"Are you sure you wanna do this?" Finn asked.
"If you wanna back out, it's okay. I won't be mad," Tennie said.
"No, I wanna do this. It's just that I didn't talk to Roman about it and that seemed perfectly fine up until this moment where I'm actually inside your house," he said.
"Relax, Finn," she giggled. "It's not a setup to get you in trouble with him."
She pulled the dress over her head and he watched her as she stood there in nothing but a light blue thong. It was the perfect match to her eye color. He let his eyes wander back up her body and watched as she pulled the elastic out of her hair and let the long, light brown waves fall down her back. She was smoking hot and he couldn't deny that he wanted to plant his dick deep inside her.
"We do this on all our birthdays," she said.
"A threesome?" He asked.
"No, a sexual fantasy. You're actually our first threesome with a man," she smirked. "We got money to buy whatever we want so instead we get a sexual fantasy come true. We have a list of what we wanna try so the other can choose and it will still be a surprise."
"But it isn't his birthday," he said.
"The one I picked this year wasn't as great in reality as on paper so I promised him an extra Christmas present instead," she winked. "I picked this one but he doesn't know it yet. He wants to come home and be surprised finding me in bed with another man. Instead of getting angry, he'll join. I know he'll be ecstatic."
"It sounds like you guys have a fun sexlife," he said.
"You have no idea," she giggled. "Get out of your clothes. He's almost here."
She pulled her thong off and walked over to open a drawer. He undressed while watching her get a bottle of lube out. She squirted some of it in her hand and walked over to him. His dick woke up by watching her come closer. She stroked his dick with her lubed up hand.
"We don't have time for foreplay. Luckily for you, I'm already getting wet just by thinking about it. Just using lube to be safe. Besides, that dick is going in my ass soon so it will be needed," she said.
"Shouldn't he be the one getting the most forbidden spot?" He asked.
"He gets that all the time," she laughed. "I wanna watch him while we do this. Maybe we'll twist it around on my birthday."
"Out of curiosity, what did he pick for your birthday?" He asked.
"A woman came by and fucked me with a strap-on while he sat there naked and watched. He wasn't allowed to join, touch me, or even touch himself. His dick was rock hard for so long that it almost looked painful in the end," she said. "It was amazing but I guess you should have been there."
She moved over to the bed and beckoned her hand in the air. He walked over to her while she laid down on her back and spread her legs. At the same time they both heard a car stop in the driveway.
"Hurry," she giggled.
He moved up on the bed and slammed into her. She let out a loud moan and he started fucking her like crazy. It didn't take long before they heard footsteps run through the house. Roman followed the sounds of two moaning people in the bedroom. He stopped for a moment and smirked at Tennie.
"Finn? I should have guessed," Roman said.
"Happy belated birthday," Finn said.
"How does he feel, darling?" Roman asked.
"Fucking perfect," Tennie moaned. "Are you gonna join us or not?"
Roman grinned and undressed in record speed. He moved over to the bed and leaned down to kiss Tennie.
"Ready for the ride of your life?" Roman asked.
"You better fuck me real good," Tennie said.
"I always do," Roman looked at Finn. "And by the sound of it, so does he. Move over, Finn."
Finn moved away from Tennie and Roman lifted her up. He laid down on his back and placed her on top of him. She slid down on his dick right away and he let out a groan.
"You're so wet. Is that Finn's doing?" Roman asked.
"Yes!" Tennie moaned.
"He's been doing a great job. Let's reward him for that," Roman said.
Roman grabbed Tennie's ass and spread her cheeks.
"Help yourself, Finn," Roman said.
Finn smirked and moved up behind Tennie. He pushed inside her slowly and moved back and forward while getting further and further inside her for each little thrust. Once he was halfway inside, he started giving her long thrusts. Roman pushed up from underneath and tried matching Finn's speed.
"Oh my god!" Tennia moaned. "Harder! Deeper! Let me feel all of you."
Both men thrust as fast and as hard as they could. It didn't take long before she cried out the first time. Roman grabbed her head and kissed her while they both continued fucking her.
"You got one more in you, don't you, darling?" Roman asked huskily.
"Always for you," Tennie panted. "Please! I need to cum again."
"And you will," Finn said.
"You heard him," Roman chuckled. "We're not stopping until you give us one more."
Tennie placed her head on Roman's chest and ran her nails and teeth over his skin. They kept going for a couple of minutes until Roman felt her tense up again. He grabbed her hair and forced her head back up so he could watch her cum a second time. She cried out beautifully and Roman grinned at Finn who grinned and winked back. Finn came a few seconds later, and Roman followed as the last one 10 seconds after Finn. They all held still while trying to catch their breaths.
"That was amazing," Roman kissed Tennie's forehead. "Thank you, darling."
"Thank you too," Tennie giggled. "I fucking loved it."
"So did I," Finn said.
Tennie giggled again and turned her head to look at Finne over her shoulder. He pulled out of her which made her giggle even more. She turned her head back around, gave Roman a quick kiss, and then jumped off him.
"I'm gonna take a quick shower," Tennie said. "Order burger for dinner for all of us. I promised Finn he could stay the night."
"Alright," Roman said.
Tennie left the bedroom and Roman sat up and looked at Finn.
"I should have guessed she would pick you. She's always been curious to see how much those trunks of yours are actually hiding," Roman said.
Finn let out a laughter and grabbed his briefs from the floor.
"This isn't going to be awkward next week in the locker room, is it?" Finn asked.
"Do you feel awkward?" Roman asked.
"Surprisingly no," Finn answered.
"Then it won't be awkward," Roman said. "Don't worry, Finn. Tennie and I have done a lot of crazy shit. This here almost felt like vanilla sex even though you're the first man to join us. We've had several women coming through here. Tennie's bisexual and I like the attention. Sometimes I just enjoy watching her with a woman."
"Yeah, she mentioned that," Finn said.
Roman stood up and grabbed his clothes from the floor.
"We got another bathroom you can use if you want to shower," Roman said.
"I'd like that," Finn said.
"I'll order food meanwhile," Roman said.
"Chicken burger, please," Finn said.
"Roger," Roman said. "It's down the hall. Final door on the left. There's towels in a dresser in there."
"Thank you," Finn said.
Finn picked up the rest of his clothes and walked over to the door. He turned around and looked at Roman.
"You know, Roman, if I ever fit into any other fantasies on your list, run them by me to see if they match some of my own fantasies," Finn said.
"You got it," Roman grinned. "I got one for her next birthday where you will be the perfect fit. We can talk about it another day when she's not around to hear it."