A/N: Honestly, with the many opportunities Minecraft provides I could create an entire sub-arc dedicated to Minecraft shenanigans.

Since I actually haven't played Minecraft technically, I'm going to be using ideas from Youtube videos to write this chapter. Specifically, the ghost kids' upcoming Minecraft shenanigans will be heavily inspired by the Minecraft videos posted by VanossGaming and his friends.

Also, WOW, there are a LOT of people who want reactions to FNAF songs. With this many people wanting them, how can I say no? I don't have an issue with the number of reviews requesting them, but I do have to point out that a few of the requests were borderline rude, and I have to politely ask that you be a little more courteous in the future. The FNAF song chapter will NOT be the next chapter or the one after that, as I have a Halloween chapter planned on Oct. 31 and that requires another chapter before that to set things up. On the plus side, this means that, yes, you will be having WEEKLY chapters for the rest of the month because of what I have planned. That being said, please recommend any FNAF1-3 songs that you are particularly interested in having the ghost kids respond to (since 4 and beyond don't exist in this fic).

JZKiller: Don't worry, UCN will be coming into play VERY soon.

Rockstar Ballora: No, I actually don't know which meme you're talking about. I'm not really all that knowledgeable on meme lore. Like, at all.

AlchemyWriter: Eh, I actually don't play many (translation: almost ANY) Horror games outside of FNAF. Despite the last arc serving as evidence to the contrary, I'm really a little chickenshit when it comes to most horror games :P

Gpinto: I'm going to wait until after the chapter to answer your review (since I already responded privately and it would take up a huge chunk of space), so let me just say that I disagree with your argument that Charlie is the second most evil character in FNAF. COMPLETELY disagree.

Chapter 87 – Fun with Video Games 4

Over the next few days, Mike introduced each of the ghost kids to the wonders of Minecraft. It had been a while since he had last played the game, but he understood the basics well enough to pass on the minimum amount of information that the kids would need to understand how Minecraft worked. Mike refused to give the children detailed instructions on how to create their own houses, instead encouraging them to experiment and explore the new world they found themselves in by themselves.

Which, as the ghost kids understood by now, meant that he was either too busy to help them or too lazy. Both of which were equally valid options, considering that Mike was still dealing with the issues caused by Nightmare Springtrap's attack on their house.

With nothing better to do for the next few days, the ghost kids got to work building their own houses. Together, the children swore an oath not to sabotage or otherwise interfere with the construction of each other's houses, promising to wait until after their houses were finished and saved under Charlie's administrative powers before they began trolling each other. This decision turned out to be a wise one, as the skeletons, zombies, spiders, and ESPECIALLY the creepers caused more than enough problems for children who were barely familiar with the game when night rolled.

At the end of the week, thanks to a combination of their own dedication and the helpful advice of Youtube guides, the children had succeeded in making houses that were nothing short of impressive for how completely new they were at the game.

Gabe had created a three-story modern-style house next to the beach with glass walls that opened up to a beautiful ocean view, a beautiful summer abode complete with its own pool. Jeremy had carved out a network of caverns for a home straight into one of the small mountains that dotted the landscape, taking the extra time to clear out the monsters inside. Susie and Cassidy had opted to work together to create an ornate mansion, easily the largest house out of all of them, a structure of grandeur and elegance that reminded them of Mike's own home except on an even grander scale. Fritz, in a gesture that was simultaneously predictable and creative, fashioned his Minecraft home in the form of a pirate ship, creating an expression of his love for pirates and Foxy on a different beach than Gabe's. Liz, perhaps drawing on her British roots, created a small medieval castle, with plans to make it much larger and grander once she gained more experience with Minecraft as a whole. And Charlie, feeling a sense of daring, had created a treehouse that towered above the rest of the houses on their island and even much of the island itself, her wooden structure seamlessly integrated into the natural environment of the tree.

The children were delighted with how their homes had turned out, and their happiness increased with the compliments they received from each other and from Mike. Once they had finished furnishing their homes, stockpiling numerous resources in chests, and saved all their hard work under Charlie's administrative powers.

And with that final step…their accord was now broken.

As the other children explored the world of Minecraft, gathering materials and fighting creatures, three of them surreptitiously met in Charlie's treehouse to plot and scheme against their friends and family.

"All right, Cassidy, Susie, Charlie, glad you could make it," Gabe muttered as the three characters, all of whom were fashioned in the likeness of their respective animatronics, met in Jeremy's treehouse. "I've brought you all here for a…special operation."

"Ooh…" Susie breathed out excitedly, "what've you got planned, Gabe?"

Gabe grinned, and the mischief in his expression immediately set off alarm bells in Charlie's mind. Out of all the ghost kids besides herself and maybe Liz, Gabe had the most well-developed sense of responsibility…which only made her even warier of his plan.

"A little prank to screw over everyone who's not here," Gabe explained. "You see, over the past few days, I've been collecting materials to make tons, and I mean TONS, of TNT crates."

The moment Gabe said the words "TNT crate", the rest of the ghost kids' minds clicked immediately. "You're going to blow up Jeremy's, Fritz's, and Liz's houses aren't you?" Susie realized.

Cassidy gasped, torn between outrage and amusement. "That's SOOOOOOOOOOO mean!" she exclaimed.

"Isn't this going a little too far?" Susie pointed out. "I know we broke our peace agreement once we finished building our houses, but we put so much work into making our first houses! Blowing them up seems really vicious and cruel."

Gabe gestured with his thumb at Charlie. "That's why Charlie's here, so that she can reset the servers after we blow them up with no lasting harm done. The only real risk is that they lose something really valuable after the server reset, but all of us already have full diamond resets and everything, so what's the worst they could lose?"

Cassidy breathed a sigh of relief. "If we're going to fix the houses with a server reset after all this, then I feel better about it."

"That's the ONLY reason why I'm agreeing to this," Charlie huffed. "And even then, I'm not going to be the one who puts all the TNT crates under their houses or pulling the trigger."

"That's fine," Gabe replied. "We only need you to reset the server afterwards, but if you really wanted to help us you could distract Jeremy, Fritz, and Liz somehow so that we can set up our prank without them knowing about it."

"Hmmm…" Charlie thought for a moment. "I do have a treasure map that I haven't yet checked out yet. I can get take those three on an adventure…"

"…while we set up the TNT crates," Susie grinned. "That's a great idea, Charlie!"

Charlie smirked in response. "Dad wanted me to lighten up a little," she replied. "No time like the present, right?"

"That's perfect!" Gabe declared. The four children shared mischievous grins and then turned their attention to their laptops. "Now then…let's get to work."

Gabe, Susie, and Cassidy got out their diamond pickaxes and prepared them for digging. The moment they were ready, Charlie led Liz, Fritz, and Jeremy on treasure hunts with her maps as a distraction. It was surprisingly easy to convince the three to follow her lead, as all the ghosts intrinsically trusted Charlie (a normally wise decision that would prove to be a grave mistake in this particular instance) and the ghost children were already exploring the world of Minecraft by their own initiative. As their targets moved away from the safety of their homes, Gabe, Susie, and Cassidy all started digging tunnels from several spaces away from their target's houses, completely undetectable on the surface, until they were right below their siblings' houses. They then proceeded to dig out caverns underneath the homes that were big enough to fill with several blocks of TNT crates, and laid down Redstone trails that would all be ignited by switches close in proximity to each other.

By the time that Charlie and their siblings had returned from their treasure hunts, Gabe, Susie, and Cassidy had buried so many TNT crates underneath their target houses that the explosion would be more than enough to wipe out any trace that had a structure had ever existed, or at the very least blow a huge crater in the buildings. Gabe, Susie, and Cassidy were very grateful that they were all spread out throughout the house and communicating to each other via voice chat rather than being physically next to each other, or they would have had a very difficult time masking suspicious behavior.

"Are you kidding me? That was three, THREE maps that led to literally the same fucking treasure chest that we opened first!" Fritz was ranting to the siblings who had joined him. "I mean, why the fuck would multiple pirate ships even have the same fucking treasure map to begin with!"

"He does have a good point," Liz agreed, calmer than her sibling but her tone was still noticeably displeased. "It does kinda kill the whole point of burying your treasure in the first place."

"At least that second chest we found had a few diamonds and emeralds," Jeremy tried looking on the bright side. "Better than nothing, I guess."

"If that's all the treasure these guys had, no wonder they sank to the bottom of the sea," Fritz grumbled. He was about to make another unflattering remark when he suddenly noticed Gabe, Susie, and Jeremy standing close to a castle that none of them had built.

"Hey guys!" Susie called out to them. "We've found something really cool!"

"Look at this really cool castle!" Cassidy added, turning her character to face one of the mountains that dotted the landscape. "We wanted to wait for you guys to come over here so we could explore it together."

"And why haven't you explored it by yourselves already?" Jeremy asked with a trace of suspicion in his voice. Something about this didn't seem quite right to him…

Fortunately for this, Gabe was more than prepared with a plausible explanation. "Because the last time we went into a castle like this, there was a dungeon full of monsters and we got the crap beaten out of us. I mean, come on, we only just started playing this game! If we tried to go in ourselves we'd get our buts kicked!"

Behind his computer screen, Jeremy shrugged. His senses had been going off that something was wrong, but since Susie was flat-out admitting that there was danger, she was probably telling the truth.

"Why don't you guys quickly go down to the entrance of the dungeon, quickly see what's inside, and come back up?" Susie suggested. "We've already seen what's down there, so once you have a better idea of what we're up against we can come up with a plan to tackle it."

"Sounds like a plan," Liz replied. She, Jeremy, and Fritz began walking towards the castle. Once they were inside, Gabe quickly moved over to one of the switches that they had hidden underneath a pile of blocks, the one they had rigged to blow up the castle. Smirking, he flicked the switch.

"Wait, I don't see a dungeon around here," they could hear Fritz say. "Did you guys hide the entrance or something?"

Gabe, Susie, Cassidy, and Charlie grinned. "The only thing we hid is the fact that you're all about to GET FUUUUUUUUUCKED!" Gabe cackled.

"Wait, WHAT?" was all their victims had time to say before the castle suddenly exploded, the many TNT crates they had buried underneath the castle detonating simultaneously. With so many explosives, there was absolutely no chance for Fritz, Jeremy, or Liz to escape the blast radius in time. The three victims all shouted in outrage and disbelief as they were instantly killed, their screens turning red as the messages informing of their deaths appeared in the bottom left corner of the screen.

"What the FUCK just happened?" Fritz yelled once he had respawned and recovered from his shock.

"We got blown up is what happened!" Liz answered, sounding more than a little irritated now that she had realized that she had been the victim of a prank.

"I had 35 levels, you jerks!" Jeremy shouted. "And now they're all gone!"

"Please tell me that we at least get to keep our stuff, right?" Fritz asked.

"No, because it all got blown up along with us!" Jeremy growled.

"Are you FUCKING kidding me?" Liz exclaimed furiously. "I had a full diamond armor set in there!"

Gabe's eyes widened. "Oh, shit…" he muttered. "Uh, Charlie? I didn't realize that all TNT instantly destroyed all your stuff."

"Calm down, guys!" Charlie placated everyone. "Luckily, I saved the server a few minutes before you guys went into the castle. Let me reset back to that point." She began working on her computer and triumphantly clicked on her mouse. "Annnnnnnnnnd….done!"

The victims of the prank all breathed a sigh of relief as the server returned to back where they were before the prank had happened. One quick check was enough for them to see that they all had their stuff back in their inventory, safe and sound.

"Oh, thank God…" Liz breathed a sigh of relief. "Charlie, you're the best!"

"No problem!" Charlie replied.

"Wait a minute…" Jeremy's tone was suspicious again. "How did you know to save the server right before we went into the dungeon?"

"Because I was in on it," the former Marionette cheerfully answered.

"You WHAT?" all three of them exclaimed.

"Yep!" Charlie grinned. "Those treasure hunts I took you guys on were all just a distraction while Gabe, Susie, and Cassidy set up the TNT crates underneath the castle. You guys fell for it hook, line, and sinker!"

Fritz shook his head in disbelief. "Wow…" he muttered. "I can't believe that Charlie and Gabe of all people were the ones behind this!"

"I wish I could've seen the looks on your faces when we blew you guys up!" Cassidy giggled.

"All right, all right, you had your fun…" Jeremy retorted. "But I think you should let us blow up the castle this time!" he added, excitement creeping into his voice.

"Not until I put everything I have in an Ender chest," Liz interjected. "After you already blew us up once, I am NOT trusting my safety with you guys without taking some security measures first."

"That's fair," Gabe agreed. "We'll be waiting for you." He, Susie, Cassidy, and Charlie waited for their targets to put away all their things and return to the block where he had hidden the switches. It had been a slight risk to let them return home with the TNT crates stockpiled underneath their houses, and part of him had been tempted to stop them from putting their things away. But that would have immediately tipped them off that something was off, and so he kept his silence. He didn't think that his siblings would notice anything anyway, and he was proven right when they came back, giving no sign that they had discovered or even suspected the death traps buried underneath their houses.

"Here you go, guys!" Susie chipped away a block hiding one of the switches. She barely managed to hide her feeling of smugness. The former Chica inhabitant had revealed a switch…but not the switch that had led to the castle. If they had been more observant, their targets would have noticed that the switch was a little closer to the beach than it was to the castle…

…specifically the beach holding Fritz's pirate ship.

"Whoo, let's blow this thing sky high!" Fritz enthusiastically declared as the pranksters desperately tried to contain their sniggers. Without even thinking about the consequences, he immediately flipped the switch. For a few tense seconds, nothing happened as the former Foxy inhabitant looked expectantly at the castle. And then…

BOOM!

Fritz whirled around to his pirate ship, excitement quickly replaced by disbelief and horror as he watched his beloved pirate ship get utterly shredded by the force of several exploding TNT crates. "NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!" he dramatically howled in despair. "WHAT? HOW? I THOUGHT THE CASTLE WAS SUPPOSED TO BLOW UP!"

Gabe, Susie, and Cassidy all collapsed into hysterics, and even Charlie and the other two targets couldn't hold back their laughter. "Oh my God, Fritz, you're such an idiot!" Susie managed to choke out in between laughs. "You fell for that hook, line, and sinker!"

Fritz groaned as he stared at the ruins of his beloved pirate ship. Because part of it was next to the water, the TNT crates hadn't completely destroyed it. But they had done more than enough damage to reduce it to a smoking ruin surrounded by a giant crater that even now was being filled in with water. "Please tell me you're going to reset the server, Charlie!" he pleaded.

"In a little bit," Charlie replied nonchalantly. "I want to admire the burning ruins of your ship first."

"I am never trusting you guys in a video game setting ever again," Fritz muttered.

"Then I guess you finally learned something," Gabe commented with a smirk. His tone suddenly became businesslike. "Enough messing around, though. Now let's show the rest of these guys how cool these explosions are from the outside. They're so crazy that we could all get blown to bits if we're even a tiny bit too close!"

"As you could probably tell," Cassidy explained, "we were lying when we said that the switch we uncovered before was the one that led to the castle. Obviously it actually led down to Fritz's pirate house." She mined down another block to reveal another switch. "THIS one is the real switch."

"I can't believe you made set up more than one explosive trap," Liz stared at the switch, before turning her attention back to the ghost kids. "Wait a sec…" she muttered, her tone clearly conveying suspicion. "How do I know that this switch won't ALSO blow up someone else's house? Like, oh I don't know…mine?"

"You think we actually had time to rig the house of every single person who wasn't part of our pranks?" Gabe asked incredulously, masking his nervousness that their cover might be blown. "Seriously, we're barely familiar with the game as it is!"

"Yeah, there's no way we'd be able to pull this off on ALL the houses," Susie added. "We only planted a bunch of explosives under Fritz's house because he's way too easy to make fun of."

"HEY!" Fritz protested, but everyone ignored him.

"Gotta say, though," Cassidy interjected, dreamily imagining the sheer amount of chaos they could cause. "That would be so fucking GENIUS if we did that!"

"After all the crap you've put us through, you'll forgive me if I don't…OH SHIT!" Liz suddenly screamed.

"What?" Gabe exclaimed.

"Creeper!" the orange-haired ghost girl shouted frantically. "CREEPER!"

The ghosts' eyes widened frantically as they saw the lime-green blocky abomination crawl shamble in their direction, its black face sneering menacingly at them. They had been so caught up in their arguments over explosive pranks that none of them had noticed Minecraft's most iconic monstrosity sneak towards them. If they had been prepared, they would have considered fighting it. But with nothing valuable or useful on them, they could only think of one thing to do.

"RUN FOR IT!" Susie shouted frantically. The ghost kids' characters all scrambled away as the Creeper began to light up. After a few tense seconds, the monster exploded, detonating the area where they had hidden the switches and leaving nothing but a smoking crater where the blocks had been seconds before.

"Oh, thank God…" Jeremy breathed in relief. Susie was about to join him, but then a worrying thought occurred to him.

"Wait a minute…" she thought out loud, "that's the spot where we started all the Redstone trails, right?"

"…yeah?" Cassidy confirmed.

"And the Creeper explosion counts as a regular explosion, so…" everyone's eyes all widened in horrified realization. "…OH GOD NO!"

"…Shit," was all Liz had time to say before the sound of multiple, thunderous explosions shattered the silence…from multiple directions.

BOOM! BOOM! BOOM! BOOM! BOOM! BOOM!

The sound and sights of piles of TNT crates utterly annihilating the houses of Jeremy, Liz, and the bait castle echoed around them, two ghost kids could only watch in transfixed horror as they watched their greatest Minecraft achievements and the culmination of all their hard work get blasted to pieces by the ruthless explosions. Where there had once been proud houses, now there were only massive craters. To add insult to injury, Jeremy had been standing too close to the bait castle, and the force of the explosion actually sent a TNT crate flying towards him, catching him in its own explosion and instantly killing him for a second time.

"Oh, come the FUCK ON!" Jeremy ranted, sounding very much like how his father did whenever he was ranting at the Rockstar animatronics during one of their "Five Nights at Freddy's" recreations. "HOW IS THIS EVEN FAIR?"

"ARRRRRRRRGGGGGGGGGGGGHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!" Liz yelled in incoherent fury, so agitated that her voice was slipping and transitioning frenziedly between her normal child and Scrap Baby voices (as was her ghostly form, even though nobody could see it).

Fritz snorted. "At least I'm not the only one anymore," he muttered.

Strangely enough, however, none of the prank perpetrators seemed to be all that pleased with the chaos and devastation that had been released. "God DAMMIT!" Gabe shouted in irritation. "The prank's ruined now because of that FUCKING Creeper!"

"Somehow the Creeper ruins our fun even when it doesn't blow us up," Charlie observed, also sounding displeased.

"We had such an awesome idea planned and now it's gone straight to Hell!" Cassidy complained.

In his room, Jeremy threw up his arms in exasperation. "What are YOU guys complaining about?" he demanded. "You're not the one whose houses got blown sky-high!"

"We were going to trick either you or Liz into blowing up your own house," Charlie explained, sounding more than a little disappointed. "Don't lie, Liz, you were about to flick that switch."

"…okay, fine," she grumbled. "But even if I did blow up my own house, there's NO way Jeremy would fall for it after both of us did it twice!"

Gabe smirked. "We know," he replied, "which is why we would've, ahem…encouraged…either Fritz or you to blow up his house instead. That way, you would've gotten angry at him and forgotten about us while we laughed at how hard we trolled you from the sidelines."

"But thanks to that goddamn Creeper, the whole second half of our prank is fucked!" Cassidy finished with a grumble.

"…that is one of the most devious things I've ever heard of," Jeremy admitted. "If my house wasn't currently BLOWN TO PIECES, I'd actually be impressed."

"…I have to admit, now that I've seen what it can do, I want to play around with TNT crates a bit," Liz commented, her interest increasing now that her anger at seeing her house destroyed had cooled somewhat. A hint of mischief suddenly entered her tone. "Who knows? Maybe I'll end up blowing one of YOUR houses instead…" she finished with a menacing giggle.

"Hey, the only reason we even went through with this prank in the first place was because we knew Charlie could reverse it," Susie reminded her sister. "If you blow up my and Cassidy's mansion and we CAN'T recover from that, I'm going to be VERY mad."

"I suppose now would be a good time to reset the server," Charlie decided, much to the relief of the prank victims. "But keep in mind…that Creeper is going to regenerate along with your houses. Once I reset, I highly recommend that you erase the redstone trails so that if the Creeper does explode again, it won't take your houses with it for a second time."

"That is a VERY good idea," Fritz muttered, and the moment that Charlie reset the server, the ghost kids scrambled to clear away the explosives that had led to so much havoc and mayhem. The pranksters did most of the work clearing away the TNT crates and erasing the redstone trails but left most of the now empty caverns intact, as the ghost kids realized that they could actually make for some excellent basements once they had time to refine their work. As Charlie had predicted, the Creeper had respawned and blown up in about the same area, but thanks to the quick work of the ghost kids, the only building that exploded was the unclaimed castle that nobody cared about, and the ghost kids could all enjoy an explosion without any of their houses being obliterated in the process.

"Things look a whole lot different when it's not your building getting blown up for a change," Liz commented once the explosions had safely died down.

"It was fun while it lasted but I'm glad there's no more TNT crates underneath my house," Jeremy agreed. "Right Fritz?" But Fritz didn't immediately respond. "Uh…Fritz?" Jeremy verbally prodded him. "You alright?"

"Guys…" Fritz spoke unusually softly, but the enthusiasm in his voice was unmistakable. "I just got an amazing idea. What if we made a statue of Springtrap, stacked it with TNT crates, and blew the everloving fuck out of it?"

There was silence from the rest of the ghost kids for a second that seemed to stretch on for an eternity. Then…

"Oh. My. God. Fritz…that is the BEST IDEA EVER!" Gabe exclaimed in delight. "I can't believe I'm saying this, but you're a fucking GENIUS!"

"Every time we saw him, we couldn't ever really do anything to stop him," Cassidy remarked, sounding just as excited about the idea as Fritz was. "I know this isn't the same thing, but I'm loving the idea of exploding that rabbit zombie asshole and wrecking him harder than you guys wrecked our houses!"

"Count me in," Liz added, determination and resolve echoing in her voice. "I want to pay him back for attacking me and my brothers from my old family as much as I can!"

"And when we're done, we can fill in the crater that's left behind with lava and pretend that that's the pit to Hell that the Purple Guy fell into!" Susie finished gleefully. "I need to find some lava right away!"

The ghosts' characters started scrambling around and scattering, eagerly trying to get their hands on as many appropriately colored blocks and TNT crates as possible. The only one who didn't move was Charlie, was still laughing lightly at the antics of her younger siblings. Though part of her was admittedly disturbed by the speed at which the other ghosts acted on their revenge (even if it was by proxy), as well as by the scenes of Mike's own brutal vengeance that played in the most distant corners of her mind, Charlie couldn't deny that the ghosts needed some form of closure after Nightmare Springtrap had beaten them so easily.

"I really need to thank Dad for introducing us to this game," she thought as she left to go collect some lava and play her part. "There are so many opportunities here. It's amazing to think that games could have advanced so far compared to when I was alive." Her brow furrowed and a thoughtful look appeared on her face. "Maybe I should ask Dad about what he was talking about when he mentioned Mods…"

/

A/N: There really are a lot of ways I could have written this chapter out, but I chose to write the Minecraft chapter out this way because, as Michael Bay would tell you, you really can't go wrong with explosives and TNT crate pranks.

This chapter was inspired by VanossGaming and friends' TNT crate prank videos on Youtube, specifically the ones where Vanoss and Terroriser rigged a Homer Simpson and many of their friends' houses with explosives. There was also elements of a previous video in which they pranked and blew up Wildcat's house, as a Creeper ended up ruining the prank for them too (albeit in a different way). Creepers are such fuckers, aren't they? Even if they don't kill you directly, they're still ruining your life :P

There will be two chapters coming out in the next two weeks in preparation for Halloween, and THEN I'll tackle FNAF songs. I'll consider it "Jamming with the Schmidts 2" even though it strictly doesn't follow the formula of the first Jamming with the Schmidts, because fuck it, this is my story and I make the rules.

With that out of the way, hope you guys enjoyed!

Oh, and as I mentioned in the beginning, here's my response to Gpinto in full, saved until the very end since I didn't want to clog up the intro before the chapter.

First off, Charlie may have been the one to enable the children to possess the animatronics, but she was NOT responsible for enslaving them or trapping them on Earth to begin with. In the books (and before you say anything, the books have different plots but story elements ARE shared between book and game universes), the children's souls couldn't move on and were trapped in the animatronics even WITHOUT Charlie's intervention. And even after the children springlocked William Afton (with the animatronics destroyed in the process), they either refused to pass on or couldn't (if the original animatronics were made of Remnant). If anything, the Puppet's participation in the FNAF3 minigames presents the exact OPPOSITE conclusion: she was trying to FREE them.

Secondly, I HIGHLY doubt that Charlie is an evil bitch who murdered innocent night guards just for the hell of it. The ONLY evidence that even remotely suggests this is ONE single UCN quote, "The Others are Like Animals But I am Very Aware." However, there is NO evidence whatsoever that this quote is representative of Charlie's thought processes outside of UCN. Unless a quote explicitly refers to a past event (such as Charlie not being afraid of William anymore), there is no evidence to suggest that the UCN quotes are referring to anything outside the state of affairs in UCN.

And this is assuming that the ACTUAL Charlie is down there to begin with. It's entirely possible that the Marionette in the UCN is merely a REPRESENTATION of Charlie created by the Vengeful Spirit, and that this representation has more awareness because the original Charlie was naturally more intelligent. Most of the other animatronics seem to merely be "constructs" created by TOYSHNK to attack the protagonist, either having "tailor-made" personalities to fit their respective animatronic (eg Foxy, Funtime Foxy, the Mediocres when VS is not speaking through them) or not having any voice-lines at all (eg Freddy, Chica). The Puppet may have a higher degree of sentience compared to the other animatronics, but when the Puppet says "she's very aware", all that means is that she's more intelligent than the rest of the UCN cast and knows its true nature. That's it.

Not to mention the fact that if Charlie really was a murderous evil bitch, then why didn't she attack anyone in FNAF1? She was obviously there from what we see in the FNAF2 flashback cutscenes, but if she really did intend to murder innocents then she should have been the first and foremost attacker in FNAF1.

There's also the fact that she still can't tell the difference between William and Mike in FFPS, even though they are in the same building together. People seem to think that she knows what William Afton looks like when he murdered her, but here's the thing...the night she was murdered was dark and stormy, and at the time of her death Charlie was looking into the pizzeria AWAY from William. Which means that it's entirely possible if not likely that she didn't see William's entire face and only a part of his body, like a purple sleeve, which would only have told her that "a guard killed her" and not William Afton specifically. Granted, she could have figured out the specific identity of her killer later (like during the FNAF3 cutscenes showing Springtrap's death), but even then she still couldn't figure out the difference between William and Mike in FPPS (it doesn't help that they both look like rotting corpses by now). Alternatively, she might have distinguished between the two but instead mistakenly believed that Mike is as evil as his father. The fact that the other family member, Elizabeth, is also evil by this point doesn't exactly help his case, especially if Charlie's aware of Mike's role in BV's death.

Lefty has nothing to do with the Puppet's mental state or morality. In canon, the blueprints make it clear that it was made to TRAP the Puppet. And the "risk assessment of 9" means absolutely nothing considering that the whole pizzeria was very likely a trap to begin with.

Am I saying that Charlie is an innocent little angel? No, of course not. She's still killed night guards just like the rest of the missing children. But that just puts her into the same category as the Missing Children in that regard, and is not any more or less guilty or innocent than they are. She certainly isn't the second most evil character in the franchise under any metric.

Also, a brief statement on Henry, there is NO evidence that Henry was involved in Fazbear Entertainment's fucked up business practices. He helped create Fredbear and Friends, the PREDECESSOR to Fazbear Entertainment, but he was never explicitly connected to Fazbear Entertainment outside of FNAF6 (which, again, was a lie and a trap). Henry's presence is never connected to Fazbear Entertainment in the FNAF1 and FNAF2 locations, let alone that he was one of the ones behind covering up the murders of the kids or the night guards or the kids. I will give you that he was irresponsible in leaving Charlie alone to die and the Springlock suits; however, the Fazbear companies stopped using them almost immediately after the first springlock accidents. And the dangerous nature of Fredbear was more than likely William's design, with Henry ignorant of it.

Your argument that Charlie is the second most evil character in the franchise is based entirely on a specific interpretation of a single UCN line, an interpretation that is flawed by its very nature.