said.
''You got it.'' Rick said taking a position against the mock wall.
''Release the attack bots!''
Demigod gets the attack bots running and with Rice Man using his speaker he plays an audio recording of walker growls and snarls to try and mess with Rick's focus but that did little to deter the Sheriff as he begins to pick off walkers with shots to the head. The accuracy and calmness he was demonstrating was no shock to the panel as they've seen how he was on the show. The first row of the horde gets taken down but as soon as Rick takes aim at the second row he goes to reload his weapon and this caught the eye of the panel.
''That reload though..'' Demigod commented.
''In a real life situation, he's walker chow.'' Rice Man added.
Rick just barely finishes the reload and continues to take aim at the horde and takes down several before his weapon simply clicks.
''Dammit CORAL!'' Rick exclaimed as he goes to clear the jam.
''Oh boy.'' Demigod said.
Rick was able to clear the jam quickly though and he continues to fire and take out walkers in the second row before the remaining finally reach him.
The team then walks over to give an accurate count of how many walkers Rick had taken down before being devoured.
''Okay so out of the horde of 30 walkers you are left with 7 eating your face, that means you have kill rate of 76% and that isn't bad at all considering you're using an older weapon to kill walkers.'' DAM commented.
''From what I see as well aside from the headshots you were able to put a tight grouping on some of these walkers meaning this is a very accurate weapon, if these were people take away the headshots the body shots from where you placed them would kill them.'' Zivon explained.
''The problem is that during the test he encountered a jam and in our game the infected are really quick so that would've costed you.'' Joel commented with a slight shake of the head.
''So I take it your girl can do better?'' Rick quipped.
''I do think so.''
Ellie fires back with a powerful bolt-action rifle, the Remington 700.
''The Remington 700 is a series of bolt-action centerfire rifles manufactured by Remington Arms since 1962. It is a development of the Remington 721 and 722 series of rifles, which were introduced in 1948. The M24 and M40 military sniper rifles, used by the US Army and USMC, respectively, are both based on the Model 700 design. In our game when you acquire it it fires only one round but with upgrades you can have at least 3 in the weapon, fires the .30-06 round and weighs 8 pounds.'' Joel explained.
''If you are going to try to do any better than Rick let's test it out in an ambush scenario which was something Ellie frequently did against the WLF after they killed you. You'll have four targets searching for you in this mock tall grass and we want you to use hit and run tactics to take them all down and you will be timed is that understood?'' DAM explained.
''It won't be a problem with me.'' replied Joel.
Joel takes his position in the grass and waits for DAM's signal.
''Begin!''
Joel creeps through the grass and once he gets the first wolf in sight he quickly pops out from the grass and fires off one round hitting it square in the jaw blowing it off. As he ducks down into the grass he makes his way to another spot as he visualizes the targets as actual wolves looking in the direction where he shot at and once he chambers another round and once he found a spot he was comfortable in he gets up again and fires another round right into the back of another target. Continuing on to the third and fourth targets he repeats his actions and puts the last two down with shots to the face and chest, the torso that was shot in the face had a massive exit wound on the other side like a volcano's crater.
''Time! 57 seconds to pull this off nice work.'' DAM said.
Zivon then walks over to see if Joel was accurate enough to kill his targets in one shot.
''The ones that have a head shot are self-explanatory, the first target you put a bullet in the jaw blowing it clean off and that would definitely kill him, if not instantly the shock alone would, the second target you shot it straight through the back and from what I'm seeing there is an exit wound and the position of it means you struck the aorta for a rapid bleed out, hit that sucker you're done for no matter what. The third target you shot him straight through the chest again and this time you're hitting the heart for another instant kill and lastly the shot to the face blows a gaping hole out the back of the skull for another instant kill. Nice work.'' concluded Zivon.
''I saw that you were able to go through it a lot smoother than Rick was with his horde test and that is a good thing.'' Demigod added.
''My only complaint is that he has only one shot per reload, if he misses an infected or person could move in and take him out.'' Rick interjected.
''I would agree, but if you're really good that wouldn't be a problem.'' Joel replied.
After testing out both rifles which one do our panelists believe take the edge?
''I'm siding with the Marlin, simply put it has a lot more rounds going for it and a single shot weapon like the Remington for me is a no go against the undead or CBI infected.'' DAM started off.
''I find myself disagreeing and I'll go with the Remington, sure in the game you usually only have one round at a time in the chamber but from what I've seen it seems to place more accurate hits on target and functions much more smoother.'' Zivon countered.
''For me it is in the technology, bolt-action weapons proved more smoother and faster than lever-action and the jamming of the Marlin did it for me, edge Remington.'' Demigod seconded.
''I agree with you two as well and the fact that Ellie can add a scope to her weapon gives her an enormous advantage at even longer ranges making it more lethal. Edge Remington 700.'' Rice Man concluded.
In long range weapons, the edge goes to Ellie for her Remington 700.
Coming up, these two teen terrors bring out their special weapons and then later, our battle for the title of deadliest warrior begins!
XXXXXX
Now the time for our survivors to reveal their special weapons comes, up first will be Ellie with her simple bow and arrows.
''The bow was an essential weapon to have if you were going to use stealth tactics and the one Ellie used in the sequel was of a recurve design. In the hands of a skilled archer you could hit targets very accurate up to a football field away and Ellie isn't some rookie, she has no problem taking down runners if they're running at her and even Seraphites that tower over her. All in all the arrows were crafted from regular blades she would find as well as some bindings and she could also craft explosive arrows if she wanted to.'' Joel said.
''We are always interested to see how skilled warriors are with their bows. Today we'll have you test it out against this stand in clicker here and you will have 5 arrows to take it down.'' DAM explained.
Joel nodded and picked up his first arrow and takes aim at the stand in clicker's head and releases the arrow. The projectile flies straight toward the target but as soon as it struck the material that represented the fungus like growth an average clicker's face would have it snapped in two and fell to the ground useless.
''Oof, tough luck.'' Rick commented.
Undeterred, Joel takes another arrow and aims it at the clicker's throat and fires, this time the arrow strikes bare flesh and becomes lodged in the throat. He strings another arrow and fires again only this time he aims at the chest and thankfully it stays in the body. Taking his fourth arrow he aims at where the heart would be and fires hitting his intended target before taking his final arrow and repeating what he did with the fourth shot.
Zivon then walks over to assess the damage and pulls each arrow out of the clicker and even picks up the broken one.
''I'll just skip the first shot since it is quite obvious but the second one struck the target on the throat so if this was an actual person it would kill them but I haven't a clue if an infected goes down to a throat shot. For the third one you struck it in the left lung and once again, I don't know if a clicker goes down to a lung shot but if it was a person he's got a collapsed lung which is not good. It leaves him exposed for your other arrows and the other ones both struck him in the heart and aorta respectively. If it was a person they're dead, clicker I am not so sure.''
''So Rick whattya think?'' Demigod asked.
''I'm just wondering if this is compared to what I'm bringing in, what I have will literally blow a hole in your clicker's skull.''
To respond to the bows stealthy approach, Carl fires back with the Colt Python revolver.
The Colt Python is a double action handgun chambered for the .357 Magnum cartridge, built on Colt's large I-frame. Pythons have a reputation for accuracy, smooth trigger pull, and a tight cylinder lock-up. They have a 6-round cylinder and weighed 38 ounces.'' Rick explained.
''It's time to put this weapon to the test by having you take down a walker and a clicker at the same time so let's see if you can pull it off.'' DAM said pointing at the target.
Rick nodded and got into position waiting for DAM's signal.
''Okay Rick on 3...2...1...shoot em up!''
Rick draws his Colt from its holster and aims at the walker and fires one shot right into the chest of the walker target before delivering the killshot with one in the head and wasted no time on aiming his weapon at the clicker who began to move in his direction. Rick opened fire on the clicker and struck the fungus covered head breaking away some of the synthetic material to simulate the actual armor of the clicker and fires again, this time the round blows a hole in the exposed face of the clicker and Rick finishes it off with one two more rounds to the face putting it down for good.
''Time! 7 seconds, that's damn fast.''
Zivon then made his way over and started his assessment by checking the walker target.
''First and foremost the round to the chest obviously isn't killing the walker but for a human it is a mortal wound since you've just missed vital organs, the head shot is an obvious assessment is that either human or walker it's dead and out.'' He then made his way over to the clicker target, ''I find myself impressed with the facial armor of the clicker and it did good in blocking the first shot but as soon as you broke away the first layer of the fungus you exposed the face for a kill shot and you turned the brain into mush with all of them. I see 2 quick kills in a shade over 7 seconds.''
''So Joel what do you think?'' DAM asked.
''It kills, but when it comes to my game or your tv show a big bang will just draw in more of them which is why either me or Ellie prefer the bow.'' said the older man.
''But the Colt wouldn't have a problem taking down your type of infected.'' Rick retorted.
After testing out the special weapons of these two survivors which one does the panel believe takes the edge?
''For me I am going with the Colt due to requiring less strength to use and you can bludgeon with it as well.'' DAM started off.
''I agree, despite the noise drawing in more walkers in of course, being a firearm hits with more force and would put you down faster. The bow you would have to compensate more with even longer shots.'' Zivon seconded.
''I am slightly going with the bow, sure it doesn't hit as hard as the Colt but stealth is really important in the apocalypse and the fact that Ellie can craft explosive arrows give it my edge.'' Demigod countered.
''I go with the Python, if confronted with CBI infected like clickers you can shoot the protective layer of fungus to take it down whereas the bow would fail every time unless you go for body shots. Sorry to say since I like Ellie's use of the explosive arrows.'' Rice Man concluded.
In special weapons, the edge goes to Carl Grimes for the Colt Python.
Coming up, Metal Harbinger gauges the x-factors of these two teen survivors to determine who is our deadliest warrior!
XXXXXX
Welcome back to the Fight Club, here we tested out the weapons of two hardened survivors to determine who is deadliest.
For short range weapons, both Ellie's switchblade and Carl's Gerber proved to be equals.
''They could easily switch blades and do the same damage, that's all I have to say.'' DAM explained.
Edge: Even
For short range weapons, the more modern Beretta 92F completely outshot the Colt M1911A1.
''More modern, more rounds, it's an easy edge despite the Colt's stopping power.'' Zivon explained.
Edge: Ellie Williams
For long range weapons, the bolt-action Remington 700 proved more smooth and reliable than the lever-action Marlin Model 1893
''Despite having one round per reload, the Remington is more accurate and not prone to jamming like some lever-action rifles are.'' Demigod explained.
Edge: Ellie Williams
And finally for special weapons the Colt Python's superior stopping power and secondary melee function bested the bow.
''Even though Ellie can make explosive arrows the Colt Python would have an easier time killing either infected or humans and requires less skill.'' Rice Man explained.
Edge: Carl Grimes
And now our computer wizz Metal Harbinger will gauge the x-factors of these two survivors.
''Let's get this show on the road.'' said the metalhead.
''First I decided to put in training and for me, I gave the edge as even. Both youngsters learned how to defend themselves from the infected in their medias by their respective fathers or father figures at around the same age so it isn't too far off. I rated them an 80 each.''
''Killer instinct went to Ellie because while Carl does kill any walker or hostile survivor that tries to mess with him or his family he will not kill every survivor he encounters. Ellie on the other hand will kill literally every single WLF soldier, every Seraphite or Rattler that even enters her general vicinity. Ellie gets a 100 to Carl's 90.''
''For survivor instinct I rated both even because whenever they are out away from their safe havens, they need to be ready for any and every walker, CBI infected or hostile human that crosses their path and what they have to deal with can get them to do crazy things just to stay alive. 95 for each.''
''Next is mental health and I gave the edge to Carl since while he is traumatized by putting down his own mother to prevent her from becoming a walker, Ellie is deeply disturbed and traumatized big time from Joel's death happening right in front of her which can have an effect on her mental state. For Carl he has an 80 while Ellie gets a 65.''
''Last but not least we have brutality and there was no doubt that Ellie was the hands down winner here. If you were a WLF, Seraphite or a Rattler, let alone Abby she would do the most intense and nastiest things to you such as torture you for information like she did with Nora by letting her suffer from inhaling CBI spores instead of downright killing her. She got a 96 to Carl's 75.''
Now that we've gathered the necessary data for our battle and Metal will run the simulator one-thousand times to determine who is our deadliest warrior.
Who will win in a battle between the teen terrors?
''In the end, only one survivor will survive, let's see who it is.'' Metal said hitting the button.
XXXXXX
It was a cloudy day in the city of Seattle and near the Hill Crest neighborhood a young adult girl with brown shoulder length hair wearing a jean jacket was seen walking in the middle of the grass covered street. The young lady was Ellie Williams and she was on a mission to hunt down the killer of Joel, the WLF soldier named Abby and she would not stop in her quest until she killed the burly woman. She continued to walk through the neighborhood until she heard footsteps which prompted her to take cover behind a car.
She takes her pistol out and had no qualms about it being a WLF soldier since she was the only one minus Dina in this entire city who weren't a member of that particular militia. Peaking her head around the rear bumper she saw the unknown person a teenage boy who was slightly younger than her and she saw that he had an eyepatch and was wearing a brown Sheriff's hat and a rifle strapped to his back. No doubt this guy was a wolf so she wasn't going to take any chance.
This was Carl Grimes and he was out on a run after running out of supplies for a camp he and his father had made. He opens a car and rummages through the vehicles and smiles when he saw that there was a small box of ammo for his Colt Python and M1911. Taking the bullets he loads it into the weapons and just as he turns around an arrow struck him in the arm causing him to drop his M1911 in the process.
Crying out in pain Carl quickly breaks the arrow and pulls out both ends before drawing his Python and aims in the direction from where it came. He saw nothing and just heard the wind blowing through the trees and not letting his guard down he tries to reason with his unknown attacker.
''I don't know who you are, but let's talk this out. I'm not looking for problems okay? I'm just trying to get by that's it.'' said the boy.
No response.
Carl continued to walk down the street with his revolver aimed in front of him and just then he heard what sounded like someone stepping on glass. Quickly snapping to face the direction he heard the sound he saw Ellie peaking out of cover from behind a window in a small shop and luckily this time before she could shoot an arrow at him he fires his revolver first.
Ellie was grazed in the upper arm and this threw her aim off and she lets the arrow fly high above Carl's head and the arrow hits a wall and explodes. Carl fires again but Ellie had already ducked behind the counter and dashed off through the back door and not wanting his attacker to get away Carl gives chase.
Ellie continues to run until she reached the entrance to a large park and leaning against brick wall she began to apply a bandage to her wound.
''Fuck that hurt.'' she whispered to herself.
Putting the bow on her back she takes out her Beretta and looks around the corner when she heard Carl approaching the area and as soon as he turned a corner she shot at him with her pistol and Carl's immediate reaction was to step back around the corner from where he came and take cover. Ellie continued to fire off her gun until it clicked empty and hearing his attacker reloading Carl pops out of cover and opens fire with his Python. Ellie was forced into cover by jumping behind a broken down car and drops her magazine in the process so she waited until Carl ran out of rounds.
''It's not too late to turn this around!'' Carl called out, ''I really don't want to fight you.''
''I don't give a fuck! All you wolves are dead!'' Ellie shouted back.
Wolves? What was this girl talking about? It didn't matter at this point for Carl because from what he can hear in her voice he knew she wasn't going to be persuaded by mere words. So he holstered his Colt and drew his Marlin Model 1893 and as he approached Ellie's magazine he kicks it away only for Ellie to pop out from behind the car and charge straight at him.
She tackles the boy and brings him to the ground. Taking her switchblade he goes to bring it down on Carl's only good eye but he manages to catch her hands just before the blade touch his body and the two attempted to wrestle for control. No matter how hard she had tried Carl was not letting up in his resistance and she was so blinded by her rage she failed to notice Carl reaching for his Python.
Carl takes his Python and and swings it as hard as he could hitting Ellie square in the jaw sending the Carl falling on her side and clutching her face in pain.
''Ugh, fuck you!'' Ellie growled.
She heard the sound of a gun being cocked and looking up she saw that Carl was aiming his Marlin at her and noticing a bottle nearby she scoops it up and tosses it at Carl hitting him in the head shattering the container. This was a life saver as Carl flinched from the impact and taking her chance she gets up and runs off into the heavily overgrown area of the park to plan her next move and when Carl recovered from the throw he looks around to see Ellie was no where in sight.
Mentally cursing himself he proceeds into the overgrow with caution as slow as he could. He jumps down into a small creek and just as he does that a shot rang out hitting the Sheriff's hat off of his head. The boy quickly gets on the ground knowing the girl had him in her gun sights. He then hears her loading her Remington and knew right away she had to reload every shot she took so he decided to try and take advantage of that.
Crawling over to pick up his father's hat he raises slightly from his position and just as he hoped Ellie had taken a shot. The hat goes flying from Carl's hands and very quickly he pops out from behind cover and spots Ellie near a tree. He sets his sights on her and fires hitting the girl in the side making her yelp in pain so the girl could do nothing but drop her rifle and sneak herself away to tend her wound. Carl kept firing off his weapon until it clicked empty and tossing it aside he draws his Gerber ready to finish to fight.
He knew he had hit her so he had to tail the wounded girl and end this. When he comes up to the tree he sees that Ellie wasn't there. Turning around he was greeted to a knife coming straight at his face and he manages to move his head to the side to avoid being stabbed and swings his Gerber cutting into Ellie's sweater but not enough to touch her skin underneath. Carl then reaches for his Python and points it at Ellie as she was charging him but this caused the girl to flinch. It was empty regardless but Carl took the chance to run up to Ellie and punch her in the gut making her cry out in pain before grabbing her by the hair and forcing her to her knees.
''Let go of me motherfucker!'' Ellie screamed at the top of her lungs.
Before Carl could drive the knife into her neck Ellie summoned the energy to free herself from Carl's grasp and goes to bite off two of his fingers. The teenage boy screams in pain and pushes Ellie away but the pain and shock of losing two of fingers took his focus off of Ellie and hearing a whistle he looks up to see Ellie throw another bottle at his face hitting him square in the face and it shatters.
Some of the shards cut into his skin putting him in even more pain and soon he felt Ellie grabbing him and holding him like some meat shield from behind.
''I made myself a promise that I'll kill every single one you fuckers!'' Ellie growled into Carl's ear before taking her switchblade and jams it into his neck.
The steel punctured his jugular vein and the poor boy was left to cry out in pain as Ellie slowly lowered him onto the ground but his cries were muffled. At the same time Ellie forced the blade deeper causing more blood to leak from his wound.
Soon Carl's futile efforts to break free and his cries stopped and he became still in her grasp. Setting the dead boy down Ellie glared hatefully at her opponent and only put her blade away.
Now that Carl was dead she scoops up his hat and puts it on and sneers at the boy's corpse.
XXXXXX
Winner: Ellie Williams
Ellie Williams: 691
Switchblade: 9
Beretta 92F: 112
Remington 700: 377
Bow & Arrow: 193
Carl Grimes: 309
Gerber Epic: 9
Colt M1911A1: 10
Marlin Model 1893: 199
Colt Python: 91
X-Factors
Training: 80/Training: 80
Killer Instinct: 100/Killer Instinct: 90
Survivor Instinct: 95/Survivor Instinct: 95
Mental Health: 65/Mental Health: 80
Brutality: 96/Brutality: 75
Following a brutal battle between two hardened young survivors it would be Ellie who won a rather one-sided victory with 69.1% compared to Carl's 30.9%. It was largely in part to her more ferocious approach to combat and unpredictability that allowed her to stay well ahead of her opponent scoring triple digit numbers with three of her weapons. In conclusion she destroyed Carl with a viciousness he never encountered.
''While it may seemed that Carl's use of two guns was an advantage it actually didn't really help in the end. As we've seen from the show Carl does much better at surviving when he is fighting walkers and saviors alongside his father and friends, when you put him on his own he'll end up making mistakes which is what caused his death in the show and here.'' DAM explained.
''I like Carl and I feel for the boy, but he just didn't have an answer to the ferocious and viciousness Ellie was bringing into the fight.'' Zivon seconded.
''Honestly I thought this fight would've been a lot closer but I was wrong, Ellie was just too much for Carl and he was just not prepared for this.'' Demigod added.
''Sure Carl was a tough kid, but he did not start out tough in the tv series and he only truly toughened up when he lost his mother and when the saviors appeared. He gave it his all but Ellie just flat out put him down.'' Rice Man concluded.
''Oh no, no ho ho ho!'' a slouched over Rick sobbed.
He had lost his wife on the tv show but now losing his son in this simulation was proving too much so the Sheriff's deputy was now reduced to a sobbing mess as he was in the third episode of TWD's season three.
''Rick he didn't really die it was just a simulation.'' Joel said patting his fellow survivor on the back.
(Ellie was seen heading out of the theater her and Dina were using as a safe house. Heading out the door she makes sure she has her newly acquired Colt Python in its holster before putting on Carl's Sheriff's hat. As she walks off she hears a walker and a clicker approaching her and glaring at the infected she draws her switchblade and walks toward them and the walker was revealed to be a reanimated Carl.)
XXXXXX
Next time on Deadliest Warrior: Fiction Edition, it's a battle of the elements between two deadly silent warriors.
Lin Kuei: Earthrealm's silent ice cold killers who put the icy fear of death in their enemies.
vs.
Mist Ninjas: Kirigakure's stealthy and relentless shinobi whose entire nation was built around bloodshed.
WHO IS DEADLIEST?!
And I apologize to Carl Grimes, Chandler Riggs and The Walking Dead fans...
Ellie and Carl are the rightful properties of Naughty Dog, AMC and Robert Kirkman.
By the way, fuck Abby we should've killed her.