A/N: This story is inspired by aspects of different things I've been into lately, specifically Victorious, which I've been binging like crazy. The main inspiration for this story, outside of Victorious, is Samaritan on Amazon Prime.
It sounds like a pretty crazy idea, especially for a Victorious fanfiction, but it's one that wouldn't leave my head, and so I decided to write it.
Yes, it pairs Cat Valentine with an OC, and it is also going to have serious subjects, as its implied through very subtle hints that Cat is abused by her family, most prominently through her subtle but noticeable regression into a more childlike mentality.
This aims to act as something that fixes that, while also keeping some of the more beloved aspects of her personality.
NOTE: Yes, this is yet another version of my OC, John Gallagher. Because unfortunately, he is a character I created years ago, had in my head for years, and have had so many ideas for. it's a wonder most of my stories don't have the character.
WARNING: Opens with a very graphic lemon.
Cat Valentine was many things. She wasn't the brightest bulb. She was incredibly ditzy, and she couldn't take criticism well. She could act childish at times, and admittedly had a habit of catching onto things late.
But she was in a performance arts school for a reason, and in spite of her many flaws, she wasn't stupid. She knew many things that normal teenagers knew. She had an interest in many things girls her age did.
Such as boys.
And she also had an interest in the more… lewd aspects of teenage life.
So she knew very well about the birds and the bees, and she had plenty of interest in it.
It didn't help that Jade, as much as Cat loved her, had a very bad tendency to overshare about her times with Beck, creating images about her friend that she felt very uncomfortable having, mainly because Beck treated her as a younger sister.
So during a party a week after the big showcase, when Tori Vega was accepted into Hollywood Arts, she couldn't help it when her attention was drawn to the teen sitting at the bar, nursing what looked to be a glass of lemonade, away from everyone else.
Cat, being her usual bubbly self, immediately found herself sitting on a stool next to him.
He was a large guy, even amongst her classmates. Beck was the tallest of them all, at 5'10", but this guy had to be at least six feet, maybe 6'3".. He was built like a freight train, his arms bulging with muscle that could easily be seen through his white T-shirt which hugged his frame, which contrasted largely with his messy black hair. He wore a pair of blue jeans, and a pair of brown cowboy boots were upon his feet, tucked under his pants legs rather than over them.
It was probably his large frame that made him stick out among the others, but the fact that he seemed to either have no interest, or was actively avoiding the others, is what made Cat decide to talk to him.
"Hi!" Cat said with a smile on her face as she sat next to the large teen, who turned to glance at her in surprise.
"Hi." He responded simply with a nod, without saying another word.
Many others probably would've been put off by the rather passive and dismissive way he'd said it, but Cat Valentine was good at making friends for a reason.
Admittedly, she was still unsure of how that led to her current position under the guy she'd met, but a part of her assumed it was from the lemonade, which in hindsight at a party like this, probably wasn't lemonade.
The other part of her was too distracted by the pleasant sensation between her legs.
Somehow, in the middle of their conversation, they had slowly become more tipsy, and had somehow ended up in a spare bedroom.
A part of her wondered if she'd regret it in the morning.
But mostly, she didn't really care.
She knew she was having her first time with a random stranger.
But she also knew that it felt amazing.
He was down low, inches from her face, his breath hot as he panted with every thrust inside her. In turn, she would let out a yelp of pleasure every time he filled her.
He was big, that much she was certain of, but despite his pretty beastly aggression in the bed, he also made sure that everything was pleasant for her.
Or maybe she just liked it rough.
Or both.
Her legs jolted every time their hips met, and she would feel as though she were pushing deeper and deeper into her with every thrust.
It was pure bliss!
"Oh god…" Cat couldn't help but gasp out, hands at each side of her head, intertwined with the sheets under them. "It feels so good…"
Her partner let out a laugh that sent an unfamiliar, but pleasant, sensation through her. "I'd hope so… that's what makes it fun for me…"
In spite of the near mind numbing pleasure shooting through her with each thrust, Cat couldn't help the characteristic head tilt as she looked up at him, curiosity finding it's way into her mostly lust addled eyes.
"Wh-AH! Wh-What does?" She gasped out, struggling to actually form the words due to the thick member currently pounding away at her womanhood.
In spite of the alcohol, the way his already messy hair seemed to just grow even more wild, and the insanely vigorous thrust of him between her legs, he managed a gentle smile as he lowered himself even closer to her face.
"Making my lover feel the best she can… that's my kink…"
Cat knew she was blushing already, but considering the nearly downright painful heat she felt in her cheeks, she was almost positive that her face was as red as her hair.
"Um… my-Ngh… my k-kink… is uh-Ah! Is uh… I don't really know…" Cat admitted, somewhat embarrassed by the fact that she was so inexperienced in the world of sex that she had no clue what really turned her on.
Outside of cute boys.
The boy above her let out another chuckle. "Give it- Hmm! Give it time… cute girl like you is bound to have guys lining up for your hand."
Cat didn't try to correct him. She simply chose to appreciate his compliment.
The feeling of his member, stretching her so pleasantly, was a feeling she would love to feel more.
She just knew that it probably wouldn't happen again, not for a long time.
She knew many people would try to take advantage of her. Many had already tried in the past, and she hadn't put the pieces together until later, or until Beck or Jade stepped in.
But the man above her was the only one who didn't try to take advantage of her. Rather, it was a mutual decision. Admittedly, one made based on lust, alcohol, and attraction, but a mutual decision nonetheless. He hadn't really tried to convince her. In fact, she'd made the first move.
And she didn't regret it a single bit.
Cat let out a surprised yelp when she was suddenly pulled up into an upright position, and found herself now bouncing instead, staring into her partner's face. If she had to guess, he was on his knees, and he was supporting her weight rather easily as he thrusted up into her.
She let out gasps and moans of immense pleasure, and she muffled them by smashing her lips into her partner's mouth, desperate for something to distract her from the overwhelming pleasure that was threatening to explode.
And in the next moments, she found herself thankful that she'd been taking birth control, even if she knew she'd probably never needed it for a long time, at this intense gathering was completely unplanned.
The next thing she knew, she was on her back once more, and her partner was completely inside her as she came undone, spilling juices all over him. Taking that as confirmation that his job was done, Cat found a few seconds later a warm and extremely pleasant feeling emanating deep inside her as her legs spasmed from her orgasm.
It took her longer than she'd like to admit to realize that she'd just been filled full of cum.
Admittedly, she missed the feeling of him inside her when he pulled himself out of her after finishing, but the warm feeling of his seed inside her served as a substitute as he fell beside her on the bed, panting.
They didn't say anything afterwards, and she assumed it was because the grip of sleep was slowly tugging at them.
The last thing she remembered was the feeling of her partner's body as she used his shoulder as a pillow.
Cat's eyes slowly blinked open as light flooded into the room around her, the pleasant warmth awaking her from her slumber as she slowly processed her surroundings.
She could feel that she was naked, and as she sat up and examined the room around her, she realized that she didn't recognize the leopard printed wallpaper of the bedroom she currently sat in.
At first, Cat was confused, and a little nervous.
But then her gaze was drawn to the slightest movement next to her.
Turning, she found herself looking at the form of the boy she'd met the night before, whom she remembered kissing after the urge over took her…
And then the events of the night prior came rushing into her mind.
She couldn't help but blush at the images that assaulted her mind, and the realization that the teen boy next to her, who was built like a bodybuilder, was also completely naked definitely didn't help.
Not that she was complaining.
She felt weird, honestly. A part of her thought that she should feel… regretful, that her first time was with a random, albeit cute, stranger as a result of a drunk fueled confidence, but she honestly couldn't bring herself to feel said emotion.
She had no clue when, if ever, she'd have her first time, and in spite of what started the events of the night before, she found herself very thankful towards the boy sitting next to her, for his main focus seemed to be her own pleasure, not his own.
A part of her wondered how he'd feel knowing it's her first time.
Based on the groaning that was now coming from him, she assumed she was about to find out.
"Aw… what the fuck…" The boy breathed out, groaning as his hand came up to his head. "Who the hell spiked the lemonade?"
Oh… so it was lemonade…
"Actually, who would spike lemonade?" He asked as he brought himself up with a grunt resting on his elbows as he propped himself up and began looking around to take in his surroundings.
When his eyes landed on Cat, he froze for a few moments.
Cat found herself uncomfortable with the way his expression changed, to one of shocked realization, and she assumed it was because he recalled the events of the night before.
"You… you're that girl who came up to me last night…" The boy recalled.
Cat suddenly felt a little self conscious from his gaze, and she unconsciously found herself shielding her still nude body with the white covers of the bed they were on. "Uh huh…"
The boy looked at her for a few moments. "You remember what happened after… right?" She could hear the slight sense of urgency and fear in his voice, and she knew why. If she didn't remember, then it was technically a form of rape from what she knew.
But she remembered it. And she loved every second of it.
"Yeah." She answered with a nod. "I… I liked it."
He looked at her for a few moments, before he gave a sigh of relief, and a small smile. "So did I… in spite of the circumstances."
The two stared at each other for a moment, and Cat found herself unsure of what to do now, the awkwardness almost suffocating for the two, unsure of how to proceed.
"Well, this is one hell of a conundrum." The stranger remarked with a chuckle, trying to alleviate the awkwardness slightly. "I never thought I'd be in this situation."
In light of everything, Cat couldn't help but giggle. "Well, I never thought this is how I'd have my first time."
The amusement vanished off her partner's face as she said this. "That was your first time last night?" He asked in disbelief. "Don't you regret it?"
Cat shook her head, though the smile had gone off her face. "Not a single second." She admitted. "I don't think I'd have my first time for a long time."
Her partner seemed surprised at having this dumped on him. "You really don't have that much confidence in yourself?" He asked with a raised eyebrow. "Woman, you are gorgeous."
Cat blushed at his compliment, and she brought a hand up to brush some of her hair out of her face. "Thank you." She said with a smile. "But I really don't think I could find a decent person. You were a stroke of luck."
The boy looked at her for a moment, taking in her words, before he sat up and turned to look at her.
"Alright, tell me."
Cat tilted her head in confusion, and looked at her friend curiously. "Tell you what?"
"Why don't you think you could get a decent person, even if for a casual get together?" He asked with a raised eyebrow.
Cat looked down in embarrassment. "Well… I'm not the smartest person. I don't always get what's right in front of me immediately, even when it's right in front of my face. I'm a little ditzy and oblivious, and I wouldn't either get the offer, or I'd be too weirded out."
The boy let out a chuckle. "Sure didn't stop you last night." He remarked. "You seemed pretty confident."
"The lemonade was spiked." Cat stated simply.
The boy looked somewhat taken aback by her words, before he chuckled. "I guess that's true, but I maintain my opinion that you could probably get someone if you wanted to." He responded.
Cat didn't reply, but she was thankful for his confidence.
He looked at her for a few moments, before extending his hand towards her. "Probably should've done this last night. I'm John."
Cat looked at his hand for a moment, before she smiled. "I'm Cat." She returned his introduction as she shook his hand.
John smiled at her for a moment, before he swung his legs over the side of the bed and stood to his feet. Cat would be lying if she said she wasn't admiring the view of his bare backside.
It was kind of disappointing that she wouldn't see it again- wait.
"Hey, do you want my number?" She asked suddenly, the idea striking her just as suddenly as she said it.
John seemed surprised by the offer, nearly tripping over his pants from how quickly he turned to look at her. "Uh, what?"
"My number!" Cat said, hopping up off the bed and walking up to him, seemingly uncaring about her state of undress now. Admittedly, now she wasn't so shy hearing his opinion of her. Perhaps it seemed a little odd, but considering what they'd gotten up to last night, it wasn't like he hadn't seen any of it already. "We can hang out, talk and stuff."
John looked down at her for a moment, before he let out a sigh and shrugged. "Sure, why not? I need to get to know people here anyway." He remarked as he smiled down at her.
Cat beamed at the praise, and on instinct, she went to reach into her pocket…
… only to remember that she was completely naked.
Blushing and hoping he hadn't noticed her mishap, Cat looked around for her discarded shorts. Upon finding them thrown across the room, she was quick to make her way towards them.
She may have made a bit of a show as she bent down to pick up her shorts… but it wasn't like hadn't been very acquainted with any of it the night before.
"So…" Cat started as she retrieved her phone, looking up at John as she bit her lip. "Are you doing anything on Friday?"
Admittedly, Cat had a bit of a skip in her step as she made her way to school the next day. She was excited to share the news with her friends.
After all, if Jade could be open with her sex life, why couldn't Cat?
Besides, they'd be happy for her! She had a date with a good looking boy and she'd lost her virginity too! Why wouldn't they be happy?
When she found her friends talking to each other, hanging out by Beck's locker in the hall sans Robbie, she couldn't keep the smile off her face.
"Hey guys!" Cat greeted as she bounced up to them, interrupting whatever they were talking about.
"Hey Cat." Tori greeted with a wave as she turned to look at her redhead friend.
"You seem happy, Little Red." Andre remarked with a small smile as she approached them. "What has you so happy?"
"I have a date this Friday!" Cat answered, bouncing with excitement.
"Oh?" Jade asked with a raised eyebrow, her usual snark making itself known. "Who's the poor idiot?"
"Jade…" Beck admonished lightly, but Cat wasn't put off by it.
"His name's John! I met him at the party last night!" Cat explained, glancing towards Jade. "The one that Derek Kramer had?"
"Oh yeah." Jade nodded with a fond smile. "I got to watch Sinjin get punched for saying something stupid."
"He was just trying to tell Miranda that she has sour cream on her shirt." Beck said with an eye roll.
Jade scoffed. "When you say white stuff, not many people immediately assume sour cream."
"Anyway, when we woke up, I gave him my number and asked him on a date!" Cat exclaimed, practically beaming at the revelation.
"That's great, Cat!" Tori congratulated with a smile. However, Andre, Beck, and Jade all noted one particular part of Cat's answer.
"Hey Cat?" Beck asked, trying to keep the supportive tone in his voice while hiding the worry that he felt. "What do you mean by 'When we woke up' ?"
"Oh, we had sex the night before." Cat answered without a care in the world, as if talking about such a topic was the most normal thing ever.
Meanwhile, Jade froze, Beck stood up straight, and Andre's eyes went wide.
"What?" Jade asked in disbelief. "You had sex with some stranger at Derek Kramer's party?" Her words caused Tori's eyes to widen.
"What?"
Cat blushed, but she nodded. "Yeah… he was sitting there alone, and he was so nice, and he was such a hottie…" Cat knew her face was turning red enough to match her hair as she spoke, but she couldn't help it.
"But, Cat… wasn't that your first time?" Beck asked slowly. "Don't you regret it?"
Cat looked to be in thought at his words, before she shook her head. "No, not really." She admitted. "I don't think I had my first time for a long time if I didn't take that chance."
"But how did he convince you?" Andre asked curiously. "Usually, you don't see the hints until after they've already walked away. No offense."
"Um… about that…" Cat laughed sheepishly. "I might've… been the one to… start it?"
At those words, all of them couldn't help but look at her in shock.
"Y-you?" Jade asked in disbelief. "Little miss 'I can't see what's right in front of my face?'"
Cat pouted at Jade's words, while Beck looked at Cat curiously. "So… what led to you… starting it?" He asked, cautious of his words. He didn't want to upset the redhead, or his girlfriend. Admit it or not, Jade was practically a mother hen when it came to Cat.
Cat blushed once more, though it was out of embarrassment this time. "Well… I may have… drunken some of the lemonade… but it turns out it wasn't actually lemonade?"
All of them looked at her, confused and baffled at her words.
"What does that even mean?" Tori asked in confusion.
"Lemonade was the only thing at the party, Little Red." Andre recalled with a furrowed brow. "What else could've-"
"Jade?" Beck's voice suddenly sounded out, and they turned to find him looking at his girlfriend, whose face was uncharacteristically pale. "Are you alright?"
"Derek spiked the lemonade." Jade revealed to everyone, her voice barely above a whisper. "I told Cat to only drink the Wahoo Punch since it was in a can."
Suddenly it occured to everyone why Jade was so pale.
Cat had mistakenly gotten drunk…
…and now they were looking at the possibility of Cat being taken advantage of.
"I didn't take advantage of him!" Cat exclaimed, feeling as if she was the one being blamed. "We were both drunk!"
"Woah, calm down, Cat." Beck said, waving his arms in assurance. "No one is saying you took advantage of anyone. But are you absolutely sure he was drunk too?"
Cat nodded vigorously. "Yeah, I'm positive! He had a lot more than I did. I think he had three drinks before I finally had one."
They looked weary, but they knew Cat. As childish as she could be, she wasn't stupid. She knew very well how serious the situation was, even if she didn't realize they were weary of her lover rather than her.
She wouldn't lie about something like this.
"Alright…" Tori said slowly, glancing towards the others. "I guess… no harm done?"
She said it slowly, as a question, but the others could sense the urgency in her tone. She was hinting that maybe they should leave it for now.
"Yeah…" Jade said, being the first to agree with Tori, if only because she didn't want to hurt Cat's feelings or dissuade her without sure proof. "Sorry. We just wanted to make sure that everything was legal."
"What's that supposed to mean?!" Cat cried out indefinitely.
"Nothing, Little Red." Andre assured. "Just wanted to make sure you were okay."
"Oh." Cat said in understanding, before giving the characteristically bubbly smile she was known for. "Kay Kay. Well, I'm gonna get to Sikowitz. See you later!"
As she walked away, the others simply glanced at each other.
They were still a little suspicious of Cat's new boyfriend.
