Sam and grace 's kidnapper reveals that his name is Cole and the reason he's hunting Dean down is because Dean killed his father twelve years ago. He tries to torture Sam not grace cause she is just a little girl for Dean's location, but Sam and grace escapes after warning Cole that Dean is a monster. It is later revealed that Cole has let them escape, and follows them to Dean. Meanwhile, Crowley and Dean have a falling out after Dean refuses to follow Crowley's orders and embarrasses him in front of his demon subjects. Realizing that the situation has gotten out of his control, Crowley contacts Sam with Dean's whereabouts to have Sam handle his brother. Sam offers to help Dean become human again, but Dean is uninterested, having found a kind of liberty in being a demon and in not caring anymore. Cole then ambushes the brothers and takes Dean on in a fight, but is easily defeated. Dean leaves him alive so that he will have to live with the shame of having been unable to avenge his father. Sam seizes the opportunity to capture the distracted Dean. In return for Crowley's help, Sam gives him the First Blade. Cole, having learned about Dean's demonic nature, starts researching the supernatural, still determined to take revenge on Dean. Elsewhere, Hannah and bella goes to visitMetatron(Curtis Armstrong) in his prison, in the hopes of making a deal to save Castiel's life, but Castiel manages to stop them , insisting that they respect his choice not to save himself through evil means but bella protest in tears that she is not losing him again she is tired of doing that castiel grap bella's face and dry her tears and told her she has no choice and tells her he loves her and grace and she says it back and he pull her into a kiss