Try
Disclaimer: I never owned Glee.
Chapter 1: Charming
Kurt Anderson entered Noah Puckerman's hospital room and noticed his face had bruises. Kurt was shocked when Noah touched his face and said, "Hey, Princess. Don't cry. Trust me, the other guy looks worse." Kurt sat beside Noah's hospital bed and slipped his hand under the covers before he rubbed the tip of his penis. The two men stared at each other as Kurt jerked Noah's penis. As Noah came all over Kurt's hand, they kissed before Noah moaned Kurt's name.
Kurt got a wipe from his bag and handed it to Noah before washing his hands in the bathroom. He exited the bathroom before Noah put on some boxers and smirked at Kurt. As Kurt sat beside Noah again, Noah said, "That was why I wanted to see you." Kurt didn't know what to say, but he knew this moment would change their relationship forever.
Then, Noah whispers, "When I woke up, I saw a male nurse, and my dick got hard. When I saw you, I got stiff again. There was a hot chick in here earlier, but my dick didn't respond until I saw the male nurse bend over. His ass was so round, I was drooling as I stared at it. I thought I would bust a nut right then. Is that how Finn or Blaine made you feel?"
Kurt blushes and nods his head. He understands Noah's comment, as he has had similar experiences. Kurt confesses, "I had the same reaction when I saw you today."
Kurt blushes and says, "Before I met you or Finn, I made a list that only you fit. I initially thought Dad fit it and was too embarrassed to tell anyone. After Blaine died, I prayed that God would send me someone to heal my heart. Then you called me and told me about being raped and mugged."
Kurt knows all too well the impact of past trauma and how it can affect one's emotions and desires. Kurt shares, "Before we met, I had that list. It was a list I made in secret, where I wrote down the qualities and attributes I wanted in a romantic partner. I thought my dad fit that list, and I hesitated to share my thoughts and feelings with him. But after seeing you today, I realized this list was not about physical attraction or superficial desires. It was about finding someone who could understand and connect with me on a deeper level."
Noah looks at Kurt, his eyes filled with understanding and compassion. He leans in and whispers, "That makes sense. I bet that's why I felt a connection to you. You understand what I am going through."
Kurt smiles softly as his eyes meet Noah's and replies, "I feel the same way about you."
Noah leans in and places a gentle kiss on Kurt's cheek. He whispers, "Thank you for being there for me and not laughing at me." Kurt returns the kiss, feeling a deep connection and affection for Noah. They sit there, sharing a private moment, knowing that they have found something unique in each other.
Soon, Noah has Kurt lie beside him, and Kurt says, "After Blaine died of COVID-19, I wondered if I would ever move on. Puck, I knew I was over Blaine as soon as we kissed. Like I said, you are everything I want in a partner."
Then Kurt slips his hand down Noah's boxers and whispers, "Everything."
Noah kisses Kurt again and says, "Call me Noah, Princess."
Kurt chuckles and says, "Noah, Papa Nono. God! How did I not know Tracy was talking about you until now? She has been talking about a Papa Nono since Blaine died and since everybody calls you Puck. I had no clue who she was talking about."
Kurt asks, "Do you remember anything from the attack?"
Noah has Kurt lay beside him as he says, "I was mugged and raped outside Scandals. I met Karofsky there to hang out, and we left separately. When I walked out, I was hit in the back of the head and woke up being fucked in the ass. A bag covered my head, and I was held down as twenty guys took turns raping me. I passed out after someone shoved a bat up my ass. The next thing I know. I'm waking up here with a massive headache. I know. Tracy wants me as her new papa, but I want you as my new boyfriend. I don't know if this will last, but I know I want this."
Kurt kisses Noah again and says, "Noah, I know this can't be easy for you. But, are you sure about this?" Noah unzips Kurt's jeans and gropes him, but says nothing.
When Noah is released, he moves in with Kurt. After they put Tracy to bed, Kurt and Noah headed to their bedroom. Noah stripped down to his boxers and watched Kurt do the same as he jerked off. Kurt lies beside Noah and kisses the tip of his penis. Before saying, "Noah, we can't do much with Tracy in the other room."
Noah kisses Kurt before licking his lips, saying, "I never tasted myself on someone else's lips before. Who tastes better, me or Blaine?" Kurt blushes but doesn't answer.
Noah goes under the covers and pulls Kurt's boxers down before licking the head of his penis. He licks Kurt's shaft and balls before giving him a blowjob. Noah gagged a few times but kept at it until Kurt came into his mouth.
Noah kisses Kurt up to Kurt's lips and lets Kurt taste himself. He smiles and says, "Well. I can't return to girls. Plus, I'm glad I did that."
He brushes Kurt's bangs out of his face and continues, "I want to do more, but I don't want to be fucked from behind." Noah gets up and looks out the window before breaking down.
He looks at Kurt and says, "I screamed for them to stop. I told them I wasn't gay until my voice was raw. When I saw that male nurse, I got pissed because the guy gave me a hard-on. I wanted to see you to prove I wasn't gay. When I blew your dick, I felt as if I had ditched Tracy now. I would be a loser like my dad. Kurt, I want this. I want you. I'm just afraid to let Tracy down."
Kurt gets up and wraps his arms around him, who turns around. They kiss, and Noah says, "I build this tough guy persona, and it takes getting raped for that to come crashing down." Noah picks Kurt up and holds him, then cries on his shoulder.
Kurt has Noah lock the door, and then they remove their boxers and stare at each other while jerking off. As they come together, they say, "I love you." Then Noah picks Kurt up again and lowers him onto his penis as they kiss.
He lets Kurt get used to his size and whispers, "This is how I could fuck girls at school and not get caught. I want to be on top when you are in me, Kurt. I know you were always on top, but I want to do things that will help me forget the rape. I don't want to be scared of gay sex when guys turn me on now."
Kurt wiggles a little and says, "Noah, the bathroom is soundproof, and the shower is big enough to lay in. I can't believe I forgot about that until now." Noah smirks and carries Kurt to the shower.
Noah then pins Kurt to the shower wall as they make love. Soon, Noah whispers in Kurt's ear, "Kurt, I came out to Quinn and your dad after I moved in. I told your dad I loved you. Kurt, I also told them about the rape. I plan to come out on Facebook soon and wanted to tell Quinn first because I hoped she would be our surrogate if we lasted that long."
Kurt pants and says, "Noah, Quinn texted me earlier, and all I can tell you is. She made a bet with Dad before we knew you were Beth's dad."
Noah kisses Kurt's neck and whispers, "I know. Your dad told me. Who do you think gave me the cap with the letter P?" As they come together, Noah lays Kurt on the shower floor and kisses his body.
Soon, Noah lowers himself onto Kurt's penis and says, "I love you, Kurt. Oh, God! This feels so good! Yes! Oh, God! Oh, Fuck!" as he bounces up and down on Kurt's penis.
When they come together this time, Noah kisses Kurt and says, "Santana will flip when I come out. She and Karosky have tried to get me to be more open to gays. Now, here I am living with you, and I have your dick in me."
Noah kisses Kurt and continues as he gets up, "Kurt, this was a crazy week, but I will do whatever it takes to be your man and Tracy's new papa."
Then he yells, "I love you, Kurt Elizabeth Anderson!"
As Noah carries Kurt back to bed. Kurt says, "I love you, too, Noah Elijah Puckerman."
Then they put on their boxers and returned to bed. Noah asks, "Why is Tracy's room Hulk-themed?"
Kurt sighs and says, "Because of you, Noah. Tracy thinks you're Bruce Banner."
Noah chuckles and pulls Kurt closer to him. He gets his phone, and Kurt watches as Noah posts, "I'm done with women. I love Kurt Anderson, and I'm gay. Mom, you didn't do anything. This is what I want."
Santana Lopez comments, saying, "I knew it! Kurt, I love this pairing. LOL, the girls are blowing up my phone about who will be your baby mama. I know it will be Quinn. You both owe it to her."
Burt Hummel comments, "Puck, Mick told me you applied for a job at the shop. Well, Mr. P., welcome to the family. I can't wait to see your gun collection."
Carole Hummel replies to Burt's comment, saying, "Burt, you better stay away from Puck's guns! You and Quinn better hope I don't tell Puck or Kurt about a bet you two made!"
Then Beth Corcoran comments, "Kurt, the bet was made before I was born. Your dad bet Quinn twenty bucks you would take her boyfriend. Finn wasn't named in the bet, and Daddy Puck, go easy on Tracy's dates, okay?"
Quinn replies to Beth's comment, saying, "Beth, who told you about the bet?"
Santana replies, "It had to be Rachel, Quinn. Who else would know about it that knows Beth?" Kurt tries to call Rachel, but she won't answer.
Then Noah calls her, and she answers, saying, "She thought Finn was her dad, and she is thirteen, Puck. I was trying to keep her from making Quinn's mistakes!"
Noah takes a deep breath and calmly says, "I'll be sure to tell Quinn that when I ask her to be our surrogate, Rachel."
Then Kurt takes Noah's phone and says, "The only mistake made was trusting you to be my surrogate. You went too far, Rachel." He ends the call and kisses Noah, who laughs in the kiss.
Noah puts his phone on the nightstand and wraps his arms around Kurt, saying, "Kurt, the night I was raped, I decided to give up on women. I didn't want to be with guys either; I was just tired of being hurt by everybody. I planned to end it all, Kurt, and then Karofsky invited me to hang out at Scandals."
Kurt snuggles into Noah, saying, "The day I heard you were in the hospital, I was at the cemetery with a gun. I pawned the gun the day I came to see you. Noah, you saved me."
Noah kisses Kurt's neck and whispers, "We saved each other, Kurt."
Chapter 2 will be up soon.