Lucifer has approached Rowena in a dream, promising her rewards if she helps him get to Sam. Dean searches for Sam, and Crowley sends him to Billie the Reaper who Sam had recently encountered. Billie lets Dean into Hell with a "witch collar" that allows Crowley to control Rowena. Castiel bella and a low level angel search to see if Amara survived, while the angel points out that Castiel is more expendable than the Winchesters. Amara survived and kills the angel, then she sends Castiel and bella to Billie with a threat carved into his chest bella watch and scream in horror , though the effort it took does appear to weaken her. Meanwhile Lucifer says Sam has gone soft. Last time he fought him, he sacrificed himself to save the world. In recent years Sam bella and Dean only want to save each other regardless of the cost. Lucifer says making a sacrifice and being his vessel is the only way to stop The Darkness, since God is gone, Gabriel and Raphael are dead, and Michael has supposedly gone insane while imprisoned. Sam refuses, not believing it's guaranteed Lucifer would win against Amara, and even if it was he'd then destroy the world himself. Lucifer pulls Dean bella and Castiel into The Cage and beats all four of them, though Rowena's spell seems to work to send him away. The brothers agree to find another way to stop Amara while Castiel and bella hangs back. Castiel, having said yes at the last second to be Lucifer's vessel but bella in tears told castiel not to he held her face in his hands rub her cheeks and dry her tears told her he loves her and grace so much bella told castiel they love him too they kiss , goes to confront Crowley and Rowena. Lucifer makes sure that Rowena is the only one who could open The Cage again, then he kills her and says he wants to talk to Crowley.